Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutR-2026-148 Maintenance and Repair - Let Love Guide Your Way SculptureRESOLUTION NO. 2026-148 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF DANIA BEACH, FLORIDA, SELECTING SHORES ART CONSERVATION FOR ART MAINTENANCE SERVICES; AND AUTHORIZING THE PROPER CITY OFFICIALS TO ENTER INTO A MAINTENANCE AND REPAIR AGREEMENT FOR THE “LET LOVE GUIDE YOUR WAY” PUBLIC ART SCULPTURE BY LLOYD GORADESKY LOCATED IN THE ART PARK AT CITY HALL; PROVIDING FOR CONFLICTS; FURTHER, PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. WHEREAS, on February 3, 2022, the City Commission leased the sculpture at a cost of Six Thousand Eight Hundred Dollars ($6,800.00); and WHEREAS, November of 2022, the City Commission purchased the sculpture for One Hundred Seventy-Five Thousand Dollars ($175,000.00), which did not include the annual cost of One Hundred Fifty Dollars ($150.00) for maintenance of the piece; and WHEREAS, the City’s Public Art Plan calls for annual assessment and maintenance of pieces in the City Public Art Collection; and WHEREAS, federal law, known as VARA, the “Visual Artists Rights Act”, is officially part of the U.S. Copyright Act, codified in the law books as 17 U.S.C. § 106A, and grants two fundamental rights to the author of a “work of visual art”: (1) the Right of Attribution, giving the artist the power to claim authorship of their work, and prevents their name from being used on their work if it has been distorted, mutilated, or otherwise modified in a way that would be “prejudicial to his or her honor or reputation”; and (2) the Right of Integrity, which provides the artist the power to prevent any intentional “distortion, mutilation, or other modification” of their work that would harm their honor or reputation or any intentional or grossly negligent destruction of a work of “recognized stature”; and WHEREAS, VARA allows the artist to file suit for mutilating, destroying or failing to maintain the artwork, despite having sold the piece to a third party; and WHEREAS, under VARA, the City has a duty to maintain the integrity of the piece; and WHEREAS, the Community Development Department received three (3) quotes for maintenance of the sculpture which include: • RLA Conservation of Art & Architecture $14,600.00 on-site • Shores Art Conservation $22,130.00 on-site • Public Art Works Inc. $21,000.00 on-site RESOLUTION #2026-148 • Shores Art Conservation $29,745.00 off-site • Public Art Works Inc. $31,000.00 off-site; and WHEREAS, on May 18, 2026, the Public Art Advisory Board unanimously recommended Shores Art Conservation for off-site restoration; and WHEREAS, the Administration recommends entering into a maintenance agreement with Shores Art Conservation for off-site restoration at a cost of Twenty-Nine Thousand Seven Hundred Forty-Five Dollars ($29,745.00). NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF DANIA BEACH, FLORIDA: Section 1. That the above “Whereas” clauses are ratified, made a part of and incorporated into this Resolution by this reference. Section 2. That the City Commission selects Shores Art Conservation for off-site restoration at a cost of Twenty-Nine Thousand Seven Hundred Forty-Five Dollars ($29,745.00), to conduct the maintenance of the sculpture. The agreement is attached and incorporated by reference into this resolution as Exhibit A. The appropriate city officials are authorized to execute the agreement. Section 3. That all resolutions or parts of resolutions in conflict with this Resolution are repealed to the extent of such conflict. Section 4. That this Resolution shall be effective 10 days after passage. Adoption. PASSED AND ADOPTED on October 13, 2026. Motion by Vice Mayor Salvino second by Mayor Davis. FINAL VOTE ON ADOPTION: Unanimous ___ Yes No Commissioner Lori Lewellen ____ X Commissioner Luis Rimoli X ____ Commissioner Archibald J. Ryan IV ____ X Vice Mayor Marco Salvino X ____ Mayor Joyce L. Davis X ____ SIGNATURES ON FOLLOWING PAGE RESOLUTION #2026-148 ATTEST: ELORA RIERA, MMC JOYCE L. DAVIS CITY CLERK MAYOR APPROVED AS TO FORM AND CORRECTNESS: EVE A. BOUTSIS CITY ATTORNEY 1 ART CONSERVATION SERVICES AGREEMENT This Art Conservation Services Agreement (“Agreement”) is entered into on _________________, 2026, by and between the CITY OF DANIA BEACH, a Florida municipal corporation (“City”), and SHORES ART CONSERVATION LLC, a Florida limited liability company, located at 847 Mayfair Circle, Orlando, Florida 32803 (“Contractor”). The Agreement becomes effective on the date it is last executed by the parties (“Effective Date”). The City owns or controls the public artwork titled Let Love Guide Your Way by Lloyd Goradesky (the “Artwork”) and desires to retain Contractor to deinstall, transport, conserve, restore, and reinstall the Artwork. Contractor represents that it possesses the specialized expertise, personnel, equipment, insurance, and facilities necessary to perform those services. For good and valuable consideration, the receipt and sufficiency of which are acknowledged, the parties agree as follows: 1. Scope of services Contractor shall furnish all labor, supervision, materials, equipment, transportation, rigging, facilities, documentation, and incidentals necessary to complete the work described in Exhibit A (the “Services”). The Services are based on Option B of Contractor’s proposal titled Let Love Guide Your Way by Lloyd Goradesky – Proposal for Art Conservation Services (the “Proposal”). The Proposal is incorporated only to the extent it describes the technical scope of Option B. Any price, exclusion, confidentiality restriction, payment term, limitation, assumption, or other legal or commercial term in the Proposal is rejected and does not apply unless expressly stated in this Agreement. Any exclusion, assumption, or limitation expressly accepted by the City shall be specifically identified in Exhibit A. Exhibit A is attached to and made part of this Agreement as of the Effective Date. Contractor shall perform the Services in a professional and workmanlike manner, using personnel experienced in outdoor sculpture conservation and in accordance with: (a) the American Institute for Conservation of Historic and Artistic Works Code of Ethics and Guidelines for Practice; (b) manufacturer requirements for all coating and treatment products; (c) applicable laws, codes, permits, and safety requirements; and (d) the standard of care ordinarily exercised by qualified conservators performing comparable work in South Florida’s coastal environment. 2. Contract time and schedule Contractor shall not begin work until the City issues a written Notice to Proceed (“NTP”). Within ten (10) calendar days after the NTP, Contractor shall submit a detailed project schedule for City approval. 