HomeMy WebLinkAbout31317 - MINUTES - City Commission j
1
MINUTES
DANIA CITY COMMISSION
REGULAR MEETING
JUNE 23, 1987
INVOCATION - Vice Mayor Jean Cook
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
i
ROLL CALL:
Present -
Mayor: Chester Byrd
Vice Mayor: Jean Cook
Commissioners : John Bertino
Howard Hirsch
Charles McElyea
City Attorney: Frank Adler
City Manager: Eugene Jewell
City Clerk: Wanda Mullikin
Police Chief: Gilbert Thivener
Absent -
Building Official : Paul Maxwell
i
PRESENTATIONS - Commendation to Kevin Snead
1
Police Chief Thivener commended Kevin Snead, an employee at the Beatle i
Shop in Dania, for his courageous actions as a concerned citizen in the
apprehension of a purse-snatcher.
(At this time, the resolution in item 1. 4 was addressed . )
,r-
Police Chief Thivener announced the accomplishments of Vince Marlin,
winning a silver medal in weight-lifting for his weight class, and James
Fondo, winning a gold medal for his weight class in this '
9 year's Police
Olympics. He expressed pride in these officers and recommended that $100
be given to each one to defray the expenses incurred.
Mayor Byrd introduced the good will ambassador for the Costa lines,
President of the Christopher Columbus Club of Florida, and long-time
President of the Dania Chamber of Commerce, Tom Sette.
Mr. Sette, as President of the Christopher Columbus Monument Committee,
announced that a bronze statue of Columbus is to be shipped from Genoa,
Italy, stopping for celebrations in many ports including Spain, N. Y. ,
Quebec, St. Thomas and Nassau, and will be coming in to Port Everglades
on August 29th aboard the Costa Riviera. Mr. Sette asked that a
Proclamation be issued to recognize the Christopher Columbus
quincentennial celebration, described plans for the August 29th
celebration and invited the Commission to attend.
i
Mayor Byrd then announced the Broward League of Cities bicentennial
committee's planned fireworks display on the 4th of July to celebrate the
200th anniversary of the signing of the Constitution.
** (At this time, 8: 15 p.m. , time for receipt of bids was closed. )
1 . CONSENT AGENDA
Minutes
1. 1 May 27, 1987, Workshop Meeting
1 . 2 June 2, 1987, Special Meeting
1. 3 June 9, 1987, Regular Meeting
j
i Resolutions
* 1 . 4 A Resolution honoring Detective Henry Rickmeyer for his many
years of service, and to recognize him for his outstanding work
in this community was read by Mayor Byrd.
L A motion was made by Vice Mayor Cook, seconded by Commissioner Hirsch fI
to approve the consent agenda. The motion passed unanimously.
Regular Commission Meeting 1 June 23, 1987
T71 ' '11 ,
2. PROCLAMATIONS - none
3. BIDS ( 8: 15 p.m. )
3. 1 Receipt of Bids for "NW First Street Roadway and Drainage
Improvements; Year XII Block Grant - Phase III" Project. j
** A motion was made by Commissioner Hirsch, seconded by
Commissioner Bertino to close the time for receipt of bids . The r
motion passed unanimously.
i
City Manager Jewell opened and read sealed bids received from
Williams Paving Co. of Miami in the amount of $295, 434. 75, with
bid bond, and from Allrite Engineering of Davie in the amount of i
$265, 759. 00, with bid bond.
i
A motion was made by Commissioner Hirsch, seconded by
Commissioner McElyea to remand the bids to the City Manager for
computation and recommendation at the next regular meeting of
July 14, 1987. The motion passed unanimously.
4. PUBLIC HEARINGS AND OTHER RELATED MATTERS
Building & Zoning
4. 1 Petitioner: Attorney Joel Gustafson; Owner: Arthur C. Boggs ;
property located at the SW corner of Ravenswood Rd. & SW 55 St .
