The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutR-1997-117 RESOLUTION NO. 117-97 I A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY OF DANIA, FLORIDA, ADOPTING THE REVISED EVALUATION AND APPRAISAL REPORT FOR THE CITY OF DANIA'S COMPREHENSIVE PLAN; PROVIDING THAT ALL RESOLUTIONS OR PARTS OF RESOLUTIONS IN CONFLICT HEREWITH BE AND THE SAME ARE HEREBY REPEALED TO THE EXTENT OF SUCH CONFLICT AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. WHEREAS, The City of Dania is reviewing the status of the City's Comprehensive Plan through the State of Florida's mandated Evaluation and Appraisal Report (EAR) process; and WHEREAS, The purpose of the EAR is to evaluate and assess the Comprehensive Plan in accomplishing its adopted objectives and to suggest changes or amendments needed to update the plan or its elements, including reformulated objectives, policies and standards; and WHEREAS, the Planning and Zoning Board, sitting as the City's Local Planning Agency (LPA) held a meeting on December 7, 1995 and recommended to the City Commission transmittal of the proposed Evaluation and Appraisal Report; and WHEREAS, The City Commission held a public hearing meeting on December 12, 1995 authorizing transmission to the State of Florida Department of Community Affairs, by Resolution No. 176-95, the proposed Evaluation and Appraisal Report; and WHEREAS, The Department of Community Affairs reviewed the Evaluation and Appraisal Report by conducting a sufficiency review pursuant to Florida Statute Section 163.3191(9) and provided comments to assist in the preparation of the EAR; and WHEREAS, The City of Dania held public hearings on August 13, 1996, and September 2, 1997 incorporating the responses to the sufficiency issues raised by the Department of Community Affairs into the Evaluation and Appraisal Report and adopting it by Resolution No. 76-96; and WHEREAS, pursuant to Rule 9J-5.0053(3)(g), F.A.C. the local governing body m` must adopt, or adopt with changes, the proposed EAR. Resolution No. 117-97 i v NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE 1 CITY OF DANIA, FLORIDA: Section 1. The Department of Community Affairs has found the proposed changes to the City of Dania's Evaluation and Appraisal Report, as heard on August 13, 1996 and September 2, 1997 are acceptable; and i Section 2. Pursuant to Florida Statutes 163.3191, the City of Dania adopts the Revised Evaluation and Appraisal Report after public hearing, on September 2, 1997 by the Dania City Commission; and Section 3. The City Clerk is hereby authorized to send copies of the adopted Revised Evaluation and Appraisal Report of the City of Dania's Comprehensive Plan to the Department of Community Affairs for their review and finding of sufficiency immediately following the Commission's public hearing; and Section 4. That all resolutions or parts of resolutions in conflict herewith be and the same are hereby repealed to the extent of such conflict. Section 5. That this resolution shall be in force and take effect immediately upon its passage and adoption. PASSED AND ADOPTED on this 2 day of September 1997. ATTEST: CITY CLERK- AUDITOR MAY'0R�COMMISSIONER APPR E.D?S TO FORM AND CORRECTNESS: CI ATTORN i Resolution No. 117-97 R:bkmn Kerr & Associates, Inc. Member,American Institute of certified Planners September 4, 1997 - Kenneth Metcalf Community Programs Administrator Florida Department of Community Affairs 2555 Shumard Oak Boulevard Tallahassee, Florida 32399-2100 RE: CITY OF DANIA EVALUATION AND APPRAISAL REPORT Dear Ken: Attached please find the revisions to the Evaluation and Appraisal Report approved by Resolution by the City Commission at its September 2, 1997 meeting. These revisions incorporate the changes outlined in my June 10, 1997 letter, (copy attached), as well as some additions/corrections the Commission made at its September 2, 1997. The following will provide an outline of the Commission's revisions: Title Page: Chan e: Traffic Circulation 1 Corrected McIntosh to read Eller Drive Traffic Circulation 5 Corrected Street to read Avenue • Planning • Zoning • Land Use • Expert Testimony • 808 East Las Olas Boulevard, Suite 104, Ft Lauderdale, Florida 33301 Phone: (954) 467-6308 Fax: (954) 467-6309 Leigh Robinson Kerr and Associates, Inc. September 4, 1997 _Page 2 of 3 Coast Management Element 5 Corrected two (2)and three (3) lane to read only two (2)lane. Also indicated that this is a roadway with expanded right-of-way which is anticipated to be used by the City for drainage. Adopted Objectives, I Additional bullet that further demonstrates Comparisons/Results compliance with Objective II. Adopted Objectives, 10 The second bullet under Object III has been revised to Comparisons/Results indicate accurately that the implementation of the project has been initiated. Adopted Objectives, 10 Objective VI: the first bullet has been revised to Comparisons/Results reflect that the wellfields will not be abandoned and this is consistent with other text changes previously included in the EAR as found under Potable Water - 11. Existing Conditions (page 10.). However, the bullet is still consistent as it does reduce the threat of salt water intrusion because there is reduced demand on the existing wells. } Adopted Objectives, 21 An additional bullet has been added to further enhance Comparisons/Results the meeting of this Objective VI. Problems of Development 2 The Commission reviewed in some detail this previously provided review of some problems of development in the annexed area. It is their belief that they intend to preserve the residential areas via the compatibility analysis. It is not likely that significant conflicts will occur. This would relate to items a. and b. As it relates to item c., Fire Service has already been developed in the area via the construction of a fire station to serve the western community. Unforeseen/Unanticipated 1-2 Item B. has been reworded. Problems and Opportunities f �4 I I Leigh Robinson Kerr and Associates,Inc. September 4, 1997 Page 3 of 3 I trust the above and the attached are consistent with our ongoing discussions regarding finding the City of Dania's EAR sufficient. This would enable us to move forward with the plan amendments needed to update our plan in conformance with 9J-5 and Florida i Statute 163. 1 look forward to hearing from you in the near future regarding the sufficiency of the Dania EAR. Sin er y, Leg R. Kerr, AICP President LRK/ker cc: Michael Sinith, City Manager 1 TRAFFIC CIRCULATION ELEMENT i . Y 4 TRAFFIC CIRCULATION ELEMENT CONDITIONS AT ADOPTION I. DATA REQUIREMENTS [9J-5.007(1)(a)(b)&(c)] A. Trafficways Plan The roads identified on the City of Dania's Future Land Use Plan map and on the Traffic and Circulation Plan are consistent with those found on the Broward County Trafficways Plan. This consistency with County requirements will be maintained as follows: Expressways(Limited Access) 1. Interstate 95 (1-95) Interstate 95 running along Dania's western edge traverses a primarily industrial and vacant area of the City. 2. Port Expressway (1-595) ? The Port Expressway will have minimal direct effect on the community since it runs along the northern City limits. Principal and Minor Arterials 1. Federal Highway (U.S. 1) Federal Highway connects the communities north of Dania with those lying to the south. 2. N.W. / N.E. 10th Street N.W. / N.E. 10th Street connects AWntesh Mead Eller Drive and Federal Highway with 1-95 and points west. 3. Sheridan Street Sheridan Street, a principal east-west arterial, serves as the boundary between Dania and Hollywood. Revised September 3, 1997 1 i III. ANALYSIS REQUIREMENTS [9J-5.007(2)(a)&(b)] Tables I - III have not changed. The Future Traffic Circulation Map has been modified to reflect the removal of SE 5th Street Avenue from the Broward County Trafficways Plan. No Changes have been made to the Street Lane Arrangement Map. The Existing Traffic Circulation Map has been adjusted to reflect the 1995 data. The Functional Classification Map has also been modified. The following represents the current level of service for each of the listed road segments. Interstate 95 With the recent expansion of this expressway there is now excess capacity. In 1989 the Interstate was operation at Level of Service D. Griffin Road No Change Stirling Road Stirling Road continues to operate below capacity Street Sheridan Street Operating below capacity, but is approaching over capacity, especially the segment west of U.S. 1. Ravenswood Road North of Stirling Road is below Capacity, but is approaching over capacity. Dania Beach Boulevard No Change U.S. 1 Is over capacity. Only the area adjacent to the airport is below capacity. Revised September 3, 1997 5 " a COASTAL MANAGEMENT ELEMENT r This is an existing facility varying from four (4) to five (5) lanes that is located in an existing 110 foot right- of-way. C. S.E. Fifth Avenue This is an existing two (2) to three (3) lane facility that presently exists from Sheridan Street on the south to Dania Beach Boulevard on the north. This roadway has expanded right-of-way which is anticipated to be used by the City for drainage. d. U.S. 1 / Dania Cut-Off Canal Bridge e. Intracoastal / Dania Beach Boulevard Bridge f. Intracoastal / New River Sound Bridge g. Dania Cut-Off Canal A. Beach and Dune Conditions The City of Dania's beaches and dunes are not experiencing any significant erosion or deterioration problems. 9. Hazard Reduction Because of the minimal development existing within the high hazard area, there is no need to consider the relocation or structural modification of the limited number of structures within the high hazard area. Also, 100% of the area is already under public ownership. D. Marina Siting [9J-5.012(4)] 1. Dania does not participate in a County wide marina siting plan. 2. Port Master Plan has been prepared by the Port Everglades Authority and that entity will evaluate that document. Revised September 3, 1997 5 w� ADOPTED OBJECTIVES COMPARISION/RESULTS 1 FUTURE LAND USE GOALS, OBJECTIVES AND POLICIES l (9J-5.0053(6)(a)(3)) OBJECTIVE I. Within one (1) year of transmittal of the Plan to Florida Department of Community Affairs, land development regulations shall be developed which promote orderly growth, development and placement of land uses which will encourage a mix of residential types and provide good quality of life for the residents of the City of Dania. - • The Dania Comprehensive Plan was adopted 4111189 • On 2127190, the Dania City Commission approved ordinances 12-90 & 13-90 which enacted concurrency for growth and development, and updated the existing LDR's of the City to enhance the quality of growth and development. • The objective was met. OBJECTIVE 11. Land development regulations will be developed which will insure that future land use amendments will only be permitted provided an analysis demonstrates that the soils, topography, natural resources and availability of the services are in place within one (1) year of the transmittal of the Comprehensive Plan to the Florida Department of Community Affairs. i • Ordinance 12-90 & 13-90 plus the implementation of a Comprehensive Plan Amendment checklist insure an analysis of an amendment's impacticompatibility with services. • These areas were adopted/mplemented 2127190 less than one year after the 4111189 Comprehensive Plan adoption. • A storm water retention recharge area is being developed along Southeast 5'h Avenue corridor, adjacent to the existing salt marsh. • The objective was met. OBJECTIVE III. Identify available land suitable for the provision of community facilities to support the existing projected population by 1991. • The available community facility land in 1987 comprised of 231 acres. • The available community facility land in 1995 comprised of 276 acres • This results in a net increase of 45 acres of community facility land within the community. The difference is identified in the future land use section of the EAR. Revised September 3, 1997 1 i OBJECTIVE III. Implement drainage improvements in the southeast area of the City. s • The City has developed a drainage study. 'est has not been imomente6 The implementation of the project has been initiated. • The objective has not been met • The plan amendment section will address necessary changes to meet this objective. This amendment will include a City-wide study. OBJECTIVE IV. Work with Broward County and South Florida Regional Planning Council to implement drainage rules and criteria. c • The City continues to work with Broward County and SFRPC to implement drainage rules and criteria of those jurisdictions and the SFWMD. This includes the environmental resource licensing by FDEP. • The objective has been met. OBJECTIVE V. Maximize water management systems, rules and regulations to discourage urban sprawl. The Comprehensive Plan and land development regulations enacted on 2127190 require compliance with all applicable water management rules and regulations to discourage urban sprawl. • City identified as a urban infill city. • The objective has been met. OBJECTIVE VI. The City shall try to discourage the further spread of salt water intrusion. • The City, to the greatest extent possible, discourages the spread of salt water intrusion via its Comprehensive Plan and land development regulations. However, since Dania is an East Broward coastal city, regional influences are significant as it relates to salt water intrusion and the majority of the City has been affected by salt water intrusion for many years. Accordingly, the City has subscribed to the Broward County Regional System wiY abandea its which reduces the demand on the existing wells, thereby reducing the threat of salt water intrusion. • The objective has been met. Revised September 3, 1997 10 I OBJECTIVE IV. Conserve native vegetative communities, wildlife habitats and marine habitats at their present levels. • The City requires that any developments in sensitive areas obtain all necessary dredge and fill permits from Broward County, FDEP, and Army Corps of Engineers. • The Dania salt marsh area which is a 122 acre area east of Southeast 5th Avenue and south of Dania Beach Boulevard has been acquired for public purposes. This has enhanced the native vegetative community, wildlife habitats and marine habitats. • The objective has been met or exceeded. • Plan amendments may be proposed to address future needs. OBJECTIVE V. Continue to coordinate with adjacent local governments and regional interests to protect natural resources. • The City continues to coordinate with the adjacent local governments of Ft. Lauderdale, Unincorporated Broward, and Hollywood as well as the Regional Planning Council. • The City continues to participate on the TAC Committee of Broward County. • The City ensures that LAPC's and urban wilderness areas are consistent with the County's environmentally sensitive land status. • The City ensures that all hazardous waste materials are fully licensed by Broward County Department of Natural Resource Protection. • The objective has been met. OBJECTIVE VI Waters that flow into estuarine or ocean waters shall continue to receive pre- treatment. • All drainage is required to meet standards of Broward County and SFWMD and all discharges receive pre-treatment. • A storm water retention buffer area is being developed along the Southeast a Avenue/salt marsh perimeter. • The objective has been met Revised September 3, 1997 21 PROBLEMS OF DEVELOPMENT PHYSICAL DETERIORATION LOCATION OF LAND USES & SOCIAL J ECONOMIC EFFECTS I i i i i i i The city needs to continually update the data so as to have the needed information available and also needs to review the impact on services and projected needs based upon the new population data. ThA annexed cGb[ems-Gf-development whi[G w+lt tta4n the-6eaprehensive44a"pdate-and- vi4utum astiens of the rates this area-inte-its-initiat+ves fer-development. Aing a�Here-is-a-rr+ajer--issae-e€-land-ace-sempatibid+ty-with-the-airpef# ential--areas—west# rd-County-has plan e—Fern ternatienat--AirpGA--whieh—includes a rnprehensive Plaa4h ssibiky-ef-ohange of land ility "he impacts-s�d-4 ohe-a}rPert: erect a G!gnW4isant4rn I ertahl-nen-resi typeI 1a;d USe Ghangesse and-enhance thtax hare f4DF the e FnHnFty- -he addressed i . the atonn to bett- 'rhos 1AtAr#ll also-he-a f itS COMPFehensive Plan _u he Gapital prw Gomnwnity. B. RATE OF DEVELOPMENT ASSESSMENT ACTUAL VS. ANTICIPATED RATE OF DEVELOPMENT As indicated in the Housing Element the projected number of housing units constructed by 1990 (7,699) has almost exceeded the projections through the year 2010 which were 7,800 units. Even though the projections were not valid the impact that this increased growth had on public facilities was Revised September 3, 1997 2 4 I 4 UNFORESEEN / UNANTICIPATED PROBLEMS & OPPORTUNITIES i i y UNFORESEEN/UNANTICIPATED PROBLEMS AND OPPORTUNITIES (9J-5.0053 (6)(a)(5)) I. PROBLEMS A. FORT LAUDERDALE/HOLLYWOOD INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT EXPANSION The proposed runway extension for the south runway of the Ft. Lauderdale Hollywood International Airport will have significant social and economic impacts to the City of Dania. The acquisition program includes 97 acres that was slated for employment-based land uses to supply a significant tax base for the City of Dania. This property was acquired by Broward County in 1995 and was removed from the tax rolls; therefore, it will no longer generate tax revenues for the City. Further, the City made significant improvements to the water, sewer and roads in this area and that investment will also be lost to the City of Dania. j The runway extension will also have impacts to the Melaleuca Isles neighborhood with the increased frequency of airport take-offs and landings resulting in increased noise in that neighborhood. There is great concern that the runway extension will have a diminution in the value of the properties in that area which would further affect the tax base of the City. In addition to the runway extension acquisition, Broward County has also acquired the Trails End Mobile Home Park, which was slated for future commercial and industrial use on the City's land use plan. This is another area of tax base loss which comprises a total of approximately 15 acres of land. B. NORTHWEST 10TH STREET rh;;,gA AGI IAtPFie6i_ eff . paFtiGwIafty MelaIeUGa isles, s +:'.': bA_A, &to the-Gi Revised September 4, 1997 I tra#isway depiste f#fsways-prnay aet-be appmpriate- The extension of NW 10'h Street into Port Everglades is problematic as to whether it is a positive step for either Dania, its related Seaport and International Airport. The Seaport has opposed it in the past due to cargo security considerations, and the Airport has expressed concerns over mixing heavy industrial traffic with its terminal traffic. For Dania our northern residential communities could be negatively impacted as well as our US 1 corridor being overloaded by cut through south bound industrial traffic by passing the 1-595 interstate corridor connector. II. OPPORTUNITIES A. ANNEXATION AREA The City of Dania annexed a large, approximately two square-mile area generally west of Ravenswood Road, since the adoption of the comprehensive plan. Approximately 4,000 people reside in this area, and it also includes a variety of industrial and commercial based activities. This is a large area of expansion to the community and will be addressed in the updated comprehensive plan. B. BASS PRO Recently the Bass Pro Corporation has selected Dania for the development of a significant retail and exposition based facility, highlighting the equipment and sales provided by the company. This facility will have significant socio-economic impacts to the community and will provide numerous employment opportunities, as well as a significant tax base for the community. This development is consistent with the comprehensive plan; however, it represents a significant opportunity as Dania continues to grow and develop. Revised September 4, 1997 2 Ls4h it hewn Kerr & Associates, Inc. Member,American Institute of Certified Planners VIA FACSIMILE June 10, 1997 Mr. Kenneth Metcalf, Community Program Administrator State of Florida Department of Community Affairs 2555 Shumard Oak Boulevard Tallahassee, FL 32399-2100 RE: Dania Evaluation And Appraisal Report ) Dear Mr. Metcalf: Following our most recent conversation, we conducted additional research and analysis related to the issues raised in the Department's letter dated October 31, 1996 concerning the Dania EAR. We are proposing several modifications to the adopted EAR based on the data that is readily available. Further analysis and revisions to the EAR required to address the Department's comments would require a substantial amount of effort and would further delay the EAR process. The revisions that we are proposing are attached hereto. I will be contacting you latter this week to discuss these revision. • Planning • Zoning • Land Use • Expert Testimony • 7 808 East Las Olas Boulevard, Suite 104, Ft. Lauderdale, Florida 33301 Phone: (954) 467-6308 Fax: (954) 467-5309 Thank you in advance for your attention to this matter. Sincer y, Leig err, AICP Pres ent LRK/ker attachments _ . i L Text to be added to the PLANAMENDMENTS Section of the adopted EAR D. UPDATE DATA/ANALYSIS To be added to this section: The five (5) and ten (10) year population projections that will be used in the plan update are 15,019 (year 2000) and 16,214 (year 2005). These projects will be utilized to determine the level of service standards and infrastructure needs for the community. F. ICE AND TRANSPORTATION UPDATE The City recognizes that the new requirements for the transportation element focus on linking land use and transportation planning processes as well as placing a strong emphasis on transit facilities. Broward County is responsible for regional roads in the area as well as the provision of transit facilities. At this time the County is considering the establishment of a regional transit authority along with Dade and Palm Beach Counties. During the plan update, the City will coordinate with Broward County in order to develop a local transportation element that is consistent with the County's efforts. Coordination mechanisms such as the MPO and TCC are currently in place and will be utilized during the plan update process. The City will also incorporate any Eastward Ho related land use plan amendments that are determined to be appropriate for the City. The City's land use element currently incorporates several provisions that promote mixed land uses. Plan amendments are anticipated to enhance these provisions and encourage developments that can support transit service. G. COASTAL MANAGMENT Revisions to Rule 9J-5 modified the definition of coastal high hazard area to include those areas located in the evacuation zone for a Category 1 Hurricane. There is no distinction between the category 1 and 2 hurricane evacuation zones within the City of Dania. In Dania, the newly defined Coastal High Hazard Area includes all of the land area located east of SE 5 Avenue/14 Avenue. The coastal high hazard area as identified in the current plan is limited to the land located east of AIA. As a result of this change in definition, plan amendments will be required to add approximately 407 acres to the coastal high hazard area. Of the 173 acres of vacant land added to the coastal high hazard area only 26 acres (15%) are developable. The remaining acreage has been purchased by the public for preservation or will be restricted for development based on Broward County Department of Natural Resource Protection regulations due to the existence of wetlands. Public investment in the newly defined coastal high hazard area is limited to roadways, bridges and utility lines. There are no public utility plants, public service buildings or hospitals located within the coastal high hazard area. The City has not met its objective to prepare a post disaster redevelopment plan by 1991. This objective will be reestablished during the plan amendment process. Broward County is embarking on a county-wide post disaster redevelopment plan and the City anticipates coordinating its post disaster redevelopment planning efforts with that of the County. Existing intergovernmental coordination mechanisms such as the League of Cities Technical Advisory Committee will be used to facilitate coordination of these planning efforts. Due to the limited public facilities in the coastal high hazard area it is not anticipated that major policy changes will be required as a result of the post-disaster redevelopment planning efforts. However, following a complete analysis of the existing improvements in the area and any damage due to previous storms, the City will evaluate the need to additional policies to protect the coastal high hazard area. H. NEW DEFINITIONS Several new or revised definitions have been incorporated in Rule 9J-5. The need for amendments to the plan related to the new definition of coastal high hazard area is discussed above. The term urban sprawl is anticipated to have a significant impact on many communities. However, Dania is located in the eastern, developed portion of Broward County. The corporate limits for the city do not extend west of SR 7. In addition, all of the land area in the City is located within the Broward County Urban Infill Transportation Concurrency Exception Area. Therefore, the new definition for urban sprawl will not impact the City of Dania. I. HOUSING ELEMENT Amendments to Rule 9J-5 require that local governments address the housing needs of very low income households. Of the vacant land in the City approximately 207 acres is designated residential on the land use plan. Over 40 % of this residential, vacant land is designated for densities of 10 dwelling units per acre or greater. Therefore, additional land area exists to accommodate residential units for very low income households. In addition, approximately one-half of the existing dwelling units are comprised of multi-family units and mobile homes. 1990 Census data also indicates that approximately 25% of the housing stock in the City of Dania is valued below $60,000 as compared to 13% countywide. Finally the median value of dwelling units in the City is $84,600 which is almost $7,000 less than the countywide median. Further analysis is required in order to determine if plan amendments are required to meet the housing needs of very low income households. However, readily available data indicates that the City of Dania currently provides a substantial amount of affordable housing. II. Text to be added to paragraph LA. on page 6 of SANITARY SEWER SUBELEMENT CONDITIONS SECTION The only area served by septic tanks in the City of Dania service area is known as Melaleuca Isles which encompasses approximately 102 acres and 367 dwelling units which translates to a density of less than (4) four dwelling units per acre. This density does not exceed the maximum density for septic tanks as specified by State regulations. In addition, the area is fully developed at this time and no additional septic tanks are anticipated. The Broward County Health Unit is responsible for permitting septic tanks. At this time, representatives of the Broward County Health Unit are not aware of any problems related to the existence of septic tanks in the City. Specifically, no ground water problems linked to the existence of septic tanks are known to exist. Ground water quality data is not collected by the City or the Broward County Health Unit. M. Text to be added to paragraph IL, on page 9 of DRAINAGNE AND NATURAL GROUND RECHARGE SUBELEMENT CONDITIONS SECTION The City retained a consulting engineering firm to complete a City-wide assessment of the existing drainage system. The report identified recommended improvements for the City's system. In addition, the City recently had a city-wide special assessment for maintenance and improvements. 9539/EAR•ADD TEXT I r I tie 1 _ STATE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY AFFAIRS "Helping Floridians create safe, vibrant, sustainable communities" LAWrON CHILES JAMES F.MURLEY Governor October 16, 1997fearl The Honorable William Hyde Mayor, City of Dania 100 West Dania Beach Boulevard Dania, Florida 33004 Dear Mayor Hyde: The Department of Community Affairs has completed its review of the revised Dania Evaluation and Appraisal Report(EAR), which the Department received on September 11, 1997. The Department has detem¢ned that the EAR is"sufficient"as defined in Subsection 163.3191(9), F.S. The City may now proceed with the adoption of amendments, including amendments unrelated to the EAR Pursuant to Section 163.3191(4),the City must adopt EAR-based amendments within one year from the adoption date of the revised EAR Therefore,the City must adopt the EAR-based amendments by September 2, 1998. The Department is authorized to grant one,six-month extension for good and sufficient cause should the City require additional time. The adopted EAR includes numerous recommendations for the adoption of the EAR-based amendmen including amendments to respond to changes in statutory and rule requirements, to strengthen and clarify existing plan provisions,and to complete studies relating to water quality, septic tanks, and stormwater needs. In particular, we would like to emphasize the need for the City to coordinate with Broward County, the Metropolitan Planning Organization and the Florida Department of Transportation in preparing the Transportation Element. Similarly,the preparation of the Post Disaster Redevelopment Plan will require significant coordination with Broward County. Department staff are available to provide technical assistance as the City prepares the amendments. The Department appreciates the cooperation of the City and your consultant in completing the revisions to the adopted EAR If you have any questions or concerns,you may contact Ken Metcalf, Comnnu ity Program Administrator, at(904)487-4545. Sincerely`d'NA/e^aa—QI C L J.Thomas Beck, Chief Bureau of Local Planning JTB/ImL/m cc: Carolyn Dekle,Executive Director, SFRPC Michael Smith,City Manager,Dania William Allen, Director,Dania Growth Managemett Leigh Robinson Kerr&Associates, Inc. 2555 SHUMARD OAK BOULEVARD • TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 32399.2100 Phone: 850.488.8466/Suncom 278.8466 FAX: 850.921.0781/Suncom 291.0781 Internet address: http://www.state.fl.us/comaff/dca.himl FINN KEYS GRBN SWAMP sourH FLOtioh REcoVmyofna /m of Oi6d Sweewmn Field Offin Area of Nd$We Comm Fldd Office P.O.824022 2796Omea Fighway,Sule212 ISSEaASumnedin _ 8600N.W.36165M Mmdwn.HaAda 330502227 hlow F"338304641 • Mini,FWda 331594022 NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING CITY OF DANIA COMPREHENSIVE PLAN EVALUATION AND APPRAISAL REPORT (EAR) A Public Hearing will be conducted by the City Commission of the City of Dania to adopt by resolution the Revised Evaluation an Appraisal Report (EAR) of the City of Dania's Comprehensive Plan. DATE: August 26, 1997 TIME: 7:30 p.m. or as soon thereafter as the same may be heard PLACE: City Commission Chambers Dania Administrative Center 100 West Dania Beach Blvd. Dania, FL 33004 The EAR is a report evaluating conditions city-wide at the time of the Comprehensive Plants adoption and at the time of the preparation of the EAR. All Plan Objectives and Policies are reviewed, and an assessment is made to determine the extent that the Objectives and Policies have been achieved in the report. Changes or amendments are including suggested matting Plan Obje to ctives,i es, Policedate the s andr its Standarrds.ntsi The purpose of the EAR Public Hearing is to adopt the EAR and State Statutesand Rule opportunity 9J-5, Florida Admen strative Code. with publicafford the For information about the EAR, contact the City's Growth Manage- ment Department at (954) 921-8700 x255. Interested persons are invited to attend the Public Hearing and/or provide written or verbal comments on the proposed EAR. FOR INFORMATION REGARDING THE EAR, THE SCHEDULE OF ACTIVITIES OR ANY ASPECT OF THE EAR PROCESS, CON- TACT THE OFFICE OF THE GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPART- MENT, CITY HALL, 100 WEST DANIA BEACH BLVD., DANIA, FLORIDA. A COPY F THEEAR MAY BE ED BY THE PUBLIC DURINGR OOPOSED RMALL WORKING HOURS.ECT- ANY PERSON WHO DECIDES TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE BY THE CITY COMMISSION WITH REGARD TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING OR HEARING WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS, AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. TERRY VIRTA Alt " GROWTH MANAGEMENT DIRECTOR •� SUN-SEI4TINEL \ PASTE,COPY OF LFX7AL NOTICE OF.RF Published Daily Fort Lauderdale, Broward County, Florida Boca Raton, Palm Beach County, Florida STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF BROWARD/PALM BEACII ' Before the undersigned authority personally appeared who om oath says that he is j&t1111" of the Sun-Sentinel, y newspaper published is DFowardh1allat Beach County, m-Fidli, that the atlac ed,,wpy of advertisement, being a is the matter of — in the Court was published in said newspaper in the issues of /,j-;F/ 9 9 7 Affant further says that the said Sun-Sentinel is a newspaper published is said Broward/ Palm Beach County, Florida,and that the said newspaper has heretofore been continuously published in said Broward/Palm Beach County, Florida,each day,and have been entered as second class matter at the post office in Fort Lauderdale, is said BFOwar'd County, Florida, for a period of one year next preceding the first publication of the attacbed copy of advertise- ment, and affiant says that he has neither paid nor promised any person,firm or corporation ,any discount, rebate,commission or refund for the purpose o[se wring this adveFti5etsent for publication in said newspaper. (Si re (rant) Sworn to and subscribed before we this cP' day of :fr^?e Tara L.Bazak L` rY^ MY COMMISSION r CMM935 EXPIRES iLGL.