2 Contractor shall achieve Final Completion within one hundred twenty (120) calendar days after the NTP, subject to written extensions approved by the City in accordance with this Section. The schedule shall identify deinstallation, transport, post-blast inspection, substrate repairs, coating application and cure periods, return transport, reinstallation, and delivery of closeout documentation. Time is of the essence. Contractor shall promptly notify the City in writing of any circumstance that may delay performance, identify the expected effect on the critical path, and propose reasonable mitigation. Notice does not itself extend the Contract Time. Contractor is entitled to an extension of the Contract Time, without cost to the City, for delay not caused by Contractor, including named tropical storms or hurricanes and related site or facility closures; acts of God; governmental restrictions; concealed or regulated conditions addressed under Sections 4 or 8; City-caused delay; and unreasonable delay in City review, approval, authorization, or direction required under this Agreement. Ordinary weather reasonably anticipated for the location and season, Contractor or subcontractor labor disputes, and material or equipment unavailability that Contractor could reasonably have anticipated or mitigated do not automatically entitle Contractor to an extension. Contractor shall request the extension in writing within ten (10) business days after the delay becomes known. The request shall identify the cause of the delay, its effect on the critical path, the additional time requested, supporting documentation, and Contractor’s mitigation efforts. The City shall not unreasonably withhold or delay approval of a reasonable extension to the extent the delay actually affects the critical path and was not caused or contributed to by Contractor or its subcontractors. An extension under this paragraph provides additional time only and does not entitle Contractor to additional compensation unless expressly authorized through a written change order. 3. Compensation and payment The City shall pay Contractor a fixed, lump-sum amount not to exceed Twenty-Nine Thousand Seven Hundred Forty-Five Dollars ($29,745.00) for complete and accepted performance of the Services. The amount includes all labor, supervision, materials, equipment, rigging, transport, travel, per diem, overhead, profit, insurance, permits, disposal, documentation, and other costs necessary to complete the Services. The City is exempt from Florida sales tax and will provide its exemption certificate upon request. Contractor remains responsible for taxes imposed on Contractor or its suppliers. 4 Contractor may invoice only after completion and City acceptance of the following milestones: Milestone Acceptance requirement Amount 1 2 3 $9,700 Each invoice must identify the milestone, describe the work completed, and include supporting photographs and documents reasonably requested by the City. Payment is subject to the Florida Prompt Payment Act, section 218.70 et seq., Florida Statutes. The City shall review and either accept a milestone or provide written notice of any nonconforming or incomplete items within ten (10) business days after receipt of the invoice and all required supporting documentation. The City shall respond to the post-blast condition report, and to any other complete submittal requiring City approval, authorization, or direction under this Agreement, within ten (10) business days after receipt. The City’s failure to respond within that period does not constitute acceptance or approval, authorize Contractor to proceed with additional or irreversible work, or entitle Contractor to additional compensation. Payment does not waive defects, release Contractor from responsibility, or constitute acceptance of nonconforming work. 4. Site conditions, inspection, and changes Contractor acknowledges that it reviewed the October 2025 assessment prepared by RLA Conservation, LLC and conducted its own site review. Contractor has included in the Contract Price those conditions reasonably observable during Contractor’s site review and disclosed in the October 2025 assessment. The Contract Price includes the corrosion, coating deterioration, missing or corroded hardware, and other conditions identified in the assessment or reasonably observable during Contractor’s site review. Contractor is not responsible for concealed, latent, or undisclosed conditions that materially differ from the conditions reasonably anticipated based on the October 2025 assessment and Contractor’s site review and that were not caused or aggravated by Contractor or its subcontractors. Any adjustment to the Contract Price or Contract Time arising from such a condition must be authorized through a written change order executed by the City before the additional work is performed. 5 After coatings are removed, Contractor shall stop affected repair work and provide the City with a written post-blast condition report describing any concealed corrosion, compromised welds, structural loss, or other condition that materially differs from the conditions reasonably anticipated. The report must include photographs, recommended treatment, a description of the work Contractor considers outside the original scope, the anticipated schedule effect, and an itemized price, if any. Submission or acceptance of the report does not authorize additional work, compensation, or time. Contractor shall not perform extra work or incur additional compensation without a written change order executed by the City before the work is performed. Oral direction, field discussions, emails from non-authorized personnel, or Contractor’s unilateral action do not amend this Agreement. If the City does not approve a proposed change, Contractor shall protect the Artwork and await written direction without compromising its condition. If the City does not issue written direction within twenty (20) business days after Contractor submits a complete proposed change order, Contractor shall provide written notice identifying the reasonable, documented, incremental costs of continued storage and insurance. The parties shall promptly meet to determine whether to authorize those costs through a written change order, modify the treatment, direct the return of the Artwork, or terminate the remaining Services under Section 16. Contractor shall not transport, return, reinstall, release, or otherwise dispose of the Artwork without the City’s prior written direction. Any return or reinstallation shall be performed in a manner approved by the City that protects the Artwork and does not expose unfinished metal or otherwise compromise its condition. All additional compensation remains subject to a written change order, lawful appropriation, and availability of funds. 5. Care, custody, transportation, and risk of loss From the commencement of deinstallation until Final Acceptance after reinstallation, Contractor has exclusive care, custody, and control of the Artwork and bears the risk of loss of or damage to it, except to the extent caused by the City’s negligence, by the pre-existing condition or inherent vice of the Artwork, or by an event beyond Contractor’s reasonable control as described in Section 2. The exclusions for a pre-existing condition, inherent vice, or an event beyond Contractor’s reasonable control apply only to the extent the loss or damage was not caused or aggravated by Contractor’s or its subcontractors’ handling, packing, transportation, storage, security, treatment, coating, reassembly, reinstallation, negligence, or failure to comply with this Agreement or the applicable standard of care. 6 Contractor shall use qualified riggers and transporters, appropriate packing and support systems, secure indoor storage, climate and environmental controls appropriate to the treatment, and commercially reasonable security. The treatment facility and storage arrangements described in Exhibit A, including performance of blasting and coating at the facility of Contractor’s approved subcontractor, satisfy the requirements of