Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutR-2000-118 RESOLUTION NO. 2000-118 A RESOLUTION APPROVING THE VARIANCE REQUEST SUBMITTED BY WILLIAM DUFFEY, D.F. CONSULTANTS REPRESENTING MOTIVA ENTERPRISES, LLC., FOR PROPERTY LOCATED AT NW CORNER OF STIRLING ROAD AND "UNIMPROVED"SW 19TH COURT—LOCATED ON THE NORTH SIDE OF STIRLING ROAD WEST OF 1-95; PROVIDING FOR CONFLICTS; FURTHER, PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. WHEREAS, the Dania Beach Code of Ordinances, Chapter 28, Zoning, Article 28, Signs, sets the signage requirements for the City of Dania Beach; and WHEREAS, William Duffey, D.F. Consultants, representing Motiva Enterprises, LLC., has applied for a variance (VA-06-00) to allow Shell Oil to permit less than 15% window treatment along the secondary (east) elevation for property located at the NW corner of Stirling Road and "Unimproved" SW 19th Court — located on the North side of Stirling Road West of 1-95 , Dania Beach; and WHEREAS, the Planning & Zoning Board on June 21, 2000, recommended that the City • Commission grant variance request VA-06-00 based upon the criteria set forth in section 10.13 of Article 10, of Chapter 28, Zoning, of the Code of Ordinances of the City of Dania Beach; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF DANIA BEACH, FLORIDA: Section 1. That that certain application VA-06-00, for a variance as described above (from requirements in Chapters 28, Zoning, Article 28 Signs), a copy of which is attached as Exhibit"A"is approved with the following conditions: 1) Submission of the City Tree Trust Fund ($23, 429) payment prior to issuance of a building permit. 2) Construction of SW'h 19 Court abutting the site (to Public Works Department specifications) prior to issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy. 3) Deletion of all signage from service station construction drawings (separate sign permit required). 4) Tree #43 (Live Oak) to.be relocated "on site". R-VA-06-00 shell oil .doc 1 RESOLUTION NO. 2000-118 • 5 Canopies to be revised to provide a itched roof. p p p Section 2 . That all resolutions or parts of resolutions in conflict with this resolution are repealed to the extent of such conflict. Section 3. That this resolution shall be in force and take effect immediately upon its passage and adoption. PASSED AND ADOPTED THIS 25'h DAY OF JULY, 2000. ,57 C.K.MCELYEA MAYOR- COMMISSIONER ATTEST: ROLL CALL: MAYOR MCELYEA - YES 4Ci,-j VICE-MAYOR BERTINO- NO SHERYL dHAPPVAN COMMISSIONER CALI - YES ACTING CITY CLERK COMMISSIONER ETLING - YES COMMISSIONER MIKES- YES BY: THOMAS/J.`ANSBRO CITY ATTORNEY R-VA-06-00 shell oil .doc 2 RESOLUTION NO. 2000-118 CITY OF DANIA BEACH GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT STAFF REPORT TO: Michael Smith, City Manager FROM: Laurence Leeds, AICP, Director Growth Management RE: VA-06-00: Variance for Shell Oil to permit less than 15% window treatment along the secondary (east) elevation SP-03-00: Site Plan for Shell Oil Service Station, Convenience Store, and Car Wash (NW corner of Stirling Road and "unimproved" SW 19th Court — located on the north side of Stirling Road west of I- 95) DATE: July 25, 2000 City Commission Meeting VARIANCE The applicant is required to provide 15% window/door glass surfaces along the east side of the building opposite SW 19th Court. Staff supports this variance because SW 19th Court is a minor local street with little exposure. Also, applicant has made a significant effort