PUBLIC HEARING -
VA-29-87 - A Variance request to allow the construction of a
warehouse/showroom facility with (a) 237 parking spaces (270
spaces required ) , (b) a 13 ' north side yard setback (25 '
required) .
Jan Hansen, Consulting Planner representing the Petitioner,
stated that this property was just recently annexed into the
City of Dania and is now owned by Marvin Mandel and his
associates .
City Manager Jewell mentioned that Mr. Mandel 's proposed project
will be entitled "Designers ' Place II" and reported Staff and
the Planning and Zoning Board recommend approval .
�..ed Mayor Byrd opened the y y p public hearing. Hearing no one speak in
favor or opposition, the Mayor closed the public hearing.
A motion was made by Commissioner Hirsch, seconded by
Commissioner McElyea to grant the variance (VA-29-87) . The
motion passed on the following roll call vote:
Commissioner Bertino-yes Vice Mayor Cook-yes
Commissioner Hirsch-yes Mayor Byrd-yes
Commissioner McElyea-yes
4. 2 Petitioner: Richard Mooney, Director, Project 80 's; Owner:
Broward County
PUBLIC HEARING -
VC-28-87 - Adoption of Resolution vacating portions of roads
d
within the jurisdiction of the International Airport.
Jeffrey Sinowski , representing Broward County, noting that Mr.
Mooney is no longer employed by Broward County, stepped forward
to request vacation of five parcels. He explained that the
parcels are ancient thoroughfares which have either been
abandoned or were never opened.
i Due to the fact that the Commission did not have sufficient time
to review this item in advance, it was suggested that a workshop
be held for further study.
Regular Commission Meeting 2 June 23, 1987
A motion was made by Commissioner Hirsch, seconded by Vice Mayor
Cook to continue this item until the next regular meeting of
July 14, 1987. During discussion, Commissioner Bertino
suggested that Mr. Sinowski see if the County would be receptive
to the idea of dedicating a parcel of land usable by the City
for a Welcome sign. The motion to continue passed unanimously.
4. 3 Petitioner: Henry Graham; Owner: L.E.S. ; property located at 8
Liberty Terrace
A) PUBLIC HEARING -
VA-25-87 - A Variance request to allow the construction of one
multi-family dwelling with a 25 ' side yard setback (30 '
required ) . i
Henry Graham, Executive Director of Liberia Economic Social
Development Inc. , stepped forward to explain that the 5 '
variance is requested for this particular building in order to
maintain the conformity of the buildings in the project.
Mayor Byrd opened the public hearing. Hearing Gloria Daly speak
in opposition, commenting on undesirable qualities of the
project and its tenants in general . The Architect on the
project expressed the opinion that the new buildings will have a
positive impact on the neighborhood. Hearing Sylvester Jackson,
Vice President of the L. E.S. Board, comment on the people's
right to affordable living and hearing Henry Graham comment on
the tenant screening process, the Mayor closed the public
hearing.
In response to questions by the Commission, Mr. Graham explained
-4 that the complex will be managed by L.E.S. and described the
L. E.S. organization and its primary objective of removing slum
and blight. ti
A motion was made by Vice Mayor Cook to grant the variance. The
motion died for lack of a second. Mayor Byrd suggested that Mr.
Graham acquaint the Commissioners and the members of the
Planning and Zoning Board with the Liberty Heights Project in
detail .
A motion was then made by Vice Mayor Cook, seconded by
Commissioner Hirsch to continue this item 4. 3A (VA-25-87) and
the site plan approval request item 4. 3B (SP-26-87) until the
next regular meeting of July 14, 1987. The motion passed
unanimously.
B) SP-26-87 - A Site Plan approval request to allow a multi-family
development in an RM-2 zoning district.
Commissioner McElyea questioned the adequacy of the dumpsters
shown on the site plan.
(Continued to next regular meeting of July 14, 1987, by
inclusion in motion passed on previous item 4. 3A. )
Administrative - none
5. SITE PLAN REQUESTS
5. 1 Petitioner/Owner: Fred Gans & Jerry Oren; property located at
1245 Stirling Rd.
I
SP-27-87 - A Site Plan approval request to allow a
warehouse/showroom facility in an IG zoning district.