this paragraph and are approved by the City as of the Effective Date, provided that Exhibit A specifically identifies the facility, its address, the subcontractor, the work to be performed there, the applicable storage and security measures, and the insurance covering the Artwork while at that facility. Approval of the facility does not waive Contractor’s responsibility for the care, custody, security, storage, treatment, or protection of the Artwork. Contractor shall not move the Artwork to a different facility or release it to a third party without the City’s prior written approval. Before deinstallation, the parties shall execute a photographic condition and custody receipt identifying all components transferred. Contractor shall immediately notify the City of any loss, theft, accident, damage, or material change in condition and shall preserve all evidence relating to the event. No repair of accidental damage may begin without the City’s written approval, except emergency stabilization reasonably necessary to prevent additional harm. 6. Artist consultation and treatment approvals Contractor shall consult with the artist, if reasonably available, before irreversible treatment to confirm the intended color, finish, movement, and appearance. The City shall be included in material communications with the artist. Artist consultation does not authorize a change in scope, price, or schedule. If the artist is not reasonably available, or if the City’s authorization or participation required under Section 7 is not provided within ten (10) business days after Contractor submits a complete written request identifying the approval or participation needed and providing all supporting information reasonably necessary for the City’s review, the resulting delay shall entitle Contractor to a reasonable extension of the Contract Time, but only to the extent the delay actually affects the critical path and is not caused or contributed to by Contractor. The City’s failure to respond does not constitute approval or authorize Contractor to proceed with irreversible treatment. Any additional compensation remains subject to a written change order. Before applying the final coating, Contractor shall submit the proposed coating system, product data, color sample or drawdown, gloss level, and application method for written City approval. Approval does not transfer responsibility for means, methods, compatibility, adhesion, durability, or compliance with the standard of care. 7 7. Artist’s rights and copyright Contractor acknowledges that the City’s ownership or control of the physical Artwork does not necessarily include ownership of the copyright or the artist’s rights under the Visual Artists Rights Act, 17 U.S.C. § 106A, or other applicable law. Contractor shall not intentionally distort, mutilate, modify, destroy, materially alter, or change the color, finish, configuration, kinetic operation, artistic elements, attribution, or appearance of the Artwork except in accordance with the treatment plan approved in writing by the City and, when required by the City, the artist. Contractor shall promptly notify the City if any proposed treatment, newly discovered condition, or repair may affect the artist’s copyright, right of attribution, right of integrity, reputation, or other protected interest. Contractor shall not obtain or attempt to obtain a waiver, consent, release, license, or approval directly from the artist without the City’s prior written authorization and participation. Any artist approval required by the City must specifically identify the Artwork and the approved treatment or modification and must be documented in writing before the affected work begins. Nothing in this Agreement constitutes a waiver, assignment, transfer, or expansion of any copyright or moral right belonging to the artist. Except for project documentation delivered to the City under this Agreement, Contractor shall not reproduce, publish, advertise, display, distribute, license, or use images of the Artwork, the artist’s name, or the project for promotional or commercial purposes without the City’s prior written approval and any additional permission required from the artist or copyright owner. 8. Protection of property and safety Contractor shall protect the Artwork, concrete plinth, sidewalks, landscaping, irrigation, utilities, structures, and the public. Contractor is responsible for barriers, traffic or pedestrian control, equipment stabilization, spill prevention, overspray containment, dust and debris control, and compliance with applicable occupational and environmental requirements. The City shall reasonably cooperate in providing any City authorization required to close or occupy a public street, sidewalk, or park area. Contractor shall prepare and timely submit all plans, applications, traffic- or pedestrian-control plans, and other information required for such authorization and shall comply with all conditions imposed by the City. Contractor remains responsible for obtaining and paying for all other permits, licenses, and approvals required for the Services. Contractor shall repair, replace, or restore property damaged by its operations to a condition equal to or better than its pre-work condition, at no additional cost to the City. The City will provide reasonable access to available water, electricity, sanitary facilities, and a laydown area, but Contractor shall verify suitability and shall provide any temporary connections or protections needed for its work. 8 Before disturbing existing coatings, Contractor shall determine and implement legally compliant handling, containment, worker protection, transportation, and disposal procedures for coating debris, blasting media, solvents, and other wastes. Contractor shall perform or obtain any testing reasonably necessary to characterize the existing coating and resulting waste before disturbing the coating, unless the City provides acceptable existing test results. The Contract Price includes ordinary testing, containment, worker protection, handling, transportation, and lawful disposal associated with removal of the existing coating and performance of the Services. If testing identifies lead, chromium, or another regulated constituent not reasonably apparent from the existing records, Contractor shall stop the affected activity, protect the Artwork and site, and submit a written plan addressing the condition. If testing identifies lead, chromium, or another regulated constituent not reasonably apparent from the existing records, Contractor shall stop the affected activity, protect the Artwork and site, and submit a written plan addressing the condition. If testing identifies a regulated constituent or concentration that materially differs from conditions reasonably anticipated by a qualified conservator based on the existing records, the nature and age of the Artwork, and Contractor’s site review, Contractor may submit a proposed change order under Section 4. Contractor is not entitled to additional compensation or time unless the City executes a written change order before the additional work is performed. No regulated material may be discharged to soil, landscaping, stormwater, sanitary systems, or City containers. Contractor is responsible for releases caused by its operations and shall provide disposal manifests or other documentation upon request. 