at tree preservation and is providing in excess of the required minimum 30% pervious area. SITE PLAN ACCESS/LOCATION This site plan is located at the NW corner of Stirling Road and "unimproved" SW 19th Court, west of Interstate 95. SW 19th Court must be constructed along the east side of the site so as to permit adequate access to the site. Both the Public Works/Utilities Director and Fire Marshal recommend approval. Applicant has provided 20 parking spaces. LANDSCAPING Applicant exceeds the minimum 30% pervious area requirement. Also, the applicant has worked with City landscape consultant to preserve several trees, either in their present location or elsewhere on the site. The site plan configuration has been driven primarily by tree preservation. For those trees where relocation is not cost-effective, or where trees are in poor condition, the applicant is required to pay money to the City Tree Fund. This fee is • estimated to be between $23,000 and $26,000 and will be finalized at the Public Hearing. SHELLS ITEPLAN062100.doc ZONING DESIGNATION The property is zoned Broward County M-1 (Light Industry). Because the underlying land use is "Commercial", the Shell property is not subject to the IROM moratorium and will remain as M-1. Shell Oil initially began this project in June 1997, STAFF RECOMMENDATION (SITE PLAN AND VARIANCE) Staff recommends approval of both the variance and site plan subject to: 1) Submission of the City Tree Trust Fund ($23, 429) payment prior to issuance of a building permit. 2) Construction of SW`h 1'9 Court abutting the site (to Public Works Department specifications) prior to issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy. 3) Deletion of all signage from service station construction drawings (separate sign permit required). 4) Tree #43 (Live Oak) to be relocated "on site". 5) Canopies to be revised to provide a pitched roof. • PLANNING AND ZONING ADVISORY BOARD RECOMMENDATION Staff recommends approval of both the variance and site plan subject to: 1) Submission of the City Tree Trust Fund ($23, 429) payment prior to issuance of a building permit. �) Construction of SW`h 19 Court abutting the site (to Public Works Department specifications) prior to issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy. 3) Deletion of all signage from service station construction drawings (separate sign permit required). 4) Tree #43 (Live Oak) to be relocated "on site". 5) Canopies to be revised to provide a pitched roof (Completed). SHELLS ITEPLAN062100.doc • The following list of trees were inspected on the proposed Shell Oil site and have been determined to be in poor condition or not be cost effective to relocate them. It is recommended that these trees be removed and the estimated value be paid to the City of Dania Tree Trust Fund. Tree# Species DBH Estimated Value I. Live Oak 16" $1,953.33 - Live Oak 18" $2,060.15 5. Avacado 08" $ 0.00 6. Strangler Fig 24" $ 305.21 9. Strangler Fig 15" $ 238.44 10. Alexander Palm 06" $ 0.00 13. Live Oak 18" $1,236.09 15. Live Oak 18" $1,648.12 17. Live Oak 15" $ 715.33 18. Live Oak 18" $ 686.72 19. Live Oak 18" $1,030.07 20. Live Oak 20" $ 847.80 1. Live Oak 20" $1,530.27 23. Live Oak 15" $ 476.88 24. Live Oak 12" $ 171.68 25. Live Oak 14" $ 915.62 30. Strangler Fig 42" $1,682.45 • 31. Lead Tree 12" $ 0.00 32. Live Oak 14" $ 623.13 34. Live Oak 17" $ 306.27 35. Live Oak 16" $1,716.79 M. Live Oak 16" $1,884.75 -)T Avacado 08" $ 0.00 38. Avacado 15" $ 0.00 