�1�1 ��= Jury20,tom (Signature of Notary Pub] •+ 9ONOEO TINU TAM FAIN INSURANCE.INC. (Name of Notary typed, printed or stamped) Personally Known _or Produced Identification CCD I�JI A i } �l CITY OF DANIA BEACH � COMPREHE NSIVE PLAN 1 � I bob, ' l 1 i EVALUATION AND APPRAISAL REPORT September 2, 1997 Resolution #117-97 I -- CITY OF DANIA - EVALUATION AND APPRAISAL REPORT I PROJECTTASKS I. CONDITION - ADOPTION CURRENT II. ADOPTED OBJECTIVES - COMPARISION / RESULTS ' III. PROBLEMS OF DEVELOPMENT; PHYSICAL DETERIORATION; LOCATION OF LAND USES & SOCIAL / ECONOMIC EFFECTS IV. UNFORSEEN / UNANTICIPATED PROBLEMS & OPPORTUNITIES V. COMPREHENSIVE PLAN IMPACTS VI. IDENTIFY NEEDED ACTIONS VII. PLAN AMENDMENTS VIII. PUBLIC PARTICIAPTION 1 I i i I I � -J CONDITIONS ADOPTION / CURRENT I i i ELEMENTS: FUTURE LAND USE HOUSING TRAFFIC CIRCULATION SANITARY SEWER, SOLID WASTE, DRAINAGE COASTAL MANAGEMENT RECREATION AND OPEN SPACE CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT i I I i i FUTURE LAND USE ELEMENT i I 1 -I � I � _J TABLE OF CONTENTS i COND/T/ONS AT ADOPTION I i PAGE i 1. EXISTING LAND USE DATA REQUIREMENTS .................. 1 11. ANALYSIS REQUIREMENT ............................................ 1 A. Available Facilities B. Vacant Land Analysis C. Land Needs D. Redevelopment E. Flood Prone Areas CURRENT I&T100 I. INTRODUCTION ............................................................. 6 I ' II. EXISTING LAND USE DATA REQUIREMENTS .................. 6 A. Residential Development B. Commercial Development C. Industrial Development D. Recreation/Conservation E. Community Facilities F. Historical Resources I G. Vacant I H. Population Projections III. ANALYSIS REQUIREMENTS 7 A. Availability of Services B. Vacant Land Analysis C. Land Requirements IV. SUMMARY ....................................................................... 9 j TABLES FOLLOW TEXT 1. Existing Land Use II. Existing Land Use By Flex Zone III. Vacant Land Use By Type I I _ 4 FUTURE LAND USE ELEMENT CONDITIONS AT ADOPTION I. EXISTING LAND USE DATA REQUIREMENTS [9J-5.006(1)(c)] I The City of Dania consists of approximately 5 square miles (3,000 acres) and includes a portion of ocean front in the east disconnected from the i balance of the City. Dania is situated south of Fort Lauderdale; north of Hollywood and east of an Unincorporated Area. Approximately 65% of the City is in a built condition. Table I identifies the existing land uses within the City as of 1987 and Table II provides the existing land uses in further detail by flexibility zone. A. Vacant Land Vacant land consists of almost 1,000 acres. The majority of the vacant land is occurring in three parts of the City. The western i portion of the community consists primarily of industrially designated land. East of the airport industrially oriented uses are permitted and the southeastern part of the City contains residentially designated lands. I B. Population Projections The City utilizes the population projections developed by the I Broward County Office of Planning as follows: 1988 1993 2010 I Resident 11,951 12,039 12,542 Seasonal 1,182 1,170 1,217 II. ANALYSIS REQUIREMENTS [9J-5.006(2)] A. Available Facilities [9J-5.006(2)(a)] 1. Traffic Circulation The City of Dania is transected by a variety of federal, state and county highways. This series of roadway systems handles the 1 , A I -- majority of total traffic demand within the City while only a small portion uses collector and local streets. There are no problems or deficiencies on the local roadway system at the present time. 2. Sanitary Sewer The City subscribed to the Broward County 201 program and is now only responsible for the development, expansion and maintenance of a collection system and transmission of wastewater to the Hollywood 201 Plant. The City's wastewater flow is consistent with its agreement with the City of Hollywood and its 201 system. The City maintains an adequate level of service for the existing and committed development within the City. 3. Solid Waste The City's solid waste disposal is presently handled through a private hauler and is disposed at the Waste Management, Inc. landfill located at the northeast corner of the Florida Turnpike and Sample Road in north Broward County. The City is entering into a contract with Reuter, Inc. to provide future solid waste disposal. At the present time the City has an adequate collection and disposal system which provides the proper level of service for the existing and committed development within the community. 4. Drainage The drainage system within the City of Dania is composed of canals and lakes which discharge to the Dania Cut-off Canal and the C-10 Canal. The entire drainage system is managed by the South Florida Water Management District, the Broward County Water Resources Management Division and the City Engineer. i The drainage system has adequately protected the existing community. 5. Potable Water The water treatment plant has a design capacity of 3.0 mgd with a present demand of 2.2 mgd reflecting an adequate J 2 i level of service. There are three areas of the City where distribution deficiencies have been identified. 6. Natural Groundwater Aquifer Recharge Broward County has embarked upon a wellfield Protection program which prohibits and/or regulates hazardous toxic i substances. The City of Dania is committed to this program. The City also requires water conserving fixtures in new construction which will further protect the natural groundwater for the City of Dania. B. Vacant Land Analysis [9J-5.006(2)(b)] This segment of the report analyzes the character and magnitude of the existing vacant or undeveloped land to determine suitability for use. 1. Vacant Land Inventory Table III provides an inventory of the vacant land within the community as of January, 1987 by land use. A vast majority of the vacant land is industrial and comprises over 50% of the available land. i 2. Physiography, Drainage and Minerals Dania is nearly level in topography. The soils are underlain by limestone which is porous allowing water to move through it laterally for long distances. Physiography, topography and drainage provide no impediments to development within any of the flex zones. 3. Soils and Wetlands Soils are an important factor which affect development potential of land. For the undeveloped portions of the City there are only two soil types that require some modification prior to construction. These soils are the perrine and i pennsucco series. Both of these soils typically contain wetland species which require permitting through the Army Corps of Engineers, .J 3 yy��, Florida Department of Environmental Regulation, and I _ Broward County Department of Natural Resource Protection. I The City Commission has taken steps to assist in the conservation through the reduction of the density east of Fifth Avenue to one (1) unit per acre which will provide greater site plan latitude to insure proper conservation of this area. _I 4. Wellfields The Broward County Water Resources Management Division is responsible for the development of a comprehensive future wellfield study. There are no future sites in the City, but existing wells and cones of influence have been shown. 5. Lakes, Beaches and Shores 1 All the beach front property within the City of Dania is held in public ownership. Further, there is no contemplated I development within the beaches or shores area. The estuarine system within the City is minimal and primarily related to some mangrove communities as previously pointed out in the soils and wetlands portion of this analysis. j All of the rivers, bays and lakes within the community are man-made. The rivers are primarily the drainage canal system and the lakes were excavated to meet fill requirements for development both in and outside the City of Dania. There are no harbors within the City of Dania. 6. Historical Resources This historical resources have been identified in the Housing Element and on the existing Land Use Plan of the j Comprehensive Plan. No vacant land development will impact these historic resources. C. Land Needs [9J-5.006(2)(c)] he Year 1993 projections of approximately 7 500 units To support t , N' � J �N y within the community, the associated land need requirements are j anticipated to be approximately 50 acres. This is established utilizing the average new starts for housing within the community of - I about 90 per year and recognizes the predominate mix of housing 4 i i i from the period of 1980 to 1987 which reflects a substantial number of multi-family permits (91%) against single-family permit issuance (9%). D. Redevelopment [9J-5.006(2)(d)] The City of Dania is one of six (6) target areas as identified in the Broward County Redevelopment Plan - Florida Statues 163. The boundaries of the target area generally lie west of U.S. #l, south of Old Griffin Road, east of the C-10 Canal and north of the Sheridan Street. E. Flood Prone Areas [9J-5.006(2)(e)] The City of Dania has limited areas which are flood prone and any development or redevelopment within these areas would have to conform to the flood insurance rate maps. The City fully subscribes with the FEMA maps and all development must conform with those standards. i I I I I I i I 5 i FUTURE LAND USE ELEMENT CURRENT INTRODUCTION The following comparisons are provided to demonstrate the changes in the Future Land Use Element of the Dania Comprehensive Plan that have accrued since 1989. i H. EXISTING LAND USE DATA REQUIREMENTS [9J-5.006(1)(a)(b)(c)& 01 Table l of the 1989 plan outlines the existing land uses and indicated the total land area of the city as being 2,924 acres. The biggest change in land usage occurred in vacant land. In 1989, the city had 956 acres of vacant land as compared to 744 acres today, a decrease of 212 acres. Vacant land was reduced by the development of Commercial, Industrial and Residential developments. Approximately 75% of the city is in a built condition as compared to 65% in 1989. The following will further analyze the different characteristics of the existing land uses within the community. A. RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT I ; Residential uses represent 915 acres or 31% of the city as compared to 28% or 828 acres in 1989. The increase of 87 acres is largely due to the increased development of single family homes. Residential vacant land use represents 27% of the vacant land inventory. B. COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT i Commercial Development has increased from 292 acres in 1989 to 366 acres or 13% in 1995. This was due to the development shopping centers and the infill of vacant commercial lots. Commercial vacant land still represents 14% of the vacant land in Dania. C. INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT j Industrial development has increased by 57 developed acres or 12% of the city. In 1989 industrial land uses occupied only 301 acres or 10% of the land area. Vacant industrial land represents the largest category in the city with 58% of the industrial land vacant. ,l 6 I i j - D. RECREATION/CONSERVATION The recreational facilities have not decreased by 8 acres as indicated on Table I. The difference is in an error discovered in the 1989 plan and not to a decrease in acreage. The 192 acres makes u indicated in Table I ma p 7% of the total. E. COMMUNITY FACILITIES Community facilities have increased by 45 acres due to the expansion of the airport into the NE section of the city. This is reflected in Table III in Flex Zone 79. F. HISTORICAL RESOURCES - No Change G. VACANT Vacant land now represents 25% of the city or 744 acres with a majority of vacant land to the east of the airport and along the 1-95 corridor. In 1989 vacant land was 33% of the city or 956 acres, a decrease of 212 acres. I H. POPULATION PROJECTIONS (Actual population as of the 1990 census) 1989 1990 1995 Residents 11,951 11,894 14,114 ' includes seasonal residents Seasonal 1,182 1,130 I Broward County Strategic 9 rate is Planning and Growth Management; The projections for 1988 were slightly off as Dania did not increase it's population at the rate anticipated. III. ANALYSIS REQUIREMENTS (Availability of Services) [9J-5.006(2)(a)] i A. AVAILABILITY OF SERVICES. (SERVICES) 1. TRAFFIC CIRCULATION No Change See Traffic Circulation Element for specific details. 7 I tow" _ " - ar 2. SANITARY SEWER No Change - See Sanitary Sewer, Solid Waste, Drainage Element for specific details. 3. SOLID WASTE The city has entered into a contract with Reuter, Inc. to provide solid waste disposal at a composting and recycling plant in Pembroke Pines. At the present time the city is recycling approximately 100% of its Solid Waste. (See Sanitary Sewer, Solid Waste, Drainage Element for more details.) i 4. DRAINAGE No Change - See Sanitary Sewer, Solid Waste, Drainage Element for more details. 5. POTABLE WATER The current status of the three areas of the City where potable distribution deficiencies were identified in the Comprehensive Plan are as follows: I a) Melaleuca Isles is situated immediately south of the Fort Lauderdale Hollywood International Airport and west of US 1. Due to its proximity to the airport and the planned expansion of the airport which has been in the planning phases for several years, the water system improvements have not occurred in this area due to the unknown impact the billion dollar airport expansion plan may have to this neighborhood. b) Southeast Area: the distribution system for the southeastern area has been improved and bolstered with a 12" lines and the problem has been rectified. c) Northeast Area (Gulfstream and HarbourTowne): This area has received the new 12" water line which has rectified the problem in the this vicinity of the City. 8 i j 6. NATURAL GROUNDWATER AQUIFER RECHARGE No Change B. VACANT LAND ANALYSIS [9J-5.006(2)(b)) 1. Vacant Land Inventory As stated previously the city contains approximately 744 acres of vacant land as compared to 956 acres in 1989. A vast majority of the land remains industrial and comprises over 50% of the vacant land inventory. A majority of the vacant land lies east of the Ft. Lauderdale International Airport and along the 1-95 corridor. At the j present time the airport is preparing for a major runway expansion and has purchased a vast majority of the vacant land. This land will not be developed and will remain in the vacant land inventory. ; 2. Physiography, Drainage and Minerals - No Change I ' 3. Soils and Wetlands - No Change 4. Wellfields - No Change 5. Lakes, Beaches and Shores - No Changes j 6. Historical Resources - No Changes C. LAND REQUIREMENTS This section of the plan identifies the permitted uses and densities of each land use category. No changes have occurred in this i section since 1989. , 9 I I - 1 IV. Summary The Future Land Use Element indicates that the city continues to grow with increases in developed residential, commercial and industrial land. The impact of the proposed expansion of the Ft. Lauderdale Airport will greatly effect the future land uses of the city. The full impact of this expansion has not yet been determined. However the impact on -7 revenues is already being felt from the loss of tax base. I The annexation of the lands west of Ravenswood road have greatly impacted the needs for public services. The impact and land uses will be addressed at the time the city develops it's new Comprehensive Plan in 1996. I' I i -.l I; Revised Ruie Revised Statute pescrintion of Chancre !based on Comprehensive Plan Oblectives 8 Policies poes Plan satisfy Rule 9J-5 F.A.C.) Rule 9J-5 and Ch. 9J-5.021(1) Each local government See"Consistency of Dania Comprehensive Plan with State and Yes comprehensive plan shall be Regional Plans"which demonstrates that 1989 Dania Plan is consistent with the appropriate compatible with and furthers the" Strategic Regional Policy comprehensive regional policy plan Plan for South Florida". 9J-5.021(4) the local government shall attach The 1989 Dania Plan contains a comparison with the State's Yes to Its comprehensive plan or plan Comprehensive Plan. amendment... a listing entitled "Consistency of the Local Comprehensive Plan with the State Comprehensive Plan" a Future Land Use Element Table III Vacant Land Use By Type Data From 1987 Flex Zone L(5) LM M MH H C I CF U TOTAL 58 4 4 78 18 274 79 _ 3 253 80 81 83 9E-900 5 34 2473 325 84 1 it 8 584 353 q 16 6 95 504 4 21 956 Data From 1995 Flex Zone L(5) LM M MH H C I CF U TOTAL 58 0 0 78 251 251 79 80 81 83 0 d43 0 0 0 55 181 0 0 253 gq 122 37 0 5 50 0 0 0 240 T T 12 37 0 5 105 432 0 0 744 Changed Data from 1987-1995 Flex Zone L(5) LM M MH H C I CF U TOTAL N881 -0 4 -3 -2 -18 -23 -10 •9 -5 21 -6676-18 -20 -53 -11 -3 -8 -111 TOTAL -26 -29 -53 -16 73 10 -72 -0 -21 -214 Source: Dania Growth Management Department 1995 FUTURE LAND USE ELEMENT -, CURRENT CONDITIONS SUMMARY OF ALL ADOPTED LAND USE TEXT AND MAP AMENDMENTS [9J-5.0053(6)(2)(b)] A. LAND USE MAP CHANGES 1. 5/8/90 - Broward County requested a change in land use for a 39 -, acre parcel of land designated as Parks and Recreation. The request was for a change in land use from Parks and Recreation to Industrial to allow industrial development in exchange for environmentally sensitive lands located in Parkland, Florida. i The Dania City Commission denied the request. However, the plan was amended despite the City's objection. 2. 11/09/93 -Adopted a Land Use amendment for 4.8 acres of land on Southeast 5th Avenue from Low 1 to Medium 16. The Future Land Use Map reflects the two land use amendments that have taken place since 1989. B. TEXT CHANGES 1. No text changes have been adopted since 1989. I i Future Land Use Element Table I Existing Land Use 1987Data 1995D3ta Change Acres % Pcres °l° Residential 828 28 , Q15 Commercial 292 10 «" 366 Industrial 301 10 3¢ 57 Recreation 200 7 r; , Education, Public Buildings and Grounds, and other Public Facilities 244 8 60 3 47 2 ,- ,� A as,'•,.13 Mobile Home Rock Pit 43 VacantlUndeveloped 956 33 744 TOTAL 2,924 100 2,924 ,. UP Source: City of Dania Growth Management Department Future Land Use Element Table II Existing Land Use By Flex Zone i 1 Data from 1987 Flex Zone SF MF-1 MH C I R-1 I R-2 U CF RP V TOTAL i 58 21 4 25 78 1 31 32 g79 p 9 259 8 2 3 157 274 504 28 81 1 1 83 128 1721 491 891 182 3 63 8 251 431 325 1,087 84 148 380 11 192 11 43 58 2 49 353 1.247 TOTAL 2761 5521 601 2921 Jul 1 461 154 13 2311 431 956 2,924 Data from 1995 Flex Zone SF MF-1 MH C I R-1 I R-2 U CF RP V TOTAL I ,I 58 78 1 26 0 27 i 79 0 82 2 16 - 212 251 563 80 0 0 81 0 83 128 196 361 123 265 0 63 8 15 0 253 1,087 84 148 443 11 242 11 43 58 2 49 240 1,247 0 TOTAL 276 639 47 365 358 43 149 26 276 0 744 2,924 Changed Data from 1987. 1995 Flex Zone SF MF-1 MH C I R-1 R-2 U CF RP V TOTAL 58 -21 -4 -25 78 0 -5 -5 79 -9 23 13 55 -23 59 80 -28 -28 81 -1 -1 83 0 24 -13 341 83 -3 0 0 -10 -43 -72 0 84 0 63 0 50 0 0 0 0 0 -113 0 TOTAL 0 87 -13 74 57 3 5 3 45 A3 212 U Source: Dania Growth Management Department 1995 'Includes U.S. 1 &Airport Uses —L-!T I A y -�� U Adjacent Land Uses ( Y y I T44 Y Y (9J-5.006(1)(f) V � LD CUSSIFICATIDN SYMBOL ♦y T \_� ,�__� ��'� j1 I ____ ___ _______________ ____ SInyle Paaf lY Estate I� Y (1 W/AC. MAX.) E single Family detached- F Y I V I E , \ ��.._—'L��\ I�.� •}(- II I I // suburban SF l•Faehan (aoderale- _ rJ L Y I 1 I \ --� o c=� C-J —� j(• l' I 11 le Mull ss than 25 W/AC.1 K_1 f - - I C -` I ` �i`\� :/ �(• I /' f multi-Fae11Y (nigh' greater than 25 W/A6.1 NF-2 -I —'1-'�"1-I-'r �(. // ( f( Mobile Homes AV I I I C Pecreatlonai Vehicles I — Vs I N V t I I_1_i v SCetlal Residential U Facilities so L ISF;I---' I _ - - ----- private Pecreation P-1 CL V C I V f Public Pecreation P-2 n-e i RP `I 4 R-2 [omercla] C I I V q_2 u P- 3 office Park/Major B CF V ' P-2 \ ExploYaxnt Center I P-1 Industrial Use A v V C CF c M II �(• Agricultural use C r F MIA BCH BLYO CON Y a- .—.. .—.__ Conservatsan B F-1 An I C q-1 -'fir------- Utf lit fes I I V Educat tonal/other Co.whitY C, b I I I c -I V I \ R-2 I Facilities C U + A Vacant/Undeveloped Land V v V C ' I A . / �'•' I( U F ne c I Historic P s q l l T I Active Pock CA Pitit Areas M PP 1f V Areas c yr u .7 Ma t M ter I I Y Transportation T R-1 CF L` R-z Y— s P- �� 1 , E ,„ v I I I ti V R-z j j j l ... Llli`Na:.„....A...,.,.:,, F _ R-2 r, 1 CF for 1 Y sxF�msx f �.✓ I� 2 C 1 MF-1 V 1 V I i I I I I I I I - CF �l R-2 i i R-2 i �a i i HOUSING ELEMENT I i I i .l .a i TABLE OF CONTENTS i ONNDI MNS�I T ADOPTION PAGE A. DATA REQUIREMENTS ................................................... 1 1. Housing Inventory 2. Characteristics of the 1980 Housing Stock 3. Subsidized Renter Housing 4. Group Homes 5. Mobile Homes 6. Historical Housing I 7. Housing Activity B. ANALYSIS REQUIREMENTS ............................................ 3 1. Household Projections 2. Land Requirements 3. Private Sector Initiatives 4. Special Needs 5. Conservation, Rehabilitation or Demolition Activities and Historically Significant Housing I CURRENT CONDITIONS A. INTRODUCTION ............................................................. 6 B. DATA INVENTORY ............................ 1. Housing Inventory 2. Characteristics of the 1980 Housing Stock 3. Subsidized Renter Housing 4. Group Homes 5. Mobile Homes 6. Historical Housing 7. Housing Activity i C. ANALYSIS REQUIREMENTS ............................................ 9 1. Household Projections 2. Land Requirements 3. Private Sector Initiatives 4. Special Needs 5. Conservation, Rehabilitation or Demolition Activities J and Historically Significant Housing I i i I - T BLES EP-L TEXT 1. Housing Inventory 11. Unit Age 111. Unit Value IV. Gross Rent V. Monthly Mortgage Cost VI. Lacking Facilities VII. Rent to Income VIII. Standard Conditions IX. Subsidized Renter Housing X. Group Homes XI. Mobile Homes XII. Historical XIII. Housing Activity XIV. Projected Dwelling Units XV. Projections of Household Size XVI. Projected Income Range of Housing Units XVII. Projected Population Housing Needs i I ; I I ' _.f i I I - I - HOUSING ELEMENT --- CONDITIONS AT ADOPTION i DATA REQUIREMENTS [9J-5.010(1)] A. Housing Inventory - 1980 [9J-5.010(1)(a) & (b)] - Table I provides an outline of the Housing Inventory for the City of Dania as of 1980. The information is provided by type of units including single family, two family, multi-family and mobile homes. The housing inventory indicates as of 1980 there were approximately 6,100 dwelling units within the City of Dania. Single family dwellings represent 36% or approximately 2,200 dwelling units, and multi-family 56% or 3,400 dwelling units. There are also approximately 400 mobile homes situated within the community primarily located in the northern reaches of the City. B. Characteristics of the 1980 Housing Stock [9J-5.010(1)(a); (b) & (c)] 1. Unit Age Table 11 outlines the unit age of dwelling units within the City of Dania by seven (7) separate age categories beginning from 1939 and running through 1980. Broward County totals are also provided. As reflected on Table II 85% of the housing has been built since 1950 and approximately 60% of the housing has been built since 1960. The City of Dania is one of the pioneer cities within Broward County and unit age is reflective of that as about 40% of the housing was built by 1960. 2. Unit Value ' Table III outlines the unit values within the City of Dania by nine categories ranging in value from less than $10,000 to over $200,000. A median value is provided and also a comparison with Broward County. Table III indicates that over 65% of the housing within the community is valued in the $40 - 100,000 price range low' I with the largest percentage (25%) of the housing in the $60 - 80,000 price range. 3. Gross Rent Table IV outlines the gross rent occurring within the City of Dania as of the 1980 census. The figures are provided in nine categories ranging from $80 - $400 per month; median rent city-wide; and Broward County. Table IV indicates that over 80% of the rents are less than $350. The median in the City of Dania is $248 per month which is approximately $64 less than the County j average of$312 per month for median gross rents. 4. Monthly Mortgage Cost Table V outlines monthly mortgage cost city-wide and within Broward County. Monthly mortgage costs range from under $100 ! to over $600 per month plus a median cost is also provided. The ' median for the City of Dania is $361 a month which is lower than the Broward County median of$389 per month. 5. Lacking Facilities Table VI reflects the number of units within the City which lack complete plumbing, kitchens or central heating. j 6. Rent to Income Ratio Rent to income ratio represents the percentage of a household's income that is utilized to provide shelter which is reflected on Table VII. According to the 1980 U.S. Census, approximately 859 of the City's 2207 units which were renter occupied paid more than 35% of their income for rent. Table VII outlines the Rent to Income Ratio within the City of Dania. 7. Standard/Sub-Standard Housing Conditions The purpose of developing definitions for sub-standard housing is to _. determine whether there are components of the City which could be available for rehabilitation or should be considered as I 2 I i dilapidated and potentially be demolished. Table VIII reflects this information. C. Subsidized Renter Housing [9J-5.010(1)(d)] The City of Dania has subsidized renter housing through the Federal Government Section 8 program. As of 1987 Table IX identifies by Census Tract the number of units within the City. D. Group Homes [9J-5.010(1)(e)] I Table X identifies the group home facilities situated within the City o Dania. E. Mobile Homes [9J-5.010(1)(f)] The inventory of mobile homes provided by FLORIDA HRS indicates j there are four (4) mobile home parks representing 663 units within the City. Table XI identifies each facility. F. Historical Housing [9J-5.010(1)(9)] i Table XII identifies historical housing occurring within the City of Dania. G. Housing Activity (1980-1987) [9J-5.010(1)(h)] Table Xlll is an inventory of housing construction activities within the City of Dania from 1980 to 1987. The data reflects a total increase of approximately 940 dwelling units since 1980. The new construction reflects a substantial increase in new multi-family housing which represents over 80% of the increase. II. ANALYSIS REQUIREMENTS [9J-5.010(2)] A. Household Projections [9J-5.010(2)(a) & (b)] To develop future housing needs it is first important to examine the projected number of dwelling units and population which will be regulated i by the Land Use Element of the City's Comprehensive Plan. Table XIV provides the anticipated number of dwelling units to be constructed in conformance with the City's Land Use Element: For the period 1988 - 1993 an anticipated additional 450 dwelling units is expected and for the period 1993 - 2010 an additional 320 dwelling units is expected. 3 I -, Table XV provides a projection of anticipated households by size to support these projections. Table XV indicates a continuing trend of the community mix that is presently in place with some increase in the two person households. _ These projections were prepared by utilizing a combination of the Bureau of Census Information, Broward County Office of Planning Projections, and City of Dania Growth Management Department Dwelling Unit Compilations for the period of 1980 to 1987 as reflected on Table XIII of the Data Requirements of this element. Table XVI provides the income range of anticipated households both renter and owner occupied based upon the 1980 Census. Table XVII provides a breakdown of the housing needs for the anticipated population. B. Land Requirements [9J-5.010(2)(c)] The land requirements necessary for meeting the anticipated additional dwelling units outlined previously is expected to be approximate 15 acres single and two family and 90 acres multi-family for the Year 1993. C. Private Sector Initiatives [9J-5.010(2)(d) & (e)] The Private Sector is expected to continue to be the main provider of housing for the future residents of the City of Dania. It is anticipated that approximately 70% - 80% of the projected housing needs will be met by private sector within reasonable market conditions which are anticipated in the future. The private sector housing delivery process within Dania and Broward County as a whole has proven to be a relatively effective interaction between the private sector and the public sector. The City of Dania has established a growth management department which essentially provides one stop permitting for many projects within the community. These would be projects with the proper zoning and land use in place. As noted in other parts of the Comprehensive Plan, services are readily available for all developments because of the communities long established history. Vacant land is readily available close to all infrastructure requirements and a mix and variety of not only housing, but non-residential properties are available. D. Special Needs [9J-5.010(2)(f)] 4 i 1. Low and Moderate Income Households — The City of Dania contains one of the six target areas within Broward County. Accordingly, a Chapter 163 Redevelopment Plan has been developed for the City of Dania and is in the implementation phase. An adequate supply of low and moderate income housing sites are presently available on vacant land still remaining within the community. The City has in excess of 200 units of subsidized renter housing. 2. Substandard Housing Conditions The Target area receives CDBG funding on an annual basis to help address the problem within that portion of the City. 3. Low/Moderate Income and Mobile Home Sites As is indicated on Table III the median unit value within the City of Dania is approximately $7,000 less than the Broward County average. Based upon 1980 census as outlined in Table III there is also a greater percentage of units which are in the lower priced bracket. The development of the 163 Redevelopment Area contains approximately 30 acres of vacant land which can provide for a mix of residential housing types. As is outlined on Table I, in 1980 Dania contained approximately 400 mobile homes which is representative of 5.6% of the housing within the community which exceeds the county-wide average of approximately 4.8%. 