The site plan was presented to the Commission. It was noted I
that the overflow parking is on City right-of-way.
Mayor Byrd invited any objections from the audience. Hearing
none, the Mayor closed the public hearing.
Regular Commission Meeting 3 June 23, 1987
1 _
I
Vice Mayor Cook announced that she will abstain from voting as
she is the broker in this transaction.
A motion was made by Commissioner Hirsch, seconded by
Commissioner McElyea to grant site plan approval (SP-27-87) .
The motion passed on the following roll call vote :
Commissioner Bertino-yes Vice Mayor Cook-abstain
Commissioner Hirsch-yes Mayor Byrd-yes
Commissioner McElyea-yes
6. EXPENDITURE REQUESTS - none
7. SPECIAL REQUESTS
7. 1 Acceptance of engagement letter/contract from Touche Ross & Co.
to serve as independent accountants for the fiscal years 1986-87
through 1988-89.
City Manager Jewell reported the proposed audit fee of $18,900
for 86-87, $21 , 000 for 87-88, and $22, 600 for 88-89, being a
total fee of $62, 500 for the three year audit engagement, was
deemed to be fair by he and Commissioner Hirsch and recommended
approval of the three year agreement.
A motion was made by Commissioner Hirsch, seconded by
Commissioner McElyea to accept the three year audit proposal of
Touche Ross & Co. The motion passed unanimously.
7. 2 Request by NY Pyrotechnic Products Inc. DBA Fireworks by Grucci
to hold fireworks display from beach on 6/27/87.
(continued from 6/9/87)
# Jeff Swain, speaking for the petitioner, stepped forward to
request permission to present a fireworks show on Saturday, June 1e-'27th, between 9: 00-9: 30 p.m. off the beach 180 ' north of the
pier over the ocean. He said the radio station WINZ is
sponsoring the show.
City Manager Jewell reported on meetings attended by Mr. Swain,
Bob Lizana, President of the Dania Chamber of Commerce, the
Police Chief and Fire Chiefs and said that all provisions for
fire, police and insurance protection are satisfactory and Staff
recommends approval.
Mayor Byrd said that Grucci is also cooperating with the City of
Dania 's Fourth of July celebration planned at the same site on
the 4th.
i
Commissioner McElyea raised a question regarding the proposed
site. City Manager Jewell clarified the issue, stating that the
agenda backup does show the location as south of the pier, but
it was changed to north of the pier in the interests of public
safety. He said this was done at a meeting held after the
agenda was prepared.
A motion was made by Vice Mayor Cook, seconded by Commissioner
McElyea to grant the request by NY Pyrotechnic Products Inc. to
hold the fireworks display 180' north of the pier, provided the
proper fire and insurance coverage is furnished by the
petitioner. The motion passed unanimously.
8. APPOINTMENTS - none
9. DISCUSSION
9. 1 Discussion regarding Master Plan Update & Noise Compatibilit
Studies on Airport. y
Appearance: Ray Lubomski , Engineering & Planning
Ray Lubomski , Assistant Director for the Broward County Aviation
Department, reported on the 20 yr. Master Plan, looking at the
airport growth, inventory, current facilities, consultants '
forecasts, and plans for projects to accommodate that growth.
j
Regular Commission Meeting 4 June 23, 1987
I ,
I '
He said during the first five years, the Plan calls for
increasing capabilities of the main runway, improving the
parking service and structure situation, and acquiring property
within the clear zone either by purchase or easement. !
Commissioner Bertino questioned how the city would be
compensated for the loss of revenue that would have been derived j
from a hotel being built on property within that building
restricted clear zone. He asked if projections have been made
with regard to the cost impact for the loss of all taxing
revenue to the municipalities and a way to rectify the
shortfall. Mr. Lubomski said the Plan did not address that
situation.