9. Personnel and subcontractors Chad Shores shall serve as Principal Conservator and remain responsible for treatment decisions and quality control. Contractor shall not replace the Principal Conservator or subcontract deinstallation, rigging, transportation, blasting, welding, coating, or reinstallation without the City’s prior written approval, which shall not be unreasonably withheld or delayed. Subcontractors and the Principal Conservator identified in Exhibit A are approved as of the Effective Date. Contractor remains fully responsible for all subcontractors and shall bind them to applicable requirements of this Agreement. No subcontract creates a contractual relationship between the City and a subcontractor. 9 10. Inspection, acceptance, and warranty The City may inspect the Artwork and work in progress at reasonable times, including at the treatment facility. Contractor shall provide at least five (5) business days’ notice before media blasting, commencement of coating application, return transportation, and reinstallation. The City may reject work that does not conform to this Agreement and require correction at Contractor’s expense. The Contract Price includes two mobilizations to the site, one for deinstallation and one for reinstallation, as stated in Exhibit A. Additional mobilizations requested by the City or made necessary by an approved change may be addressed through a written change order, but only to the extent the additional mobilization is not caused by Contractor’s or its subcontractors’ act, omission, delay, defective work, failure to coordinate, or failure to comply with this Agreement. No additional mobilization is compensable unless authorized in writing by the City before it occurs. Final Acceptance occurs only after the Artwork is safely reinstalled and its kinetic components operate in a manner consistent with their documented pre-treatment condition and the mechanical scope stated in Exhibit A, the site is restored, all punch-list items are completed, and the City receives and accepts the final treatment report and closeout materials. Contractor’s mechanical scope is limited to inspection and lubrication of the existing mechanical components as stated in Exhibit A. Machining, bearing or bushing replacement, and fabrication or replacement of mechanical components are not included in the Contract Price and may be addressed by written change order. Notwithstanding the foregoing, Contractor remains responsible, at no additional cost to the City, for correcting any damage to or impairment of the mechanical or kinetic components caused or aggravated by Contractor’s or its subcontractors’ deinstallation, handling, transportation, storage, treatment, coating, reassembly, or reinstallation activities. The City shall complete its final inspection and either issue Final Acceptance or deliver a written punch list within ten (10) business days after Contractor’s written notice of completion and delivery of all required closeout materials. The City’s failure to respond within that period does not constitute Final Acceptance, waive nonconforming work or latent defects, or authorize final payment. Contractor warrants for one (1) year after Final Acceptance that its workmanship will be free from defects, coatings will not prematurely peel, blister, delaminate, or fail due to deficient preparation or application, and repaired or replaced components will perform as intended. This warranty excludes damage caused by vandalism, collision, City-directed alteration, an extraordinary event beyond the design limitations of the approved system, or the City’s material failure to perform specific maintenance expressly identified in Contractor’s final written maintenance recommendations, but only to the extent Contractor demonstrates that such failure directly caused the claimed damage. 10 The warranty also excludes a condition of the existing substrate only if Contractor identified and documented the condition in the post-blast report, advised the City in writing of its effect on the warranty, and obtained the City’s written acceptance of the condition before applying the coating system. Contractor shall begin warranty correction promptly after written notice and complete it at no cost to the City. 11. Documentation and ownership of records Contractor shall provide a final electronic treatment report in PDF format containing: pre- treatment, during-treatment, and post-treatment high-resolution photographs; condition findings; treatment methods; materials and product data; coating batch and color information; cure conditions; repairs and replacement hardware; names of treatment personnel and subcontractors; maintenance recommendations; and any manufacturer warranty actually issued for the coating system. Contractor does not warrant that the coating manufacturer will issue a project-specific warranty, which may require a certified applicator, third-party inspection, or other conditions outside the Contract Price. The City owns the project-specific reports and photographs upon payment and may use, reproduce, disclose, and archive them for governmental, maintenance, educational, and public-record purposes. Contractor retains ownership of its pre-existing methods and know-how but grants the City a perpetual, royalty-free license to use any such material included in the deliverables. As a condition of final payment, Contractor shall provide a final affidavit confirming payment of its subcontractors and suppliers and releases of lien or claim in a form acceptable to the City. Contractor shall keep the Artwork and City property free of liens, security interests, storage charges, possessory claims, and encumbrances arising from the Services. Contractor shall not withhold or retain the Artwork as security for a disputed payment and shall return it promptly when directed by the City, without waiving either party’s lawful remedies. 12. Insurance Before the NTP and throughout the period in which Contractor has any obligation or custody of the Artwork, Contractor shall maintain insurance issued by authorized insurers and provide certificates and endorsements acceptable to the City: • Commercial general liability: $1,000,000 per occurrence and $2,000,000 general aggregate, including products-completed operations, contractual liability, and care, custody, or control coverage without an exclusion that defeats coverage for the Artwork. • Automobile liability: $1,000,000 combined single limit for owned, hired, and non-owned vehicles. 