4. Group Homes and Foster Care Facilities Group homes and or foster care facilities which are licensed by the Florida Department of Health and Rehabilitative Services are situated within residential communities in the City of Dania. E. Conservation, Rehabilitation or Demolition Activities and Historically Significant Housing i As noted in the Redevelopment Plan for the target area, there is a continuing identification of housing for rehabilitation and demolition j activities. J 5 I� HOUSING ELEMENT CURRENT CONDITIONS I. INTRODUCTION The following comparisons are provided to demonstrate the changes to the Housing Element of the Dania Comprehensive Plan. In compiling the new data numerous errors were discovered in the 1980 data. The comparison tables contained in this section reflect the corrected data for 1980. II. DATA INVENTORY A. HOUSING INVENTORY (1980 - 1990) [9J-5.010(1)(a)(b)] Table I shows the difference in the housing inventory for the City of Dania from 1980 to 1990 based on the United States Bureau of Census - 1990 The housing inventory indicates that in 1980 there were 6,091 dwelling units within the City of Dania. In 1990 the number of housing units increased to 7,529 dwelling units. An increase of 1,438 dwelling units. The major increase is reflected by a 493 unit increase of single family homes and an increase of 661 multi-family dwelling units B. CHARACTERISTICS OF THE HOUSING STOCK 1980 - 1990 [9J-5.010(1)(a)(b)&(c)] 1. UNIT AGE Table II indicates that the age of the housing units in Dania continues to be older that that of Broward County. 90.62% of the housing has been built since 1950 and 187 units have been demolished. 2. UNIT VALUE Table III shows the comparison of the unit values in each of nine categories. Over 56.8% of the housing is valued in the $40 - to - $100,000 price range as compared to 65% in 1980 with the largest percentage (41.5%) of the housing in the $60 - $99,000 price range. ' l _. 6 q�I 9� w In 1980 the median value of dwelling units was $53,900 compared to $84,600 today. The City of Dania price range is compatible with Broward County except Dania has a slightly higher number of housing valued lower than $40,000. I "i 3. GROSS RENTS Table IV indicates the difference in the gross rents that have occurred since the 1980 census. Over 20.8% of the rents are less than $350 as compared to 80% in 1980. The median in the City of Dania is $484 per month as compared to $248 in 1980. i The median rent in Dania is approximately 8.5% lower than Broward County today as compared to 7.9% in 1980. 4. MONTHLY MORTGAGE COSTS Table V shows the mortgage comparisons in the city as compared to 1980. The median mortgage cost in 1980 was $361 per month. Today's median mortgage cost is $754 per month. The increase can be attributed to higher mortgage rates and new housing that was built in the city since 1980. The median mortgage rate in Broward County is $856 as compared to $754 in Dania. Dania's lower mortgage rate is attributed to the housing units in Dania being older structures. 5. LACKING FACILITIES Table VI indicates that in 1980 110 units were lacking plumbing as compared to 41 units in 1990, 117 units were lacking kitchens as compared to 88 units today. There was no current data available for heating and overcrowding. The difference in the above mentioned categories can be attributed to two factors: 1) increased code enforcement and 2) upgrading of the older units by the owners. i i 7 6. RENT TO INCOME RATIO Table VII reflects the changes from 1980 to 1990. According to the 1990 census approximately 943 of the city's 2,564 units or 36.8% are renter occupied that pay more than 35% of their income for rent, compared to 859 out of 2,207 units or 38.8% in 1980. j 7. STANDARD/SUB-STANDARD HOUSING CONDITIONS Table VIII reflects the changes from 1980 to 1990. In 1989 the city had 266 dwelling units that were classified as substandard. Today only 26 homes can be classified as substandard. C. SUBSIDIZED RENTER HOUSING [9J-5.010(1)(d)] Table IX reflects the difference between 1980 and 1990. According to the 1980 data reported, there were 222 units that were rent subsidized as compared to the current reported data of 2,179 units. D. GROUP HOMES [9J-5.010(1)(e)] Table X identifies the changes in group home facilities in the City of Dania. E. MOBILE HOMES [9J-5.010(1)(0] I Of the five mobile home parks listed in the 1989 plan only 4 remain today. Trails End has been Purchased by Broward County for Airport related uses and the 224 units have been removed leaving a total of 507 units today. Table XI reflects this decrease. F. HISTORICAL HOUSING [9J-5.010(1)(g)] The inventory of historical housing shown in Table XII has not changed since 1989 except that the residence located at 202 S. Federal Highway was moved to John Houston Park to make way for commercial development. The home was moved in 1993 as a joint effort between the developer, the city and concerned citizens. G. HOUSING ACTIVITY (1980 - 1995) [9J-5.010(1)(h)] Table XIII has been updated to reflect housing construction activities as of 1995. Approximately 939 dwelling units were constructed from 1980 to 1987. Since 1987 1,120 units have been constructed. 8 A III. ANALYSIS REQUIREMENTS i Tables XIV- XVII have been adjusted to reflect the data available today. A. HOUSEHOLD PROJECTIONS [9J-5.010(2)(a)(b)] I Table XIV "Projected Dwelling Units" predicted that in 1993 the city would have a population of 12,039 residents and that in 2010 the city would increase to 12,542 residents. According to the 1990 census the city has a population of 13,024. The city has already exceeded the projected population for the year 2010. It was projected that in 1993 the city would have 7,480 dwelling units, however we surpassed that number in 1990 with 7,699 units constructed. The year 2010 projections will also be exceeded before that time. I 5,794 dwelling units are indicated to be vacant by the 1990 census. This is less than that projected for 1993. Table XV 'Projection of Household Size" indicates that the number of single person household has increased to 34%, 2 person households decreased by 2% and 3 person households remained the same. Four person households have decreased by 1% and 5 person households account for only 4% as compared to 8% in 1980. Three percent of the households are occupied by 6-7 persons. The percentage difference in household size seems to be in keeping with that of Broward County. Table XIII indicates the Housing Activity from 1987 to 1995. Table XVI 'Projected Income Range of Housing Units" provides the income range of anticipated households. None of the projections were achieved in the Low and Moderate Income ranges. In the Middle Income range the City exceeded the 1993 projection in 1990 according to the 1990 census. No data is available to update Table XVII at this time. B. LAND REQUIREMENTS [9J-5.010(2)(c)] As indicated by the number of housing units constructed to date the city projections for land requirements were reversed. More acres were devoted to single family development and less to multi-family development than were anticipated in 1989. 9 C. PRIVATE SECTOR INITIATIVES [W-5.010(2)(d)(e)] The Private Sector Initiatives have not changed since 1989. D, SPECIAL NEEDS [W-5.010(2)(f)] 1. Low and Moderate Income Households. j The low and moderate income housing in Dania continues to grow. Both single-family and multi-family housing have been constructed in the low to moderate income range. I ' 2. Substandard Housing Conditions. As indicated in Table VI the City of Dania has made great strides in improving substandard housing conditions. 3. Low/Moderate Income and Mobile Home Sites. The median unit value in Dania still remains approximately $7,000 less than Broward County average and we still have a greater percentage of units which are in the lower priced bracket. Dania's remaining four (4) mobile home facilities presently provides adequate sites to support this segment of the housing needs. 4. Group Homes and Foster Care Facilities Group Homes and Foster Care facilities continue to be situated within residential communities in the city. Dania has five (5) Foster Care Facilities according to the Department of Health and j Rehabilitative Services. Dania has five (5) active Foster Care Facilities according to the Department of Health and Rehabilitative Services. j E. CONSERVATION, REHABILITATION OR DEMOLITION ACTIVITIES AND HISTORICAL SIGNIFICANT HOUSING The city continues to identify housing for rehabilitation and or demolition within the Target area. Since 1989 19 residential units have been identified and demolished. ; 10 i i Table I Housing Element Housing Inventory 1980 Data 1995 Data Total Change Single Family naacheaiDetachea 2,P28 2,721 493 Two Family 926 1,048 122 Multi-Family 2,538 3,199 661 3.4 Family 571 3.4 Family 590 5.9 Family 325 5.9 Family 356 10-49 Family 1 098 10-49 Family 1,756 50+Family 544 59.Family 497 Mobile Home 399 507 108 Other 54 54 TOTAL 6,091 7,529 1,438 Sources: 1990 Census Data 1995 Building & Zoning Records 1 Housing Element Table II Unit Age 1989 Data 1990 Data pANIA BROWARD COUNTY DANIA BROWARD COUNTY Unit Age Total %"r ;`' Total % }7dtal , % Total % 1989-90 NO"`Data 120 o- `1i56% 18.153 3% 1985-88 No,pata 620 6.75% 75,507 12% 1980-84 - No pats . •' 913 ; ', ;11.86% 78,395 12% 1970-79 2,294 3 ..7 234,238 49% 2,628 34.13% 227,092 36% 1960-69 M671 23.9 145,406 30% ;" 1,727 . 22.43% 131,930 21% 1950-59 1,419 23:4 76,234 16% 1;069 13.88% 79,421L. 13% 1940-49 489 " "8 13,696 3% ;: 415 " `' 5.39% 13,236 2% Before 1939 432 7 7,994 2% + " . 3071 3.99% 6,926 1% TOTAL $,091 I00 477,568 100% 7,6991 100.00% 630,660 100% Source: US Census Data 1990 of,ppits i)ullt.in 1950and # of Units Demolished from 1989 -7/95, 187 4 1 Housing Element Table III UNIT VALUE DWELLING UNITS _ 1980 DATA 1990 DATA CHANGE DATA DANIA BROWARD COUNTY DANIA BROWARD COUNTY IA I 13ROWARD COUNTY VALUE NUMBER % NUMBER % NUMBER I % NUMBER M. ,Number %Chen a Number %Change (Po to Ceemq Less Than$15,000 - .I a..51 .18A 1,518 1% 24 ::1.42% 433 0.20% ,:27 -52.9% 1,085 -71.6% $15,000.19.999 42 -: 2.6 1,739 1% - 33 . t95% 349 0.16% 9 -:-21.4% 1,390 -79.9% $20,000.24,999 r 92 � .,c 4.5 3.455 2% ' - 26 v :�:'-1:54% 515 0.24% 46 +"-63.9% (2,940 :,.-85.1% $25,000-29.999 '79 ' " i 4.9 4,942 3% 19 "1:12% 650 0.30°h a!,: 60 i"-75.9% 4,292 -86:8% $30,000-34.999 86 6.3 7.807 5% 12 st-.:'�0.71% 1.168 0.53% r: 4 86.0% 6,639 85.0% $35,000-39,999 r...103 :6.4 10,267 6% ': :5 7-77 3.25% 1,656 0.76% 48 � -.i4e.6% (8,631) -83.9% $40,000-49.999 256 ': 15.9 27,076 160/. 98 5.80% 7,599 3.48% '' 156 .61.7% (19,477) -71.9% $50,000-59,999 .226 " 14.1 26,936 16% ' 160 9.46% 17,545 8.03% 68 ! -29.2% (9,391) .34.9% $60,000-99,999 594 36.3 60.809 35% 702 41,51% 98,706 45.18% 118 20.2% 37,897 62.3% $100.000-149.999 90 5.6 17,737 10% .397 n' 23.48% 47,406 21.70c/o -307 7 341.1% 29,669 167.3% $150,000-199,999 14 '..0.8 4,945 31/0 - '115 , " -6.60% 20,828 9 53% '! 401 "'221.40A 15,883 321.2% $200,000 or More - ' 8 - 0.5 4,591 3% 50 " '2.96% 21,612 9.89% .i 42 . ,525.0°b 77,021 370.76/6 TOTAL 1,811 100 171,842 100°h -4,691 '�100.00% 218,467 100.00°k L: , Median Value $: 63,900.00 $ 60,900.00 $ 84,600.00 $ 91,300.00 $ 30,700,00 $ 30,400.00 Source: 1990 Census Data I --- Housing Element Tama IV i GROSS RENT 1980 DATA 1990 DATA %OF CHANGE B. COUNTY B. COUNTY DANJA B. COUNTY Gross Rent($) Total ti. %st, .; Total % Total : °/a ' Total % ;.Total '%. Total LESS THAN 100 29 "`: , -1 3% 1,971 1.7 i'S7 ,2E2% 1,084 0.6% ;28' ,%9&6% (887) -45.0% 4,189 3.6 100-149 - i' 167 is°' .°k 66 R ;';Z0% 2,112 1.3% 84 :(121 ! ::=64:7% (2,077) 49.6% 150-199 ,'394 ".; 17:9%0 9,076 7.8 C30 ' "1 2% 1.826 1.1% `j!` (364) ` 92!4% (7,250) -79.9% 200-249 482 ; - 2t9% 15,776 13.5 " 53 :21% 1,765 1.0% :::' 429) <:? 89.0% (14,011) -88.8% 250-299 $72 16.9% 20,434 17.5 "-144 ' '1 5:6% 2,953 1.8% ` y:(228) ' ` 613% (17,481) 85.5% 300-349 .330 J&0% 18,545 15.9 '>184 ' 7.2% 4,796 2.8% (146) %-44.2% (13,749) -74.1% 350-399 153 >` ',6:9% 16,177 13.9 "'`292 11.4% 8,879 5.3% 39 ,' .90.8% (7,298) -45.1% 400+ ' ' ,199 ":i :9.0% 26,038 22.3 `(,1;666 " "`:65:0% 140,377 83.4% .' ,1;467 :i73Z.2% 114,339 439.1% No Cash Rent 61 "2.7% 4,381 3.8 ;'72 t"'?2t8% 4,596 2.7% '11 18:0% 215 4.9% TOTAL 2,207 100% 116,587 100 2,564 ''100% 168,388 100% Median Rent $248 $312 $484 . $575 Source: 1990 Census Data `i i Housing Element Table V Monthly Mortgage Cost Owner Occupied 1980 DATA 1990 DATA %OF CHANGE DANIA B.COUNTY DANIA B. COUNTY pANIA B. COUNTY Monthly Mortgage Cost($) ;;Total 'PA. Total % Total. °i6;:• Total % Total< 96 . Total Less Than 200 120 `'•13 7% 14,967 11.7% 0 0.0% 1,0151 0.6% .(120) 00,0% (13,952) 93.2% 200-299 159 `18.1% 25,330 19.8% 33 ' 3i2% 4,6821 2.7% `.''(126) 79:2% (20,648) -81.5% 300 -399 :222 . 25;3% 27,696 21.6% ?: 69 6:7% 8,457 4.9% ':;t153) 6819?/0 (19,239) -69.5% 400- 599 297 33:8% 36,689 28.6% "' ` .'240 ',23i1"/o 24,075 14.0% s (57) =192% (12,614) -34.4% 600 + 81 9.2% 23,440 18.3% 695 ' 67;0% 133,867 77.8% 614 .'I:758.0% 110,427 471.1% TOTAL 879 ' '100% 128,1221 100% '= 1,637 9•100% 172,096 100% Median $361.00 1 $ 389.00 $ 754.00 $ 856.00 Source: 1990 Census Data Dania 52.2% Increase County 55% Increase I I I i i I i Housing Element Table VI Lacking Facilities 1980 DATA 1990 DATA Condition Dwelling Units Condition Dwelling Units % of change Lacking Complete Plumbing 100 Lacking Complete Plumbing 41 -59% Lacking Complete Kitchen 117 Lacking Complete Kitchen 88 -25% Lacking Central Heating 563 Lacking Central Heating No Current Data Overcrowded 372 Overcrowded No Current Data Source: 1990 Census Data Ir I Housing Elements Tabie VI Rent-To-Income Ratio Income Range 1980 Data 1990 Census:Data Less than $10,000 $10,000 to $19,000 $20,000 or More Less than$10,000 $10,000 to$19,0001 $20,000 or More Rent-to- Income Ratio Total % Total % Total % Total % . Total `0/( Total Mo Less Than 20 41 1.9 207 9.4 237 10.6 25 4i0% ' 37 14% 570 ,?22.2% 20%-24% 57 2.6 171 7.7 66 3 0 " 0.0% 19 .0 7% 379 14 8% 25%-29% 95 4.31 159 7.2 31 1:2% 57 2.2% 174 +'' 6.8% 30%-34% 50 2.3 48 2.2 19 0.7% 59 2.3% 92 3.6% 35%or More 755 34.1 104 4.7 578 22.5% ! 289 11.3% 76 -1.0% Not Computed 181 8.2 24 1.1 12 0.5 '115 '' `4.5% 18 '11'01% 26 1.0% TOTAL 1,179 53.4 713 32.31 3151 14.3 "'768 '; 30:0% "479 ' t1&68% ^ 1,317 -.0 51,4"/0 Based on 2,207 Renters Based on 2,564 Renters' Source: 1990 Census Data Housing Element Table VIII Standard / Substandard Housing Conditions 1987! 1984 Data "113�0 Date;'. Change A Standard Substandard �' "$teq'dard' Substandard. Census Standard Substandard Census Tract Units Units Census T(aot U►jlts Units Tract Units Units 801 (1) 5,224 91 e81 5,��L3 1 801 -90 802 (1) 634 111 502 " 626 ` '81 802 -3 805 (2) 1,083 164 '805 `1066 171 805 -147 Sources: Field Survey (1) Dania GM Dept. (2) Dania Target Area Redevelopment Plan 1984 Housing Element Table IX Subsidized Renter Housing 1980 Data 1990 Data Change Census Tract Units Census Tract Units Census Tract Units 801 1,343 801, 802 83 802 362 801, 802 1,622 805 139 805 474 805 335 Source: Dania Housing Authority- 1987 (1980 Census) Dania Housing Authority- 1995 11995 Census) • a Housing Element Twie X Group Homes 1987-89 Data 1990 Data Facility Type Census Tract Capacity Facility Type Census Tract Capacity FOSTER AND SHELTER HOMES 802 9 FOSTER AND SHELTER HOMES 802 9 805 5 805 5 RESIDENTIAL FACILITIES 801 12 RESIDENTIAL FACILITIES 801 12 802 16 802 16 8051 24 805 24 ADULT FOSTER HOMES 8051 1 ADULT FOSTER HOMES 8051 1 Source: FL Dept. HRS Housing Element Table XI MOBILE HOMES 1 1987 DATA 1995 DATA CHANGE IN DATA Mobile Home Parks Capacity Mobile Home Parks Capacity Mobile Home Parks Capacity I - � TRAILS END TRAILS END TRAILS END 999 North Federal 999 North Federal 999 North Federal Hwy. (Southwest Hwy. (Southwest Hwy. (Southwest Comer of Federal Comer of Federal Comer of Federal Hwy and New Griffin Hwy and New Griffin Hwy and New Griffin Rd.) 224 Rd.) 0 Rd.) -224 i HITCHING POST HITCHING POST HITCHING POST 945 South Federal 945 South Federal 945 South Federal Hwy. (Eastside of Hwy. (Eastside of Hwy. (Eastside of Federal Hwy North of Federal Hwy Northof Federal Hwy North cf SE 10 St.) SE 10 St.) SE 10 St.) 80 80 0 ADRIONDACK ADRIONDACK ADRIONDACK 922 South Federal 922 South Federal 922 South Federal Hwy. (Westside of Hwy. (Westside of Hwy. (Westside of Federal Hwy,North of Federal Hwy,North of Federal Hwy,North of SE 10 St. SE 10 St. BE 10 St. 90 30 0 I OCEAN WATERWAY OCEAN WATERWAY OCEAN WATERWAY 1525 Griffin Rd. 1525 Griffin Rd. 1525 Griffin Rd. (Southwest comer of (Southwest comer of (Southwest comer of Bryan Rd.and Old Bryan Rd.and Old Bryan Rd.and Old Griffin Rd.) 269 Griffin Rd.) 269 Griffin Rd.) 0 WEINER WEINER WEINER 801 W.Dania Beach 801 W.Dania Beach 801 W.Dania Beach -� Blvd. (Southwest Blvd. (Southwest Blvd. (Southwest Comer of Guldstream Comer of Guldstream Comer of Guldstream and Dania Beach and Dania Beach and Dania Beach - 68 Blvd.) 68 Blvd.) 0 Blvd.) .� TOTAL 731TOTAL 507 TOTAL -224 !Source: City of Dania Growth Management Department. Note: i ,Trails End Mobile Home Park has been purchased by Broward County as part of their ongoing Airport 1 Expansion Project. _ Housing Element Table Xll 1ot2 HISTORICALLY SIGNIFICANT PROPERTY .SITE / LOCATION SITE FILE # John Boehm Residence 251 South Federal Highway 8DB00118 Helen And Martin Frost House 400 South Federal Highway 8BD00120 Dania Bank Building Dania Beach Boulevard and Federal Hwy 8BD00121 i Dania Counseling Center 150 North Federal highway 8BD00139 Dania Beach Hotel 180 East Dania Beach Blvd. 8BD00141 1 La Normandie Restaurant 129 North Federal Highway 8BD00142 Hotel Poinciana 141 NW First Avenue 8BD00143 J.W. Black Residence 146 SW First Avenue 88D00144 Dania Community Library Women's Club 17 NW First Avenue 8BD00145 Parish Residence I 134 SW First Avenue 8BD00147 Ocean Waterway Residence 1500 West Old Griffin Rd. 8BD00148 i 110 Bryan Road 8BD00137 113 S. Federal Highway 8BD00140 I Nyberg Swanson House 202 S. Federal Highway (Relocated to 102 West Dania Beach Blvd.) 8BD00119 _J Ir I . Housing Element Table XII 2ot2 I John Bryan Residence Bryan Road 8BDO0199 Priestly Residence North Federal Highway 8BDO0146 .I 301 S. Federal Highway 8BD00080 Source: Florida Master Site File i I i I _I II .J e Housing Element Table XIII HOUSING ACTIVITY ' i _._ Year Single Family Duplex Multi-Family Total i 1980 15 12 257 284 1981 6 16 76 98 1982 6 6 99 111 1983 3 6 60 69 1984 ill 41 65 80 19851 101 14 841 108 r 1986 9 18 85 112 1987 9 10 58 77 iSUB-TOTAL 69 86 784 939 i 19881 591 10 1361 205 J19891 381 4 3321 374 1990 301 10 77 117 1991 54 2 0 56 1992 47 0 16 62 1993 121 6 26 153 1994 14 2 37 53 Thm J0ry 1995 61 2 37 100 SUB-TOTAL 424 36 661 1,120 TOTAL 1 .4931 122 1;445 _2 059 S crude: Growth Management Department, Residential Certificates of Occupancy, 1987 and 1995 i Data I ' tow Housing Element Table XIV Projected Dwelling Units 1980 Census Data jIgis Data1980 Data 1988 Pmle 1993 Prgetlad 2010 PrgeCedPopulation 11,796 11,951 12,039 12,5423,024 Dwelling Units 6,091 7,030 7,480 7,8007,699 Occupied Units 5,051 5,905 6,283 6,552 5;794 Household Size 2.33 2.00 1.9 1.924 Sources: (1) U.S. Bureau of Census 1980 (2) Broward County Office of Planning (3) City of Dania Growth Management Dept. (4) U.S. Bureau of Census 1990 .I i i I I ._i Housing Element Table XV Projections of Household Size 1980 Projections for,988 Projections for 1993 Projealons(or 2010 - "1990 DATA # % # % # % # % . # % 1 Person 1,827 30 2,179 31 2,318 31 2,340 30 ; . .1'987 . 34% 2 Persons 2,426 40 2,882 41 3,142 42 3.354 43 ;:' ',''2;213 . " ' ``'38% 3 Persons 792 13 844 12 824 111 858 11 765 13% 4 Persons 548 9 562 8 598 8 624 8 439 8% 5 Persons 488 8 562 8 598 8 624 8 ` 221 4% 6 Persons 104 2% 7 Persons 64 1% TOTALS 6,081 1001 7,029 100 7,4801 100 7,8001 1001 5,803 100% Source: U.S. Bureau of Census 1990 i Ir Housing Element Table XVI Projected Income Range of Housing Units 1980 Projections for 1988 Projections for 7993 Projections for 2010 1990 DATA Units % Units % Units % Units % Units %. Low Income (Under$10,000) Owner 656 13 768 13 691 11% 590 9 214. 50A Renter 1,566 31 1,831 31 1,759 28% 1,769 27 768 18% Moderate Income ($10,000-$19,990) Owner 556 11 649 11 754 12% 852 13 239 "6% Renter 960 19 1,122 19 1,257 20% 1,310 20 1. 479 11% Middle Income ($20,000+) Owner 909 18 1,063 18 1,194 190/. 1,310 201 1,238 29% Renter 404 8 472 8 628 10%1 721 ill 11317 31% TOTAL 5,051 100 5,905 100 6,283 100% 6,552 100 4,255 100% Source: U.S. Bureau of Census 1990 R Housing Element Table XVII Projected Population Housing Needs 1988 - 1993 1993 -2010 Income/Bedroom Owner Renter Owner Renter SF MF SF MF SF MF SF MF Low Income 9 49 7 133 5 23 4 82 1-2 Bedrooms 6 33 5 93 4 16 3 57 3 Bedrooms 2 12 2 33 1 6 1 20 4 + Bedrooms 1 2 0 7 0 1 0 5 Moderate Income 8 42 4 81 8 34 31 61 1-2 Bedrooms 5 29 3 57 6 24 2 43 3 Bedrooms 2 11 1 20 2 9 1 15 4 +Bedrooms 1 2 0 4 0 1 0 3 Middle Income 12 69 2 34 11 53 2 34 1-2 Bedrooms 8 48 1 24 8 37 1 24 3 Bedrooms 31 17 1 9 3 13 1 9 4 + Bedrooms 1 4 0 1 0 2 0 1 TOTAL 29 160 131 248 24 110 9 177 I I . i TRAFFIC CIRCULATION ELEMENT 1 i i i TABLE OF CONTENTS CONDITI01Y,SATADO PAGE I. DATA REQUIREMENTS ................................................... 1 A. Trafficways Plan II. ANALYSIS REQUIREMENTS ............................................ 2 C�JRRENT CONDITIONS I. INTRODUCTION ........................... 4 .................................. A. Transportation Network j If. DATA REQUIREMENTS ................................................... 4 A. Trafficways Plan 111. ANALYSIS REQUIREMENTS 5 i TABLES FOLLOW TEXT I. Classification of Roads 11. Regional Roadway Network-Adoption III. Regional Roadway Network- Current I I I I I 4 TRAFFIC CIRCULATION ELEMENT CONDITIONS AT ADOPTION 7I. DATA REQUIREMENTS [9J-5.007(1)(a)(b)&(c)] A. Trafficways Plan The roads identified on the City of Dania's Future Land Use Plan map and on the Traffic and Circulation Plan are consistent with those found on the Broward County Trafficways Plan. This consistency with County requirements will be maintained as follows: Expressways(Limited Access) 1. Interstate 95 (1-95) Interstate 95 running along Dania's western edge traverses a primarily industrial and vacant area of the City. 2. Port Expressway (1-595) The Port Expressway will have minimal direct effect on the community since it runs along the northern City limits. Principal and Minor Arterials 1. Federal Highway (U.S. 1) Federal Highway connects the communities north of Dania with those lying to the south. 2. N.W. / N.E. 10th Street N.W. ! N.E. 10th Street connects Eller Drive and Federal Highway with 1-95 and points west. 3. Sheridan Street i Sheridan Street, a principal east-west arterial, serves as the boundary between Dania and Hollywood. I _ t 4. Dania Beach Boulevard Dania Beach Boulevard essentially divides the City into northern and southern segments. 5. Stirling Road Stirling Road connects Dania with cities in the far western reaches of the County. Collectors 1. Bryan Road Bryan Road is the important north/south collector in the area of the City lying east of 1-95. 2. Griffin Road Griffin Road is an east/west collector. 3. N.W. 10th Street N.W. 10th Street is currently the only link between 1-95 and Federal Highway in that part of the City. II. ANALYSIS REQUIREMENTS [9J-5.007(2)(a)&(b)] I Level of Service D is the capacity value normally used in Broward County for the transportation planning process. It is characterized by relatively satisfactory operating speeds with most of the drivers being restricted in their freedom to select their own speed, change lanes or pass. Once the standards are known, an examination of the existing traffic on a city's streets is necessary to determine how the current traffic volumes relate to the standards. Therefore, through the Broward County Planning Council staff and the Broward County Metropolitan Planning Organization (MPO) analysis of the existing and projected level of services on the regional roadway network, an evaluation of the system can be made. The above referenced study identified over capacity rods (roads operating below level of service "D" ) for three time horizons; 1987, 1994 and 2010. The 2010 traffic projections were taken from the Year 2010 Long Range Transportation Plan. The 1994 traffic projections were based on an 2 interpolation between current counts and 2010 projects. The 1994 roadway network includes roads in the Five Year Transportation Improvement Program while the 2010 network includes rods on the 2010 Highway Network and adopted by the MPO. Table I illustrates the analysis as included in the MPO Review. I Interstate 95 As it traverses the community, is operating in excess of Level of Service D design capacity. Griffin Road Has recently been expanded and is operating below capacity. Stirlin4 Road Has recently been expanded and is operating below capacity. Sheridan Street East of Dixie Highway is operating below capacity. Ravenswood Road North of Stirling Road was below capacity and exceeded capacity in the Year 1994. Dania Beach Boulevard Is operating below capacity and will likely remain so due to limited potential for future development. I U.S. 1 Has been recently improved in conjunction with the expansion of the Fort Lauderdale-Hollywood International Airport and is currently operating below capacity. it 3 i TRAFFIC CIRCULATION ELEMENT CURRENT_ I. INTRODUCTION A. TRANSPORTATION NETWORK -; 1. Expressways - No Changes 2. Principal Arterial - No Changes 3. Minor Arterial - No Changes 4. Collectors - No Changes 5. Local Streets - No Changes 11. DATA REQUIREMENTS (9J-5.007(1)(a)(b)&(c)] A. TRAFFICWAYS PLAN The roads identified on the City of Dania's Traffic Circulation Plan Map are still consistent with those found on the Broward County 1 Trafficways Plan. The only change to the map is the elimination of SE 5 Ave. from the Trafficways Map of the city and Broward County. This change is reflected on the current maps. 1. Expressways - No Changes 2. Interstate 95 (1-95) - No Changes 3. Interstate 595 (1-595) - No Changes i4. Principal and Minor Arterials - No Changes 5. Federal Highway (U.S. 1) - No Changes 6. N.W./N.E. 10th Street- No Changes 7. Sheridan Street - No Changes 8. Dania Beach Boulevard - No Changes 9. Stirling Road - No Changes 10. Collectors - No Changes 11. Bryan Road - No Changes 12. Griffin Road - No Changes 13. N.W. 10th Street - No Changes _i 4 tow. i III. ANALYSIS REQUIREMENTS [9J-5.007(2)(a)&(b)] Tables I - III have not changed. The Future Traffic Circulation Map has been modified to reflect the j removal of SE 5th Avenue from the Broward County Trafficways Plan. I No Changes have been made to the Street Lane Arrangement Map. The Existing Traffic Circulation Map has been adjusted to reflect the 1995 data. The Functional Classification Map has also been modified. The following represents the current level of service for each of the listed road segments. Interstate 95 With the recent expansion of this expressway there is now excess capacity. In 1989 the Interstate was operation at Level of Service D. Griffin Road No Change Stirling Road Stirling Road continues to operate below capacity Street Sheridan Street Operating below capacity, but is approaching over capacity, especially the segment west of U.S. 1. I Ravenswood Road North of Stirling Road is below Capacity, but is approaching over capacity. Dania Beach Boulevard No Change U.S. 1 Is over capacity. Only the area adjacent to the airport is below capacity. 5 _ I III During the Plan update the City will also analyze traffic circulation levels of service and system needs based upon accident frequency data that may be available for the City of Dania. The Plan update will also address the need for the new facilities or expansions as required by Rule 9J-5.007 (2)(a). The Plan update will also provide an analysis of projected levels of service and system needs based upon the Future Land Use Map and address the need for the facilities or expansions required by Rule 9J-5.007(2)(b). I I I I I I i i 6 A TABLE I ANALYSIS REQUIREMENTS Classification of Roads Road Name From TO Classification Interstate 95 (1-95) Stirling Road Dania Cut-Off Canal Expressway Port Expressway (1-595) Federal Highway Northern City Limit Expressway Federal Highway Sheridan Street Northern City Limit Principal Arterial N.W./N.E. 10" Street Western City Limits McIntosh Road Principal Arterial Sheridan Street Western City Limits Eastern City Limits Principal Arterial Dania Beach Boulevard Bryan Road Dania Beach Minor Arterial Stirling Road Western City Limits Federal Highway Principal Arterial Bryan Road Griffin Road Stirling Road Collector Ravenswood Road Stirling Road Griffin Road Collector I 9513881cepUWM 802.wp5 Ir Trelfic Circulation Element Table II ANALYSIS REQUIREMENT Regional Roadway Network-1989 Data i EAST 1987 1987 LOS D 1994 TIP LOS D 2010 2010 LOS D WEST LINK ADT DESIGN CAP 1987 ADT DESIGN CAP 1994 ADT DESIGN CAP 2010 ROADWAY X1000 CODE X1000 WC X1000 CODE X1000 VIC X1000 CODE X1000 Vic Sheridan East of Dixie 31 423 34.9 0.89 30.7 423 34.9 0.88 30.1 623 53.5 0- Street Hghway (4 Lanes) East of U.S.#1 11.4 420 30.4 15.3 420 30.4 0.5 24.1 620 46.8 0.51 0.38 Sliding East of I-95 19 620 46.8 0.41 20.6 620 46.6 0.44 24.3 620 46.8 0.52 Road (6 Lanes) Griffin Road East of 1-95 33 613 59.6 0.6 35.5 613 59.6 0.6 41.4 623 53.51 0.77 (6 Lanes) Ravenswood North of 11.1 211 11.9 0.93 12.7 211 11.9 1.07 16.5 211 11.9 1.39 Road Stirling Road 1 (2 Lanes) North of 6.6 211 11.9 0.55 9 211 11.9 0.76 14.7 211 11.9 1.24 Griffin Road 1-95 North-of 143.E 615 124.8 1.15 174.3 lulol 208 0.84 243.9 1015 208 1.17 I (6 Lanes) Sheridan Street I North of 147 615 124.8 1.18 188.1 1015 208 0.9 282 1015 208 1.36 Stidin Road North of 142.1 615 124.8 1.14 181.9 7015 208 0.87 272.8 1015 208 1.31 I I � i 1 J i • TABLE II ANALYSIS REUUIREME1Nf Regional Roadway Network EAST 1987 1987 LOS D 1994 TIP LOS D 2010 2010 LOS D WEST AM DESIGN CAP 1987 AM DI-SIGN CAP 1994 AMDESIGN CAP 2010 ROADWAY LINK X1000 CODE X1000 V/C X1000 CODE X1000 V/C X1000 CODE X1000 V/C U.S. #1 North of 28.6 423 34.9 0.82 28.8 423 34.9 0.83 29.3 423 34.9 0.84 (4 Lanes) Sheridan Street 28.9 423 34.9 0.83 33.9 423 34.9 0.97 95.3 423 34.9 1.3 (6 Lanes) North of Stirling Road North of 46.4 615 124.8 0.37 46.8 615 124.8 0.37 47.7 615 124.8 0. Griffin Road Dania Beach East of U.S. #1 13.0 410 33.9 0.38 14.1 410 33.9 0.42 16.7 410 33.9 0.49 Boulevard (4 Lanes) { I I TABLE IQ ANALYSIS REQUIREMENT Regional Roadway Network 1994t11 TIP(2) LOS D 2010 2010 LOS D EAST WEST ADT DESIGN CAP 1994 ADT DESIGN CAP 2010 ROADWAY LINK X1000 CODE X1000 V/C X1000 CODE X1000 V/C Sheridan Street East of SW 12'h Ave. 27.6 423 34.9 0.79 30.1 623 53.5 0.36 (4 Lanes) East of U.S. NI 23.9 420 30.4 0.79 24.1 620 46.8 0.51 Stirling Road (6 East of 1-95 29.5 620 46.8 0.63 24.3 620 46.8 0.52 Lanes) Griffin Road (6 East of 1-95 15.9 613 59.6 0.27 41.4 623 53.5 0.77 Lanes) Ravenswood North of Stirling Rd. 10.8 211 11.9 0.91 16.5 211 11.9 1.39 Road (2 Lanes) North of Griffin Rd. 8.7 211 11.9 0.73 14.7 211 11.9 1.24 North of Sheridan St. 238.5 1015 208.0 1.15 243.9 1015 208.0 1.17 1-95 North of Stirling Rd. 209.3 1015 208.0 1.00 282.0 1015 208.0 1.36 (10 Lanes) North of Griffin Rd. 213.5 1015 208.0 1.03 27 .3 1015 20 .9 1.31 U.S. Nl North of Sheridan St. 34.1 423 34.9 0.98 29.3 423 34.9 0.84 (4 Lanes) North of Stirling Rd. 32.5 423 34.9 0.93 45.3 423 34.9 1.30 U.S. N1 North of Griffin Rd. 34.0 615 124.8 0.27 47.7 615 124.8 0.38 (6 Lanes) Dania Beach Boulevard East of U.S. N1 20.5 410 33.9 0.60 16.7 410 33.9 0.49 (4 & 6 Lanes) I tll As updated July 20, 1995 (2) The revised 1994 LOS D capacity and the 2010 information have not been revised and made available by Broward County as of August 1, 1995, therefore, 1994 and 2010 V/C data may need to be revised, specifically for 1-95. 9513881rco2MM8()2.wp5 I SANITARY SEWER SOLID WASTE DRAINAGE ELEMENT i I i I � 1 k J I a TABLE OF CONTENTS C�IVDIT/O11/S A T ADOPT/ON PAGE I. SANITARY SEWER SUB-ELEMENT................................... 1 i 11. SOLID WASTE ELEMENT ................................................ 2 III. DRAINAGE & NATURAL GROUNDWATER RECHARGE .... 3 IV. POTABLE WATER SUB-ELEMENT ................................... 4 CURRENT COND/T/ONS I. SANITARY SEWER SUB-ELEMENT................................... 6 11. SOLID WASTE ELEMENT ................................................ $ j Ill. DRAINAGE & NATURAL GROUNDWATER RECHARGE .... 9 I IV. POTABLE WATER SUB-ELEMENT ................................... 