Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutR-2005-106 Stirling Suites Site Plan RESOLUTION NO. 2005-106 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY OF DANIA BEACH, FLORIDA, APPROVING THE SITE PLAN REQUEST SUBMITTED BY RICHARD G. COKER,JR.,ESQ., COKER & FEINER, ON BEHALF OF B & JCM PROPERTIES, LLC, FOR PROPERTY GENERALLY LOCATED AT THE NORTHWEST CORNER OF INTERSTATE 95 AND STIRLING ROAD, DANIA BEACH; PROVIDING FOR CONFLICTS; FURTHER, PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. WHEREAS, Section 8.4 of Article 1 of Chapter 8 of the Code of Ordinances of the City of Dania Beach, Florida, states that a site plan is required as a condition to the issuance of a building permit; and WHEREAS,the firm Coker&Feiner, on behalf of B & JCM Properties LLC, has applied for site plan approval for the proposed construction of a 150 room hotel, for property generally located at the northwest corner of Interstate 95 and Stirling Road, Dania Beach; and WHEREAS, the Planning & Zoning Board on June 15, 2005 recommended that the City Commission grant the site plan request(SP-16-04),based upon the criteria set forth in Section 8.4 of Article 1 of Chapter 8 of the Code of Ordinances of the City of Dania Beach; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF DANIA BEACH, FLORIDA: Section 1. That that certain application (SP-16-04) for site plan approval, a copy of which is attached and made a part of this Resolution as Exhibit"A", is approved. It is further noted that the original Site Plan is maintained in the office of the Community Development Department of the City of Dania Beach. Section 2. That based upon the criteria set forth in Section 8-4(p)of Article 1 of Chapter 8, of the Code of Ordinances of the City of Dania Beach, all site plan approvals shall automatically expire and become null and void unless building permits are obtained on or before 18 months from the date of this Resolution. Section 3. That all resolutions or parts of resolutions in conflict with this Resolution are repealed to the extent of such conflict. Section 4. That this Resolution shall be in force and take effect immediately upon passage and adoption. PASSED AND ADOPTED on September 13, 2005. C."', 6,; ANNE CASTRO MAYOR-COMMISSIONER ATTEST: ROLL CALL: . COMMISSIONER ANTON - YES -�� COMMISSIONER BERTINO - YES LOUISE STILSON COMMISSIONER MCELYEA - YES • CITY CLERK VICE MAYOR FLURY -NO MAYOR CASTRO - YES APPROVED AS TO RM AND CORRECTNESS BY: /�% i M'- THOMIAS J. ANSBRO CITY ATTORNEY 2 RESOLUTION#2005-106 AGENDA REQUEST FORM CITY OF DANIA BEACH A- AGENDA ITEM NO.- To 1. DATE OF COMMISSION MEETING: SEPTEMBER 13, 2005 2. DESCRIPTION OF AGENDA ITEM: PUBLIC HEARING—SITE PLAN REQUEST SP-16-04 (CONTINUED FROM AUGUST 23,2005 HEARING) 3. COMMISSION ACTION BEING REQUESTED: ADOPT RESOLUTION 4. SUMMARY EXPLANATION & BACKGROUND: The applicant, Richard Coker, Jr. Esq. on behalf of the property owner B&JCM Properties, LLC., is requesting variances and site plan approval to allow the construction of a 150 room hotel located at the northwest corner of Interstate 95& Stirling Road. 5. ATTACHED EXHIBITS AND ADDITIONAL BACKUP MATERIALS (PLEASE LIST): Resolution Staff Report Comment Sheets Application Location Map Survey Site Plans 6. FOR PURCHASING REQUESTS ONLY: Dept: Amount: $ 7. REVIEWED AND APPROVED FOR ADDITION ON AGENDA: Submitted by: Laurence G. Leeds, AICP, Director Date: AUGUST 10, 2005 Community Development Department City Manager Date . CITY OF DANIA BEACH COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT STAFF REPORT DATE: September 13, 2005 T0: Ivan Pato, City Manager VIA: Laurence Leeds, AICP, Director Corinne Church, AICP, Principal Planner C,V -- SUBJECT: VA-25-05/SP-16-04: The applicant, Coker & Fiener on behalf of the property owner B&ICM Properties, LLC., is requesting variances and site plan approval to allow the construction of a 150 room hotel located at the northwest corner of Interstate 95 & Stirling Road. VARIANCES: • 1) To allow 6 stories; 5 stories permitted. 