11 • Workers’ compensation: statutory limits, and employers’ liability of at least $500,000 each accident, disease-policy limit, and disease-each employee, unless a lawful exemption is documented and accepted by the City. • Professional liability/errors and omissions for conservation services: $1,000,000 per claim and aggregate, maintained for at least two years after Final Acceptance. • Fine arts/inland marine coverage, including transit, rigging, loading, unloading, storage, and treatment, on an all-risk basis in an amount equal to the Artwork’s replacement value, which the City shall state in writing before the Effective Date, with the City named as loss payee. The City and its officials, employees, and agents shall be additional insureds on the general and automobile liability policies on a primary and noncontributory basis. Contractor shall provide waivers of subrogation where commercially available. Deductibles and self-insured retentions are Contractor’s responsibility. Insurance does not limit Contractor’s liability or indemnity obligations. Contractor shall confirm the availability and cost of all required insurance before executing this Agreement. Delivery of certificates, endorsements, and evidence of fine-arts coverage acceptable to the City is a condition precedent to issuance of the NTP and to Contractor’s possession of the Artwork. If Contractor cannot obtain the required coverage, the City may, after consultation with its Risk Manager, elect to modify or waive a particular requirement in writing or terminate the Agreement without liability. Contractor is not entitled to an increase in the Contract Price based on its insurance costs unless the City materially changes the insurance requirements or the stated replacement value after the Effective Date and authorizes an adjustment through a written amendment or change order. City Comment: The City agrees to provide the Artwork’s replacement value before the Effective Date so Contractor can price and bind the required coverage. Contractor must confirm its insurance costs before execution. The City cannot agree to an automatic price adjustment based on Contractor’s internal insurance allowance. If the required insurance cannot be obtained, the City may determine whether to modify the requirement or terminate before the Artwork is transferred. 13. Indemnification To the fullest extent permitted by law, Contractor shall indemnify and hold harmless the City and its officials, employees, and agents from claims, damages, losses, liabilities, fines, penalties, and reasonable attorneys’ fees and costs, to the extent caused by the negligence, recklessness, intentional misconduct, breach of this Agreement, or violation of law by Contractor or anyone for whom Contractor is responsible. Contractor’s duty includes claims arising from injury, death, property damage, environmental release, infringement, or loss of or damage to the Artwork while in Contractor’s care, custody, or control. 12 Nothing in this Agreement waives the City’s sovereign immunity or expands the limits of section 768.28, Florida Statutes. This section survives termination. 14. Independent contractor; compliance with law Contractor is an independent contractor and controls its personnel and means and methods, subject to the results and requirements of this Agreement. Nothing creates an employment, agency, partnership, or joint venture relationship. Contractor shall obtain and pay for all licenses and permits required for the Services and comply with applicable federal, state, county, and municipal laws. Contractor shall comply with section 448.095, Florida Statutes, regarding use of the E-Verify system. Contractor shall require each subcontractor to provide the affidavit required by law and shall retain it for the duration of the Agreement. The City may terminate this Agreement as required by section 448.095. Contractor certifies that it is not on the convicted vendor list or discriminatory vendor list and is not prohibited from contracting with a public entity under applicable Florida law. Contractor shall provide any affidavit or certification required by sections 287.133, 287.134, or 287.135, Florida Statutes, if applicable. 15. Public records Contractor shall comply with Florida’s Public Records Law. To the extent Contractor is acting on behalf of the City, Contractor shall: 1. Keep and maintain public records required by the City to perform the Services; 2. Upon request from the City’s custodian of public records, provide the City with a copy of requested records or allow inspection or copying within a reasonable time at a cost that does not exceed the cost provided by law; 3. Ensure that records exempt or confidential and exempt from disclosure are not disclosed except as authorized by law; and 4. Upon completion, transfer to the City, at no cost, all public records in Contractor’s possession or keep and maintain them as required by law. If Contractor transfers all records, it shall destroy duplicate records that are exempt or confidential and exempt. All electronically stored records must be provided in a format compatible with the City’s systems. IF CONTRACTOR HAS QUESTIONS REGARDING THE APPLICATION OF CHAPTER 119, FLORIDA STATUTES, TO CONTRACTOR’S DUTY TO PROVIDE PUBLIC RECORDS RELATING TO THIS AGREEMENT, CONTACT THE CITY’S CUSTODIAN OF PUBLIC RECORDS AT 954-924-6800, CITYCLERK@DANIABEACHFL.GOV, OR 100 W. DANIA BEACH BOULEVARD, DANIA BEACH, FLORIDA 33004. 13 16. Termination and suspension The City may terminate this Agreement for convenience upon seven (7) calendar days’ written notice. In that event, the City shall pay for conforming Services actually performed and accepted through the termination date, including the reasonable, documented pro rata value of any milestone in progress, plus reasonable, documented, noncancelable commitments approved by the City in writing before they were incurred, and the reasonable documented costs of demobilization, return transport, and reinstallation of the Artwork directed by the City, less prior payments and amounts due the City. Contractor is not entitled to anticipated profit on Services not performed**, unabsorbed overhead, consequential damages, or any other termination charge.** The City may suspend work or terminate for cause if Contractor fails to perform, endangers the Artwork or public, violates law, fails to maintain insurance, or otherwise breaches the Agreement. Except in an emergency or a breach not reasonably curable, the City will provide written notice and ten (10) calendar days to cure, provided that, if the breach cannot reasonably be cured within ten (10) calendar days, the City may approve additional time in writing if Contractor begins corrective action within the initial cure period, provides a reasonable written cure schedule, and diligently pursues the cure to completion. Upon suspension or termination, Contractor shall immediately stabilize and protect the Artwork and, at the City’s direction, return and safely reinstall or deliver it to a location designated by the City. The City’s rights and remedies are cumulative. 17. Notices Formal notices must be in writing and delivered by personal delivery, nationally recognized overnight courier, or certified U.S. mail, return receipt requested, to the addresses below. Email may supplement but does not replace formal notice unless receipt is acknowledged in writing. City Contractor Attn: City Manager 100 W. Dania Beach Boulevard Dania Beach, Florida 33004 Attn: Chad Shores 847 Mayfair Circle Orlando, Florida 32803 14 18. Miscellaneous Appropriation. The City’s obligations are subject to lawful appropriation and availability of funds. Assignment. Contractor may not assign this Agreement or any right to payment without the City’s prior written consent. No third-party beneficiaries. This Agreement benefits only the parties and creates no right in any other person. Governing law and venue. Florida law governs. Exclusive venue for any action lies in Broward County, Florida. Attorneys’ fees. Each party shall bear its own attorneys’ fees except as otherwise required by law or expressly provided in this Agreement. Waiver; severability. A waiver is effective only if written and applies only to the specific instance. If a provision is unenforceable, it shall be severed or limited to the minimum extent necessary, and the remainder remains effective. Order of precedence. In a conflict, the order