Mr. Lubomski then described the remaining part of the Plan of
expanding gates and building additional concourses to existing
terminals. He said the Master Plan is scheduled to start at the
end of this year.
Mr. Lubomski reported on the Part 150 Noise Compatibility Study,
looking at the airport and the way it operates and the types of
aircraft flying in and out. He described the Part 150 as a
specific plan to set the guidelines for noise mitigation in the
community and said the reason for the plan is to aid the County
in competing for federal dollars.
The plan 's recommended runway operations were discussed. During
discussion of Piedmont 's use of F28's on the south runway, Mr.
Lubomski mentioned that Piedmont has restricted its operation by
a self-imposed voluntary time curfew. x_
Property values and appraisals with regard to the purchase
assurance and voluntary acquisition programs were also
discussed.
*** (At this time, agenda item 9.4 was addressed . )
9. 2 Discussion of pending case - James Serpe and Statewide Security
vs. City of Dania.
Appearance: Charles T. Whitelock
(Withdrawn from agenda. )
9. 3 Discussion regarding property on SW 8 Street (dedicated as SW
Third Avenue) .
City Manager Jewell reported that the Commission had decided to
declare the SW 8th Street property surplus and directed Staff to
advertise for bids. However, upon the advice of City Attorney
Adler, the property was dedicated for the use of the public, is
not owned by the city, and therefore cannot be sold. The two
options available to the city are to use it or vacate it .
City Manager Jewell recommended that the Commission readdress
the vacation request (VC-03-87) of the adjoining property owners
(Charles & Diane McKenna and Philip & Mary Linsalata ) who have
been maintaining the property.
A motion was made by Commissioner Bertino, seconded by Vice
Mayor Cook to agenda consideration of the vacation request
(VC-03-87) for the next regular meeting of July 14, 1987. The
motion passed on the following roll call vote :
! Commissioner Bertino-yes Vice Mayor Cook-yes
Commissioner Hirsch-yes Mayor Byrd-no
Commissioner McElyea-yes
L
Regular Commission Meeting 5 June 23, 1987
I
r
i
r
ADDENDUM ITEM:
9. 4 Update regarding Airport. Commissioner Cook
Appearance : Bob Mikes
Vice Mayor Cook reported on the meeting held at the Hollywood
Hills High School , thanked the Attorney, hired by the City for
this special issue, who, along with the two hired consultants, .
and Bob Mikes, made a very good presentation before the County b
Commission. She recognized Mr. J. Topper, representing the
Griffin Rd. Civic Association, who also made a fine presentation
at that meeting.
i
s
Bob Mikes, Airport Advisory Committee Chairman, presented in
detail the report and recommendations regarding current airport
expansion proposals dated June 12, 1987. The report advised
that if a project alternative cannot be developed, the
alternative "nine" proposal, with recommended modifications
suggested by the Airport Advisory Committee, offers the best
potential for compatibility for both commercial and residential
community interests.
Mr. Iacino, commenting on the importance of purchase assurance
and property value issues, acknowledged the fine efforts of Bob
Mikes and the Committee members and expressed confidence that a
large majority of the recommendations contained in the
Committee 's report will find their way into the final published
consultant ' s report.
Vice Mayor Cook commended Bob Mikes, Mr. Iacino, Craig Leonard
and the other members of the Airport Advisory Committee for
their efforts in preparing an excellent report .
10. CITIZENS ' COMMENTS
i
No verbal or written requests for Citizens ' Comments for this night 's
meeting were received.
11. ADMINISTRATIVE REPORTS
11. 1 City Manager Jewell - no comment.
11. 2 City Attorney Adler reported action taken regarding the Houston
Park case.
i
12. COMMISSION COMMENT
12. 1 Commissioner Bertino - no comment.
i
12. 2 Commissioner Hirsch - no comment.
i
12. 3 Commissioner McElyea - no comment.