2) To allow 153 parking spaces; 175 spaces required. 3) To allow a pole sign area of 100 square feet; 48 square feet permitted. SITE PLAN: 150 room Best Western hotel VARIANCE ANALYSIS 1. To allow 6 stories The code allows a maximum of 5 stories, 62 feet tall building. Height variances for 6 - 10 stories have been previously approved for hotel use along the I-95 corridor. 2. To allow 153 parking spaces. The code requires 175 parking spaces for a 150 room hotel. The applicant is proposing, 153 parking spaces, or 1.0 parking space per room. The Springhill Suites and Hilton Gardens (located on Stirling Road behind the Burger King) each provide 1.1 spaces per room. • Wyndham and Marriot hotels both obtained parking variances (0.75 and 1.0 spaces per room respectively) based on a commitment to provide dedicated airport shuttle service. The applicant has agreed to provide such a service. 3. To allow a pole sign area of 100 square feet. The hotel is directly visible from I-95. The sign code also permits significant wall signage for a building of this size at this location. The hotel is separated from the interstate by an exit ramp, therefore staff can support a variance to allow a 100 square foot pole sign. SITE PLAN ANALSIS The applicant is requesting approval to construct a 150 room hotel with associated parking &. pool. The submitted plans were distributed for review to several City departments. The Broward Sheriff's Office reviewed the project for Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design (CPTED) principals and recommended changes, which the applicant has agreed to provide. The applicant has obtained a tree preservation/removal permit (approved by . the city landscape consultant) for the site. CITY COMMISSION PREVIOUS ACTION On July 26, 2005 the City Commission continued this item to allow the applicant and adjacent property owner to work with FDOT regarding property access for both sites. On August 9, 2005 the City Commission continued this item at the applicant's request. On August 23, 2005 the City Commission continued this item to allow the applicant to meet with FDOT and the neighboring property owner. PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD RECOMMENDATION VARIANCES 1. Building Height: Approval for 6 stories. 2. Parking: Approval, provided applicant provides dedicated airport and seaport shuttle service. 3. Pole Sign: Approval for 100 square feet. SITE PLAN Approval, provided the applicant addresses BSO's most critical CPTED issues. Engineers, l nn rs , Surveyor 0100 Boulevard of C 617 North Lauderdale, FL 33066 � 5 Babcor-k St.-Urdt B. Palm Bay, FL 32909 tel: (954)96"100,fax:(954)989-M tel:(321)874-9336,fax:(321)674-3&U E-mail:denuzzlo(Mbsllsouth.nat LEER OF MANSMMAL TO: Corinne Church, Growth Development DATE: June 1, 2005 City of Dania Beach 100 W. Dania Beach Blvd. Dania Beach, FL [PROJECT NO: 01023 954.924.3704 - - RE: Stirling Suites JUL - F _ TOTAL NUMBER OF (S): 1 1'! PAGES PER SET: 1 I)ear Corinne, Enclosed please find the Are test results for Stirling Suites to be 1`0 i arded to Freddck , the City consulting engineer for utilities, per elr request Iandly contact me at 954.969.5100 ext.3 If you have any q ons regarding this matter. Thank you, �►�' Johanna J. �eig (y" JUN -I zl o'7 1 TRANSMITTED VIA: FedEx DATE: June 1, 2005 L RECEIVED BY: SENT BY: BB _ r:vonan►, - r ■ r ! 