of precedence is: (1) written amendments and change orders; (2) this Agreement; (3) Exhibit A; and (4) the technical portions of the Proposal. Contractor’s standard terms never control. Entire agreement; amendment. This Agreement and its exhibits are the entire agreement regarding the Services and supersede prior discussions and proposals. An amendment must be in writing and executed by authorized representatives of both parties. Counterparts and electronic signatures. The Agreement may be executed in counterparts and by electronic signature, each of which is deemed an original and together constitute one instrument. Authority. Each signer represents that the signer is authorized to bind the identified party. SIGNATURES ON THE FOLLOWING PAGES 15 IN WITNESS OF THE FOREGOING, the parties have set their hand and seal the day and year first written above. CITY OF DANIA BEACH, FLORIDA, a Florida municipal corporation ELORA RIERA, MMC JOYCE L. DAVIS CITY CLERK MAYOR APPROVED AS TO LEGAL FORM AND CORRECTNESS EVE A. BOUTSIS, CITY ATTORNEY CANDIDO SOSA-CRUZ, ICMA-CM CITY MANAGER 16 CONTRACTOR: WITNESSES: SHORES ART CONSERVATION LLC, a Florida limited liability company SIGNATURE SIGNATURE PRINT Name PRINT Name SIGNATURE Title PRINT Name STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me by means of ☐ physical presence or ☐ online notarization, on , 2026, by _______________ (name), _______________________ (title), of SHORES ART CONSERVATION LLC, a Florida limited liability company, who is personally known to me or has produced as identification. NOTARY PUBLIC My Commission Expires: State of Florida Let Love Guide Your Way by Lloyd Goradesky Proposal for Art Conservation Services January 2, 2025 REVISED SEPTEMBER 16, 2026 Prepared for Prepared by The City of Dania Beach Chad Shores Community Development Principal Conservator ℅ Cultural Planning Group Shores Art Conservation 954.804.3044 321.541.5500 linda@culturalplanning.com chad@shoresconservation.com Proposal for Art Conservation Services Shores Art Conservation www.shoresartconservation.com 321.541.5500 To Whom It May Concern: Thank you for the opportunity to provide a proposal to conserve the Let Love Guide Your Way sculpture by Lloyd Goradesky sited in Art Park in Dania Beach, Florida. We’ve reviewed the condition assessment report performed and authored by RLA Conservation and performed our own cursory condition assessment of the piece on-site. Based on our observations and those documented by RLA, we are pleased to present the following proposed scopes of work and associated cost estimates. ABOUT OUR PRACTICE Shores Art Conservation is a trusted partner for art collectors, designers, and museums navigating the challenges of Florida’s coastal climate. Salt air, high humidity, and extreme weather events pose constant risks to outdoor art, requiring specialized expertise. Founded by Whitney and Chad Shores, our practice delivers tailored conservation solutions that protect both the beauty and long-term value of significant art collections. Chad brings over a decade of experience in sculpture conservation, with a focus on outdoor works sited in coastal environments. Our work adheres to the highest professional standards, as outlined by the American Institute for the Conservation of Historic and Artistic Works (AIC). ARTWORKS TO BE TREATED • Let Love Guide Your Way by Lloyd Goradesky sited at Arts Park in Dania Beach, Florida OBSERVATIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS After reviewing RLA’s condition assessment and treatment proposal of the piece, Chad Shores, Principal Conservator for Shores Art Conservation, visited the site on December 12, 2025 to review the artwork in person. We found conditions consistent with those found by RLA during their assessment in October 2025. Please find annotated photos of our observations in Exhibit A at the end of this treatment proposal. Considering the scale and condition of the sculpture, we would recommend that the city consider carrying out a full-scale restoration of the piece in the controlled conditions of an off- site studio. Temporary stabilization treatment of the piece, as outlined in the condition assessment provided by RLA, would only serve as a temporary stop gap measure and not address the wholesale deterioration of the sculpture. We agree with RLA’s opinion that there would also be considerable time spent hiding spot treatments in-situ that could not be guaranteed to weather consistently as the untreated areas of the sculpture. We believe it would be a better use of the city’s resources to uninstall the piece, transport it to an off-site Proposal for Art Conservation Services Shores Art Conservation www.shoresartconservation.com 321.541.5500 facility for treatment and restoration, and perform a final reinstallation of the restored sculpture. With that being stated, we would offer the following options for the city’s consideration. OPTION A – TREATMENT AS PRESCRIBED BY RLA Our firm would prefer to perform this work from an articulating boom lift so we can address all of the identified issues with better access. We are including protection of adjacent surfaces including sidewalks, grass, and plantings in our proposal. PROPOSED TREATMENT: 1.Document the treatment with a written report and high-resolution digital photographs. Provide a Dropbox link to all treatment images as well as recommendations for ongoing routine maintenance. 2.Rinse the sculpture with filtered tap water. Follow this with a cleaning of a conservation grade detergent and filtered tap water. Rinse with filtered water followed by a distilled water rinse. 3.Carefully remove, source, and replace corroded hardware with appropriate 316N grade stainless steel washers, nuts, and bolts. This will be done in a manner that does not compromise the sculpture’s secure connection to the plinth. a.Add a corrosion mitigating anti-seize lubricant to the hardware that comes in direct contact with mild steel. 4.As needed, spot clean areas of significant soiling and mineral deposits with organic solvents. 5.Gently remove areas of loose paint material on the sculpture using hand tools and gently spot abrade areas of paint loss down to sound material. 6.Degrease metal and prepare for repainting. 7.Spot prime areas of bare steel with a zinc rich primer via brush. a.Allow to cure per manufacturer’s instructions. b.Sand to an appropriate texture. 8. Prime areas of loss with an industrial-grade primer via brush. a.Sand to an appropriate texture. b.If needed, apply additional coats to build up thickness to blend with adjacent surfaces. 9.As needed, fill areas of dimensional loss to the steel substrate. a.Sand to an appropriate texture. 10.If fills are needed, apply an additional coat of primer to prevent swelling of the fill material sand to an appropriate texture. Proposal for Art Conservation Services Shores Art Conservation www.shoresartconservation.com 321.541.5500 11. In-paint areas of loss with a conservation grade paint suitable for metal surfaces via airbrush to blend with the surrounding color. a. Given the flat smooth nature of the sculpture and the red pigmented topcoat, color matching and blending of repairs is incredibly difficult. The client should expect the area of repair to be visible under close inspection (less than 5’). Due to fading of the sculpture, the inpainting color for specific areas may need to be adjusted based on their exposure to UV. This is a time-consuming process and requires on site testing by a Conservator. i. Please note, even though the area of repair will blend with adjacent surfaces, the in-painting material will age and weather differently than the original coating system as they are different ages and made of different binders and pigments. As such, the in-painted areas may become more pronounced over time and require the in-painting to be renewed in the future. 