12. 4 Vice Mayor Cook - no comment.
h 12. 5 Mayor Byrd - no comment.
a
i
;i
i
This Regular Commission Meeting was then adjourned. �
T,
MAYOR-COMMISSIONER+
CITY CLERK-AUDITOR
i
Regular Commission Meeting 6 June 23, 1987
Y AGENDA
DANIA CITY COMMISSION
REGULAR MEETING
JUNE 23 , 1987
j 8: 00 P.M.
!i
INVGCATION
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE I
1
ROLL CALL
I PRESENTATIONS - Commendation to Kevin Snead.
1 1 . CONSENT AGENDA
Minutes
1. 1 May 27 , 1987 , Workshop Meeting
1. 2 June 2, 1987 , Special Meeting
1 . 3 June 9 , 1987, Regular Meeting
Resolutions
1 . 4 "A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY OF DANIA, FLORIDA, HONORING
DETECTIVE HENRY RICKMEYER FOR HIS MANY YEARS OF SERVICE; AND
TO RECOGNIZE HIM FOR HIS OUTSTANDING WORK IN THIS
COMMUNITY. "
2. PROCLAMATIONS - none
3. BIDS (8: 15 p.m. )
3. 1 Receipt of bids for "NW First Street Roadway and Drainage
Improvements; Year XII Block Grant - Phase III" project.
4. PUBLIC HEARINGS AND OTHER RELATED MATTERS I
Building 8 Zoning
4. 1 Petitioner - Attorney Joel Gustafson; Owner - Arthur C.
Boggs; property located at the SW corner of Ravenswood Road
and SW 55 Street
Public Hearing - VA-29-87 - A variance is requested to allow
the construction of a warehouse/showroom facility with (a) G
237 parking spaces ( 270 spaces required) , (b) a 13 ' north j
side yard setback ( 25 ' required ) . I
4. 2 Petitioner - Richard Mooney, Director, Project 80 's; Owner -
Broward County
Public Hearing - VC-28-87 - Adoption of resolution vacating
portions of roads within the jurisdiction of the
International Airport.
i
I I
i
I
I
1 OF 3
I`
I
J
Fir
4. 3 Petitioner - Henry Graham; Owner - L.E.S. ; property located
at 8 Liberty Terrace
a) Public Hearing - VA-25-87 - A variance is requested to allow
j the construction of one multi-family dwelling with a 25 ' side
yard setback ( 30 ' required) .
b) SP-26-87 - A site plan approval is requested to allow a
multi-family development in an RM-2 zoning district.
�
Administrative - none r
5. SITE PLAN REQUESTS i
5. 1 Petitioners/Owners - Fred Gans & Jerry Oren; property located
at 1245 Stirling Road
SP-27-87 - A site plan approval is requested to allow a
i warehouse/showroom facility in an IG zoning district.
i 6. EXPENDITURE REQUESTS - none
i
7. SPECIAL REQUESTS
7. 1 Acceptance of engagement letter/contract from Touche Ross &
Co. to serve as independent accountants for the fiscal years
j 1986-87 through 1988-89.
I 7. 2 Request by NY Pyrotechnic Products Inc. D/B/A FIreworks by j
j Grucci to hold fireworks display from beach on 6/27/87.
(continued from 6/9/87)
i
8. APPOINTMENTS - none
4
9. DISCUSSION
9. 1 Discussion regarding Master Plan Update & Noise Compatibility
Studies on Airport.
Appearance: Ray Lubomski , Engineering & Planning `f
9. 2 Discussion of pending case - James Serpe and Statewide
Security vs. City of Dania. !
Appearance: Charles T. Whitelock
i
9. 3 Discussion regarding property on SW 8 Street (dedicated as SW
Third Avenue) .
10. CITIZENS ' COMMENTS - Comments by Dania citizens or interested
parties that are not a part of the regular agenda should be given
in writing or communicated verbally prior to 4 : 00 p.m. the second
( 2nd) and fourth (4th) Monday of each month. Comments of any
nature will be responded to by the office of the City Manager. In
the event that the concern remains unresolved, the citizen(s) or j
party will be asked to address the City Commission during the
meeting.
