Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutProvided under City Attorney ReportNovember l1 , 2026 Office of the Attomey General James Uthmeier Attention: Opinions Division Collins Building 107 West Gaines Street Tallahassee. FL 32399 Re: Implementation of Senate Bill 1 134 Dear Attomey General The City of Dania Beach has historically provided funding for local high school students to attend Florida Boys State and Florida Girls State sponsored by the American Legion and American Legion Auxiliary through Post 209. At the direction of the City Commission, I request an advisory opinion conceming the application ofsections 166.04971 and 287.139, Florida Statutes, enacted by chapter 2026-43, Laws of Florida, to the City's continued support of these programs and to a proposed grant approved and paid before Jarr.l:ry 1,2027 . i. Whether section 166.04971, Florida Statutes, prohibits a municipal grant approved and fully disbursed before January 1" 2027, solely because the recipient expends the funds after that date for students to attend Florida Boys State and Florida Girls State in 2027. Does the answer depend on whether the City must take further official action concerning the grant after January 1,2027? 2. 2. Whether, on or after January i, 2027, section 166.0497 | prohibits the City from providing equal grant funding for Florida Boys State and Florida Girls State, where independent nonprofit organizations administer substantially similar civic education programs and participation in each program is limited by sex. 3. 3. Whether any exception or rule of construction in section 166.04971 permits such funding, including subsection (7)(b)4. or subsection (7Xd)3., and whether the federal heatment ofBoys State and Girls State under 20 U.S.C. $ 1681(a)(7) affects that analysis. Background history on the Legion and Programs: The Legion Family consists of subgroups known at the American Legion, the American Legion Auxiliary, Sons of the American Legion and the American Legion Riders. Questions Presented: The American Legion Auxiliary was founded in 1919, and administers hundreds of volunteer programs. The American Legion Auxiliary is the world's largest women's patriotic service organization. Members are often the mother, wife, daughter, sister, grand-daughter, great-grand- daughtel or grandmother ofmembers ofThe American Legion, and deceased veterans who seled in the United States Armed Forces during eligible war eras. The Florida Boys State program website advises it is an educational program designed for rising high school boy seniors to experience the workings ofloca1, county, and state govemment through a mock govemment simulation. "Pa(icipants, called "citizens," engage in elections, legislative sessions, and judicial processes, gaining practical knowledge of civic responsibilities and leadership skills in a non-partisan environment." The program operates as a 501(c)(3) organization. Florida American Legion Boys State prepares young men for civic engagement, leadership roles, and a deeper understanding of govemment. Annually, 530 boys attend in Florida. Over 20,000 participate nationwide. The Florida Girls State Program sponsored by the American Legion Auxiliary, is also a 501(c)(3). This program is also a non- partisan, non-political, non-sectarian program, like Boys' State, that attempt to teach govemmental processes for young women. Girls State "was organized as a national Americanism activity ofthe American Legion Auxiliary in 1947 to inspire and develop interest in the study of govemment, foster civic leadership, but most of all, to stimulate a desire to protect the privileges and responsibilities of the United States' democratic form of govemment. Outstanding high school girls attend Girls State each year." Nationally about 20,000 young women attend yearly. Florida has 300 each year. For several years the Cif of Dania Beach has sponsored grants to the American Legion for high school boys to attend Boys State, and the American LegionAuxiiiary for high school girls to attend Girls State. The funds are provided to American Legion Post 209. The Cost is approximately $600, per student. I have contacted the American Legion and American Legion Auxiliary to determine whether they have and DEI policies. I did not find any on their websites. Howeveq I am waiting on confirmation, so as to ensure compliance with F.S. 287.139, which prohibits a recipient of a municipal grant from usi-ng municipai frrnds in "requiring its employees, contractors, volunteers, vendors, or agents to ascribe to, sfudy, or be instructed using materials relating to diversity, equity, and inclusion ... as defined in [Florida Statutes Section] 166.04971(1)." Facts: The City would like to continue to provide funding to these two programs in the future. The City is concerned with the application of Senate Bill 1 134, which becomes effective Jmuary 1, 2027 . The bill enacted, amongst other statutes, F.S. Section 166.04971, entitled "Prohibition of official The American Legion was founded by an Act of Congress after World War I. The American Legion advocates for support ofevery generation ofveterans, service members, and their families who pledge to protect our nation. actions of municipalities relating to diversity, equiry and inclusion; penalty; remedy." The statute defines diversity, equity and inclusion as: (1)(b) "Diversity, equity, and inclusion" means any effort to:*** 2. Promote or provide preferential treatment or special benefits to a person or group based on that person's or group's race, color, sex, ethnicity, gender identity, or sexual orientation; or 3. Promote or adopt fiaining, programming, or dctivities designed or implemented with reference /o race, color, sex, ethnicity, gender identity, or sexual orientation. The statute also provides that a "municipality may not fund ot promote, directly or indirectly or take any official action, including, but not limited to, ... programs, or policies, as it relates to diversity, equity, and inclusion. Nor can the City promote "activities designed or implemented with reference to ... sex." The City's concem is that the programs' sex-based eligibility requirements may bring the proposed funding within section 166.04971(1Xb), particularly subparagraph 3. Although the City would provide equal funding for substantially similar programs administered by independent nonprofits, those circumstances may not resolve the issue because subsection (2) reaches indirect municipal funding and promotion. The City therefore seeks clarification before proceeding. The City also requests consideration of the exceptions and rules of construction in subsection (7). In particular, the City seeks guidance conceming subsection (7)@)a. and whether the programs' treatment under federal education law has any bearing on subsection (7Xd)3. The City is not representing that participating students are trauma-involved or at-risk youth; any reliance on that circumstance would require factual verification. Application to payment before the effective date The City is considering approving and fully disbursing a grant in December 2026 for students' padcipation in the 2027 programs. The recipient would retain the funds and apply them to program expenses in 2027 . The City requests clarification whether that later expenditure, without a further municipal appropriation or disbursement, would cause the completed pre-effective-date grant to violate section | 66.0497 l. The City further requests guidance conceming whether the answer depends on any continuing municipal role after January 1,2027, including student selection, payment authorization, grant administration, or promotion of the programs. Because subsection (4) characterizes a violation as misfeasance or malfeasance in office. the Citv seeks clarification before acting on the proposed grant. Because Section 166.04971 provides enforcement mechanisms and potential consequences for noncompliance, the Ci[ seeks guidance before taking future action. The City is looking to fund these programs in December 2026 to the American Legion. The American Legion and Auxiliary would disburse the funds in 2027 to pay for the students' participation in the two programs. Would this disbursement in December for use in 2027 be considered a violation ofthe statute? Conclusion The City seeks clarification regarding the application of section 166.04971, Florida Statutes, to municipal grants supporting the Florida Boys State and Florida Girls State programs, both ofwhich are longstanding civic education progftrms administered by independent nonprofit entities. Specifically, the City requests guidance as to whether equal funding of both programs would constitute prohibited funding or promotion ofdiversity, equity, and inclusion under the statute. and whether grant funds approved and fully disbursed by the City before Jau:ruary 1,2027 , but expended for program activities occurring after that date, would be affected by the statute's restrictions. The City seeks this guidance to ensure compliance before approving the proposed grants. Given the proposed December 2026 funding schedule, the City respectfully requests expedited consideration.