12. Apply appropriate varnish to blend with the finish of adjacent surfaces and provide mitigation from damaging UV light. 13. Repaint concrete plinth with appropriate matte black mineral paint intended for masonry substrates. OPTION B – FULL RESTORATION • Consult with the artist prior to work activity to ensure proposed restoration treatment means and methods protect their artistic intention. • Mobilize to the site. • Adjacent surfaces including sidewalks, grass, and adjacent plantings will be temporarily protected during site work • A pre-treatment condition assessment of the sculpture will be performed from an articulating boom lift to determine and confirm the condition of the artwork prior to disassembly. Found conditions will be documented with photographic and written means. • The sculpture will be carefully rigged, systematically disassembled, and lifted during deinstallation activity. The sculpture components will be carefully packed and strapped onto a transport vehicle for delivery to our off-site facility for treatment. • Transport the sculpture components to our facility for media blasting and refinishing. Media blast the sculpture components to remove the existing coatings and fully reveal underlying corrosion. • Perform a condition assessment of the sculpture after coatings are removed to assess the full extent of any underlying corrosion or other potentially compromised conditions that may be unforeseen. Share findings with the client. • Treat and fill corroded portions of the sculpture components with appropriate corrosion inhibitor and fill materials. Restore original profiles, shapes, and dimensions to apparent areas that have been lost due to corrosion. Proposal for Art Conservation Services Shores Art Conservation www.shoresartconservation.com 321.541.5500 • Inspect and lubricate mechanical components of the sculpture to ensure proper movement and performance. • Replace any steel hardware components in the sculpture assembly with appropriate 316N stainless steel hardware. • Repair and/or replace compromised welds with appropriate in-kind material. • Prepare the surface of the sculpture components to receive the new coatings system in accordance with manufacturer’s surface preparation recommendations. • Apply a high performance three-coat industrial coatings system that includes the following: a zinc rich primer, an epoxy intermediate coat, and followed by a top coat with outstanding resistance to ultra-violet light degradation. The top coat will be color matched to the artist’s original choice of color. All coatings will be applied according to manufacturer recommendations. • Once the coatings system has appropriately cured according to manufacturer recommendations, the sculpture components will be carefully packed for transportation back to the site. • The existing concrete column will be painted with an appropriate matte black mineral paint intended for masonry substrates. A waterproofing membrane will be installed to avoid moisture contact between the painted sculpture and the concrete column. • Transport the sculpture components and re-mobilize to the site. • Adjacent surfaces including sidewalks, grass, and adjacent plantings will be temporarily protected during site work • Sculpture components will be carefully rigged, systematically lifted and reassembled during reinstallation activity. • Installation hardware will be replaced with appropriate 316N grade stainless steel washers, nuts, and bolts. • At the completion of site work, all materials, debris, and equipment will be removed, and the site will be returned to its pre-existing condition. • All work will be performed and documented to American Institute for Conservation of Historic and Artistic Works (AIC) standards. A brief treatment report will be provided after the completion of work to include a summary of treatment processes, photo- documentation (before, during, and after photos), and all product data. Unless otherwise specified, the report will be delivered electronically in PDF form. • The duration for this option will be approximately six weeks. Proposal for Art Conservation Services Shores Art Conservation www.shoresartconservation.com 321.541.5500 COST Option Treatment Scope of Work Cost A Conservation treatment as outlined by RLA’s Condition Assessment Report with amended access $22,130 B Complete conservation treatment and restoration of the sculpture as outlined above. $29,745 Our estimated costs are based on observations made from ground level. Because these observations are limited, unforeseen conditions may be discovered once close access to the upper sections of the sculpture is obtained. INCLUSIONS -Labor -Materials -Equipment -Insurance that is typically required by the City of Dania Beach Procurement Services as listed on their public website: General Liability, Automobile Liability, and Workers' Compensation. -Standard working hours -Per diem and travel costs EXCLUSIONS -Tax (if applicable) -Additional or specialized insurance beyond what is required by the City of Dania Beach Procurement Services as listed on their public website: General Liability, Automobile Liability, and Workers' Compensation. - Multiple mobilizations -Water & power at the site -Sanitary facilities -Laydown area and storage for equipment and supplies during installation/reinstallation activities We are grateful for the opportunity to potentially serve the City of Dania Beach and their public artwork. Thank you, Chad Shores Whitney Shores Principal Conservator Managing Director Proposal for Art Conservation Services Shores Art Conservation www.shoresartconservation.com 321.541.5500 PLEASE NOTE • This proposal contains proprietary information from Shores Art Conservation. This proprietary information is submitted solely for the purpose of evaluating the proposal and it is understood and agreed that this information shall be kept confidential where allowed by law. • If applicable to your project, a signed Capital Improvement Certificate or tax- exempt certificate must be submitted. If we do not receive a completed certificate indicating that this work falls under the capital improvement or tax-exempt programs, appropriate sales and/or use tax will be added to the price upon invoicing. • If applicable, pricing assumes regular working hours days. Overtime, additional shifts, or additional workers to accommodate a compressed schedule are not included in our pricing. • Shores Art Conservation preferably will accept payment by electronic bank transfers, details of which will be provided upon contract. Work shall occur on a mutually agreeable schedule to be determined between the Client and Shores Art Conservation after our receipt of a purchase order or signed contract. Proposal for Art Conservation Services Shores Art Conservation www.shoresartconservation.com 321.541.5500 EXHIBIT A – Annotated Images of Observations Detail image of corroded mild steel components found on the sculpture. Active corrosion is occurring underneath the failed