I
i
2OF3
f
11 . ADMINISTRATIVE REPORTS
11. 1 City Manager
11. 2 City Attorney
12. COMMISSION COMMENTS
12. 1 Commissioner Bertino '
i 12. 2 Commissioner Hirsch
12. 3 Commissioner Mc Elyea
12. 4 Vice Mayor Cook
12. 5 Mayor Byrd
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
ANY PERSON WHO DECIDES TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE BY THE CITY COMMISSION
t
WITH REGARD TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING OR HEARING WILL NEED
A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS, AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT
A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE
TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED.
1
i
a
` i
I
i
i
I
i
j
j
I
II
3 OF 3
i
I �
J
ADDENDUM
DANIA CITY COMMISSION
REGULAR MEETING
JUNE 23, 1987
8:00 P.M.
IiI
f
9. DISCUSSION (continued) f
9 . 4 Update regarding Airport. Commissioner Cook
Appearance: Bob Mikes j
1 �
I
t
i
i
I
w-
j
f�
I
I
i
f
J
ci
FORM P"N, MEMORANDUM OF VOTING C�'=,�FLICT FOR
COUNTY, i NICIPAL, AND OTHER LOCAL P 110 OFFICERS
LAST NAME-FIRST NAME-.MIDDLE NAME NAME OF BOARD, COUNCIL.COMMISSION, AUTHORITY,OR COMMITTEE
MAILING ADDRESS THE BOARD, COUNCIL. COMMISSION. AUTHORITY,OR COMMITTEE ON
WHICH I SERVE IS A UNIT OF: _
F.'CITY . 'COUNTY OTHER LOCAL AGENCY
CITI cou NTY
NAME OF P ITICAL SUBDIVISION:
i
DATE ON wHIC'H \01E OC(LRRED
PoSI TION IS: t
ELECTIVE _ APPOINTIVE i
f
WHO MUST FILE FORM 88
i
This form is for use by any person serving at the county, city,or other local level of government on an appointed or elected board,
council,commission, authority, or committee. It applies equally to members of advisory and non-advisory bodies who are presented
with a voting conflict of interest under Section 112.3143, Florida Statutes. The requirements of this law are mandator),; although
the use of this particular form is not required by law, you are encouraged to use it in making the disclosure required by law.
Your responsibilities under the law when faced with a measure in which you have a conflict of interest will vary greatly depending
on whether you hold an elective or appointive position. For this reason, please pay close attention to the instructions on this form
j before completing the reverse side and filing the form.
i
s
i
INSTRUCTIONS FOR COMPLIANCE WITH SECTION 112.3143, FLORIDA STATUTES
"IAI
ELECTED OFFICERS:
A person holding elective county, municipal, or other local public office :MUST ABSTAIN from voting on a measure Which inures j
to his special private gain. Each local officer also is prohibited from knowingly voting on a measure which inures to the special
1 gain of a principal (other than a government agency) by whom he is retained.
I
In either case, you should disclose the conflict:
PRIOR TO THE VOTE BEING TAKEN by publicly stating to the assembly the nature of your interest in the measure on
Which you are abstaining from voting; and
I i
WITHIN 15 DAPS AFTER THE VOTE OCCURS by completing and filing this form \with the person responsible for recording
the minutes of the meeting, who should incorporate the form in the minutes.
APPOINTED OFFICERS:
A person holding appointive county, municipal, or other local public office MUST ABSTAIN from voting on a measure which
inures to his special private gain. Each local officer also is prohibited from knowingly voting on a measure which inures to the
special gain of a principal (other than a government agency) by %%horn he is retained.
A person holding an appointive local office otherwise may participate in a matter in which he has a conflict of interest, but must
idisclose the nature of the conflict bet'ore making any attempt to influence the decision by oral or written communication, whether
i made by the officer or at his direction. f
IF YOU INTEND TO MAKE ANY ATTEMPT TO INFLUENCE THE DECISION PRIOR TO THE MEETING AT WHICH I
THE VOTE WILL BE TAKEN:
• You should complete and file this form (before making any attempt to influence the decision) with the person responsible for
recording the minutes of the meeting, who %%ill incorporate the form in the minutes.