4 , pp _ + F , } S _ e a + a '9 i � 3 v x� f e w , 4 i ,�`r,�'``r. .1 i ; ,� � 'i •.'tit+,f`r�. :r - ♦ .af• � �`S'�:-tom#� .. y� r Ord •. •� �T.' ,�.J f., ra t� � r: •+ •®� , Pot , Thmo , , �. no Min b 4wr A. Freder ®h er, PHID. P.E. Offw@: (954'-926-3492 ors/sits raiew sw"suhes dot a Calvin, viordano & Associates, Inc. Engineers * Surveyors • Planners June 17,2005 Ms.Corinne Church,AICP Planning and Zoning Department City of Dania Beach 100 West Dania Beach Boulevard Dania Beach, Florida 33004 RE: Site Plan Review=Stirling Suites,SP-16-04 COA Project No, 97-1826.8 review#7 Dear Ms. Church: We have reviewed information submitted in response to our June 2, 2005 letter and v all items have been addressed to our satisfaction. They also have responded satisfactorily to items 3 through 8 in Attachment A of your Staff'Report dated June 1 S,2005. " Please let me know if you have any comments or questions. Calvin, Giordano and Associates, Inc. is an independent reviewing entity and has no financial or professional interest in this project or with the entity making this site plan application. Sincerely, CALVIN,GIORDANO Jk ASSOCIATES,INC. i . Karl Ke edy, P.E. Reply to: Assoeia 0 1$00 Eller Drive,Suite boo Fort Lauderdale,FL 33316 Phone:954.921.7781 Fax:954.921.8w7 560 village Blvd.,Suite 340 • , West Palm Beach,FL 33409 Phone:561.684.6161 Fax:561.694.6360 OL-calvin-giordano.com P:IProjects\19971971926 Dania MiscellaneousTnginecringlCorrespondenccILetters and Re'ports\Stirling Suites 7rdt rev Site Plan.doc w CITY OF DANIA BEACH COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT ROUTING SHEET `l 1 y��'` •MGL j0�is.f.. Route Date: , PZ Log; 3p,j -04I Project: Stirling sultea Folio: 50�2.33-OA-0370 Route Via: Mail Pickup: In-house: ❑ PLEASE REVIEW THE ABOVE REFERENCED PROJECT FOR COMMENTS TO BE INCORPORATED IN THE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIRECTOR'S STAFF RECOMMENDATION TO THE PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD AND CITY COMMISSION. PLEASE LOG YOUR TIME SPENT AND COMMENTS ON THE ATTACHED REPORTING SHEET. THANK YOU. ❑ Fire Marshall: L7 Planner. ® Public Service: (] Landscape Consultant ❑Approved as submitted: p Denied: Comments must be addressed and resubmitted prior to City Commission Approved with conditions: List conditions: L _ Signature •_._._.__._._ . . _ 1 �X1111)ro1' Print Name 1 Cal, �, Giordano & Associates, soclates, Inc. Engineers o Surveyors 0 Planners June 2,2005 Public Service Departfient City of Deals Beach 100 West Dania Beach Boulevard Dania Beach, Florida 33004 R'Z: Site Plan Review—Stirling Suite,, SP-16-04 CDA Project No. 97-1826.8 review�6 Comments are noted below for the above noted site lam P . Review date—611105 Route Date—5/27/05 1; Sheet 2 of 9 Site Plan ` �Ceq 6 "Sight distaere given in notes but no graphical representation 2. Sheet 3 of 9 Wate;and Sewer Plan was shown, 2.1 The designer appended a Plan s . connection (about 1,500 eet in len numbered 3'�of 9. It shows a circuitous the Property, cutting th on a 3" PVC forced main) between along SW 18th Court and SW 1st Strettfor ,ridge and ramps) . running station. The 3" PVC forced main is tie-in with an existing lift The designer needs to should mall. A ��� slue allowed is 4", existing ground surf and an P�vide longitudinal profiles showing the Based on the proposed profiles we wlould ities or obstructions along the route. not. As a general note, the plan is quite confusing to whether ders understand work or number of unnecessary Information. a to a Proposed wet well discharging to? Please provide the route . It is recommended that DIP