coatings system and will continue to break through the failed coatings. Proposal for Art Conservation Services Shores Art Conservation www.shoresartconservation.com 321.541.5500 Detail image of corroded steel found on the sculpture. As the corrosion progresses, it will continue to expand outward as the substrate material breaks down. The area indicated by the arrow has completely corroded and will require removal and reinstatement. Proposal for Art Conservation Services Shores Art Conservation www.shoresartconservation.com 321.541.5500 Detail image of the axle housing and attachment plate that illustrates several locations where active corrosion is visible underneath (and broken through) the coatings as indicated by arrows. These surfaces are compromised and will require corrosion mitigation and recoating. Proposal for Art Conservation Services Shores Art Conservation www.shoresartconservation.com 321.541.5500 Detail image of extensive corrosion visible on the front and base plates of the axle housing. This corrosion will continue to progress until is it mitigated back to sound steel material and recoated with an appropriate industrial coatings system. Proposal for Art Conservation Services Shores Art Conservation www.shoresartconservation.com 321.541.5500 Detail images of representative areas of active corrosion observed on the sculpture during our cursory on-site assessment. Corrosion is especially evident along leading edges, where water runs off (top left); in areas where moisture is retained through capillary uptake (top right); and in depressions where water pools (lower left and lower right). The presence of biological growth (visible in the lower left image) suggests that standing water is particularly prevalent in these locations. Chad Shores Principal Conservator Professional Biography Chad entered the field of art conservation and historic restoration in 2014 after completing his master’s degree in historic preservation and materials conservation at Columbia University’s School of Architecture. Chad has executed a variety of public and private projects, ranging from short-term preliminary art condition assessments to multiyear restoration projects. He has been fortunate to work on some of the most significant sculptures, technological artifacts, and historic buildings found in the United States. Areas of Expertise o Conservation Assessment and Treatment of Public Art Installations o Sculpture, Objects and Architectural Conservation o Project Development and Management Education 2013 Master of Science, Historic Preservation and Materials Conservation Columbia University Graduate School of Architecture, Planning and Preservation, New York, NY 2007 Bachelor of Arts, History Lee University, Cleveland TN Professional Association 2019 Board Member and Officer Florida Association of Public Art Professionals Representative Honors & Awards 2022 Jefferson Memorial – Roof and Portico Stone Restoration Design & Construction Award – DC Preservation League Drexel University – Great Court Ceiling Restoration Grand Jury Award, Preservation Alliance for Greater Philadelphia 2019 The John and Mable Ringling Museum, Ca’ d’Zan – Terra Cotta Restoration Outstanding Achievement in Restoration/Rehabilitation, The Florida Trust for Historic Preservation Representative Projects The John and Mable Ringling Museum | Sarasota, FL Project Manager and conservator for multiple projects at the Ringling Museum most notably the conservation treatment of a full scale bronze edition of Michaelango’s David, complete refurbishment of an early 20th century wooden floor imported from Europe, and an award-winning terra-cotta restoration of the historic Belevedere Tower. Perez Art Museum Miami | Miami, FL Project Manager and conservator for annual conservation maintenance of a collection of sculptures on outdoor display in Florida’s maritime environment, including works of art by Mark di Suvero, Jedd Novatt, Anthony Caro, and Pablo Atchugarry. Kennedy Space Center | Cape Canaveral, FL Project Manager and conservator overseeing multiple conservation treatments of spaceflight artifacts. Projects include select components of a Saturn IB rocket on outdoor display, partial reconstruction and conservation treatment of a historic Gemini-Titan engine, conservation cleaning of the Space Shuttle Atlantis, and treatment of an early Saturn V F1 engine prototype Chad Shores Principal Conservator US Capitol Building | Washington, DC Project Manager for stone restoration on the west façade of the US Capitol Building, including stone consolidation of historic stone, chemical stripping of painted coatings, and the application of new potassium silicate coatings to the historic stone. Thomas Jefferson Memorial | Washington, DC Project Manager and Conservator for the laser cleaning and steam cleaning restoration of the Thomas Jefferson Memorial for the National Park Service. University of Florida, Art in State Buildings | Gainesville, FL Conducted a comprehensive conservation condition assessment for over 60 pieces of public art sited at the University of Florida. Provided conservation treatment and maintenance recommendations for each piece. Prioritized treatments based on the condition of each piece. Developed budgets for on- going care, restoration, and conservation treatments. University of West Florida | Pensacola, FL Conservation consultant for twenty-one public art proposals submitted to the STEAM sculpture project on-campus. Provided the selection committee conservation oversight for the proposed materials to be used. Offered recommendations for the long-term durability of each proposal. Provided mitigation measures to ensure the long-term success of the completed public art project. Art in Public Places | Jacksonville, FL Project Manager and conservation oversight for 24 public art pieces in the City of Jacksonville’s collection. Reviewed and coordinated condition assessments of each piece and developed budgets for on-going care, restoration and conservation treatments. Managed and coordinated restoration and conservation treatment for 14 selected works of art. UN Plenary Hall | New York, NY Conservation technician for the conservation treatment of two Leger murals and historic Dutch metal finishes inside the United Nations assembly space. Call-Collins House | Tallahassee, FL Lead architectural conservator for the conservation treatment of historic 19th century entryway windows, including replication and replacement of lead ornament, wooden tracery,and period glass lights. The Red House | Port of Spain, Trinidad Project conservator for the conditions assessment and packing of historic plaster ceiling elements of the Senate chamber ceiling inside the historic Parliament for the Republic of Trinidad and Tobago Wyoming State Capitol | Cheyenne, WY Conservator for the historic finishes investigation uncovering historic decorative paint, stenciling, and early 20th Century wallpaper from three historic decorative campaigns. Representative Sculpture Conservation Treatments Performed in Private Practice Composed Presence, Albert Paley Untitled, by Joel Shapiro Anasazi, by Allan Houser Gilalay and Ginnetoy, Boaz Vaadia Wind Sphere, George Sherwood The Drummer, Barry Flanagan Le Penseur, Auguste Rodin Trial Scene, Tom Otterness Jaguar Bench, Judy Kensley McKie Harmony, Ruth Bloch Seward Johnson, Seward Johnson Atelier Jill Goodacre, Glenna Goodacre Chad Shores Principal Conservator