42. Live Oak 14" $ 623.13 43. Live Oak 13" $2,149.97 48. Live Oak 23" $ 0.00 50. Live Oak 23" $ 560.60 52. Live Oak 25" $ 662.34 54. Strangler Fig 15" $ 357.66 55. Avacado 07" $ 0.00 60. Gumbo Limbo 14" $1,196.40 TOTAL $25,579.20 * It is recommended that Live Oak 943 be relocated reducing the price total to $23,429.23. CITY OF DANIA BEACH '• ROUTING SHEET 100 W. Dania Beach Blvd. Dania Beach, FL 33004 Phone: (954) 924-3645 Fax: (954) 922-2687 DATE: May 31, 2000 PROJECT NAME Shell Oil PROJ. NO SP-03-00 -REVISED VIA: MAIL PICKUP IN-HOUSE X PLEASE REVIEW THE ABOVE REFERENCED PROJECT FOR COMMENTS TO BE INCORPORATED IN THE GROWTH MANAGEMENT DIRECTOR'S STAFF RECOMMENDATION TO THE PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD AND CITY COMMISSION. PLEASE LOG YOUR TIME SPENT AND COMMENTS ON THE ATTACHED REPORTING SHEET. THANK YOU. ❑ FIRE MARSHAL: Ed Tarmey • gK UTILITIES DIRECTOR: Bud Palm ❑ CITY ENGINEER: Calvin Giordanno ❑ PLANNING CONSULTANT: Leigh R. Kerr ❑ CITY ATTORNEY: Thomas Ansbro ❑ TRAFFIC CONSULTANT: Molly Hughes ❑ LANDSCAPING CONSULTANT: Bill Tesauro POLICE DEPT.: Chief Anton GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT- SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS/NOTES: • petition routing sheetdoc gig _ CITY OF DANIA BEACH ROUTING SHEET 100 W. Dania Beach Blvd. Dania Beach, FL 33004 Phone: (954) 924-3645 Fax: (954) 922-2687 DATE: May 31. 2000 PROJECT NAME Shell Oil PROJ. NO SP-03-00 -REVISED VIA: MAIL PICKUP IN-HOUSE X PLEASE REVIEW THE ABOVE REFERENCED PROJECT FOR COMMENTS TO BE INCORPORATED IN THE GROWTH MANAGEMENT DIRECTOR'S STAFF RECOMMENDATION TO THE PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD AND CITY COMMISSION. PLEASE LOG YOUR TIME SPENT AND COMMENTS ON THE ATTACHED REPORTING SHEET. THANK YOU. FIRE MARSHAL: Ed Tarmey G 1 5+00 0le- ❑ UTILITIES DIRECTOR: Bud Palm • ❑ CITY ENGINEER: Calvin Giordanno ❑ PLANNING CONSULTANT: Leigh R. Kerr ❑ CITY ATTORNEY: Thomas Ansbro ❑ TRAFFIC CONSULTANT: Molly Hughes LANDSCAPING CONSULTANT: Bill Tesauro ❑ POLICE DEPT.: Chief Anton GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT - SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS / NOTES: SIGNATI ME petition routing sheet.doc PULICE LAND SURVEYORS. INC. 5381 NOB HILL ROAD SUNRISE,FLORIDA 33351 u TELEPHONE(954)572-1777 • FACSIMILE(954) 572-1778 e-mail: surveys(dpulicelandsurveyors.com May 17 , 2000 Mr. Tom Turner Motiva Enterprises 6671 W. Indiantown Road, #56-459 Jupiter, Florida 33458 RE : SHELL SITE AT STIRLING ROAD &' SOUTHWEST 19TH COURT DANIA, FLORIDA Dear Tom, I Hereby Certify: that there are no Schools , Public Recreation Areas , Churches , or Chapels within 350 yards of the subject Shell property. • Sincerely, / 7CE7 SURVEYORS , INC. / John F. Pulica, Pres. Professional land Surveyor 42691 State of Florida xc: Bill Duffey e e stamp U APPLICATION( — O NUMBER: :ITY OF DANIA BEACH— O 00 TEST DANIA BEACH BLVD. u DANIA BEACH. FL 33004 °' . (954) 92 1-0 i 00 X262 APPLICATION FOR VARIANCE ^e inaersianea petitions the City Commission of the City of Dania 8eacn =ionda to consider -�,e variance or the carcel(s) of land describea in this application. 'LAME OF APPL(CANT >iilliam Duffey i D.F. --cnsuitants, =zc. -DDRESS OF APPLICANT 9000 Sheridan St. , .#136, Pembroke Pines, T 33024 Z^ =ROPERTY INTEREST OF APPLICANT Engineer x' 'NAME AND ADDRESS OF PROPERTY OWNER: Motiva Enterprises, r.LC ^50 S. .Iorthlake 450, Altamonte Springs, `-L 32701 DDRESS AND LEGAL DESCRIPTION OF SUBJECT PROPERTY' NIWIC! of S i rl i ng Road ant 9th (,-curt; Tract ":y" cf "-eto Park"; Folio #023337002 =pES?