• A copy of the form should be provided immediately to the other members of the agency.
• The form should be read publicly at the meeting prior to consideration of the matter in \%hich you have a conflict of interest.
g1 PAUL
1{�
June 12, 1987
Mayor Chester A. Byrd
City of Dania
100 Nest Dania Beach Boulevard
Daniap Florida 33004
From; Dania Airport Advisory Committies
Re: Initial Report and Recommendations Regarding
Current Airport Expansion Proposals f r
Dear Mayor Byrd:
i
We have reviewed the various airport proposals in a
series of weekly-meetings and have reached a number of
conclusions as to which proposal is the least offensive to
our Dania community. Our selection does not endorse the
concept that the south airport expansion is the only
alternative. We believe there are other potential
alternatives (such as re-directing general aviation to the
south runway) which should be considered.
When the airport proposals were studied it became
obvious that the alternative "nine" had the least impact to
Dania and adjacent communities. litsosal '
runway use to only stage III aircraft a dpsets a curfewsouth
for
south night operations. Since the claimed necessity for this
runway was to give more
believe a'.7:00 P.M, to Peak capacity during mid-day, we
compromise to su 1 7:00 A.M. curfew is a reasonable
PP y Peak capacity but relieve night noise,
residential impacts. This will also serve to limit the use
of this marginal non-instrumentation runway t I
daylight hours. We feel this restriction is basically
to both aircraft and the communities surrounding
feature i
_....i� runway, grounding the south
SCOPE
In reviewing the airport data for impacts to N.E. and
that t Dania residents it was apparent from the 1990 projection
that N.E. Dania was to a large extent left out o£ the noise
abatement "land use proposal•" The committee believes that
this needs to be remedied.
DATA AND METHODOLOGY
While we have not had access to all of AV-PLANS Data,
1990 projections we
feel that there is a basic fault in a noise plan that is using
for a noise abatement program that is reaching
completion in their Phase II period more sense t contours. to - 1992-1995. It would make
valid noise c use projections 1995 in order to have more
The following summary sheets and attached drawing summarize
our committies current recommendations to the City Commission.
J
l
j
j I NOISE CONTROL STRATEGY
GENERAL AIRPORT
SOUTH RUNWAY
i Restrictions on use of the runway to only stage III aircraft
during daylight hours (7 A.M.-7 P.M.) will allow the airport the
additional capacity during daylight peak hours while allowing the j
adjoining communities relief and additional safety during the !
evening hours.
SOUTH TERMINAL
E.F.U. cooling should be required as well as a run-up
monitoring program.
13-31 RUNWAY
Usage and particularly night operations should not be
allowed to exceed present levels.
SPECIFIC AREAS
N.W. DANIA/MELALEUCA GARDENS
Ahdual berm concept has been developed and documented on
an attached drawing.
One landscaped berm would be on airport property, close
to the ground level generated noise of airport operations. This
berm would run approximately the full length of the adjacent
' k south runway.
The second berm would run along loth street and require the w
aquisition of approximately 14 houses and several duplexes as
well as the current tennis court section of the local city park.
This aquisition would allow a landscaped berm to run from 13th
avenue to 6th avenue. The plan reduces the access to loth street
to just two thru streets (at 12th and 6th) and allows the use of
cul-de-sacs on the previous seven other streets and alleys
connecting to loth street. To restore the tennis courts it is
proposed to take the remainder
of the block of duplexes i
domain) at N.W. 12th and 13th and use the remainingexes (eminent
Property to
improve the 10thp y
,f street/Griffin Road entrance and for the relocated
Park (tennis courts) and required parking.