10 i I 1 d I ow INFRASTRUCTURE ELEMENT CONDITIONS AT ADOPTION SANITARY SEWER SUB-ELEMENT [9J-5.011(1)(c)(d)(e)&(f)] A. Introduction Dania originally operated its own treatment facility but it was 1 abandoned in 1974 and the City entered into a larger user agreement with the City of Hollywood to provide for wastewater treatment. The City presently operates and maintains its own + sanitary sewage collection system and appurtenant sewage lift i station. B. Existing Conditions The City sewage collection and transmission system consists of j approximately thirty-three (33) miles of gravity sewer lines ranging from eight (8) inches in diameter to twenty-four (24) inches in diameter. There are eleven (11) sewage pump stations and approximately six (6) miles of sewage force mains with diameters of up to eighteen (18) inches. I j Approximately ninety (90) Percent of the City is served by the sanitary sewer system with an area of single family homes located north and east of the Dania Cut-Off Canal and west of U.S. 1 presently being served by septic tank. The Broward County 201 facilities plan, as approved by the State, provided for the wastewater from the City of Dania to be treated by the City of Hollywood Wastewater Treatment Facility. The plant has a design capacity of thirty-eight (38) million gallons per day and currently treats approximately thirty-three (33) million gallons per day on an average. C. Analysis of Existing System The present wastewater and future flows generated by the City of Dania are tabulated as follows: Average Peak 1 1989 2.7 MGD 3.78 MGD 1 I 1990 2.8 MGD 3.92 MGD 1995 3.8 MGD 5.32 MGD 2000 4.7 MGD 6.58 MGD The contract, known as a "Large User Agreement", is being updated to the following flows for the City of Dania: Average Peak 1989 3.00 MGD 4.2 MGD 1990 3.00 MGD 4.2 MGD 1995 3.80 MGD 5.32 MGD 2000 4.68 MGD 6.58 MGD The sewage lift stations and force main systems were analyzed in 1986 for the ultimate flow projections. Certain deficiencies were identified, such as undersized stretches of force main, undersized master meters and upgrading of pumps. These deficiencies were addressed by the City and the improvements have been completed. The remaining improvement to the system that would need to be addressed is the installation of a pump station and force main to service the unsewered area north of the Dania Cut-Off Canal should the septic tank system fail. The level of service standard for the City's sanitary sewer facilities shall be 300 gallons per day per residence which shall equal one ERC. II. SOLID WASTE ELEMENT [9J-5.011(1)(c)(d)(e)&(f)] iA. Existing Conditions The City of Dania Public Works crews pick up lawn trash and brush on a continuous basis and haul the refuse to the National Resource Recovery site located at the Turnpike and S.R. 84 in Davie. The solid waste generated by other sources is hauled to the Central Disposal Facility under contract to Seacoast Sanitation. The Central Disposal Facility consists of five land fill cells of approximately 400 acres. The Central Disposal Facility has a design capacity as follows: Cell 1 16,400,000 C.Y. Cell 2 Not developed Sub Cell 3A 1,950,000 C.Y. nJ JI 2 :'Ft In 1987 the Central Disposal Facility handled 1,151,000 tons of solid waste. B. Analysis The City of Dania entered into a disposal contract with Reuter Recycling of Florida Inc. for disposal of its processable waste. The l Average Annual Tonnage for the City of Dania is 10,000 tons. The j plant was scheduled to go into production in July 1990 and has a capacity of 200,000 tons per year. The contract allows that when the plant capacity of 175,000 tons per year is reached, the plant capacity will be increased by 100,000 tons per year to 300,000 tons per year. The contract calls for the following minimum waste stream for the City of Dania: Year Average Annual Tonnage 1990 10,000 1995 10,772 2000 11,605 2005 12,502 2010 13,468 III. DRAINAGE AND NATURAL GROUNDWATER RECHARGE [9J-5.011(1)(g)(h)l i A. Existing Conditions The primary drainage system of the City of Dania as well as Broward County is controlled by the canal and pump system of the South Florida Water Management District (SFWMD). The SFWMD maintains a canal and pump systems and controls discharge based on the capacity of the system to remove storm water. The southeast area of the City is quite low in elevation, having an average elevation of+4.0 to +5.0 N.G.V.D. This area is drained by a series of storm sewers connecting to a 3 acre lake with a 15,000 gallon per minute pump system that discharges through a series of T J ditches to the Dania Cut-Off Canal. The City adheres to the minimum standards of Broward County and South Florida Water Management District and establishes the following levels of service: .1 to ' I i Road Protection - 10 year Flood Criteria Map Buildings - 100 year Flood Elevation Map I Storm Sewers - Florida Department of Transportation Zone 10 rainfall curves Flood Plain Routing - Modified SCS routing method as established by the SFWMD "Basis of Review" Best Management Practice B. Analysis of Existing System The drainage system of the City functions adequately and is able to meet the area wide level of service standards. The southeast area of the City located east of U.S. 1 and south of Dania Beach Boulevard perhaps have the most severe drainage problems. This area is in need of further storm sewer improvements and the pump station, though completely rebuilt in 1984 would probably need replacement in 10 years. The estimated cost of these improvements are: Storm Sewers $100,000 Pump Station $ 60,000 I IV. POTABLE WATER SUB-ELEMENT [9J-5.011(1)(c)(d)(e)&(f)] A. Existing Conditions j The City of Dania's water distribution system consists of approximately thirty (30) miles of pipe with diameters varying from six (6) inches to twelve (12) inches. The entire City is served by potable water with the exception of a warehouse complex in the southwest corner of the City. The City also has in place five (5) interconnects with adjacent utilities as follows: City of Fort Lauderdale 1 - 12 inch j City of Hollywood 2 - 6 inch i 1 - 8 inch Broward County 1 - 12 inch �J 4 J The City of Dania follows the standards established by the Broward County Public Health Unit and the City to determine the adequacy of potable water services. The City of Dania Water Treatment Plant has the following characteristics: Average Daily Flow 2.1 million gallons/day Peak Flow 3.0 million gallons/day Design Flow (ADF) 3.0 million gallons/day Estimated Remaining Life 5 years The plant operates twenty-four hours per day. B. Analysis of Existing Conditions The following chart gives the anticipated daily flow demands for the City of Dania: i Average Peak 1990 2.1 MGD 3.2 MGD 1995 2.8 MGD 4.2 MGD 2000 3.5 MGD 5.3 MGD The distribution system of the City has been analyzed by the hydraulic analysis and three areas of the City were determined to have weakness, the extreme southeast area, the area north of the Dania Cut-Off Canal known as Melaleuca Isles and the area north and south of the Dania Cut-Off Canal in the extreme eastern part of the City. The plant operates adequately and is in reasonably good shape. It is expected that the plant will operate satisfactorily for approximately five to ten years without major replacements. Planning is underway for an additional ground storage facility in the „I northeast area of the City with a volume of 500,000 gallons to 1,000,000 gallons considered, with high service pumps. The City of Dania, being a coastal community, has historically had difficulties with its raw water wells. The wells in the eastern portion 7 of the City have been discontinued in use due to high levels of J chlorides in the water. In the early 1980's, two new wells were installed west of the city limits and these wells are currently in use. 5 i a SANITARY SEWER SOLID WASTE, DRAINAGE, POTABLE WATER AND NATURAL GROUNDWATER AQUIFER RECHARGE ELEMENT CURRENT CONDITIONS SANITARY SEWER SUB-ELEMENT [9J-5.011(1)(c)(d)(e)&(fll I I. INTRODUCTION The City of Dania combined the departments of Public Works and Utilities into one department in 1994. The responsibilities of the department include the operation, maintenance and construction of all of the city's public grounds along with the water/sewer system. i The following will compare the changes to the Sanitary Sewer Sub- Element of the 1989 plan to those of today (1995). I A. EXISTING CONDITIONS The city sewage collection and transmission system consists of gravity sewer lines, pump stations and force mains. The City of Hollywood, Florida, through a large user agreement, provides for wastewater treatment. The city still services about ninety (90) percent of developed areas with a sanitary sewer system. The only area served by septic tanks in the City of Dania service area is known as Melaleuca Isles which encompasses approximately 102 acres and 367 dwelling units which translates to a density of less than (4) four dwelling units per acre. This density does not exceed the maximum density for septic tanks as specified by State regulations. In addition, the area is fully developed at this time and no additional septic tanks are anticipated. The Broward County Health Unit is responsible for permitting septic tanks. At this time, representatives of the Broward County Health Unit are not aware of any problems related to the existence of septic tanks in the City. Specifically, no ground water problems linked to the existence of septic tanks are known to exist. Ground water quality data is not collected by the city or the Broward County _. Health Unit. -1 6 J i The Broward County Public health Unit has not revised their maximum discharge or their design criteria since 1989. The design flows established by the Broward County Department of Natural resource Protection and adopted by the city have not changed since 1989. B. ANALYSIS OF EXISTING SYSTEM The following shows the changes in the wastewater flows _. generated by the city compared to what was projected in 1989 and the projections for the year 2005. III 1989 1995 1989 1995 Average Average Peak Peak 1989 2.7 MGD N/A 3.78 MGD N/A 1995 3.8 MGD 2.6 MGD 3.78 MGD 3.6 MGD j 2000 4.7 MGD 3.0 MGD 5.32 MGD 4.2 MGD 2005 N/A 3.5 MGD N/A 4.9 MGD The difference in the 1995 projection and the actual 1995 MGD is a result of the airport expansion project. The land east of the airport was projected to have several hotels constructed and major airport related uses. Due to the expansion program these facilities will not i be built. Dania still contracts with the City of Hollywood for wastewater treatment. the contract known as a "Large User Agreement' is being updated to reflect the following flows for the city. Average Peak 1995 3.80 MGD 5.32 MGD 2000 4.68 MGD 6.58 MGD The "Large Users Agreement' is being revised to reflect the projections indicated above which reflect the anticipated growth of the city. -+ C. ECONOMIC ASSUMPTIONS No Changes 7 m1 tow i I SOLID WASTE ELEMENT I [9J-5.011(1)(c)(d)(e)&(t)j i ._. I. INTRODUCTION The City Charter establishes a Department of Public Works which has the responsibility of providing for lawn and brush pick up and administering the contractor who picks up garbage. II. EXISTING CONDITIONS The City of Dania now contracts with Southern Sanitation, a private contractor, to collect the solid waste within the city and deliver the waste to the Reuter Recycling facility in western Pembroke Pines. This facility has a design capacity of 660 tons per day. The current demand at the facility is 550 tons per day. The City of Dania's portion of this demand is established at 29.5 tons per day. The city no longer hauls to the Central Disposal Land Fill facility. III. ANALYSIS No Change IV. ECONOMIC ASSUMPTIONS I No Change 8 DRAINAGE AND NATURAL GROUND RECHARGE [9J-5.011(1)(g)(h)] i I , iI. INTRODUCTION The City of Dania Growth Management Department is still responsible for assuring proper drainage is installed on all new projects as per Section 4605 of the South Florida Building Code while the Public Works Department is responsible for existing systems and their extensions. It. EXISTING CONDITIONS Since 1989, $200,000 worth of improvements have incurred to the i drainage system within the community. This included upgrading the pump system within the southeastern portion of the City and it is presently in good repair. The City retained a consulting engineering firm to complete a City-wide assessment of the existing drainage system. The report identified recommended improvements for the City's system. In addition, the City recently had a city-wide special assessment for maintenance and improvements. I III. ANALYSIS OF EXISTING SYSTEM The western portion of Broward County through the 790 square mile conservation is the primary aquifer recharge area for the City of Dania and Broward County and these areas are maintained by the South Florida Water Management District. Other aquifer recharge occurs within the City limits through the Dania cut-off canal, exfiltration systems and on-site retention/detention areas. However, it is important to note that most of the entire limits of the City of Dania are impacted by salt water intrusion due to its close proximity to the coastal areas of eastern Florida. IV. ECONOMIC ASSUMPTIONS No Change ..I 9 _.l POTABLE WATER SUB-ELEMENT 19J-5.011(1)(c)(d)(e)&(f)] i I. INTRODUCTION I The Charter of the City of Dania provides for a Department of Public Works and Utilities which is responsible for the potable water treatment and distribution system. H. EXISTING CONDITIONS In 1993 the city entered into an agreement with Broward County to provide raw water and is presently receiving one million gallons per day temporarily from Broward County System 3A: The Broward County South Regional Raw Water Supply System was completed and operational in 1996. The City of Dania will supplement its wells from that system for anything over 2 million gallons per day. This supplement will come either from the Broward County System 3-A or Brian Piccolo Park in western Broward County. I The Waterwells and Cones of Influence Map has not been revised. I I The potable water flow projections have not changed. The City of Dania Water Treatment Plant has the following flow characteristics: I 1 1989 1995 Average Daily Flow 2.1 MGD 2.8 MGD Peak Flow 3.0 MGD 3.0 MGD Design Flow 3.0 MGD 3.0 MGD jEstimated Remaining life 20 years 3 I ! 10 A I III. ANALYSIS OF EXISTING CONDITIONS The following table gives the anticipated daily flow demand for the city: 1989 1995 1989 1995 Average Average Peak Peak 1995 2.8 MGD 2.8 MGD 4.2 MGD 4.2 MGD 2000 3.5 MGD 2.8 MGD 5.3 MGD 4.2 MGD The difference in the year 2000 projection is a reflection of the airport expansion into the area east of Federal Highway and the loss of development anticipated to take place. i The water treatment plant went through a complete renovation in 1991 and now is considered to be in excellent condition and is expected to operate for an additional 20 years without major improvements. IV. ECONOMIC ASSUMPTIONS No Change J J J J " A i Revised Rule Revised Statute DeScdotion of Change (based on Comprehensive Plan Obtectiyes 8 Policies Does Plan satisfy Role 9.1.5 F.A.C.1 Rule 9J•5 and Ch. 9J-5.0055 163.3180 Concurrency Management System. City of Dania has adopted a concurrency management system Yes Implementing LOS standard pursuant to "Capital Improvements' Element. 9J•5.0055 (6) 163.3180(5)(b) Transportation Concurrency The City has not adopted an TCEA/Urban Infill Amendment Yes (TCEA will be Exception Areas (TCEA) (Optional) Included In EAR amendments) 9J-5.006(1)(b)1 Map existing potable water wells Potable water wells In the City of Dania have been mapped. Yes 9J-5.006(1)(Q3 Map existing dredge spoil sites This requirement is addressed in Port Everglades Master Plan see 9J- which Is Incorporated by reference in the Coastal Element. 5.012(5)(e) 9J•5.006 (2)(1) 163.3178 (6) Estimate need for additional dredge This requirement is addressed in Port Everglades Master Plan see 9J- j spoil sites which Is Incorporated by reference in the Coastal Element. 5.012(5)(e) 9J-5.006 (2)(g) Estimate development and There are No hazard mitigation reports relating to sites in Yes (NIA) redevelopment based on hazard Dania. mitigation reports 9J-5.006 (3)(b)5 Coordinate coastal planning area See :Future Land Use Element(See Objective Vill Yes population densities with local hurricane evacuation plan 9J-5.006 (3)(b)8 The element shall contain one or The Future Land Use Element does not address Interagency Yes(The City will more objectives which coordinate hazard mitigation because interagency hazard mitigation address IHMR in future land uses by encouraging the reports (IHMR) are not yet available ICE if reports elimination or reduction of uses that available) are inconsistent with any interagency hazard mitigation report. 3 i Revised Rule Revised Statute �escdot on of Chance (based an Comprehensive Elan_O_ blect_ives & Policies oes Plan satisfy Rule 9J•5 F.A.C.1 Rule 9J-5 and Ch. 163 9J-5.006 (3)(b)11 163.3178 (6) Ensure availability of dredge spoil This requirement is addressed in Port Everglades Master Plan see 9J.5.012 disposal sites which is incorporated by reference In the Coastal Element. (5)(e) 9J•5.006 (3)(c)3 Policy requirement to ensure public See"Capital Improvements' (Objective III) and Yes facilities are available concurrent 'Intergovernmental Coordination' (Objective III) Elements, and with Impacts "Future Land Use' (Objective VIII) 9J-5.006 (3)(c)6 Policy requirement to designate There are no proposed future wells in the city and existing No (However, a appropriate uses within wetifield water wells have been mapped(A policy designating policy relating to protection area (WPA) appropriate uses within a WPA will be added to the Plan) WPA will be added to the Plan) 9J•5.006 (3)(c)g 163.3178 (6) Policy requirement to designate This requirement Is addressed in Port Everglades Master Plan see 9J-5.012 dredge spoil disposal sites which Is Incorporated by reference In the Coastal Element. (5)(e) 9J.5.006 (4)(a)11 Map transportation concurrency Transportation concurrency management areas are not show Yes (N/A) management areas on the Future Land Use Map (Optional item) 9J-5.006 (4)(b)1 Map potable water well protection Existing wells (and Wellfield Protection Areas) have been Yes areas mapped and there are no proposed wells In the City. 9J-5.006 (4)(b)6 Map coastal high hazard areas The Coastal High Hazard Area Is not show on the Future Land No, amend Future Use Map Land Use Map Series 9J-5.006 (4)(c) 163.3177(10)(k)11(6) Mixed land use categories The-plan provides Mixed Use Categories (Optional) Yes FJ•l I 06 (5) 163.3177(10)(k)11(6) Provisions of discoursing Urban Addressed in "Future Land Use"(Objective VIII) Element Yes sprawl i i, �I li 4 4 COASTAL MANAGEMENT i ELEMENT i I I I 1 l I .� i I TABLE OF CONTENTS CONDITIONS AT DOPTION PAGE DATA AND ANALYSIS REQUIREMENTS .......................... A. Coastal Zone Inventory B. Estuarine Conditions C. Natural Disaster Planning D. Marina Siting CURRENT COND/T/ONS l i i I. INTRODUCTION ............................................................. 6 II. DATA AND ANALYSIS REQUIREMENTS .......................... 6 A. Coastal Zone Inventory B. Estuarine Conditions C. Natural Disaster Planning I III. SUMMARY .................................. 8 TABLES EOLLOW TEXT I. Coastal Zone- Existing Land Use II. Coastal Zone-Vacant Land Use i I J COASTAL MANAGEMENT ELEMENT CONDITIONS AT ADOPTION I. DATA AND ANALYSIS REQUIREMENTS (9J-5.012) The coastal zone within the City of Dania is considered to be that area east of U.S. 1 consisting of approximately 1,500 acres. A. Coastal Zone Inventory [9J-5.012(2)(c)] Table I identifies the existing land uses within the coastal zone utilizing the same land use hierarchy identified in the Land Use Data Section of the Land Use Element. In addition there is I approximately 625 acres or 40% of the property that is presently vacant. 1 Table II identifies the vacant land within the zone by future land use type utilizing the same hierarchy identified in the Land Use Data Section of the Land Use Element. At the present time there are no conflicts with shoreline uses as the beach front is public and maintained as a recreational facility for the I residents of the community. Because of the growing marine industry within the general Broward County area and the lack of facilities with ready access to the Intracoastal and Atlantic Ocean, Dania finds itself as a desirable location for this type of development. The economic base of the coastal portion of Dania as reflected in existing land use provides for a diverse array of both residential and commercial activities. Industrial activities within Port Everglades plus commercial activities along Dania Beach Boulevard, including Dania Jai-Alai, provide employment opportunities and tax revenue for the community. I The natural resources occurring within the coastal zone have been identified on the Coastal Resource Map. There are mangrove communities occurring within portions of the eastern segment of the City. The portions of the coastal zone which contain natural resources include generally the area of east 5th Avenue and south of Dania Boulevard which is a mangrove habitat and the area east of Fort Lauderdale/Hollywood International Airport which also contains a __1 mangrove habitat. The City Commission has reduced the density east of 5th Avenue and south of Dania Beach Boulevard from Low(5) Residential to Estate(1) Residential which significantly reduces the intensity of any development that may occur in this area. For the area east of the Fort Lauderdale/Hollywood International Airport the same developmental constraints would be in place for any activities within this area. The key difference with this area is that it is the primary employment center for the City of Dania and hence a primary tax base. Therefore, it does provide substantial economic benefits to the community. However, a balance between protection of natural resources and economic benefits can be obtained and properly managed. i The proposed future land uses have no effect on coastal flooding within the area as that primarily is related to the beachfront which is { a public beach facility and will continue to be maintained as such IJ by the City of Dania. The historic resources have been identified on the coastal resources map and there are no redevelopment efforts through this 1 ) Land Use Plan which would have an impact on historic resources (there are no archeological sites) in the coastal area. The City of Dania beach coastal high hazard area is non- contiguous to the remainder of the City as indicated on the future land use maps. B. Estuarine Conditions [W-5.012(2)(d)] The New River Sound which is located in the Dania Beach area and depicted on the Estuarine Map is located in an area which due to its proximity to the Port Everglades Inlet receives a substantial tidal flow and related flushing. Accordingly, the pollution within this area is very limited and the water quality which is designated as a Class III by the Florida Department of Environmental Regulation is good. There are no point or non-point source pollution problems within the estuarine area. In addition, as noted earlier, the City of Dania will not permit any additional development which will have a negative impact to the water quality of this estuary. 1 2 I The beach area of the City of Dania has existing infrastructure in place which will suffice for both existing and proposed land uses. -, The area is accessed by Dania Beach Boulevard (four lane divided) from the west and AM (two lanes) from the south, both of which are part of the State primary road system. C. Natural Disaster Planning [9J-5.012(2)(e)] I 1. Hurricane Evacuation The emergency preparation office of the Broward County government is responsible for the preparation and implementation of a hurricane evacuation plan for Broward County. The plan includes two (2( categories: Plan A which calls for the evacuation of all residents east of the intracoastal waterway in the event hurricane winds are in the 74 mph to 100 mph range. Plan B extends the evacuation line to everything east of U.S. 1 and this is for a hurricane with winds in excess of 111 mph. iThere are no residents within the City of Dania living east of the intracoastal waterway that would be affected by Plan A. Plan B would affect approximately 4,000 residents of the City. The proposed land use plan as it relates to the coastal zone is not anticipated to have any particular impact as it relates to hurricane evacuation. 2. Existing / Proposed Land Uses [9J-5.012(2)(e)] The existing land uses within the coastal high hazard area consist primarily of the Dania Beach area which includes the fishing pier, public restrooms, and a small food establishment which serves as a take-out business for beach users. I 3. Beach and Dune Systems [9J-5.012(2)(f)] .-� The beach and dune system located on the Dania beach area is in good condition. There has not been any programmed rehabilitation of this particular beach, however, John Lloyd State Park immediately north of the City and the City of Hollywood Beaches immediately south have both had restoration projects. A new restoration was planned for the summer of 1989. The primary impact of the restoration will J occur about a mile north of Dania Beach, but the responsible I 3 agency, Broward County Environmental Quality Control Board, indicates that Dania Beach will benefit from this work. The Broward County Environmental Quality Control Board does not feel that Dania is experiencing deterioration and the beach ecosystem has been maintained in reasonable good condition. 4. Public Access [9J-5.012(2)(g)] Beach public access within the City of Dania is excellent as there is a 26.5 acre beach front park available to all residents. There is a substantial parking facility also available and all facilities are open to the general public. These areas also provide suitable scenic overlooks of the beach area and public boat ramps/docks are available at Houston Park for launching of small crafts. Houston Park Marina is approximately 1 mile west of the Intracoastal Waterway and situated on the Dania Cut-Off Canal. Dania Beach also enjoys the fishing pier which has been in existence for many years and is a popular spot for residents and tourists alike. 5. Structures with a History of Repeated Damage There are no structures with a history of repeated damage damaged from the coastal storms. i 6. Coastal or Shore Protection Structures There are no coastal or shore protection structures currently iin place in the City of Dania. 7. Infrastructure [9J-5.012(2)(h)] The existing infrastructure within the coastal area of the City of Dania consists of the following items: { a. U.S. 1 Federal Highway This is an existing facility varying from four (4) to five (5) lanes and has an existing right-of-way of 106 feet which may be expanded. 4 _.I I b. Dania Beach Boulevard East of U.S. 1 - This is an existing facility varying from four (4) to five (5) lanes that is located in an existing 110 foot right- of-way. C. S.E. Fifth Avenue This is an existing two (2) lane facility that presently exists from Sheridan Street on the south to Dania Beach Boulevard on the north. This is a roadway with expanded right of way which is anticipated to be used by the City for drainage. d. U.S. 1 / Dania Cut-Off Canal Bridge e. Intracoastal / Dania Beach Boulevard Bridge f. Intracoastal / New River Sound Bridge g. Dania Cut-Off Canal 8. Beach and Dune Conditions The City of Dania's beaches and dunes are not experiencing any significant erosion or deterioration problems. 9. Hazard Reduction ' Because of the minimal development existing within the high hazard area, there is no need to consider the relocation or structural modification of the limited number of structures within the high hazard area. Also, 100% of the area is already under public ownership. D. Marina Siting [9J-5.012(4)] 1. Dania does not participate in a County wide marina siting plan. 2. Port Master Plan has been prepared by the Port Everglades Authority and that entity will evaluate that document. -J 5 i COASTAL MANAGEMENT ELEMENT CURRENT CONDITIONS — [9J-5.012(2)(a)-(h)l I. INTRODUCTION The purpose of the Coastal Management Element remains the same. The following will compare the differences from the 1989 plan through 1995. II. DATA AND ANALYSIS REQUIREMENTS A. COASTALZONEINVENTORY Table I identifies the existing land uses within the coastal zone in 1985 and in 1995. In 1989 approximately 625 acres or 40% of the - property was vacant compared to 491 acres or 32% today. In Flex Zone 84, 122 acres (25%) of the vacant land lies east of SE 5th Ave. This land has been purchased by Broward County as part of West Lake Park, an environmentally sensitive wetland. In Flex Zone 79, 251 acres are industrial and account for 51% of the total vacant land. I � Table II identifies the vacant land by future land use type for 1989 and 1995. Vacant lands have decreased from 625 acres to 491 acres. There still remains no conflict with shoreline uses as the beach front remains public and is maintained as a recreational facility for i the public. The Coastal Resources Map indicates the coastal zone boundaries, the water dependent and related areas, historic structures, wetland vegetation and evacuation routes. B. ESTUARINE CONDITIONS No changes have occurred in estuarine conditions. The beach area remains developed for recreation purposes and the traffic circulation remains the same. A new water and sewer system was installed in 1995 to support the newly constructed pier and anticipated restaurant. J 6 i i I -- The Generalized Wetlands / Estuarine System Map shows the jareas of wetlands, lakes and canals and estuary areas. There have been no changes to this map. C. NATURAL DISASTER PLANNING 1. Hurricane Evacuation I The Broward County Office of Emergency Preparedness is still responsible for the preparation and implementation of a hurricane evacuation plan for Broward County. During Hurricane Andrew the City of Dania reacted in accordance with this plan. The Coastal Resources Map indicates the evacuation routes. 2. Existing/Proposed Land Uses ! The Existing land uses within the coastal high hazard area still consist primarily of the Dania Beach area. 3. Beach and Dune System The beach is not in need of renourishment at any time in the foreseeable future. The existing dune system is in good shape and is continually being upgraded and improved. 4. Public Access - No Changes 5. Structures with a History of Repeated Damage I There are no structures with a history of repeated damage in coastal storms. 6. Coastal or Shore Protection Structures I There are no coastal of shore line structures in place in Dania. ' I 7. Infrastructure - No Changes i 8. Beach and Dune Conditions The city's beaches and dunes are not experiencing any J significant erosion J i -- 7 a� l ---� 9. Hazard Reduction - No Changes w, D. MARINA SITING jBroward County has not developed a County wide marina siting plan. i 111. SUMMARY The Coastal Zone Element remains virtually unchanged since 1989. There have been no significant problems develop over the years. Hurricane management worked well during Hurricane Andrew. i i I I I i i i 8 i Coastal Management Table I DATA AND ANALYSIS REQUIREMENTS Coastal Zone Existing Land Use - 1987 By Flex Zone Traffic Zone SF MF-1 MH C I R-1 R-2 U CF RP V TOTAL 78 1 31 32 79 9 59 2 3 157 274 504 84 148 226 8 112 43 56 2 24 350 969 Total 148 226 8 122 1 59 43 89 5 181 624 1505 Coastal Zone Existing Land Use - Current Data By Flex Zone Traffic Zone SF MF-1 MH I C I R-1 R-2 U CF RP V TOTAL 78 1 26 27 79 0 82 2 16 153 251 504 84 148 269 11 171 43 41 2 44 240 969 Total 148 269 111 172 82 43 69 18 197 491 1=:F:1:5:0�0] Source: Dania Growth Management Department 1995 Coastal Management Tabie 11 DATA AND ANALYSIS REQUIREMENTS Coastal Zone Vacant Land Use By Type - 1987 Data Traffic Zone L(5) LM M MH H C I CF U Total 78 79 3 253 15 271 84 138 46 90 11 6 58 4 353 Total 138 46 90 11 61 61 1 253 1 4 15 624 Coastal Zone Vacant Land Use By Type - 1995 Data Traffic 5-16 16 up Zone L(5) LM M MH H C I CF U Total 78 79 0 251 0 251 Q84 122 26 37 0 5 50 0 240 1221 261 371 01 51 501 2511 01 0 491 Source: Dania Growth Management Department CONSERVATION ELEMENT 'I i i I I � I I � I i I � ' J TABLE OF CONTENTS CZONS A T ADOPTION PAGE I. INTRODUCTION ............................................................ II. DATA AND ANALYSIS REQUIREMENTS .......................... 