=NT �ONING.� -3 _OT SIZE'AREA: 4491 ac=eaQe!63124 SQ.FI'. P S U RESENT ! PROPOSED E OF PROPERTY Present use: Pr000sed use: Construct convenience store with car wash & seif-egtie gasoline ft ® DESCRIPTION OF VARIANCE (S): (LIST THE CODE SECTION YOU WOULD LIKE THE VARIANCE FROM AND WHAT 1S PROPOSED): Request variance from Section 6 . 64 ( 4) ( h) requiring 15% alass on secondary elevation _:STD-'E NAMES. .4DDRESSES ,-,ND PuONE `LUMBERS OF ANY CNSUL- "JT- :.F 44Y (I.E. :r;'ITE:--` .=•TTCRNE':` :•Iilliam Duffey P .E . i 954 ) -4846 000 Sheridan Street . 41 16 , Demhroke Dines , ='T. 7 -)r)? 1 PLEASE COMPLETE THIS PORTION OF THE APPLICATION CAREFULLY. EACH REQUEST FOR , VARIANCE MUST STAND ON ITS OWN MERITS WITHOUT REGARD TO ANY OTHER PROPERTY. --�e rciiowina auestions certain tc the criteria ucon wnich the CIN Commission =na F1annina and Zonrr =oara wiii consider this aopticavon. Describe how soeciai conditions and circumstances exist which are cecunar to the +and. structu ^r building mvolvea and wnicn are not aooticable to other ianas. =structures cr ouildinas in tt same zoning district. The cronosed site is basically an " in-lot" with no secondary st "he proposed 1 9th rr�urt 'yi i 1 he an access �-nari -n i v _ ornnnseci T: +-; cy;;t7 i -ter nrnvi rips -gat lira 1 harriers on tenth c i rip -1 Pvafii nns _ 4 =---vice eviaence t^at the =_cec:ai cncitions anc c:-c,-:mstances ::o not r=suit '-cm the actions c. ,-.e aooiicam. =ooiicant has curcnasea -.incieveioced 7rccer--- .;ii -onditions -:escrice now granting the reouestea variance(s) ✓Jni not confer anv seeciai onvilege on tht _ooucant that is eemeo cv the 7cnma ccce to cmer anas. cuiminas or structures in this same zonina oistnct. abundance of trees ,--and reauired `ree mit,_aation require arc-itectural variance -n 'cuildinct :esian. Provide evidence that the literal interpretation of the provisions of the zoning code would depriv' 'he applicant of rights commoniv en)oyeo by ,other properties in the same zoning distinct an, would worK unnecessary and undue hardship on the applicant. Literal inervretation of the code would reauire alteration of `he crevious v-atDnrov d t--ree mi iQatinn 1.escr.oe now the reauesteo variance is the minimum variance that :✓ui maKe possible th -easonaole use of the Tana. bwidino or structure. ' 1l -the*- rode reauiremerts have 2een ® :l "xoiain now the grant of the vanance(s) will be in narmony with the general intent and purpose the zoning code. and that such variances) will not be inlurious to the area involved or otherwi: detrimental to the public welfare. Since the parcel is not at an intersection, the side elevations .re -:oc -.-isaDle from S- tiriina Roaa. -'ease Sao anV tnef -cmments :✓nice may assisi .7e -Jmmission anc t., �13nnlno of nlno t3oara to reviewlno this request. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -Js is 'c cervty that 1 am the owner cf the subiem ,anacst ciescneea-above in the oetition for vananc -=meie -.-)IV _opncaoiei ^ave _iso uthonzea -ne _naersionea cetitior ';1 i i l i am u f L ev 'o maKe anc file this aooncauo r variance. �iGNATURE OF AP�F'Ll T , STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF BROWARD �p0(1 7 '-,E foropina instrument was acKnowieoaea before me on -� - '�- a as(tittel o ;or iname of entity] _ - Florida CorporaUoof.wino is '✓ aersonatly known to me. or ucea � i ication. '.tv Commission cxbires. 