be used for sanitary line from the RrPh to: line, the forced main outside casements. e ro ants, property 1800 Eller Drive.Sidle goo. 2.2 The water main connection Fort Lauderdale.FL Sy516 Phone;934.911.7781 west of this connection,point and thereforis to an e has only which dead ends just Fax:954.941.8807 We have concerns that since the water main is not looped one at source °f water. ❑ 560 village Blvd,Strite 540 may be compromised. We recto fire protection West Palm Brach,FL 55409 another source of water and require a recommend that this water main be looped to Fax.36 -684.6M.0 , issuance of the engineering q PPfOYal °f the fire faa:561.684.6.1f� department prior to 8 permit for this project. Page 2 3. Sheet of 9 Pavin June 2,Zoos 4 ' . g and Drainage Plan . 3.1 ' Please provide a copy of the storm water management calculations.has not been addressed, This comment still 3.2 It is recommended that slope for the proposed dry retention South Florida Water Management District Permit Information be 4:1 (maximum Manual Volume.IV. per �• Sheet 6B of 9 Lift Station Details Please provide a lift station site plan at 1"=10' scale showing the . fencing and proposed grading. This comment still has not been t location of utilities, dressed. . . Please let me know if you have any comments or Inc, is an independent reviewing entity and has no questions. Calvin, (3iordanu and Associates, or with the entity making this site lan a financial or professional interest in this project P application.' Sincerely, CALVING GIORDANO & ASSOCIATES,INC. Karl Kennedy ' E. .Associate i P:\Pro*101997,971826 Dania MiscellaneausIFngineering\Cortespondence'l.etters and ReportslStirlin®Suites 6rd rev Site Plan dui ' R ! - CITY OF DANIA BEACH COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEP ARTMENT ROUTING SHEET x Rout® Date: 6/8/2005 ', PZ Log: 3�-9 Project: Stlrling Sultes Follo: 5042-33-00_p370 Route Via: Mail ❑ Pickup: 52 _ .._........ ._._._......_-... ..... ... ; In- PLEASE REVIEW THE ABOVE REFERENCED PROJECT O COMMENTS TO BE Q INCORPORATED IN THE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIRECTOR'S STAFF RECOMMENDATION TO THE PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD AND CITY COMMISSION, PLEASE LOG YOUR TIM SPENT AND COMMENTS ON THE ATTACHED REPORTING SHEET. THANK YOU. E D Fire Marshall: ❑ Planner: • -- _-�] Public Services 0 BSO-Richard Tarrant(CPTED Review LJ A roved as submitted: CJ Denied: Comments must be addressed and resubmitted prior to City Commission APProved with conditions: List conditions: Signature JKOWK. 7�e/wiV-T Print Name Date KEN JEANE SHERff BROWARD COUNTY P•O.BOX 9507 FT•LAUDERDALE, FL. 33310 MEMO TO: Larry Leeds GMwthMftef City of Dank Beach FROM: Detective Richard DATE: June 13,2005 SUBJECT: Western At your request I Miewed the site plan for the Beg Western Hotel. the I�9S co r. O the for savim g stele s w pvM UPOD tourist ad ' hawl 'ots of motelsrs st our hotels. Numerous resultim insto + P is the • bWUPWO Security and not folio the C.P.T'.E.D. the tatels for the Broward s In � ns of the cukwh were well onOWW ��and Way north or south on I-9S to I havergvLwW the site pIn and as a Crime making the folio n recommendations ssres to be ° I a� ed. ® Video Ve forone camm wCeL "CM to record 24 hours 7 days a week, tapes ® I • umm • lot so the ' � under , art the grounds and entire aa=is ® Instanc8memto capture both interior and exterior doors and around the entire par1�lot, to include bvv co Ys• avoid co foliage to ® Install two C81M=she by side at the end to n of the vehicle. ® to •ghtiM �P both driver tag to Mu , a the entire gr+ound& ® Post si a It the entrance stag* Property is Under Surveill =.nstall gates to control BMW into the they vuaDand be issued a O A is checked in gate pass to enter tine Post si at the allguests - area. Run complete l kground c on allall potential to drop off e, G5°4b'a CITY OF ®- O I. 6 BEACH j COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT ROUTING SHEET Route Date: 7/a0t)g; IllPZ Log: ��.'