1 A. Water Resources B. Flora and Fauna C. Wetland Communities D. Air Quality E. Lakes and Minerals F. Soil Erosion G. Fisheries, Wildlife, Marine Habitat and Vegetated Communities H. Pollution Problems I. Current and Projected Water Needs CURRENT CONDIT/ONS I. INTRODUCTION .................................... 5 II. DATA AND ANALYSIS REQUIREMENTS .......................... 5 A. Water Resources B. Flora and Fauna C. Wetland Communities D. Air Quality E. Lakes and Minerals F. Soil Erosion G. Fisheries, Wildlife, Marine Habitat and Vegetated Communities H. Pollution Problems I. Current and Projected Water Needs L w CONSERVATION ELEMENT CONDITIONS AT ADOPTION I. INTRODUCTION A. Purpose The Conservation Element of the City of Dania is prepared to provide a guide for the conservation, use, and protection of natural resources within the City and immediately adjacent property. i B. Physiography The City of Dania is situated in southeastern Broward County which is the second largest county based upon population within the State of Florida. The County consists of approximately 1,200 square miles; however, only the eastern third (414 square miles) is considered within the planning or development area. Of the 414 1 square miles the City of Dania comprises approximately 5 square miles. II. DATA AND ANALYSIS REQUIREMENTS (9J-5.013) (1) (a) (b) (c) A. Water Resources 1. Surface Water The Dania area is generally drained by the Dania Cut-Off (C-11) canal which divides the City north and south. The C- 10 canal provides the major drainage conveyance primarily serving the southern and western portions of the community. C-10 ultimately discharges into the Intracoastal and ultimately through Port Everglades inlet into the Atlantic Ocean. Existing drainage in the City is adequate and as development occurs each development is to meet drainage improvement requirements in accordance with the standards of the South Florida Water Management District, Broward County Water Resources Management Division, as well as the City requirements. 2. Flood Plains The Flood Plains Map for Dania, which is prepared pursuant to the National Flood Insurance Program, identifies areas 1 A within the City that are subject to flooding for the 100 year period. Dania participates in the National Flood Insurance Program of the U.S. Department of Housing Urban Development. 3. Ground Water j The sub-surface strata below the City can be grouped into three general categories: (1) Biscayne Aquifer, (2) The Floridian Aquiclude, and (3) The Floridian Aquifer. The Biscayne Aquifer is the unit closest to the surface and is composed primarily of Palmico Sands, Miami Oolite, Anastasia Formation and Fort Thompson Formation, The Floridian Aquiclude primarily consists of impermeable strata I which prohibits the intermingling of water between the Biscayne Aquifer and the Floridian Aquifer which is beneath the aquiclude. The Biscayne Aquifer is one of the most productive water producing aquifers in the world. It has been designated the only reliable source of drinking water for all of Broward County and since 1979 has been designated as the sole source of drinking water by the U.S. j Environmental Protection Agency. i B. Flora and Fauna I Table I will provide a generalized list of the flora and fauna which generally occurs within Dania. Table II will provide a generalized list of the wildlife; however, there are no endangered animals or plants within the community. C. Wetland Communities The remaining wetland communities within the City of Dania consist of mangrove communities in the eastern fringes of the City. j D. Air Quality Due to the prevailing breezes occurring in southeastern Florida, the air quality is generally good for the Dania area. While the Comprehensive Plan provides for expansion of industrial opportunities for the community, these will be light industrial/office park type developments which will have minimal impacts on the air quality. 2 I E. Lakes and Minerals All of the lakes occurring within the City are man made and have been developed for providing fill for development or for providing commercially valuable minerals. F. Soil Erosion At the present time the City of Dania is not experiencing any soil erosion problems. Whenever soil erosion problems occur or a situation arises which may indicate that soil erosion could potentially occur, the Soil Conservation Service office is contacted to provide proper planning to minimize any negative impact. Also, the City in its review of site plans particularly for new lake excavations insures that all sites are properly sloped and vegetated as soon as possible after construction. G. Fisheries, Wildlife, Marine Habitat, and Vegetative Communities The existing mangrove communities east of S.E. 5th Avenue and east of the airport do contain wildlife habitat. Through proper site planning controls and mitigation of any impacts to wetlands areas these habitats can be enhanced and provide for a more suitable habitat for the propagation of a greater variety of i flora and fauna. Manatees are generally found in the New River Sound estuary and to a limited extent along Dania Cut-Off canal. They have no natural predators. Manatees are protected under the Endangered Species Act and the Marine Mammal Protection Act but because of these impacts by navigational uses a general decrease in the population is expected. H. Pollution Problems There are no known pollution problems affecting existing natural resources within the City of Dania. Hazardous waste are controlled through the Broward County Environmental Quality Control Boards adopted hazardous material regulations and storage tank regulations. i I 3 I. Current and Projected Water Needs As noted in the Potable Water Element, there exists adequate capacity of both present and projected water needs for the build- out of the community. These projections incorporate the anticipated land uses within the City including the industrial expansion. In addition, the City endorses the Broward County Raw Water Regional System which is presently being implemented and this will continue to ensure an adequate quality and quantity of this resource. The current and projected water needs and sources for the next ten-year period based upon residential, commercial, industrial and other uses is outlined below. i Wellfield Sites prepared for Broward County in 1986. AVERAGE DAILY WATER DEMAND (1,000,000 gallons per day) I City of Dania 1989-1999 Residential Non-residential Other Uses Total 1989 1.4 .4 .3 2.1 1999 2.2 .8 .5 3.5 Based upon the existing capacity of the City of Dania treatment facility the City will be able to supply all needs for the next ten _I years. i 4 CONSERVATION ELEMENT CURRENT I INTRODUCTION A. PURPOSE i The Conservation Element of the City of Dania was prepared to provide a guide for the conservation, use, and protection of the natural resources. This guide has served the city well and has helped to protected it's natural resources. II. DATA AND ANALYSIS REQUIREMENTS [9J-5.013(1)(a)(b)&(c)] A. WATER RESOURCES 1. Surface Water The Dania Cut-Off canal serves as the main discharge point for most of the city. The South Florida Water Management District is responsible for water conservation, flood control and drainage requirements. 2. Flood Plains The Flood Plains Map indicates the two flood zones that lie within the City of Dania. Since 1989 they remain unchanged. The city, in an effort to better protect it's population has increased it's minimum flood elevation from 7 to 8 feet above sea level. 3. Ground Water- No Change B. FLORA AND FAUNA Table I and II have not changed since 1989 C. WETLAND COMMUNITIES The Coastal Resources Map locates the wetlands communities within Dania. Since 1989 no changes have occurred in our wetland J communities. 5 D. AIR QUALITY With the introduction of emission control standards for automobiles and manufacturing, the air quality in Dania and Broward County as a whole has improved. E. LAKES AND MINERALS The Minerals Map displays the general areas of the city's mineral resources. F. SOIL EROSION The city continually monitors new development to insure that no excessive soil erosion takes place during construction. The Soils Map depicts the soil associations located within Dania. J G. FISHERIES, WILDLIFE, MARINE HABITAT AND VEGETATED COMMUNITIES - No Changes H. POLLUTION PROBLEMS - No Changes I � I. CURRENT AND PROJECTED WATER NEEDS 1989 1995 1989 1995 AVERAGE AVERAGE Peak Peak 1995 2.8 MGD 2.8 MGD 4.2 MGD 4.2 MGD 2000 3.5 MGD 2.8 MGD 5.3 MGD 4.2 MGD I i 1 6 ,.i RECREATION AND OPEN SPACE ELEMENT I l , TABLE OF CONTENTS CONDITIONS A T ADOPTION/l PAGE I. INTRODUCTION II. DATA REQUIREMENTS .................................................. 1 A. Neighborhood Parks B. Community Parks C. Need - Existing / Future CURRENT CONDIT/ONS I. INTRODUCTION ............................................................. 3 II. DATA REQUIREMENTS ................................................... 3 A. Neighborhood Parks B. Community Parks III. ANALYSIS REQUIREMENTS ............................................ 6 j A. Neighborhood Parks B. Community Parks i IV. SUMMARY ..................................................................... 6 I TABLES FOLLOW TEXT I I. Existing Park Facilities- Neighborhood I II. Existing Park Facilities-Community Ill. Existing Park Acreage VII. Recreational Guidelines City/State Comparison l two, _. A RECREATION AND OPEN SPACE ELEMENT CONDITIONS AT ADOPTION -- I. INTRODUCTION [9J-5.014] The Recreation and Open Space Element for the City of Dania Comprehensive Plan is intended to provide for a comprehensive system of public and private recreational and open space facilities which will be available to the public. Tables i and II will outline the existing recreational facilities within the community including the identification of the types of recreational activities which are provided by these individual sites. II. DATA REQUIREMENTS [9J-5.014(1)] A. Neighborhood Parks 1. Brooks Park 1.5 acres 2. Northwest Park 1.5 acres I 3. Airport 10 Park 1.3 acres 4. Collins Elementary School 4.9 acres i 5. Modello Park 9.7 acres 6. Florida Audubon Society 2.9 acres I 7. Frost Park 10.1 acres I 8. Mullikin Park 1.0 acres I 9. Boisy Waiters Park 3.2 acres 1 10. Ely Boulevard Park 2.5 acres 11. Dania Elementary School 2.6 acres 12. Southeast Park 10.0 acres 13. Olsen Middle School 9.9 acres TOTAL 61.10 acres 1 I i B. Community Parks 1. Tigertail Park 39.3 acres 2. I.T. Parker (Houston Park) 22.3 acres 3. Dania Beach 26.5 acres TOTAL 88.1 acres 1 + C. Needs - Existing / Future [9J-5.014 (2)(a) (b) & (c)] I � The City of Dania is responsible to insure that adequate amounts of local and community parks are available for the residents of the 1 City. Broward County is responsible for the provision of adequate regional parks. Typically Broward County and the City are able to obtain necessary park and recreational requirements through the platting process. Meeting park and recreational requirements is one of the service requirements which must be reviewed and approved by the City and County before issuance of building permits. Broward County requires 3 acres/1,000 population of regional parks to comply with its standards. The City of Dania also requires 3 acres/1,000 for neighborhood and community parks to insure an adequate supply of recreational facilities for the residents of the community. Based upon the 1988 and 2010 population estimates of approximately 12,000 residents, the City is responsible for the provision of approximately 36 acres of neighborhood and community parks. As noted on Table III there are presently in excess of 60 acres of neighborhood and 88 acres of community parks with a grand total of approximately 150 acres. Accordingly, the City is in an excellent position regarding land requirements for neighborhood and community parks for the present and the year 2010. I 2 L RECREATION AND OPEN SPACE ELEMENT CURRENT CONDITIONS 1. INTRODUCTION The following evaluation is intended to describe the state of the Parks and Recreation facilities today as compared to 1989. The Recreation and Open Space Map shows the existing facilities within the City of Dania. II. DATA REQUIREMENTS [9J-5.014(1)] A. NEIGHBORHOOD PARKS 1. Brooks Park (1.5 ac.) This facility remains the same and mainly serves as a place to rest and relax as residents observe the airport. 2. Northwest Park (1.5 ac.) This park has been renamed to Southeast Garden Park. New playground equipment including a play structure, swing set and the refurbishing of the two tennis courts were completed in 1995. 3. Airport 10 Park (1.3 ac.) jThis 1.3 acre facility was leased to the city for as long as the property was owned by the lessor. This park is no longer leased by the city, however, a plat restriction requires the park to be kept as open space, and is included in the inventory. 4. Collins Elementary School (4.9 ac.) Collins Elementary school has recently completed a renovation to the school facilities. Improvements include new class rooms and a new playground. 5. Modello Park (9.7 ac.) Modello Park has under gone a face lift since 1989. The baseball field was renovated to include new fencing, irrigation system, lighting and concession stand in 1993. In 1995 the tennis court Jwas converted to a basketball court due to the demand for 3 i 1 basketball, the existing two basketball courts were resurfaced and new playground equipment was installed. The existing swimming pool is being completely rebuilt and should be completed by the end of this year. 6. Florida Audubon Society Property (2.9 ac.) - No Changes 7. Frost Park (10.1 ac.) A new playground facility was constructed along with the resurfacing of the tennis and basketball courts in 1995. In 1994 a jogging facility was completed. 8. Mullikin Park (1.0 ac.) I This park was completely rebuilt in 1995 to include new fencing, irrigation system, play structure, swings and tennis court. f 9. Boisey Waiters Park (3.2 ac.) - No Changes I 10. Ely Boulevard Park (1.7 ac.) Renamed to Chester Byrd Park in 1994 this facility is also i undergoing renovation. New playground equipment and swings were installed early in 1995. Currently, a new irrigation system is being installed and new fencing and a jogging/fitness trail have been added. 11. Dania Elementary School (2.6 ac.) Dania Elementary school has recently completed the addition of new class room space to their facility. 12. Southeast Park (10.0 ac.) This facility, better known as the "Dania Salt Marsh", is a 10 acre wetlands area that is in the middle of West Lake Park owned by Broward County. 13. Olsen Middle School (9.9 ac.) Olsen Middle school also has completed renovations to it's facility. I! J 4 A _ J 1 14. Sun Garden Isles Park (1.2 ac.) This 1.2 acre park is located adjacent to the C-10 Canal. It serves as a passive park and contains picnic facilities and a new fishing deck. This park was left out of the 1989 plan by mistake. B. COMMUNITY PARKS I. Tigertail Park (39.3 ac.) This facility was given to the City of Dania by Broward County in 1993. 2. I. T. Parker (Houston Park) (22.3 ac.) In 1994, a new boat docking facility was completed along the Dania Cut-Off Canal. 3. Dania Beach Park (26.5 ac.) In 1995, 11 new picnic shelters, two new play structures, swings, a fitness center and a new fishing pier were I completed. Tables I and II have been revised to reflect the changes in Dania's ' park and recreation system since 1989. The following explains the changes that have taken place since 1989: Table I depicts the changes that have accrued in the parks and recreation facilities. The number of ball fields, playgrounds shuffleboard and pool facilities remains the same. A decrease in one (1) tennis court is indicated. This tennis court was converted to a basketball court at Modello Park due to the demand for additional basketball facilities. Basketball courts increased by three (3), because of a deletion in the 1989 data. Picnic facilities have increased due to additions at six (6) park facilities. Two (2) paddle ball courts were not included in the 1989 plan, along with the addition of a jogging path and a fishing deck at two of the parks. Table II reflects the changes in the Community Parks. Picnic facilities have increased with the addition of new facilities at Tigertail and Dania Beach Parks. One (1) boat ramp was added at Tigertail Park and boating is permitted at all of the community parks. Two (2) playgrounds have been added at Dania Beach Park and a boat dock at Houston Park. Table III indicates changes that came about because of errors in the 1989 data. -I 5 III. ANALYSIS REQUIREMENTS [9J-5.014(2)(a)] A. NEIGHBORHOOD PARKS Based upon the current population, the city more than provides sufficient neighborhood parks to serve it's population and that in the foreseeable future. B COMMUNITY PARKS Based upon the current population the city more than provides sufficient community parks to serve it's population and that in the foreseeable future. Based upon the 1990 census data, Dania's population is 13,024 residents. Using the formula of 3 acres of parks per 1,000 population, the city needs to provide 39 acres of recreational lands. 1 Table III indicates that the city currently has 61.4 acres of neighborhood and 88.1 acres of community parks. The City of 1 Dania, for the foreseeable future, will not need to acquire any new park land to meet the needs of it's future residents. 1 I Tables IV, V, and VI have not changed since 1989. Table VII has been revised to reflect the amount of park acreage and facilities needed for the existing 1990 population. IV. SUMMARY The state of the recreational facilities have improved in the City of Dania by the physical improvements made to the various parks such as resurfacing of the courts, replacement of the swimming pool, construction of a new 900 foot fishing pier and additional picnic facilities at the various parks. The City of Dania has more than an adequate amount of park . . lands in it's inventory to cover additional population increases for the future. �I 6 Recreation/Open Space Element Table I DATA REQUIREMENTS Existing Park Facilities- Neighborhood- 1989 Data Tennis Passive Parks I Ballfields Playground Courts Basketball Shuffleboard Pool Park Picnic Brooks I 1 2 Northwest 1 2 Airport 10 1 Collins 1 1 2 Modello(') 1 1 1 1 1 j Audobon 1 j Frost(") 1 3 1 3 1 1 6 1 Mullikin 1 1 Boisy Waiters 1 Ely Boulevard 1 Dania Elementary 1 1 3 Southeast 1 Olsen 4 7 Total 6 6 1 i 13 6 1 6 4 Existing Park Facilities-Neighborhood- 1995 Data Tennisl I I I Passive Jogging Fishingl Paddle Parks Ballfields Playground Courtsl Basketballl Shuffleboard Pooll Park Picnic Path I Deck Ball Brooks I I I 1 1 2 S. E. Garden 1 2 1 Airport 10 1 Collins 1 2 Modello(") 1 1 3 1 4 1 Audobon 1 Frost(") 1 3 1 1 3 1 6 4 1 1 Mullikin 1 1 1 Boisy Waiters 1 Chester Byrd 1 1 Dania Elementary 1 1 3 Southeast 1 Olsen 1 4 7 Sun Garden Isles 1 1 1 Total 6 6 10 16 6 1 6 14 1 1 2 Source: 1995 Recreation Department i i i I � r i I Recreation/Open Space Element Tauie II DATA REQUIREMENTS Existing Park Facilities - Community - 1989 Data Fishing Community Boat Passive Parks Picnic Beach Pier Center Ramp Park Boating r Tigertail 1 Houston Park 1 4 Dania Beach 1 1 1 Total 1 1 1 1 1 1 4 1 0 1 Existing Park Facilities - Community - 1995 Data Fishing Community Boat Community Play Boat Parks Picnic Beach Pier Center Ramp Park Boating Ground Dock Tigertaii 1 1 1 1 Houston Park(') 1 4 1 1 4 Dania Beach 16 1 1 1 1 2 Total 17 1 1 1 1 5 3 3 2 4 (') Multi-use Recreation Building and Community Center Source: Recreation Department Recreation/Open Space Element Table III ANALYSIS REQUIREMENTS EXISTING PARK ACREAGE NEIGHBORHOOD COMMUNITY 1987 Data 1995 Data 1987 Data 1995 Data Parks Acres .Acres Parks Acres Acres ` -, Brooks 1.5 1.5 Tigertail 39.3 393 Northwest 1.5 1.5 Houston Park 22.3 ;22=3 Airport 10 1.3 1:3 Dania Beach 26.5 26 5 j Collins 4.9 4:9 Modello 9.7 97 Audobon 2.9 2:9 Frost 10.1 10.1 Mullikin 1 1 Boisy Waiters 3.2 " .12 y Ely Blvd. 1.7 1:7 v rx Dania Elementary 2.6 2.6 W'�� I Southeast 9.9 9.9 Olsen 9.9 Sun Garden Isles i TOTAL 60.2 " 61.41 TOTAL 88.1 . $81 Source: 1995 Recreation Department l jl i �I I _ J A V� 1 Recreation/Open Space Element Table VII ANALYSIS REQUIREMENTS Recreational Guidelines City/State Comparison - 1989 Data State Recommendation City of Dania Dania (#or amount) (#or amount) Comparison i Facility: Tot Lot 5 6 +1 Neighborhood Park 24 acres 61 acres +37 acres Community Park 24 acres 62 acres +38 acres Beach Access 6 acres 26 acres +20 acres Activities: Swimming(non-pool)shoreline 1 mile 4 mile +,3 Fishing(off-shore) 3 boat ramps 4 boat ramps +3 Fishing (on-shore) 1900 feet pier/seawall 400 ft. -pier +10,000 Tennis 6 courts 11 courts +5 j Baseball/softball 4 fields 11 courts +5 Football/soccer 3 fields 3 fields +0 Handball/racquetball 1 courts 4 courts +3 Basketball 2 courts 13 courts +11 Recreational Guidelines City/State Comparison- 1995 Data State Recommendation Cito of Dania Dania (#or amount) (#or amount) Comparison i Facility: Tot Lot 6 6 0 Neighborhood Park 26 61.5 +35.5 Community Park 26 62 +36 Beach Access 6.5 26.5 +20 Activities: Swimming (non-pool) shoreline .1 mile .4 mile +.3 Fishing (off-shore) 3 boat ramps 4 Boat Ramps +1 900' Fishing Pier/ -I Fishing(on-shore) 1900 feet pier/seawall 2 mi Seawall N/A Tennis 6 courts 10 Courts +4 BasebalUsoftball 4 fields 6 Fields +2 Football/soccer 3 fields 3 Fields 0 HandbalUracquetball 1 courts 4 Courts +4 Basketball 2 courts 14 Courts +12 Source: Recreation Department I j INTERGOVERNMENTAL COORDINATION ELEMENT i 1 j a J I TABLE OF CONTENTS COND/T S T ADOP1/ON PAGE I. INTRODUCTION ................................ II. DATA REQUIREMENTS .................................................. 1 j A. Overview B. Existing Coordination 1 Ill. ANALYSIS REQUIREMENTS ........................................... 3 A. Existing Coordination Mechanisms - Effectiveness ' B. Opportunities for Improvement C. Area of Concern/Regional Policy Plan D. ACSC t i CURRENT CONDIT/ONS I. INTRODUCTION ............................................................. 8 i II. DATA REQUIREMENTS ................................................... 8 III. ANALYSIS REQUIREMENTS ............................................ 8 MATRIX FOLLOW TEXT INTERGOVERNMENTAL COORDINATION ELEMENT CONDITIONS AT ADOPTION I. INTRODUCTION This element sets guidelines and implementation standards to insure and foster the spirit of cooperation among all parties affected by the actions of the City of Dania and by which I Dania might be affected. II. DATA REOUIREMENTS I A. Overview [W-5.015(1)(a)j The intergovernmental data requirements include the area of concern for the City of Dania which represents the Cities of Hollywood, Fort Lauderdale, and Unincorporated Broward. The City of Dania is not adjacent to a County line so this report will only be relative to Broward County. The following . , governmental entities will be examined. I 1. State Agencies , I a. Florida Department of Environmental Regulation (DER) b. Florida Department of Community Affairs (DCA) c. Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT) d. Florida Department of Professional Regulation (DPR) j e. Florida Department of I Natural Resources (DNR) f. Florida Department of Health and Rehabilitative Services (HRS) 2. Regional Agencies a. South Florida i Water Management District (SFWMD) j b. South Florida Regional Planning Council (SFRPC) tow ,a J Ir 3. County Agencies a. Broward County Board of County Commissioners (BCC) b. Broward County Planning Council (BCPC) c. Broward County Environmental Quality Control Board (EQCB) d. Broward County i Parks and Recreation Division e. Broward County ..I Sheriffs Office 4. Cities i a. City of Hollywood i b. City of Fort Lauderdale c. Unincorporated Broward 5. Special Districts I a. Florida Power and Light b. Broward County Leagues of Cities c. Cable Systems d. Broward County School Districts e. South Broward Hospital District f. South Broward Park District (merged with Broward County) 6. Federal Government a. United States Army Corps of Engineers b. Federal Aviation Administration i B. Existing Conditions [W-5.015(1)(b)] I Table 1 will provide a synopsis of the existing coordination mechanisms, the nature of the relationship and the office primarily responsibility for coordination with the Agency. I ' 2 tow _.. i III. ANALYSIS REQUIREMENTS i A. Existing Coordination Mechanisms - Effectiveness [W-5.015(2)(a)] I The following will describe the effectiveness of the existing coordination mechanisms which are presently in place. I 1. State Agencies a. Florida Department of Environmental Regulations (DER) Primary interaction would be as it regards to any wetland permitting that may be occurring within the City that would need the review and assistance by the DER staff. Also, any amendments to formal agreements related to potable water, resource recovery, or other environmental regulations. Interaction with the agency continues on an as needed basis and response has been effective and satisfactory. b. Florida Department of Community Affairs (DCA) 1. Development of Regional Impact/Binding Letters The coordination of these matters has been improved substantially in the last few years. i 2. Comprehensive Planning The effectiveness of this system has been coordinated in an effective fashion, considering the number of local governments in the State. Some opportunities for improvement in the comprehensive planning segment will be addressed later in this report. G. Florida Department of Professional Regulation (DPR) It is an informal coordination effort that is handled on an as- needed basis, and is working effectively in this manner. d. Florida Department of Health and Rehabilitative Services (HRS) This department's interaction with the City primarily relates to the licensing of nursing homes within the community. .r ✓ 3 i Interaction between HRS and the City of Dania has worked reasonably well. 2. Regional Agencies a. South Florida Water Management District (SFWMD) The City's Engineering Department in concert with the South Broward Drainage District insures that the water management plans are in conformance with City Code. b. South Florida Regional Planning Council (SFRPC) The Regional Planning Council's primary role in the past has been the coordination, review, and approval of all ` Developments of Regional Impact. The SFRPC has provided exceptional guidance in monitoring this program. 3. County Agencies ja. Broward County Office of Planning (BCOP) This agency is responsible for the review of plats for new development within the County. The interaction with the City is primarily with the Growth Management Department and the coordination has been satisfactory to date. i b. Broward County Property Division (BCPD) The primary interaction is with the Engineering and Growth Management Department of the City with the petitioner usually being a private party. C. Broward County Water Resources Management Division (BCWRMD) The City insures that all future development conforms with the requirements of the Broward County Water Resources _. Management Division's standards and criteria. The interaction with this office has been satisfactory to date. 4 L 1 d. Metropolitan Planning Organization (MPO) The City of Dania is represented on this organization's Technical Coordinating Committee. The Growth Management Department serves as the representative. This group meets on a monthly basis and coordination has been effective. i e. Emergency Medical Services (EMS) The fire department is responsible for provision of EMS services city-wide. f. Broward County Planning Council (BCPC) The agency interacts primarily with the City's Growth Management Department to insure that the Certified Land Use Plan for the City of Dania is in conformance with the Broward County Land Use Plan. Coordination with this agency has been effective. i g. Broward County Environmental Quality Control Board } (BCEQCB) The Growth Management Department for the City of Dania insures that any projects proposed within this Agency's jurisdiction are closely coordinated with that office to insure proper protection of the natural resources. 4. Special Districts a. Broward County League of Cities I The League of Cities serves as an effective lobbying group for j all cities within the community. They meet on a monthly basis and coordination and communication has been very good. b. Broward County School Board (BCSB) i The Broward County School Board is responsible for public schools within the community and is also responsible for provision of public education grades K-12. The effectiveness of this coordination with the School Board has been satisfactory to date and there are no problems occurring. J 5 i C. South Broward Hospital District Coordination and interaction with the South Broward Hospital District has been extremely effective and is expected to continue. d. South Broward Park District The South Broward Park District through an agreement with the Broward County Commission was dissolved as of October, 1988. 5. Cities a. Unincorporated Broward The primary interaction with unincorporated Broward has been general planning issues and airport related issues. The TAC has served as an effective means to coordinate planning issues. i b. Hollywood The City of Hollywood (201 Program) through an agreement with the City Commission provides for the treatment and disposal of all waste water for the City. This interaction has worked very effectively. I The balance of the agencies described in the data section of the analysis have interacted on a infrequent basis. Coordination or need thereof has been minimal and there have not been any serious problems with those agencies. B. Opportunities for Improvement [9J-5.015(2)(b)) .1 1. Florida Department of Community Affairs (DCA) I The Department of Community Affairs is responsible for the review and approval of Comprehensive Plans and amendments thereto. There is a need for closer interaction between the Tallahassee Office and the local governments. The difficulty lies in the inability of the State staff to have a good understanding of the local situation including unique geographic and sociological concerns of the local 6 I areas. The following suggests two ways to approach the problem and they are as follows: a. Establish a regional office and staff it with State personnel. Also, the State staff would be able to become part of the Technical Advisory Committee which is very active within Broward County. b. It may be more appropriate to assign the appropriate Regional Planning Council with the duty of serving as the State's liaison. This would be a logical and immediate means to improve coordination with the State. 2. South Florida Regional Planning Council (SFRPC) In the past couple of years, substantial improvements have occurred in the efficiency of the Development of Regional Impact review process including the monitoring of development orders and insuring that conditions of approval are adhered to in accordance with development orders. The Regional Planning Council has also become very involved in the Comprehensive Planning review and approval process and has made an extra effort to interact with local governments in advance of comprehensive plan development. This should help to eliminate possible inconsistencies between the local plans and the Regional Policy Plan. C. Area of Concern / Regional Policy Plan [9J-5.015(2)(c)] The area of concern for the City of Dania includes the City of Hollywood to the east and south, Unincorporated Broward to the west and to the North jboth Unincorporated Broward and the City of Fort Lauderdale. A comparison has been made with the South Florida Regional Policy Plan and this does not reveal areas which require additional planning coordination to proper implement the Comprehensive Plan beyond that f which is already incorporated into the City of Dania's Comprehensive Plan. ..i D. ACSC [9J-5.015(2)(d)] There is no ACSC within the area of concern for the City of Dania. �I 7 I -- I i INTERGOVERNMENTAL COORDINATION ELEMENT CURRENT [9J-5.015(1)&(2)] i I. INTRODUCTION iNo Changes !I. DATA REQUIREMENTS i No Changes III. ANALYSIS REQUIREMENTS No Changes Until the new guidelines are received for this element there will be no changes made. i i i . -.