By putting these few property owners„who would be most
heavily noise impacted, under eminent domain aquisition, the
committee feels that the majority of the neighborhood could have
a considerable reduction in noise. With the balance of the neighbor-
hood under the Purchase Aquisition Program, it was felt that displaced
owners who wanted to stay in the neighborhood could relocate to
properties who opt for the Purchase Assurance Program. Non-resident
duplex owners could reinvest in other rental properties elsewhere
without suffering undo tax hardships.
Since this loth street berm will not run the full length of
the neighborhood, we are recommending the existing concrete wall have
3 feet of height added to it and a solution devised to reduce the gap
between the Griffin road bridge and the existing wall.
-2-
N.E. DANIA
This section of Dania will benefit from the restrictions on
operations as previously stated.
In the area between the airport and the Dania canal, is a
significant area of undeveloped land within the Dania City limits.
This area used to be heavily vegitated and a natural buffer to
sound crossing the canal into the residential areas of the city.
Dania needs to tighten up its site plan approval process and its
landscaping ordinance to allow better control of development in
this area. The use of an architectural review board to evaluate
the siting of future commercial buildings would be an additional
recommendation.
Due to the fact that most of the noise impacts, in N.E.
Dania is from aircraft at height, the major emphasis is on bringing
this area into the program for consideration as to ai controls and financial mitigation programs, rport operation
II LAND USE MANAGEMENT STRATEGIES
PURCHASE ASSURANCE PROGRAM
Implementation -
A minimum period of five years should be allowed for
residents to exercise this option. This will give them sufficient
time to evaluate the new noise impacts, the success of the noise
abatement controls and the overall stability of the neighborhood.
RELOCATION ALLO@iANCE
The sponsor Browaxd County) should provide a relocation
allowance similar to what the Federal program would qualified homeowners and tenants, g Provide for
COMPARABLE MARKET VALUES
Appraisal values should be drawn from comparable areas
outside the airport noise zones. This is particularly important
for long term homeowners who have suffered lack of property
appreciation due to ever increasingairport
a number of areas the airport ng Po noise impacts. In
for commercial development.
is gaining potentially valuable land
SCOPE
Expand program to noise impacted areas of N.E. Dania
III FACILITATING ACTIONS
COMPLIANCE COMMITTEE
The committee concurs with the B.C.A.D, suggestion to
implement a compliance committee (including citizens groups)
to monitor noise abatement program controls.
NOISE CONTROL OFFICER
The committee agrees that the hiring of a control officer
is a necessity.
NOISE MONITORING
ittee
Portable
hnoisemmonitoringeequipmenttis needed of h Permanent
and
noise abatement compliance. to properly monitor
AIRPORT USERS EDUCATION PROGRAM
The committe
education program. e supports the concept of a pilot and facility
i
-3-
IV SAFETY
SOUTH RUWAY
Limiting operations to basically daylight hours should
keep this marginal
g� runway with numerous obstructions
Operational during the most favorable conditions,
PIEDMONT OPERATIONS SOUTH
The F-28 o e RUNl7AY
committee p rations, in the opinion of pilots on our pp
are marginal for the current runway and would be
a safer operation on the north runway,
STAGE III AIRCRAFT j
Dania, and all communities surrounding the airport,
would have their quality of life improve and safety if B.C.A.D, started Lakin yinc
to upgrade their FTI, fleet tonegestepsr and more y increase
P require carriers
advanced aircraft.
In summary, after meeting weekly, since April 8
committee members are of the opinion that if a
alternative cannot , the
that the be developed we believe project
t
alternative "nine" proposal offers thebest time,
for compatability for both commercial and residential interests
I in our Community, Potential
Previous (with the modifications suggested on the
Pages
The committee will
basis to keepcontinue to meet on
and to network uwith airport developments f a less frequent
adjoining u affecting our city
involvements, g communities working on similar
i
Sincerely,
APB I
cc: Dania City Manager Bob Mikes ++�
Dania City Commissioners Airport Advisory I
Committee Chairman
Airport Advisory, Committ
B.C.A.D. ee
i i
-4-
i
i
1