. . . .. ... . . . Project: Sterling Sulttea Folio:r5042-B-00-0370 Routo\ft Mail p Pickup: p In-houso: PLEASE REVIEW THE ABOVE REFERENCED PROJECT FOR COMMENTS TO BE INCORPORATED IN THE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIRECTOR'S STAFF RECOMMENDATION SPENT AND COMMENTS ON THE ATTACHED REPORTING SHEET.THANK YOU. ❑ Firo Marshall: 91 Planner. C] Public Service: ❑ Landscape Consultant 0 Approved as submitted: ❑ Denied: )Ocomments must be addressed and resubmitted prior to City Commission v Approved with conditions: List conditions: @�. ran ycL*Cj,-J �OvY1 � Signature Print Name Date i I Stirling Suites SP-16-04 6-1.05 1• Incomplete Information nformation was provided, therefore additional review and comm be provided by staff at time of further review of this project. ant will 2. 1 wall sign per street frontage Is permitted, however, 4 w all sign submitted; 2 for east elevation, 1 for west elevation, 1 for north elevation. were 3. Provide letter from solid waste provider ion. Clarify, required to service proposed building size and regarding collect on schedule dumpsters agreement/contract is not sufficient). 2"d request. hedule (service 4. Provide Ilghting plan showing foot candle levels as identified in th Check List. 2 request. a City's Document 5. Submit parking security and lighting plan for review by S SO. 2n4 request. NOTES 0 Color rendering of all sides of building and fence is needed for P Commission submittals. &Z and City 0 One wall sign per street frontage is permitted on east facade facing Leeds 11-23-04), g 195 (per L. ° The City now has a new landscape consultant, therefore new comments will be provided. landscape VARIANCES 0 6 stories 0 parking 0 pole sign area Church Corinne From: Frederick Bloetscher(h2o man(Qbellsouth.not) Sont: Monday,May 30, 2005 3:11 PM To: bods®denuzzb .com Cc: Leeds, Larry;Church,Corinne;Tarmey, Ed Subject: SUdIng SUltes Hotel Good Morning Boris I have received and reviewed Your plan submittal for the above project. Thera,w and Mr. Tarmay on the project, were 5 issues raised by Mr. Leeds 1. Number and spacing of fire hydrants-there are now three, no more than 4 2. SPOdeI notes were added to the PlanaOA f®et apart. This is sufficient 3. Planting around the fire hydrant was removed and hydrant Went barter areas -this 18 sufficient 4. Fire flow caleulatlone w®rp submitted b a od-this Is sufficlant flow test conducted at�®Oita to Oct tho b Ilne dato used fbr tho analysis? If Y regieter®d PE. The submittal is sufficient,but woo them a fire to me(fQx 954-923-2602). If not you need a fire flour tes4. The line 8� pleasm provide a copy S. Looping of the pipeline in Itp currsrnt configuration can only be The e i the I ®la the street should be Oufflci®nt sO flor the line to be Winded by future prof®rty owners. This line the®asem on � You have left must be conveyed to the City to permit�ture looping. No spite la lin will be a 083te line require the next developer to do to this line and extend it with Intent that loopin Itt nt over this l Some point d. Thm city will g be accomplished at OPQ this Is helpful to you Should You have any questions, pleas®let me know. Sincerely Fred Bioetscher, Ph®, PE 5/31/2005 CITY OF DANIA BEACH i COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT ROUTING SHEET Rout®Date: d7/2Q9l3, PZ Log: Project: Stirling Saw Folio: 804a-33-00-p370 Route Via: Mall ❑ Pickup: ® In-house: ❑ PLEASE REVIEW THE ABOVE REFERENCED PROJECT FOR COMMENTS TO BE INCORPORATED IN THE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIRECTOR'S STAFF RECOMMENDATION TO THE PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD AND CITY COMMISSION. PLEASE LOG YOUR TIME SPENT AND COMMENTS ON THE ATTACHED REPORTING SHEET. THANK YOU. ❑ Flan Marshall: ❑ Planner. ❑ Public Service: ® Landscape Consultant N_;APProved as submitted: ❑ Denied: _ ❑ Comments must be addressed and resubmitted prior to City Commission Approved with conditions: List conditions: �i Signature G Print Na e i Date City of Dania ®each, Florida Gro*th Management Department Planning and Zoning Division (954)924-3E4,1 2 ® Plat ®evel®p�gent A '.';ark - ® Vadanc® PpBOca t®. Special Exception sit®Man Q Rezoning ®ate,RG'de ® Land U80 Change ® AoWgnment Of Flex/Reserva Unite Petition Ri®.s__P.l�Di- other tl n Request ® ® er This appllcaft must be Completed In full and submitted a U s W LL NOT®t �with all n L Its Coif PEACED oig A ItodetermingARDurnents for be APPROPRIATE the suefOr n�pAPirequired on Type and .�u � ON'@ AGENDA CN F®R EACN TYd W1>� STAFR Docu�ftPR�� � State � sue. Fu1A C"'O •a�� DE THE Sg� Of ftrkl4 went and a prop design Pro*signed and searequired a mud Collated In Pint proms to the Pertinent Is. The aPPikant of record architect utha"r� For alb� aPPltCatbns, the responsible 11x:1r failure b®attendp u ons�n record shall the a Pot the dis Present at�board hears applicant or their authorized legal agent must be pre5ena at allPm a orb Pled on an Location Address: Inge. agenda, ems): Bloc. Subdivision: Recorded Plat Name: g I '�C Ol 7M Folio Number(s); 2. I ®� Legal Description: Present Zoning:.� Present Land Use:'r Wp Explanation of Request: ^ c . �V�t "t Prop. Net Acreage: of Gross Acreage: Prop, Square Footage: ��l (060 s r- Value of Improvement: U�,0 00�p00 Esed Date of Completion:Will Project be Phased: 1°-C , ;Cp1 Exrs 1 ( If yeS' Esed Completion of each Phase: t't l 31. '' (y dng use: CAl�T LIA+�u� < Proposed Use: C �t Name of App"c nVConsultant/Representative(drde one): 'l—A lib Address of Applicant; L VAS Ia rtZ� i Business Telepha Home: 3O S 'AA 108 Fax: 305 Ai Name of pm PedY Owner: Address of Property Owner: 3�01 (1 tJ 1 07`�AA1C 5 �� � Aul rcr. :: 3 i ?8 Business Telephone: joS'�t�7 9i 3 . y Home: _ 30 s 2 � 70�3� Fax: d 4 S2 S I i Q ( , Ust any additional melon (Le. special exception,variance, rezoning, etc.)that may betm support P project: Ust all previous actionthat has occurred on this property: NOTES ALL SIGNATURESBUST Ili<i� NOT'ERIZE® ®� OI�ERE® OF ®_ COMM9 ON, IA 6EACN Cny T to day subscribed befbre r►sulte hnZn 20,de A Publk S Sign ito of( .t ) (Prim Nance) )0 7 i� Print Nance�Notary Sid I�3 �I �g'31 St Addre , Cam, State and Zip Cow Commission ComSeal: w 7 `% EDDTH ULTiI! O �13 yCOMMrsNONroDUMTermsNx EX�!RSS:5er".trabrt 7�,20A'/ WHER9 POMONER IS NOT THI OWNER 0(� THE SUBJECT PROPf�i�T�, PL THL,FOLLO►NIN®t E COMPLETE This Is t® certify that I am the owner of subject lands described above and that I have(APPlkant/Consubnt/Representative) a authorized application. to make and file the aforesaid Sworn to and subscribed before me This day of 20 Owner: Signature: Date: Sign Name of Notary Publk State of( ) (Print Name) Print Name of Notary Street Address, City, State and ZIp Code Commission Expires: Seal: Telephone No.&Fax No. � � 1 LOCATION: • I I I I � I f I f i Thai I f SRO I i I I • � 1 �v � . bitIla lllt �g,r� s a!s Isar g,leaa�l !� a H 1 a 8 u.�®ae aw.ram f Ia ►t I . � �1�� U7 wl ri 0 till',Z dri .` Igo �a 1a LWAL" ITAll fill 1111; ry J e LL