� 8 TABLE I DATA REQUIREMENTS Intergovernmental Coordination Relationship Organization Subject Relationship Responsible Officer 1. State N FDER Dredge/Pill, Sewer Permitting Growth ^' (407) 964-9668 Management Engineering DCA Planning Advisory Growth (904) 487-4545 Kinagement FLOT State Roads Maintenance & Construction Engineering (305) 524-8621 DPR Business License Advisory City Manager (305) 467-4448 DNR Parks & Recreation Grants, Advisory PE.rks and (904) 488-8217 Recreation Growth Management 1 OEM HRS Health Care Advisory City Manager (305) 467-4298 DHR Historic Resources Advisory City Manager 2. Regional SFiW Water Management Permitting Engineering (407) 686-8800 Water Supply SFRPC Planning Advisory Growth (305) 961-2999 Management 3. .County BCC County Government Elected Body City Commission (305) 357-6300 City Manager BC'PC Planning Certifies Local City Commission (305) 357-6695 land Use Plans Growth Management EQCB Water/Sewer Approval Body Engineering (305) 765-5881 Sheriff Law Enforcement Provides Police City Manager 765-4321 Services • `• a a Jon 6N& i 4. Cities City of Fort Lauderdale Long Range Planning, Advisory City Manager (305) 761-5000 Zoning, Transportation Growth Facilities and Construction Management City of Hollywood Lang Range Planning, Advisory City Manager (305) 921-3501 Zoning, Transportation Growth Facilities and Construction Management a Unincorporated Broward Long Range Planning Advisory City Manager (305) 357-6666 Zoning, Transportation Growth iFacilities and Construction Management i 5. Special Districts School Board Schools Operates and Plans City Manager (305) 76.5-6285 Schools Growth Management I South Broward Health Care Operator Public City Manager Hospital Hospital (305) 987-2000 i I I i i I I South Broward C.B. Smith Merged with Broward Parks and Parks District Park County Parks and Recreation (305) 961-4430 Recreation (10/i/68) FPQ Electricity Provides Power City Commission (305) 765-3111 League of Cities Local Government Coordinates City Commission (305) 357-6300 Interests Port Everglades Operates Port Coordinates City Manager 6. Federal Government FAA Airports Fort Lauderdale/Hollywood City Commission international Airport City Manager Army Corps of Engineers Wetland Permitting Growth (305) 591-1302 Dredge/Fill 1bnagement CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT ELEMENT i .l TABLE OF CONTENTS i COND /ONSATADOPT/ON PAGE I. INTRODUCTION ............................................................ 1 1 i II. DATA REQUIREMENTS .................................................. A. Public Facilities Needs B. Public Education and Public Health Systems C. Public Health Systems D. Revenue Sources i III. ANALYSIS REQUIREMENTS ........................................... 3 A. Local Practices B. Public Education / Health Care Infrastructure C. Timing and Location CURRENT COND/T/OlV$ I. INTRODUCTION ............................................................ 5 II. DATA REQUIREMENTS .................................................. 5 A. Traffic Circulation B. Parks and Recreation C. Sanitary Sewer, Solid waste, Drainage, Potable Water and Natural Groundwater Aquifer Recharge D. Public Education and Public Health Systems E. Revenue Sources III. ANALYSIS REQUIREMENTS ........................................... 7 i IV. SUMMARY ..................................................................... 7 TABLES FOLLOW TEXT I. Analysis Requirements Projected Operating Costs J I _1 . CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT ELEMENT CONDITIONS AT ADOPTION I. INTRODUCTION The Capital Improvements Element for the City of Dania is developed to evaluate public facilities which are identified as needed in other comprehensive plan elements. i _ II. DATA REQUIREMENTS A. Public Facilities Needs [9J-5.016(2)(b) & (c)] 1. Traffic Circulation No identified local needs. 2. Parks and Recreational There are no identified needs which must be addressed at the present time or for the next five (5) year period and the Year 2010. 3. Sanitary Sewer, Solid Waste, Drainage, Potable Water and Natural Groundwater Aquifer Recharge The City of Dania has made substantial improvements for these basic infrastructural needs. Limited areas of line upgrading which have been identified are planned to occur with development of those areas. CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT NEEDS l Tvpe of Facility Cost* Timing Sanitary Sewer Infiltration / Ex-infiltration Study $35,000/yr Ongoing Potable Water Distribution $200,000 1990 Storage Tank $200-400,000 1994 Drainage Storm Sewers $100,000 1994 Pump Station $ 60,000 1994 "The above noted cost estimates were based upon registered Civil Engineer's estimates for the improvements. B. Pubic Education and Public Health Systems [9J-5.016(1)(b)] 1. Public Education Dania is fortunate to have several schools situated within the jurisdictional limits of the City. School Name Collins Elementary Dania Elementary Olson Middle School 2. The School Board serves all of Broward County C. Public Health Systems [9J-5.016(1)(b)] i The primary public health system serving the City of Dania is the South I Broward Hospital District (SBHD) whose principal offices are located at Memorial Hospital in the City of Hollywood. Memorial Hospital (an eight hundred (800) bed facility) which is situated at 35th and Johnson Streets serves the majority of South Broward and provides indigent care at the present time for the City of Dania. The SBHD serves southern Broward i County. D. Revenue Sources [9J-5.016(1)(c)&(2)(f)] The following will describe the various revenue sources and mechanisms which are available for capital improvement financing requirements of the City of Dania. 1 1. Ad Valorum Taxes 2. Revenue Bonds ' 3. Florida State Funds a. Department of Natural Resources b. Department of Transportation c. Department of Commerce d. Department of Environmental Regulation 4. Federal Funds a. Department of Transportation ` b. Department of Interior 5. Gas Taxes a. State b. County i _l 2 j 6. County Funds 7. Impact Fees a. Parks and Recreational B. Licenses and Permits 9. Interest Income 10. Sales Tax I REVENUES AND OTHER FINANCING SOURCES i • Property Taxes • Intergovernmental Utility Taxes • Rents and Fees • Franchise Fees • License & Permits • Fines & Forfeitures Other • Loan Proceeds • Transfers In III. ANALYSIS REQUIREMENTS A. Local Practices [9J-5.016(2)(a)j The City of Dania guides the timing and location for capital improvements which are required by growth and development within the community. The following will outline the current local practices: i 1. Growth trends and demands for services are determined by each department with input from the Growth Management Department. 2. Departments submit recommendations for capital improvements. 3. City Manager/Finance Director consider impacts related to supplemental funding and responsibilities outside the City's purview such as state funding, federal funding and their related mandates and requirements. 4. City Manager makes recommendation to City Commission for enactment and budgeting per the City Charter. .J I B. Public Education/Health Care Infrastructure [9J 5.016(2)(d)] All the public education and health care infrastructure requirements for any facilities that have been identified in this element have already been provided. C. Timing and Location [9J-5.016(2)(e)] The entire premise of the City of Dania Comprehensive Plan has been and j continues to be the provision of public facilities to support efficient land idevelopment. I .I I i i I i i i J j 4 . �d I CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT ELEMENT CURRENT CONDITIONS INTRODUCTION The following shall evaluate the progress and changes made to the Capital Improvement Element of the Dania Comprehensive Plan. II. DATA REQUIREMENTS [9J-5.016(2)(b)&(c)] A. Traffic Circulation The road systems listed in this segment are the responsibility of Broward County of F.D.O.T. to maintain and to provide for increased capacity. Of those streets listed as East/West Streets, Sheridan Street, Stirling Road and Griffin Roads have undergone or are undergoing capacity improvements at the 1-95 intersections. Interstate 595 is now complete and St. Rd. 84 has also been improved. No changes have been made to Dania Beach Blvd. The North/South streets with the exception of 1-95 have not been improved. 1-95 has been widened as a part of the 1-595 construction No local streets were identified as needing improvements in 1987. i B. Parks and Recreation I No capital improvements were identified in the 1989 plan. However the following capital improvements were made to the Parks and Recreation Facilities: I New Fishing Pier\Dania Beach Park $ 1,850,000.00 New Swimming Pool\Modello Park $ 103,055.00 New Baseball Field\Modello Park $ 45,709.00 Boat Dock\Houston Park $ 42,721.00 Playground Equipment $ 100,902.00 Hard Surface Courts Resurfacing $ 48,535.00 Fishing Deck\Sun Garden Isles Park $ 10,300.00 Total Capital Expenditure $ 2,201,222.00 .7 I i C. Sanitary Sewer, Solid Waste, Drainage, Potable Water and Natural Groundwater Aquifer Recharge. The solid waste recycling facility has been opened and the City of Dania i has contracted with them to handle and recycle all of the solid waste generated by the city. Identified in the plan are three (3) Capital Improvement needs: I 1. Sanitary Sewer: Infiltration/Ex-infiltration Study i This study and associated repairs were to be funded at the rate of $35,000 per year. To date the City has allocated and spent $800,000 for the studies and associated line repairs. 2. Potable Water: Distribution and Storage Tank The water distribution system in Dania is constantly undergoing repair. 30,000 Lf. of line has been replaced at a cost of$300,000. The Storage Tank Facility listed at a cost of $200 - $400,000 has not been funded. 3. The Pump Station listed at a cost of$60,000 has not been funded. D. Public Education and Public Health Systems [9J-5.016(1)(b)] 1. Schools I All three of the public schools Collins Elementary, Dania Elementary and Olsen Middle School have been expanded or completely rebuilt by the Broward County School Board. 2. Public Health System - No Change 1 E. Revenue Sources [9J-5.016(1)(c)] The revenue sources listed remain the same in 1995 as they were in 1989. 6 I I III. ANALYSIS REQUIREMENTS [9J-5.016(2)(a)&(f)] To the extent possible the tables listed below have been revised to reflect the 1995 data. Due to the annexation of those areas west or Ravenswood Road, a j majority of the tables could not be revised because there is no way to separate the data. i A. Table II - No data available B. Table III - Has been revised to reflect the actual funds and long-term debt through 1994. C. Table IV- No data available D. Table V- No data available lE. Table VI - Has been revised to reflect the actual operating costs through the year 1991, the year of the annexation. IV. SUMMARY [9J-5.016(2)(e)] The 1989 plan identified the capital improvements needed to support the plan. Since 1989, as reflected in the Evaluation and Appraisal Report, other capital improvements became apparent and were funded. The drainage improvements have not been addressed to date, however, the need for these improvements remain along with the water storage facility. In general, the city has made good progress in it's capital programs with the exception of those mentioned above. i i I 7 I - A �h1 Capital ln,y,ovement Element ANALYSIS REQUIREMENTS ($Thousands) Projections of Debt-Current Bond Issues Notes Payable Enterprise Funds General Long-Term ebt Account Group Projected Projected Projected �4cly�� Actual Actual Projected Projected Projected Actual Actual Acjua1 Fiscal Year Principal Interest Totals i Princl al `Interest ;:, Totals Principal Interest Totals ',Pnncl al Interest '.'Totals 1989 $ 20 $ 14 $ 34 $J' '' '22.1 14 4 36 $ 170 $ 122 $ 292 $ 147 $ 123 ;$ ','270' 1990 $ 20 $ 13 $ 33 $" ;'i'• _19` $ ^16' $ `:`"35 $ 170 $ 110 $ 280 $ :; `191 :$. , '98 $.;- 289 1991 $ 20 $ 12 $ 32 $!;',_ .,20 '$ 12, t$ :' 32 $ 170 $ 98 $ 268 r$ .`i171, $ '. 87 `$; .258 1992 $ 20 $ 10 $ 30 $" 34' $ ' 12 $ 'I 46 $ 170 $ 86 $ 256 $ 147 $ 81 $ :' 228 1993 $ 20 $ 9 $ 29 $ :965' $ 48 1$ 1,013 $ 170 $ 73 $ 243 I$ _100 $ 50 $ 150 1994 $ 100 $ 22 $ 122 $, :° .163 $ ' 33 $ . 1196 $ 850 $ 184 $ 1,034 $ 105 '$ -65 $ 170 Totals 1 $ 200 $ 80 1 $ 280 $i ++ 1,223 $' 135 $ 1,356 $ 1,700 $ 673 $ 2.373 $ . 861 $ 504 $ 1,365 Sewer Revenue Bands Fiscal Year Projected Projected Projected Apty�l : Actual f Actual Ending In: Principal Interest Totals FYE! PrincJ al ;;Interest; Total's. 1989 $ 55 $ 37 $ 92 l�': •1909 ;$t 55,, 1$t •:'37.' '$:' 92 1990 $ 60 $ 35 $ 95 i` ` : 1990 '$ ' :W t$ f,` 35S $1, -:95 1991 $ 60 $ 32 $ 92 1991 '$ "W >$ :39'` i$;r' 91 1992 $ 60 $ 30 $ 90 1992 A "''-.60 ?$ 31` 1993 $ 65 $ 27 $ 92 1993 f$ ' :'`65` f$ +'.274 `$ 92 Thereafter $ 630 $ 99 1 $ 729 1994 .$ 70 :I$ 25 $" .95 Projected Totals $ 930 $ 260 $ 1,190 ActuaJTotaJs,,:;:$ 370i $;. 556 Unamortized Unamortized Bond Discount $ 8 $ 8 Borid'Discount $ 8; $, $" . 8 Totals $ 938 $ 260 $ 1,198 $ 378. $ 186 $ 564 Source: Dania Finance Department 1995 Capital improvement Element Ta....: A PROJECTED OPERATING COSTS ($ Thousands) YEAR Projected Projected Projected all : Actual Comparison Comparison Comparison 1989 1990 1991 1888 ; , . 19911 1991 1989 1990 1991 General tx} Government $ 2,900 $ 2,987 $ 3,076 $ 2,02F' `$ r1' 344 $`, 1,509 $ (874) $ (1,643) $ (1,567) Public Safety $ 3,400 $ 3,502 $ 3,607 $ 3',920+ $ �4;492 $'' 5,128 $ 520 $ 990 $ 1,521 Physical Environment $ 360 $ 370 $ 381 $ . 422. �.$ 479 $ 530 $ 62 $ 109 $ 149 Public Works $ 890 $ 916 $ 944 $ ' `.8t30 $ "1237 `$' 1,425' $ (10) $ 321 $ 481 Economic Environment $ 274 $ 282 $ 290 $ 282 $ 4t34 $ 528 $ 18 $ 182 $ 238 Human Services $ 52 $ 53 $ 55 $ 1143" "$"S°'`'53 `$' 62 $ (9) $ - $ 7 Culture / Recreation $ 390 $ 401 $ 413 $ 43 + Z,$�`t ',646 $ 670 $ 47 $ 245 $ 257 Capital Outlay $ 129 $ 132 $ 136 78 $ 24 $ (19) $ (58) Debt Service $ 65 $ 66 $ 68 $` ` 270" ;$s "i89 $ 258 $ 205 $ 223 $ 190 Total „",t;✓ ,'F „; Expenditures 8,709 $ 8,970 $ 8,443 408 $ 1,218 "Numbers in parenthesis indicate a negative figure I Source: Dania Finance Department ADOPTED OBJECTIVES COMPARISION/RESULTS a i i I .J FUTURE LAND USE GOALS, OBJECTIVES AND POLICIES (9J-5.0053(6)(a)(3)) OBJECTIVE I. Within one (1) year of transmittal of the Plan to Florida Department of Community Affairs, land development regulations shall be developed which promote orderly growth, development and placement of land uses which will encourage a mix of residential types and provide good quality of life for the residents of the City of Dania. • The Dania Comprehensive Plan was adopted 4111189 • On 2127/90, the Dania City Commission approved ordinances 12-90 & 13-90 which enacted concurrency for growth and development; and updated the existing LDR's of the City to enhance the quality of growth and development. • The objective was met. OBJECTIVE II. Land development regulations will be developed which will insure that future 1 land use amendments will only be permitted provided an analysis demonstrates that the soils, topography, natural resources and availability of the services are in place within one (1) year of the transmittal of the Comprehensive Plan to the Florida Department of Community Affairs. I • Ordinance 12-90 & 13-90 plus the implementation of a Comprehensive Plan Amendment checklist insure an analysis of an amendment's impact/compatibility with services. • These areas were adopted/implemented 2127190 less than one year after the 4111189 Comprehensive Plan adoption. • A storm water retention recharge area is being developed along the SE 5t'Ave. corridor, adjacent to the existing salt marsh. The objective was met. OBJECTIVE III. Identify available land suitable for the provision of community facilities to support the existing projected population by 1991. The available community facility land in 1987 comprised of 231 acres. • The available community facility land in 1995 comprised of 276 acres • This results in a net increase of 45 acres of community facility land within the community. The difference is identified in the future land use section of the EAR. I J j _. i I No new community facilities are anticipated to be needed to meet future needs. The objective was met. OBJECTIVE IV. Continue to implement redevelopment and renewal of blighted areas within the Dania CDBG. The number of substandard units within the community in 1987 totaled 266. • The total substandard units in 1990 totaled 26 units for a net reduction i of 240. The City has also supported the development of the Habitat for Humanity subdivision of approximately 7 single family homes as well i as other significant improvements within the community including the following low and moderate income housing: Housing Authority Saratoga 40 units Subsidized rental housing DEDC Byrd Pointe 25 units Single family low/moderate income ownership DEDC 9 units Single family low/moderate income ownership Liberty Heights 64 units Subsidized rental housing Project Impac 26 units Rental housing subsidized The objective has been exceeded. Objectives will be reestablished during the plan amendment process. I OBJECTIVE V. Develop land development regulations, zoning ordinances and other administrative rules to implement the Comprehensive Plan within one (1) I year of transmittal to the Florida Department of Community Affairs. Ordinances 12-90 & 13-90 enacted concurrency in land development regulations and administrative rules which implemented the Comprehensive Plan. These actions occurred on 2/27/90 which is less than one year from the adoption date of the Comprehensive Plan of 4111189. The objective was met. OBJECTIVE VI. Natural resources and historic resources shall be maintained at their present levels at a minimum. � - 2 ow Natural resources have been actually enhanced and increased via the acquisition for public ownership of the Dania Salt Marsh which is approximately 122 acres in size and situated east of Southeast 5th Avenue and south of Dania Beach Blvd. • All other natural resources have been preserved via the dredge and fill permitting process as well as the other implementing ordinances required via the land development regulations adopted by this City through Ordinances 12-90 & 13-90 on 2127190. 1 All historic resources have been maintained at their present levels which includes the relocation of a historic home from downtown Dania to a site across from City Hall which will be available for community functions. This home is known as the Nyberg Swanson (site rile #8BD00119) and was originally constructed in 1904. The City will continue to identify historic resources. • The objective has been met. 1 OBJECTIVE VII. Land development regulations will be adopted by 1990 which will insure the future residential densities for land uses within the coastal hazard zone will be limited by the hurricane evacuation standards identified within the Broward County Hurricane Evacuation Plan. • Land development regulations adopted via Ordinances 12-90 & 13-90 related to the implementation of the Comprehensive Plan which includes the coastal high hazard zone. • Residential land use categories are not permitted within the coastal hazard zone of the City of Dania. • The objective has been met. OBJECTIVE Vill. New growth and development will only be permitted where services are available and meet the level of service standards of the Comprehensive Plan thereby eliminating urban sprawl. The land development regulations enacted via Ordinances 12-90 & 13-90 by the City on 2127190 include the provision and requirement for services being available and meeting the level of service standards of the Comprehensive Plan. • The City is an urbanized eastern Broward City. It has been identified as an infill City which by definition controls urban sprawl. 1 The objective has been met. mI 3 I ' OBJECTIVE IX. Land development regulations will be developed within one (1) year of Plan adoption which will insure that any uses found inconsistent with the communities character are not permitted. • The land development regulations enacted via Ordinances 12-90 & 13-90 by the City on 2127190 include the provision and requirement for services being available and meeting the level of service standards of the Comprehensive Plan. These land development regulations which enact the Comprehensive Plan mandate that inconsistent uses are not permitted. • The objective has been met. _ I OBJECTIVE X. Within one (1) year of adoption land development regulations shall be developed which provide for mixed land uses and other unique a development techniques. The land development regulations enacted via Ordinances 12-90 & 13-90 by the City on 2127190 include the provision and requirement for services being available and meeting the level of service standards of the Comprehensive Plan. • Mixed uses and other unique development techniques are permitted within the land development regulations of the City of Dania. • The objective has been met. I i 4 HOUSING GOALS, OBJECTIVES AND POLICIES OBJECTIVE I. Assist the private sector with the provision of 450 additional housing units by 1993 and 770 total units by 2010. The housing will be of various types and affordability to existing and anticipated population growth. Since 1987 there has been an addition of 424 single family units; 36 duplex units; 661 multi family units for a total of 1120 dwelling units. • The housing activity was significantly greater than anticipated when the Comprehensive Plan was developed in 198811989. This is due to the i favorable economy and attraction for new growth and development within the community. The objective has been exceeded. • Objectives will be reestablished in the plan amendment process. OBJECTIVE If. Demolish at least 5 dilapidated units by 1990 and on an annual basis provide a minimum of 1 rehabilitation and 1 new housing unit. • Since 1990 a total of 19 dilapidated units have been demolished. • Since 1990 on an annual basis the City has provided a minimum of 88 unit rehabilitations and 33 new housing units (total 164 units). The objective has been exceeded. o Objectives will be reestablished during the plan amendment process. OBJECTIVE Ill. Continue to record code enforcement actions related to structural and community appearance improvements to existing housing. The City maintains two (2) code enforcement officers who document structural and community appearance improvements to existing housing. Since 1991, 11,796 enforcement actions related to structural and community appearance improvements have been recorded by the City. The number of enforcements by year is provided below: I 5 �i i 1 • i CODE ENFORCEMENT COMPLAINTS (1991 - 1995) a I 1991 1,244 1992 2,426 1993 2,992 1994 2,358 1995 2_,776 (JAN - NOV) TOTAL 11,796 The objective has been met. I OBJECTIVE IV. r Identify by 1990 two (2) sites for low and moderate income housing. I Since 1990 the City has identified the following sites for low and moderate income housing: Housing Authority Saratoga 40 units Subsidized rental housing DEDC Byrd Pointe 25 units Single family low/moderate income ownership DEDC 9 units Single family low/moderate income ownership Liberty Heights 64 units Subsidized rental housing Project Impac 26 units Rental housing subsidized Habitat for Humanity 7 units Single family low income ownership I o The objective has been exceeded. Objectives will be reestablished during the plan amendment process. i OBJECTIVE V. Group homes or foster care facilities licensed by Florida HRS shall be permitted in specified residential categories of the Dania Comprehensive Plan. Group homes and foster care facilities are permitted within the j Comprehensive Plan which was adopted on 4111189. The City complies with Florida Statutes as it regards sitings of group homes and foster care facilities licensed by Florida HRS. Y The objective has been met. i 6 OBJECTIVE VI. Continue the conservation, rehabilitation and demolition of housing, and the identification of historically significant housing. The Nyberg Swanson house has been rehabilitated and relocated onto public property and will be utilized for a community facility for the residents of the City. New sites will be identified, particularly in the northwestern portion of the City, during the plan amendment process. The objective has been met. OBJECTIVE VII. Identify Historically Significant Housing by 1992. The City of Dania Historical Survey was completed in 1992. The project was financed by the U.S. Department of Interior. The New sites will be identified, particularly in the northwestern portion of the City, during the plan amendment process. The objective has been met. i OBJECTIVE Vill. Provide relocation housing for residents displaced as a result of Community Development Block Grant activities. The Community Development Block Grant activities have not caused the displacement of a resident since 1990. Those displaced in the future will be provided with relocation housing in accordance with the Community Development Block Grant program. Temporary relocation has been provided with project impact. The objective has been met. j OBJECTIVE IX. Formulate a Housing Implementation Program by 1992. A housing implementation program has been developed by the City of Dania. Federal funding for Saratoga Apartments has been utilized. Street improvements such as curbs, sidewalks, and parks have been provided as part of the program. i • The objective has been met. I J I i SANITARY SEWER ELEMENT GOAL, OBJECTIVES AND POLICIES I - OBJECTIVE 1. Continue to contract with the City of Hollywood to provide wastewater treatment. The City continues to contract with the City of Hollywood for the provision of wastewater treatment. The objective has been met. OBJECTIVE II. Meet the wastewater service demands of the City of Dania. The projected average daily flow of wastewater via the City for 1995 was 3.8 MGD. The actual 1995 average flow is 2.6 MGD which is a reduction of 1.2 I MGD since 1990. This reduction occurred because the land east of the airport was projected to have significant commercial and airport related uses. However, the airport I expansion plans will now eliminate the potential for these uses to be built. The City complies with the levels of service standards. The City has implemented an inflow and infiltration program which reduced flow. The City spent$800,000 (or$160,000/year) on this program. The objective has been met. I SOLID WASTE GOAL, OBJECTIVES AND POLICIES i OBJECTIVE 1. Meet the contractual obligations of the Reuter Recycling of Florida, Inc. contract. The City continues to contract with the Reuter Recycling of Florida, Inc. The City has a waste flow of 29.5 tons/day (10,767 tons/year) which is consistent with the estimate for 1995 of 10,772 tons/year. The objective has been met. I 8 I OBJECTIVE 11. Adopt the standards of level of service as established by Broward County and the South Florida Regional Planning Council. _ The level of service standards established by Broward County and the SFRPC have been incorporated into the Comprehensive Plan and Land Development Regulations for the City of Dania. The objective has been met. OBJECTIVE III. Discourage urban sprawl through a solid waste policy. The city has been identified as an infill city. The City has established a solid waste policy through its Comprehensive Plan and land development regulations thereby, discouraging urban sprawl. The objective has been met. DRAINAGE GOALS, OBJECTIVES AND POLICIES OBJECTIVE I. Ensure for flood protection. • Dania is a member of the National Flood Insurance Program. Minimum floor elevation requirements have been exceeded by city ordinance. The City's Comprehensive Plan and Land Development Regulations established the minimum flood standards in accord with Broward County and South Florida Water Management District requirements. The objective has been met. OBJECTIVE 11. Encourage use of Best Management Practice for all drainage systems. The Comprehensive Plan and land development regulations require the use of best management practices in the development of all drainage systems within the community. The objective has been met. - 9 lI I e OBJECTIVE III. Implement drainage improvements in the southeast area of the City. • The City has developed a drainage study. • The implementation of the project has been initiated. • The objective has not been met " ' The plan amendment section will address necessary changes to meet this objective. This amendment will include a City-wide study. OBJECTIVE IV. Work with Broward County and South Florida Regional Planning Council to implement drainage rules and criteria. • The City continues to work with Broward County and SFRPC to implement drainage rules and criteria of those jurisdictions and the SFWMD. This includes the environmental resource licensing by FDEP. The objective has been met. I OBJECTIVE V. Maximize water management systems, rules and regulations to discourage i urban sprawl. i The Comprehensive Plan and land development regulations enacted on 2127190 require compliance with all applicable water management rules and regulations to discourage urban sprawl. City identified as a urban infill city. • The objective has been met. OBJECTIVE VI. The City shall try to discourage the further spread of salt water intrusion. • The City, to the greatest extent possible, discourages the spread of salt water intrusion via its Comprehensive Plan and land development regulations. However, since Dania is an East Broward coastal city, regional influences are significant as it relates to salt water intrusion and the majority of the City has been affected by salt water intrusion for many years. Accordingly, the City has subscribed to the Broward County Regional System which reduces the demand on the existing wells, thereby reducing the threat of salt water intrusion. The objective has been met. J 10 � I II POTABLE WATER SYSTEM GOAL, OBJECTIVES AND POLICIES OBJECTIVE I. Meet the service demands of the City as follows: Averse Peak 1990 2.1 MGD 3.2 MGD 1995 2.8 MGD 4.2 MGD 2000 3.5 MGD 5.3 MGD The projected average daily flow of 2.8 MGD by 1995 is the average daily flow and has been met by the community. The projected peak flow of 4.2 MGD for 1995 is actually a current peak of 3.0 MGD, and the objective has been met.. The projection of the average daily flow for the year 2000 of 3.5 MGD is now 1 estimated to be 3.0 MGD. The plant has been renovated so the plant life is twenty years. Objectives will be reestablished during the plan amendment process. i OBJECTIVE II. Provide for the expenditure of approximately $1,500,000 to implement the e treatment distribution and storage facilities. necessary improvements to th The water treatment plant underwent a complete renovation in 1991 and is expected to operate an additional ten years without major improvements. Storage facilities were not constructed due to budget constraints, The objective has been met. Objectives will be reestablished during the plan amendment process. OBJECTIVE III. The City shall discourage urban sprawl by requiring connection to potable water system when within 1/4 mile of a subdivision or within 100 feet of a residence. City requires connection within 250 feet of a residence an E.A.R. based amendment will be developed with the Plan Update which would revise Objective Ill to read, '250' vs. 100', as it currently states. . The City discourages urban sprawl by requiring connection with potable system within 1/4 mile of a subdivision or within 250 feet of a residence. This is implemented through the Comprehensive Plan and land development regulations of the City which were enacted in 2/27/90. The City is also an eastern Broward infill community. The objective has been met and exceeded. II I Ievised Rule Revised Statute Descriation of Change Abased on Comprehensive Plan Objectives 8 Policles Does Plan satCh mule 9J-5 F.A.C.1 Hule 9J-5 and Ch. 9J-5.0013(1)(a)5 Requirement to identify and analyze This analysisnot Included in Comprehensive Plan. The City of No Important fish and shell fish Dania will amend the plan as required by 9J•5.002 (8)in 1997 communities to address this criteria. 9J•5.0013(1)(b) Requirement to Identify and analyze This analysisnot Included in Comprehensive Plan. The City of No hazardous waste pollutant for each Dania will amend the plan as required by 9J-5.002(8)in 1997 resource to address this aiteria. 