4?%0c'c" DOROTHY tit.BRANCATO NOTARY PUBLIC '.1Y COMMISSION RES:08R9200268� J P1 _ATO X DOROTHY P..� C. -. I-E(W-S-NOTARY pia.Naary Semcca&BaWtad Co. =0R USE WHEN APPLICANT 'S NOT OWNER OF SUBJECT PROPERTY' -'CIS =T;r'� "HAT ; -4E ',VNER CF `-!E S,JBJE-:7 =.NDS [=CE:ISECD .=8OVE 'N ' -PPI_!C. TICN F-;R SIGN =DJUSTMEr ® 'JO =AT -.yVE =UTHORIZED taKE ND = LE -- ;:,"RESAID APPl-!CAT;CN F :-R AG 1 r uJL ST`tE>!T :GiNAT'LRE _V, NEZ. STATE OF FLORIDA :OUNTY OF BROWARD _._,,e roraotna instrument was acxnowteogeo oetore me oR 7 -888 by as ititlei ��L- �� w 'or[name of enutvj a Flonaa Corocration. :rno is --erSCM211V Known tome. or - s taenttficatton. '.iv Ccmmsston Excires: NOTARY PUBLIC _•` MY COMMISSION :hecK list for Planning Dept.: Plan Fee Survey J _XPIRES:Ocf , 'D"00d rh,. +araw JBL1C i N G 7 7 aNIA EE.-1 �: ,-o __nma Ecarc --on '-ErEaTter .osslc;e_ --.e -anla z-'eacr, :,,mmissu :r :-a:rje cnTer. .'lest _ai ila =EaC;' _.'�C E3C,. - ^.'a rurO05e -.'. _ 77—m.ems :lntcn " last ze —age ._ :-e ._iicwinc anance Eauest .'Jililam = ,fev. _r,sultants .ecresentlna Motiva c- -r,oeriv ccatea on .ne Norinviest __,rer Enna aria _ ' -venue. he �eaue' r12nce '"']m '.`�aoter :3. _Jnina. -mc:e -. e -,:mmerc:at 7-eslan ulaehnes (s cf the Gasoline Station C.es+an G.;lae!lnes .)nlc-; state :r.at Gass wmaows ana actors mus �f :he cnmary e!evauon at-to = . _f :he seccnaarj =evaucn --is variance request Ism c 'rim a site clan ammroval reauest for me construction of a Sheit SeFvice Station _saany aescnbea: A portion of Tract cf 'Leto ParK accoralna :o the otat thereof as recoraea it '.8 at oaae 39 of the puoftc recoras of Erowara County. Florida: Eeina more carticuiany aescnbea a Seam at the most southerly southwest corner of sato Tract '.-" -hence run norm 00 degrees 40 r :econas east along the west line of saia Tract "A" for a distance of 278.86 feet to a eoint: Thence rL .earees 58 minutes 59 seconas east for a distance of 230.92 feet to a ocint on the east line of saic -'pence run south 00 dearees 40 minutes '.6 seconas west atona the east line of saia Tract for `.et a coinr '-ence so�um = cearees —mutes C8 seconas ':vest for a distant colnt CT Intersect:cn 'Mtn :ne arc oT s c:rcuiar ._;:rve concave tc the northwest. :he centE :ears rortn 36 cearees 1' minutes :'.9 seconcs west from saia court -fence run southwesteriv aio .: saia cure navina a radius or 2002:=6 feet. :`ru a central anale cr 05 decrees 21 minutes 09 sec! _rc olstance of 215.07 feet to a colnt cf non-tanaency: -hence run norm 90 aegrees 00 minutes i .vest for a distance of 4 98 feet to the point of beginning. Containing: 63.124 square feet = 1 4491 or Less. ® �omtes of the crocoseg cetttlon are avaiiable far 'dewing :n *!7e Growth Management Oemartment Dania Eeacn Siva.. manta Beacn. =lortoa oetween the nours cf 8:00 a.m. ana 4-00 o.m.. Mona. -lease call (954) 924-3645 for more Information. nteresteo tames may aocear 2t :he cuolic hea _.,...dance •:ltn :'-e -rrier,cc.,. r,h _.saulllties :_erc, ^c ec!. _= iS:ar_� - _ nIC:o -.-.e-P _.-.acman --'rT mis-Lra:ivE e=n. .,.,no oecices '_ aoce.=i :n: ..ec:slon -aa _ _ gym'=_sicr rn =caro :7siderec at :nls ^,eetina c, -,earmq ':'ill eea 3 rECCrd c. ".e =c—eecir.Cs ana _ C curoose ' .erca:Im 7rd... _-on :urn= .7,e aoeeal is c casec. _ . ,nanam _....;C:an, ?allec lie =C00 BU DLIGIIT PLAT (141 � E .. j BUD COKE a DUKE OLAT UB (12-4-46) (12S-21 - 1. ©©�� 11 ♦f��R�4 .J 1 -AT7217 IZa ? YIC i : a r i A-5 R.0 Ck • WC ES' .. J - h eA