9J-5.013 (2)(b)2 The element shall contain one or Addressed In Conservation Element(Objective p VI, Policies Yes more specific objectives to conserye 6.1, 6.2) and protect the quality/quantity, of waters that flow into estuarine waters or oceanic waters 9J-5.0013(2)(c)1 Policy to protect water quality and See Conservation Element Objective II Yes quantity from adverse land uses 9J-5.013 (2)(c)10 The element shall contain one or See Conservation Element Objective V(Policy 5.5) Yes more polices for.. See Conservation Element Objective II(Policy 2.2), (10) Management of hazardous wastes to protect natural resources. 9J•5.013 (3)(a) & (b) Policies addressing wetlands: The Dania Sall Marsh Is the major wetland feature within the Yes (a)Wetlands shall be conserved..... City of Dania. The Comprehensive Plan Includes the following (b) Future land uses which are policies related to its protection and conservation: Incompatible with the protection of Future Land Use: Objective II (Policy 2.1), Objective VI wetlands shall be directed away (Policies 6.1, 6.2, 6.3) from wetlands.... Conservation: Objective IV (Policy 4.1) Objective V (Policies 5.1, 5.4) 9J.5.014(1) Identify fresh water beaches There are no fresh water beaches Yes (NA) 9J•5.014 3(b)1 Objective to ensure public access to There are no fresh water beaches Yes (N/A) fresh water beaches and shores �I 10 _ .. t TRAFFIC CIRCULATION GOALS, OBJECTIVES AND POLICIES OBJECTIVE I. Transportation Planning shall continue to be closely coordinated with future land use planning concepts and designations as developed in the County Land Use Plan, Certified Local Land Use Plans and requirements of the Local Government Comprehensive Planning and Land Development Regulation Act, Chapter 163, Florida Statutes. The City of Dania serves on the Technical Coordinating Committee of the Metropolitan Planning Organization of Broward County. Thereby, the City closely coordinates future land use planning concepts with the County's efforts as it relates to transportation planning. • The City participated in the TCEA development by Broward County for Eastern Broward County which enhances the urban infill aspects of community development and eliminates the urban sprawl aspects of urban development. The objective has been met. • The Plan Amendment section will speak to amendments related to the TCEA implementation within the City plan. i OBJECTIVE IL Preserve existing and future right-of-ways. • The City's Comprehensive Plan incorporates the Broward County Traffrcways Plan which preserves existing and future rights-of-way of the transportation corridors within the regional transportation system. • The City's land development regulations require preservation of existing and future rights-of-ways in the land development subdivision regulations of the City's Code. New right-of-way is required through the platting process. • The objective has been met. OBJECTIVE III. The City of Dania shall adopt the Level of Service D as the lowest acceptable operating level of its transportation network. • The Comprehensive Plan does adopt level of service D for the lowest acceptable operating level and the City maintains this level of service in the review of development proposals within the community. 12 + Broward County oversees the regional transportation network and the maintenance of the level of service within this area. The adoption of the TCEA for Eastern Broward County requires new developments to ° pay mass transit fees which will help fund improvements to the Broward County mass transit system. These future improvements will help to minimize the impacts to the roadway system within the community. _. + The objective has been met. + The Plan Amendment section will address the incorporation of TCEA into the community's Comprehensive Plan. OBJECTIVE IV. Take all reasonable precautions to prevent the level-of-service on any segment of the regional roadway network in the City from falling below level-of-service D. l + The Comprehensive Plan does adopt level of service D for the lowest acceptable operating level and the City maintains this level of service in the review of development proposals within the community. + Broward County oversees the regional transportation network and the maintenance of the level of service within this area. The adoption of the TCEA for Eastern Broward County requires new developments to pay mass transit fees which will help fund improvements to the Broward County mass transit system. These future improvements will help to minimize the impacts to the roadway system within the community. + The objective has been met. j + The Plan Amendment section will address the incorporation of TCEA into the community's Comprehensive Plan. i 13 I ' COASTAL MANAGEMENT GOALS, OBJECTIVES AND POLICIES j OBJECTIVE I. Protect, conserve and enhance coastal barriers and wildlife habitat in the coastal zone at present levels. • The land development regulations which were adopted on 2127190 for the implementation of the Comprehensive Plan insure the enhancement of the coastal barrier areas and the maintenance at their present level. Dania Salt Marsh is a 122 acre enhancement that was recently acquired by the public. • The objective has been met. OBJECTIVE II. Develop criteria which will prioritize shoreline uses and give priority to water dependent uses by 1990. The City has redeveloped the pier on the Dania Beach which is a water dependent use which encourages community utilization. The City is also negotiating with FAU on the development of an oceanographic institute in an existing structure within the coastal high hazard area. • The objective has been met. OBJECTIVE Ill. Maintain or improve the existing beaches and dunes. The Dania Beach Pier has been rehabilitated for public utilization and recently re-opened in 1995. • No development has occurred which affects the dunes or will inhibit their existence. j C Dunes are continually monitored and improved to ensure enhancement and protection. . The objective has been met. 1 _l 14 i OBJECTIVE IV. Limit public expenditures that subsidize development in coastal high hazard areas. The public expenditures within the coastal high hazard area have been for the maintenance and repair of existing facilities such as the Dania Beach pier and for the restoration and enhancement of natural resources. The objective has been met. OBJECTIVE V. Comply with Broward County Hurricane Evacuation Plan and maintain or improve evacuation times. I i . The City has worked with the Broward County Hurricane Evacuation l Plan and Emergency Management to improve evacuation times. The City has also embarked upon a program of training for key personnel within the City for future emergencies. The objective has been met. 1 OBJECTIVE VI. Continue to require that any development within Port Everglades be consistent with its Master Plan. O No new development within the City limits of the port area has occurred since 1990. The City coordinates all development that may occur within the port area with port administration. The port authority was recently incorporated into Broward County government and coordination is now offered through that agency. The objective has been met. I OBJECTIVE VII. Maintain or improve estuarine environmental quality. The estuarine environmental quality has been enhanced with the acquisition of the Dania Salt Marsh which is south of Dania Beach Boulevard and east of Southeast 5th Avenue. This area consists of approximately 122 acres which was once slated for an estate residential development on the City's plan and Low (5) Residential density on the Broward County Land Use Plan. Accordingly, this will be an enhancement of the estuarine environmental quality and this is a 15 A i i direct linkage to the West Lake Regional Park which is a 2,000 acre mangrove preserve immediately east of this Dania salt marsh. The objective has been met. OBJECTIVE Vill. Direct residential construction away from the coastal high hazard area. Residential development is directed away from the coastal high hazard area. There is no residential land use permitted within the coastal high hazard area the City of Dania. The objective has been met. OBJECTIVE IX. Prepare a post disaster redevelopment plan by 1991. a . The objective has not been met. Objectives will be reestablished during the plan amendment process. I OBJECTIVE X. Maintain the present public access to the Dania Beach. The present public access to the Dania Beach is the same as in 1989 with full access for all community residents as well as visitors to the community. In actuality, the public access has been enhanced with the redevelopment of the Dania Beach Pier. The objective has been met. OBJECTIVE XI. Continue to maintain the historic resources within the coastal zone. Historic resources have been maintained at the 1989 levels within the coastal zone area. The objective has been met. _1 J 16 I I _J I i OBJECTIVE XII. / Levels of service for public access and provision of infrastructure shall be maintained at standards of the Comprehensive Plan Elements with no new public infrastructure within the coastal zone high hazard area. The level of service for public access has been maintained or enhanced and the provision of infrastructure has only been provided for the rehabilitation or enhancement of existing facilities such as the Dania Beach Pier. i The objective has been met. I .I .J 17 .J RECREATION AND OPEN SPACE GOALS, OBJECTIVES AND POLICIES OBJECTIVE I. Maintain current standards of public access to all recreational facilities and open space. The City continues to maintain full public access to all public facilities within the City of Dania. With the redevelopment and rehabilitation of the Dania Beach Pier, the access to this facility along the ocean front has been enhanced. The objective has been met. OBJECTIVE II. Public and private resources will meet the standards of the Recreation and Open Space Element to insure recreational demands of the community are met. All public and private development within the community is required to meet the land development regulations and level of service standards of the Comprehensive Plan The City meets the level of service requirements of the Recreation and Open Space Element. The City continues to make the most efficient operation of its park and recreational facilities as is reasonably possible. The objective has been met. I OBJECTIVE III. Maintain the Park and Recreational Facility requirements of the Recreation and Open Space Element. The current level of service for parks continues to exceed the 3 acres/1000 population requirement of the Comprehensive Plan. The 1987 available acreage is in excess of the requirements projected for the year 2010. Y The facility changes included a conversion of a tennis court to a basketball court due to demand, and 3 additional basketball courts are reflected currently because of an omission in the 1989 plan. Additionally, picnic facilities have been increased at 6 park facilities. J • Plan amendments may be proposed for the park facility requirements to account for future growth and development. Y The objective has been met. 18 IJ I 1 OBJECTIVE IV. �I Maintain the present standards of the Recreation and Open Space Element to insure that open space is responsive to the community needs. • The present park system is equitable and uniformly applied throughout the j community. • Parks are spatially distributed throughout the community. The objective has been met. I i J i i I 14 i CONSERVATION GOALS, OBJECTIVES AND POLICIES i j OBJECTIVE I. Maintain or improve present air quality within the City. The City continues to cooperate with the County, State & Federal Government in monitoring existing air pollution standards within the community. a New industrial development is encouraged to minimize any air quality impacts. New industrial developments are typically consistent with the IRO (industrial Research Office) category of the City's zoning code which encourages light industrial type uses that minimize impacts on air quality. The landscaping code of the City continues to provide for vegetative cover which aids in the cleansing of the air. s A bypass system was recently implemented for reducing the congestion of traffic on US 1 in the center City. This will enhance the air quality aspects of the community. The objective has been met. OBJECTIVE II. Maintain or improve the quantity/quality of water resources. i • The land development regulations adopted 2127190 ensure that all development provides for the proper protections of discharges as it relates to the Biscayne Aquifer and water resources within the community. The City also continues to comply with the conservation program of SFWMD. The City continues to comply with the Broward County Wellfield Protection Program which provides for restriction of uses in close proximity to wellfields. The objective has been met. I OBJECTIVE III. Continue to maintain present mineral areas. The mineral excavation for community development has essentially been completed. Any future development will obtain fill requirements from mineral areas in close proximity of the community. The objective has been met. rl 20 � i i OBJECTIVE IV. Conserve native vegetative communities, wildlife habitats and marine habitats at their present levels. The City requires that any developments in sensitive areas obtain all necessary dredge and fill permits from Broward County, FDEP, and Army Corps of Engineers. The Dania salt marsh area which is a 122 acre area east of Southeast 5th Avenue and south of Dania Beach Boulevard has been acquired for public purposes. This has enhanced the native vegetative community, wildlife habitats and marine habitats. The objective has been met or exceeded. Plan amendments may be proposed to address future needs. I OBJECTIVE V. Continue to coordinate with adjacent local governments and regional interests to protect natural resources. The City continues to coordinate with the adjacent local governments of Ft. Lauderdale, Unincorporated Broward, and Hollywood as well as the Regional I Planning Council. The City continues to participate on the TAC Committee of Broward County. The City ensures that LAPC's and urban wilderness areas are consistent with the County's environmentally sensitive land status. The City ensures that all hazardous waste materials are fully licensed by Broward County Department of Natural Resource Protection. The objective has been met. OBJECTIVE VI. Waters that flow into estuarine or ocean waters shall continue to receive pre- treatment. i All drainage is required to meet standards of Broward County and SFWMD and all discharges receive pre-treatment. A storm water retention buffer area is being developed along the SE 5h Avenue/salt marsh perimeter. The objective has been met. i 21 tow i INTERGOVERNMENTAL COORDINATION GOALS, OBJECTIVES AND POLICIES i Objective I. Continue to coordinate the comprehensive planning activities of the City with other affected governmental agencies. The City continues to coordinate with the school board and adjacent local governments on new growth and development. The City has recently enacted a major annexation for the western limits of the City which was in concert with adjacent local governments and the State Legislature. The Plan Amendment section will address incorporation of the annexed areas into an amended Comprehensive Plan. Development proposals that affect adjacent local govemments are coordinated with those local governments. The objective has been met. 1 Objective II. Continue to coordinate with affected governmental agencies the development impacts of the Comprehensive Plan. The City continues to participate in the Technical Advisory Committee of Broward County which fosters coordination among local governments. The City does notice adjacent local govemments when a Comprehensive Plan Amendment is along its borders. The City also reviews and comments on Comprehensive Plan Amendments within neighboring communities that may affect the City of Dania. All comprehensive plan amendments are coordinated with Broward County Planning Council through its plan amendment process and its recertification process in accord with the Broward County Charter. The City ensures that all development is consistent with its Comprehensive Plan. The City will develop an Element in accordance with the ICE legislation. The objective has been met. i i 22 Objective III. Continue current practices coordinating the provision of adequate consistent levels of service as outlined in the Comprehensive Plan for public entities that have operational and maintenance responsibilities for these facilities. • The City coordinates with Broward County Parks and Recreation Division as it relates to County regional parks within or adjacent to the j community. The City continues to interface with the Technical Coordinating Committee of the MPO. ' . The City ensures that all development complies with the Broward County Wellfeld Protection Ordinance and the City participates in the Regional Raw Water program of Broward County. Wastewater treatment is coordinated through an interlocal agreement with the City of Hollywood. -I • The City is closely monitoring the expansion of the Ft. Lauderdale/Hollywood international Airport including the extension of the south runway and the impact of the amendment to the DRI which is currently being reviewed. The objective has been met. • Plan amendments will address potential objective modifications as it relates to the Airport coordination. i j I J 23 i CAPITAL IMPROVEMENTS GOALS, OBJECTIVES AND POLICIES OBJECTIVE 1. All land use decisions shall be coordinated with fiscal resources and will maintain adopted levels of service. • All comprehensive plan amendments are reviewed in light of the fiscal resource requirements and that all infrastructure and adopted levels of services are maintained with the impact of the proposal. • The objective has been met. 1 OBJECTIVE 11. The Capital Improvements Element will be utilized as a vehicle for the construction of capital facilities to address the existing deficiencies, to accommodate future growth and to replace obsolete facilities. • This City follows the Capital Improvements Element and its physical requirements as it relates to replacement of facilities within the community. • Some of the proposed improvements have not yet been completed due to budgetary constraints. • The objective has been partially met. OBJECTIVE III. Future development shall bear its proportional share of the cost of facility improvements which are necessary to the development. All new developments shall conform to the level of service standards outlined in the comprehensive plan. • Land development regulations adopted in ordinances 12-90 and 13-90 by the City on 2127190 require that all new development complies with the level of service standards of the comprehensive plan. • All new development contributes fees to mitigate the impacts of development. The objective has been met. OBJECTIVE IV. Public expenditures in the coastal high hazard areas will be limited to maintenance and repair. 24 i I - Expenditures in the coastal high hazard area are only for the maintenance and repair of existing infrastructure facilities. This is reflected in the rehabilitation and redevelopment of the Dania Beach Pier which reopened in 1995. The objective has been met. OBJECTIVE V. Public facility construction provided for in Plan Elements shall be monitored through the land development review process to insure that the City is not _. required to construct improvements beyond its financial capacity. The public facility construction within the community is monitored • through the land development review process of the City and the City I does ensure that the constructed improvements will not be beyond its financial capacity. New developments participate in the development of public facility requirements needed to support the impacts of those developments. . The objective has been met. l l 25 1 PROBLEMS OF DEVELOPMENT PHYSICAL DETERIORATION LOCATION OF LAND USES & SOCIAL / ECONOMIC EFFECTS i i , i PROBLEMS OF DEVELOPMENT; PHYSICAL DETERIORATION; LOCATION OF LAND USES; AND SOCIAL / ECONOMIC EFFECTS 9J-5.0053 (a)(4)(a.-o.) A. ACCURACY OF POPULATION PROJECTIONS The population projections used in the plan were derived from a combination of the U.S. Census Data (1980) and the Broward County Office of Planning. Considering the 1990 data the city has almost exceeded its population projections for the year 2010. One of the major reasons for the deviation in the population projections can be found in a review of Table XIII Housing Activity (Housing Element). Between 1980 and 1987 only 69 single family homes were constructed while from the period between 1988 to 1995, 424 units were built. A total of 1,120 new units were built between 1998 - 1995. At the same time that single family units were being constructed the average household size increased. The household size was projected to 1.9 persons per unit. The 1990 census data places the average household size at 2.24 persons per unit, again a reflection of the increase { in single family development. The city can project future population by considering past building permit activity on the area of vacant residential land. According the Vacant Land fInventory there is approximately 122 acres of Low (5) land available for single family development. Therefore, there is potential for an additional 610 units with a household size of 2.24 or 1,366 new residents at build out for single family units. In addition there are 43 acres of Low Medium (10) Residential and 37 acres of Median (16) Residential vacant land available for development. There is a potential for an additional 1,032 units with a household size of 2.24 or an additional 2,312 residents when the multi- family units are completely constructed. This would amount to an additional 3,678 people when residential development is completed. As of 1991 the city annexed a large area that was not included in the 1989 plan. When the current plan is updated it is anticipated that problems will arise in determining the actual population due to the problem of comparing census data with municipal boundaries. The census data (tracts) do not coincide with the new municipal boundaries. - The city will use the 1990 census data as its base. Using new housing start data from 1990 to the present, the city can determine the number and type of residential units built. It may then apply the standard anticipated persons to household type to project the actual city population. The city needs to continually update the data so as to have the needed information available and also needs to review the impact on services and projected needs based upon the new population data. B. RATE OF DEVELOPMENT ASSESSMENT ACTUAL VS. ANTICIPATED RATE OF DEVELOPMENT As indicated in the Housing Element the projected number of housing units constructed by 1990 (7,699) has almost exceeded the projections through the year 2010 which were 7,800 units. Even though the projections were not valid the impact that this increased growth had on public facilities was minor. The city had the infrastructure in place to handle any unanticipated growth. At this time the impact of the newly annexed area has not been determined. In order to evaluate and prepare an updated comprehensive plan the city will need to determine the actual number and types of housing units already constructed, the amount of existing commercial and industrial development and prepare a vacant land inventory by type to determine the over all impact on public facilities. This will be a time consuming task that was not considered at the time of annexation. It was assumed that Broward County could provide this data, when in fact they can not. The city should begin this data gathering as soon + as possible. C. CONCURRENCY ASSESSMENT EFFECT OF CONCURRENCY Upon adoption of the City Land Development Code, standards were established as a guide to making a concurrency determination. Levels of service were determined based on those adopted by Broward County for the j following. 1. Potable Water 2. Wastewater 3. Drainage 4. Solid Waste 5. Recreation 6. Transportation j -- Regional transportation is reviewed by Broward County. i, Regional transportation has had the greatest impact on the location of development with Dania. Even though the land use plan indicates categories of J 2 land development and their locations the actual pattern of development has been determined by the regional transportation system. The development of vacant commercial properties along the over capacity U.S. 1 (Federal Highway) corridor has been severely impacted by traffic concurrency and virtually brought to a standstill. The redevelopment of commercial facilities has continued, but was limited by traffic concurrency. In may cases an existing building could be only replaced by a development that created the same or less impact. Residential development has occurred primarily along S.E. 5th Avenue corridor, where previously approved developments had little or no impact on the local and regional road system. Those developments that were vested are continuing to be developed. In 1995 Broward County adopted and implemented a transportation concurrency exception area (TCEA) land use amendment that allows for the development of infill properties even if the regional system is over capacity. This new rule allows for the development of commercial, industrial and residential development by contributing to the county mass transit system. The City will need to amend its Comprehensive Plan and Land Development code to reflect this new rule. I The other concurrency reviews are done by the city and have not had an effect on the development of residential, commercial or industrial properties because sufficient capacity is available. D. LEVEL OF SERVICE/ MAINTENANCE ACHEIVEMENT MAINTENANCE OF LOS STANDARDS i Since the adoption of the Comprehensive Plan and the Land Development Code, the City has been able to maintain its level of service standards at their current levels. There has been no need to either increase or decrease the LOS Standards based on development pressure. These standards may need to be evaluated during the Comprehensive Plan update due to the newly annexed area. The City provides for all public services in the annexed area except for water and sewer services. The LOS standards set by Broward County for water and sewer may need to be adopted if they differ from those of the City. � � 3 i E. PUBLIC FACILITY COORDINATION COORDINATION OF DEVELOPMENT WITH SERVICES All development are reviewed in terms of meeting concurrency requirements for water, wastewater, drainage, solid waste, recreation and transportation. The City of Dania, as stated earlier, has all of the water and sewer infrastructure framework in place for the development of the City. Developers are required to extend the water and sewer distribution systems into their property to serve their development. ! In the few isolated cases where the water and sewer distribution system is not available the developer will be required to extend the system to the property line. The developer then receives a credit against impact fees. 1 The City of Dania has adequate park acreage to meet ultimate build-out projections but still requires parks to be dedicated or fees in lieu of dedication for new residential developments. F. REVENUES -ACTUAL / PROJECTED ACTUAL VS. PROJECTED REVENUES / EXPENDITURES The Capital Improvement Element, Table VII identified three (3) capital improvements: 1) Infiltration/Exfiltration, with a budget of $35,000 each year or a total of $175,000 was to have been spent from 1989 - 1994. The study was completed and $800,000 has been expended for associated repairs. 2) Repair and extensions to the potable waster distribution system was included for 1990 at a cost of$200,000 along with a new water storage tank at a cost of $300,000. The city has spent $300,000 replacing parts of the old water distribution system. The water storage tank has not been constructed due to budget constraints. 3) Drainage and the replacement of the drainage pump station have been funded. In some of the lower lying areas of the city flooding is a constant problem and needs to be addressed by the city. The city has budgeted for a study to create assessment district for Dania in order to generate the funds necessary to resolve the drainage problems. This program needs to be addressed in the Comprehensive _..: Plan update. I I i J 4 G. NEW REVENUE SOURCES The creation of a special assessment district to complete necessary capital improvements is one source that has gained momentum. In addition to the imposing of a special assessment district for drainage improvements the city is exploring the possibility of a special taxing district for solid waste, emergency medical services and fire protection. New sources of revenue need to be identified so that the unfunded capital improvements may be completed. New capital improvements that may be included in the comprehensive plan update should provide for a funding source. H. PUBLIC FACILITIES/INFRASTURCTURE - PHYSCIAL DETERIORATION DETERIORATION OF PUBLIC FACILITIES 1. WATER, SEWER, AND DRAINAGE 1 The City of Dania is the oldest municipality in Broward County, being chartered in 1904. As is to be expected, some of the infrastructure is quite old and in need of repair. Knowing this, the city has spent $800,000 studying and repairing the existing sanitary sewer system and will continue to do so. The city water supply distribution system is constantly undergoing repair. Since 1989 the city has replaced 30,000 I.f. of water line at cost of$300,000. 1 The drainage system in the city is inadequate to handle the run-off generated by South Florida rains. This is not due to neglect, but rather the lack of adequate regulations of the past when a vast portion of the city was constructed. Recognizing the fact the city did include drainage improvements in the 1989 plan, but unfortunately funding never became available. The City has now authorized a drainage study for the entire City in hopes of developing a special assessment district for the city to generate the funds necessary to upgrade the system. 2. PARKS AND RECREATION, PUBLIC BUILDINGS As noted in the EAR, Capital Improvements section, the city has expended 2.2 million dollars upgrading its parks and recreation facilities. Three parks contain recreation buildings that are outdated and need to be reconstructed. Funding sources have not been identified for these upgrades. The city's other public buildings are in sound condition for the purpose for which they are used. - 5 i _ The city should consider in the Capital Improvements Element of the updated plan a program for the improvement of these facilities. I 3. ROADS Dania, like all communities, has local streets in need of repair and replacement. With the recent annexation of the western portion of the city, it inherited a large section where paved streets do not �l even exist. 4. SUMMARY I The city needs to update its Capital Improvement Element to include all the above and other facilities such as a EMS/Fire Station, Public Works Facilities, and Administrative Records Storage. It also needs to prepare a long term capital improvement budget, and find the funding sources necessary. 1. COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL BUILDINGS - PHYSICAL DETERIORATION Dania is the oldest community in Broward County and contains a number of older structures. In the past five years several older buildings in the downtown district have been renovated. In general there are very few vacant buildings. An old dilapidated industrial site of approximately 45 acres is in the first stages of redevelopment. This site, previously known as the Lindsley Lumber site, was contaminated and has since been cleaned up and is now been planned as a 200,000 square feet retail facility and a 50,000 square feet museum. The city will need to address this form of physical deterioration in the Comprehensive Plan update. J. HOUSING STOCK- PHYSICAL DETERIORATION DETERIORATION OF HOUSING STOCK AND MOBILE HOMES Knowing that Dania is the oldest City in Broward County, chartered in 1904, deterioration in the housing stock is to be expected. Table Vill Standard/Substandard Housing Conditions (Housing Element) indicates that since 1987 a total of 240 substandard housing units have been eliminated. In the same time frame, a total of 245 housing units have j been constructed as low and moderate income housing. I _ 6 tow In 1987 the city had 60 acres of land developed as mobile home parks. Today, due to the purchase of a 13 acre park by the airport for runway expansion the city has only 47 acres remaining. Most of the mobile home parks in Dania were built in the late 60's or early 70's and have developed as seasonal homes only, being occupies only 4 to 6 months a year. As can be expected, these homes have deteriorated over the years. The city needs to address this issue in the Comprehensive Plan Update and identify the substandard mobile home units and plot a course of action that will improve the situation. Dania continues to make vast strides in the area of rehabilitation of its housing stock. The Code Enforcement Division of the city has recorded 11,796 violations of property maintenance codes since 1991 and will continue to try to improve the condition of its housing stock including mobile homes. K. DEVELOPMENT / INFRASTRUCTURE ASSESSMENT The relationship of infrastructure(public facilities) and actual development did not result in significant problems as all development is required to meet concurrency requirements. The City of Dania has all of the necessary framework of services in place to provide for the ultimate build out of the city. Potable water and sanitary sewer capacities are adequate and transmission line and distribution systems are in place to accommodate growth. Police and fire services along with emergency medical services are sufficient to handle any emergency situation. The city's local road network has the capacity to handle the future projected traffic volumes. Broward County reviews the iimpact on the regional transportation system. L. DEVELOPMENT LOCATION ASSESSMENT As stated in the Housing Section of the EAR, Table XIV, the rate of residential development exceeded the 1993 projection by 219 units and is only 101 units less than that projected for the year 2010. Even though the housing starts were more than projected, all of the necessary infrastructure and public services were in place to service the increased development. I 7 There has been no evidence that the city's growth has created urban sprawl, has created incompatible land uses, created any natural hazards or endangered resources. M. HIGH HAZARD ASSESSMENT DEVELOPMENT IN THE COASTAL HIGH-HAZARD AREA The City of Dania has approximately 26 acres of land that lies in the coastal high-hazard area. All of this land is owned by the city and no residential development is allowed. This area, known as Dania Beach Park has been developed as a recreational facility and will remain as such. A commercial facility, developed through a lease agreement with the city, is the only private development in the coastal high-hazard area. Negotiations are underway to utilize this facility as a part of Florida Atlantic University's Department of Oceanographic Engineering. No one will reside in the coastal high-hazard area. Broward County Office of Emergency Preparedness is responsible for the preparation and implementation of the hurricane evacuation plan for Broward County. The city should coordinate with the county any additional evacuation measures that may be needed for this facility. I N. ENVIRONMENTAL SENSTIVE AREAS ASSESSMENT IMPACTS ON ENVIRONMENTAL SENSITIVE AREAS The Coastal Resources Map locates the wetlands communities within Dania. Adequate provisions had been made to protect the lands. The Broward County Office of Natural Resource Protection is charged with overseeing the preservation of these lands. Dania relies on their expertise to determine if development can occur in these areas. The city has approximately 122 acres of identified wetland located adjacent to and east of S.E. 5th Avenue. This land has recently been acquired and incorporated into Westlake Park, a 1,400 acre wetland preserve. The City of Dania needs to amend its Comprehensive Plan to identify this area as a park and wetlands area. It also needs to indicate the other wetland areas indicated on the Coastal Resources Map in order to protect them from any development. Land uses abutting these areas need to be evaluated so as to minimize the impact that they might have on these environmentally sensitive lands. I 8 UNFORSEEN / UNANTICIPATED PROBLEMS & OPPORTUNITIES I I i I , I _ I UNFORESEEN/UNANTICIPATED PROBLEMS AND OPPORTUNITIES (9J-5.0053 (6)(a)(5)) I. PROBLEMS A. FORT LAUDERDALE/HOLLYWOOD INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT EXPANSION The proposed runway extension for the south runway of the Ft. Lauderdale Hollywood International Airport will have significant social and economic impacts to the City of Dania. The acquisition program includes 97 acres that was slated for employment-based I land uses to supply a significant tax base for the City of Dania. This property was acquired by Broward County in 1995 and was removed from the tax rolls; therefore, it will no longer generate tax i revenues for the City. Further, the City made significant improvements to the water, sewer and roads in this area and that investment will also be lost to the City of Dania. jl The runway extension will also have impacts to the Melaleuca Isles neighborhood with the increased frequency of airport take-offs and landings resulting in increased noise in that neighborhood. There is great concern that the runway extension will have a diminution in the value of the properties in that area which would further affect the tax base of the City. In addition to the runway extension acquisition, Broward County has also acquired the Trails End Mobile Home Park, which was - slated for future commercial and industrial use on the City's land use plan. This is another area of tax base loss which comprises a total of approximately 15 acres of land. B. NORTHWEST 10TH STREET The extension of NW 10th Street into Port Everglades is problematic as to whether it is a positive step for either Dania, its related Seaport and International Airport. The Seaport has opposed it in the past due to cargo security considerations, and the Airport has expressed concerns over mixing heavy industrial traffic with its terminal traffic. i r I For Dania, our northern residential communities could be negatively impacted as well as our US 1 corridor being overloaded by cut through-south bound industrial traffic by passing the 1-595 interstate corridor connector. II. OPPORTUNITIES A. ANNEXATION AREA The City of Dania annexed a large, approximately two square-mile area generally west of Ravenswood Road, since the adoption of the comprehensive plan. Approximately 4,000 people reside in this area, and it also includes a variety of industrial and commercial based activities. This is a large area of expansion to the community and will be addressed in the updated comprehensive plan. 1 B. BASS PRO Recently the Bass Pro Corporation has selected Dania for the development of a significant retail and exposition based facility, highlighting the equipment and sales provided by the company. This facility will have significant socio-economic impacts to the community and will provide numerous employment opportunities, as well as a significant tax base for the community. This development is consistent with the comprehensive plan; however, it represents a significant opportunity as Dania continues to grow and develop. I I i I 2 i COMPREHENSIVE PLAN IMPACTS i I , f I i I I I it CONSISTENCY OF DANIA COMPREHENSIVE PLAN WITH STATE & � REGIONAL PLANS Rule 9J-5.0053(6)(a)(6), F.A.C. requires the FAR examine consistency with State and Regional Plans. This section examines consistency of the Dania Comprehensive Plan with changes to the State Comprehensive Plan, South Florida Planning Council Regional Policy Plan, Rule 9J-5, F.A.C. and Chapter 163, F.S. Chapter 163.3191 (1), F.S. states generally that the Evaluation and Appraisal Report process shall be the principal method for updating local comprehensive plans to reflect changes in state policy on planning and growth management. Amendments to the Comprehensive Plan are identified below in response to changes to the State Comprehensive Plan, Rule 9J-5 F.A.C., and Chapter 163 F.S. adopted after 1989. I. Changes to State Comprehensive Plan since 1985 In 1989 the Florida Department of Community Affairs (DCA) found the Dania I Comprehensive Plan in compliance with all applicable requirements. This compliance determination indicated the City Plan was consistent with the State Comprehensive Plan (Ch. 187, F.S.). however, the State Comprehensive Plan has been amended since the adoption of the 1989 Comprehensive Plan. All relevant changes to the State Plan (insofar as they relate to the Dania Plan) between 1985 and 1993 are addressed below: Hazardous and Non Hazardous Materials and Waste (Ch 187,201 _(13)(b)F.S.) has added new policies: 1. By 1994, reduce all volume of solid waste requiring disposal by 30 percent. 2. By 1994, provide all counties a countywide solid waste collection system to discourage littering and illegal dumping of solid waste. 3. Initiate programs to develop or expand recyclable material markets, especially those involving plastics, metals, paper and glass. The reduction in volume of solid waste, provision for county-wide solid waste collection system, and recycling are addressed in Objectives #1 and 2 of the Solid Waste Sub-Element (Infrastructure Element). Please note: Broward County has reduced its waste stream by 30 percent to the change in state law. 0 In addition, the Dania Comprehensive Plan is compatible with and furthers the w Hazardous and Nonhazardous Materials and Waste goals and policies of the State Comprehensive Plan. Therefore no changes are required in the Dania Plan as a result of the amendment to Ch 187.201(130(b). Downtown Revitalization (Ch. 187.20107) F.S.) has been added as a goal of the State Plan: (a) Florida shall encourage the centralization of commercial, governmental, residential, and cultural activities within downtown areas. r (b) Policies - 1. Provide Incentives to encourage private sector investment in the preservation and enhancement of downtown areas. II. Changes to the Strategic Regional Policy Plan (SRPP) In 1989 the compliance determination issued by DCA regarding the Dania Comprehensive Plan indicates that the City Plan was consistent with the "Regional Policy Plan for South Florida". In 1991, the South Florida Regional Planning Council adopted the :"Regional Plan for South Florida" (RPSF). All amendments to the Comprehensive Plan since its adoption have been found to be generally consistent with the 1991 RPSF. In August 1995, the South Florida Regional Planning Council adopted a "Strategic Regional Policy Plan for South Florida" (SRPP). This newly adopted plan replaced the :"Regional Plan for South Florida" (RPSF). The most substantial policy changes between the 1991 RPSF and the new 1995 SRPP relate to natural resources, education and emergency management. j (1) "Natural Resources of Regional Significance": The Dania Salt Marsh is a "Natural Resource of Regional Significance". The Comprehensive Plan contains goals, objectives and policies to maintain, conserve and preserve this area (Conservation Element: Objective IV and V). I i I j _ I ' 2 1 (2) Education: The City of Dania has a limited role in furthering the education i goals of the SRPP. Education is primarily the responsibility of Broward I County School Board and various colleges and universities throughout the region. The School Board is currently developing a School Facilities Element which is proposed to become a part of the Broward County Comprehensive Plan. The City of Dania will continue to utilize existing coordination mechanisms i to assist in the implementation of this element. In addition, the City's new Intergovernmental Coordination Element will address school issues. (3) Emergency preparedness and hurricane evacuation: Broward County is designated by state law as the agency responsible for emergency management. The City of Dania actively coordinates emergency preparedness activities with Broward County (Coastal Element: Objective V). Each applicable goal of the "Strategic Regional Policy Plan for South Florida" is evaluated in the following table for consistency with the City's Comprehensive Plan, specifically, the applicable objectives in the plan. The table indicates the Dania Comprehensive Plan is compatible with and furthers the goals and policies of the regional policy plan. Therefore, no changes are required in the Dania Comprehensive Plan as a result of adoption of the I "Strategic Regional Policy Plan for South Florida". i I _1 ,J 3 I 4 III. Changes to Rule 9J-5, F.A.C. "1 In 1989, the Dania Comprehensive Plan was consistent with Rule 9J-5, F.A.C. Subsequent to adoption of the 1989 Dania Plan, Rule 98J-5, F.A.C. was amended. The most significant Rule changes include concurrency management, intergovernmental coordination, definition changes, and the requirement to evaluate the Future Land Use Element to ensure that it discourages the proliferation of urban sprawl. Each relevant change to the Rule is reviewed in the following table for consistency with the City's Comprehensive Plan. Proposed Plan amendments resulting from changes in Rule 9J 5, F.A.C. are identified in the Plan Amendments Section of the EAR. VI. Changes to Chapter 163, Part 11, F.S. In 1989 the City of Dania's Comprehensive Plan was consistent with Chapter 163, Part II, F.S. Subsequent to adoption of the 1989 Dania Plan, Ch. 163, Part II, F.S. was amended. All relevant changes to Chapter 163, Part II are assessed in the following table for consistency with the Dania Comprehensive Plan. Proposed Plan amendments resulting from changes in Chapter 163, Part II are identified in the Plan Amendments Section of the EAR. I I I i ..a _1 4 I _ Strategic Regional Goals Compohen*e Plan Objective(s) Does Plan Further Regional Goals? Goal 2.1 Achieve long-term efficient and sustainable Future Land Use: 11, VI, VII Yes development patterns by guiding new development and Coastal: IV, VIII, XII redevelopment within the region to areas which are most Capital Improvements. IV intrinsically suited for development... Goal 2.2 Increase the public and private investment Housing: 11, III, IV, VI, VIII Yes which is directed to urban areas that are in need of rehabilitation... Future Land Use: IV Goal 2.3 Enhance the economic competitiveness of the Capital Improvements: II Yes region and ensure that adequacy of its public facilities... Goal 3.1 Eliminate the inappropriate uses of land by Future Land Use: II, VI IX Yes improving the land use designations and utilize land Conservation IV, V acquisition where necessary.... Goal 3.2 Develop a more efficient and sustainable Conservation: II Yes allocation of the water resources of the region Goal 3.3 Achieve improved air quality throughout the Conservation: I Yes region through a reduction of transportation related impacts and the increased use of natural plantings. i Goal 3.4 Improve the protection of upland habitat areas Conservation: IV, V Yes and maximize the interrelationships between the wetland and upland components of the natural system. Goal 3.5 Develop a plan for public access that Conservation: IV, V Yes delineates the Natural Resources of Regional Significance and high quality natural areas compatible with human recreation... Goal 3.6 Set aside for the acquisition, protection, Conservation: IV, V Yes restoration and maintenance of the Natural Resources of Regional Significance and suitable adjacent natural areas. _ l Strategic Regional Goals Comprehensko Plan Objectrve(s) Does Plan Further Regional Goals9 Goal 3.7 Educate South Floridians to achieve an Conservation: V Yes increased awareness of the natural system and of its significance with respect to the overall regional system. Goal 3.8 Enhance and preserve natural system values Conservation: IV, V Yes of South Florida's shorelines, estuaries, benthic communities, fisheries, and associated habitats... Goal 3.9 Restore and protect the ecological values and Conservation: IV, V Yes functions of the Everglades System Goal4.1 Achieve a competitive and diversified regional Intergovernmental Coordination: I Yes economy, including lower unemployment rate and higher Capital Improvements: II per capita income than the state and national average Future Land Use: I (including Policy 1.3 ) for Dade, Broward and Monroe Counties.... Goal 4.2 Achieve a coordinated regional strategy to Intergovernmental Coordination: I Yes address opportunities and threats and promote the Capital Improvements: II region's assets for economic development activities. Future Land Use: I (including Policy 1.3) Goal 5.1 To achieve mutually supportive transportation Traffic Circulation: I, II, III, Yes planning and land use planning that promotes both mobility and accessibility... Goal 5.2 To enhance the regional transportation Traffic Circulation: I, II, III, Yes system's role in system-wide preparedness for Coastal : V emergency situations Goal 5.3 To achieve a coordinated transportation Traffic Circulation: I (Policy 1.1), III Yes system planning process across jurisdictions and across issue-areas so that barriers are minimized and consistency across the region is achieved. tow A I comprehensive Plan Objective(s) 7Go St/ategic Regional Goals j Goal 6.1 Ensure the availability of adequate, affordable Housing : IV housing for very low, low and moderate income ""The plan does not address very low income households within a reasonable commute distance of job housing. However, the City currently provides centers housing for very low income households, and Housing Objective IV will be revised accordingly to address very low income housing. Goal 6.2 Increase or improve the existing supply of Housing: I (Policy 1.4), III, IV, VI adequate affordable housing through the stabilization and revitalization of existing neighborhoods. Goal6.3 Decrease the cost and increase the efficiency Housing : I (Policies 1.1, 1.2), IV of providing affordable housing in the region Goal 7.1 Direct future development away from the areas Coastal: IV, VIII Yes most vulnerable to storm surges. Future Land Use: VII Goal 7.2 No increase risk to hospital patients and Coastal: IV, VIII Yes special needs population due to an emergency Future land Use: VII Goal7.3 Encourage all levels of government and the Coastal: IV, VIII Yes private sector to work together to ensure adequate and Future Land Use: VII timely shelter within the region for those residing in the i hurricane evacuation areas Goal7.4 Achieve consistency between goals and Coastal: IV, VIII Yes objectives of agency plans and emergency plans Future Land Use: VII Goal 7.5 Minimize future risk to lives and property partly Coastal: IX Yes through the timely completion of post-disaster redevelopment plans Goal 7.6 Achieve flexible and comprehensive Coastal: V, VIII Yes emergency planning for a variety of emergencies i i 3 Revised Rule Revised Statute Descrip0on_of Chance (based on Comprehensive Plan Oble_coves & Policies Does Plan saBsN Rule 9J-5 F.A C.) Rule 9J-5 and Ch. 163? 9J-5.003 163.3164 1 B new/revised definitions in Rule Pursuant to 9J-5.003, the Comprehensive Plan adopted In Yes 9J-5 and 6 new definitions in Ch. 1989 complies with definitions adopted at that time. All future 163 F.S. amendments to the Comprehensive Plan (subsequent to EAR amendments)will use revised definitions as expressed In the Statute and Rule. None 163.3167(11) Communities are encouraged, but (Vision Statement Optional) Yes (N/A) not required, to develop a vision of the community None 163,3174 (4)(a) Revised Public hearing requirements Public hearings/Public participation process addressed in Yes "Monitoring/Evaluation" The comprehensive plan shall Marina Siting Plan is not included In Broward County Yes (not 9J-5.005(1)(c)4 Include a Countywide marina siting Comprehensive Plan. applicable) plan 9J-5.005 (1)(c)7 The comprehensive plan shall To be addressed with ICE. See 9J-5.015 include an Intergovernmental below coordination process 9J-5.005 (2)(e) Population estimates and projections In 1989 the Dania Comprehensive Plan was based on Yes (However, shall be either provided by the Broward County population projections, which were deemed City intends to University of Florida, the Executive acceptable by DCA. update Office of the Governor, or the local projections) government 9J-5.005(6) Goals, objectives and policies shall The 1989 Plan provides goals, policies, and objectives Yes establish meaningful and predictable consistent with this requirement. standards for the use and development of land 1 Revised Rule tLevlsed Statute Descdotlon of Chanae (based on Comorehensive Plan Objectives 6 Policies goes Plan satisfy Rute 9J•5 F.A.C.1 Rule gJ-5 and Ch. 163 9 9J-5.005 (7) The comprehensive plan shall Monitoring and evaluation procedures are included in Yes contain a section identifying five-year "Monitoring and Implementation' and "Capital Improvements" monitoring, updating and evaluation Elements procedures 9J•5.005 (9) 163.3161 (9) Local governments may include Recognition of private property rights and vested tights is Yes provisions recognizing statutory and optional common law vested rights 9J•5.005(10) Duplication of Regulations The Comprehensive Plan does not duplicate state or federal Yes regulations. i 2 Revised Rule Revised Statute Description of Change (based on Comprehensive Plan Obiectives & Policies goes Plan satisfy Rule 9J-5 F.A.C.1 Rule 9J-5 and Ch. 9J•5.0055 163.3180 Concurrency Management System. City of Dania has adopted a concurrency management system Yes implementing LOS standard pursuant to "Capital Improvements" Element. 9J-5.0055 (6) 163.3180(5)(b) Transportation Concurrency The City has not adopted an TCEA/Urban Infill Amendment Yes (TCEA will be Exception Areas (TCEA) (Optional) Included In EAR amendments) 9J.5.006(1)(b)l Map existing potable water wells Potable water wells In the City of Dania have been mapped. Yes 9J•5.006 (1)(03 Map existing dredge spoil sites This requirement is addressed in Port Everglades Master Plan see 9J- which Is Incorporated by reference in the Coastal Element, 5.012(5)(e) 9J-5.005 (2)(0 163.3178 (6) Estimate need for additional dredge This requirement is addressed in Port Everglades Master Plan see 9J- spoil sites which Is incorporated by reference in the Coastal Element. 5.012(5)(e) 9J-5.006 (2)(g) Estimate development and There are No hazard mitigation reports relating to sites in Yes (N/A) redevelopment based on hazard Dania. mitigation reports 9J.5.006 (3)(b)5 Coordinate coastal planning area See :Future Land Use Element (See Objective VII) Yes population densities with local hurricane evacuation plan 9J.5.006 (3)(b)6 The element shall contain one or The Future Land Use Element does not address interagency Yes (The City will more objectives which coordinate hazard mitigation because interagency hazard mitigation address IHMR in future land uses by encouraging the reports (IHMR) are not yet available ICE if reports elimination or reduction of uses that available) are Inconsistent with any interagency hazard mitigation report. 3 I Revised Rule Revised Statute Description of Channe (based on Comprehenslve Plan Oblectives 8 Policies goes Plan satisN Rule 9J•5 F.A.C.1 Rule 9J-5 and Ch. 1637 9J-5.006(3)(b)l1 163.3178 (6) Ensure availability of dredge spoil This requirement is addressed in Port Everglades Master Plan see 9J-5.012 disposal sites which is Incorporated by reference in the Coastal Element. (5)(e) 9J-5.006 (3)(c)3 Policy requirement to ensure public See"Capital Improvements" (Objective III) and Yes facilities are available concurrent 'Intergovernmental Coordination"(Objective III) Elements, and with impacts "Future Land Use"(Objective VIII) 9J-5.006 (3)(c)6 Policy requirement to designate There are no proposed future wells In the city and existing No (However, a appropriate uses within wellfield water wells have been mapped ( A policy designating policy relating to protection area (WPA) appropriate uses within a WPA will be added to the Plan) WPA will be added to the Plan) 9J-5.006 (3)(c)9 163.3178 (6) Policy requirement to designate This requirement is addressed in Port Everglades Master Plan see 9J-5.012 dredge spoil disposal sites which is Incorporated by reference in the Coastal Element. (5)(e) 9J-5.006 (4)(a)11 Map transportation concurrency Transportation concurrency management areas are not show Yes (N/A) management areas on the Future Land Use Map(Optional item) 9J-5.006 (4)(b)l Map potable water well protection Existing wells (and Wellfield Protection Areas) have been Yes areas mapped and there are no proposed wells in the City. 9J-5.006 (4)(b)6 Map coastal high hazard areas The Coastal High Hazard Area is not show on the Future Land No, amend Future Use Map Land Use Map Series 9J-5.006 (4)(c) I 163.3177(10)(k)11(6) Mixed land use categories The plan provides Mixed Use Categories (Optional) Yes 9J-5.006 (5) 163.3177(10)(k)11(6) Provisions of discoursing Urban Addressed in"Future Land Use" (Objective VIII) Element Yes sprawl 4 I I Revised Rule Revised Statute Description of Change (based on Comprehensive Plan Objectives & Policies goes Plan satisfy Rule 9J-5 F.A.C.) Rule 9J-5 and Ch. 1637 9J-5.007(3)(c)l The local governments shall adopt LOS standard for Dania and FOOT Roads addressed in : Yes the level of service standard 'Traffic Circulation"(Objectives II and III) Element established by the Department of Transportation for the Florida Intrastate Highway System. The local governments shall adopt adequate level of service standards for all other facilities ... 9J-5.010 The purpose of this (Housing) See "Housing" Element Yes"" element Is to ... develop appropriate plans and policies to meet Identified *"'The plan does not address very low income housing. or projected deficits In the supply of However, the City currently provides housing for very low housing for moderate income, low Income households, and Housing Objectives will be revised Income, and very low Income accordingly to address very low income housing. households, group homes, foster care facilities, and households with special housing needs... 9J-5.010(1)(a) 163.3177(6)(02 Housing Element Data Requirement DCA has not yet published a Housing Needs Assessment for Yes, See 9J. ... the City of Dania.— 5.010 (2) ( f) 1) (a)An Inventory ... including the affordable housing needs assessment, when available ... 9J-5.010(1)(c) 163.3177(6)(02 Affordable housing needs DCA has not yet published a Housing Needs Assessment for Yes, See 9J- assessment the City of Dania. 5.010(2) ( f) 1 9J-5.010(2)(b) 163.3177(6)(f)2 Housing needs assessment for DCA has not yet published a Housing Needs Assessment for Yes, See 9J- current residents and affordable the City of Dania. 5.010(2) ( f) 1 housing 5 i i woes Plan satisN �2evlsed Rule Revised Statute Description of Change(based on Comorehenslve Plan Objectives 8 Policies Rule 9 I end Ch. Mule 9J•5 F.A.C.1 1637 9J•5.010(2)(01 (Analysis of)the provision of housing The Dania Plan contains an analysis indicating the City is Yes with supporting Infrastructure for all providing significantly greater than its 'fair share' of affordable current and anticipated future housing residents ...emphasis on the creation or preservation of affordable housing... 9J-5.010(3)(b)1 163.3177(6)(0 1 g The element shall contain one or See Housing Element, Objectives IV, VI Yes more specific objectives ....which provide for: The creation and/or preservation of affordable housing.... gJ-5.010 (3)(b)3 163.3177(6)(0 1 g The element shall contain one or See Housing Element(Objectives II, IV, V) Yes (See 9J- more specific objectives ... which 5.010 addressed provide ..... adequate sites and previously ) distribution of very-low-income, low- Income and moderate income housing, and adequate sites for mobile and manufactured homes 9J-5.010 (3)(02 The element shall contain one of See Housing Element(Objective 1) Yes more policies for each objective which address.... actions to streamline the permitting process and minimize costs and delays for affordable housing 9J•5.010 (3)(c)5 Policy for criteria guiding location of See Housing Element(Objectives 1, 11, IV, V) Yes housing types 9J•5.010 (3)(c)6 Policy for criteria for establishing See Housing Element(Objective V) Yes group home location 9J-5.010 (3)(c)8 163.3177(6)(0 1 9 Policy to utilize job training This policy is optional and has not been utilized. Yes (N/A) I 6 Revised Rule Revised Statute pescription of Chance (based or, Comprehensive Plan Oblectives & Policies goes Plan satisN ' Rule 9J-5 F.A.C.1 Rule 9J-5 and Ch. 1637 9J-5.0 (3)(010 High value housing communities The City of Dania's comprehensive plan accommodates Its 'fair Yes (N/A) may establish inledocal agreements share'of affordable housing. to satisfy affordable housing needs -5.010 (3)(c)l1 The element shall contain one or See Housing Element(Objectives 1, II, IV, V. IX ) Yes more policies ...... Designating sufficient sites at sufficient densities 1 to accommodate the need for affordable housing over the planning time frame. 9J-5.011 (1)(04 An analysis of soil surveys for areas Addressed in the Sanitary Sewer Sub-Element(Existing Yes served by septic tanks and an Conditions) of the Infrastructure Element explanation of suitability of those soils for such facilities.... 9J-5.011 (1)(g) Topographic map of major drainage See Comprehensive Plan Map Series Yes features including recharge areas 9J-5.011(1)(h) Identification and assessment of See "Drainage and Natural Groundwater Recharge"Sub- Yes recharge area Element In the Infrastructure Element 9J-5.011(2)(a) Goal requirements for each resource The Dania Plan Includes separate goals for sanitary sewers, Yes or facility solid waste, drainage, potable water, and natural groundwater aquifer recharge 9J-5.011(2)(b) Objective requirements for each The Dania Plan includes separate objectives for sanitary Yes resource or facility sewers, solid waste, drainage, potable water, and natural groundwater aquifer recharge 9J-5.011(2)(b)5 Objective requirements for recharge See "Drainage and Natural Groundwater Recharge" Sub- Yes protection Element in the Infrastructure Element 9J-5.011(2)(c) Policy requirements for each The Comprehensive Plan includes separate policies for Yes resources or facility sanitary sewers, solid waste, drainage, potable water, and natural groundwater aquifer recharge 7 i goes Plan satisfy �evlsed F��Rule Revlse_d_Statute Descdotion of Change (based on Comprehensive Plan Objectives 8 Policies Rule 9J•5 and Ch, Rule 9J-5 F.A.C� 63 Policy requirement to establish LOS Levels of service have been established for each public facility: Yes 9J-5.011(2)(c)2 standards for each public facility Sanitary Sewer, Solid Waste, Drainage, Potable Water, Natural Groundwater Aquifer Recharge 9J.5.011 (2)(c)5(a) The element shall contain one or Addressed in Conservation Element(Objective#VI, Policies Yes more policies which address.... 6.1. 6.2) establishing water quality standards for storm water discharge and new and existing storm water management systems. 9J-5.012(2)(a) Inventory of existing land uses In Addressed in Coastal and Future Land Use Elements Yes coastal planning area 9J.5.012(2)(b) Inventory and analysis of effect of Addressed in Coastal and Future Land Use Elements Yes land use in coastal planning area 9J-5.012(2)(c) Inventory and analysis of effect of Addressed in Coastal and Future Land Use Elements Yes impacts of development In coastal planning area 9J•5012(2)(g) Analysis of public access facilities to Marina Siting Plan is not included in Broward County Yes (NIA) be coordinated with countywide Comprehensive Plan marina siting plan 9J•5.012(2)(h) Inventory of existing Infrastructure In Addressed in Coastal and Future Land Use Elements Yes coastal planning area and capacity analysis 9J-5.012(3)(c)5 Policy to address post disaster See Coastal Element (Objective IX) Yes redevelopment during EAR process 8 i DoesDoes Plan satisfy FrW-5.012(3)(C)B Revised Statute Description of Change (based on Comprehensive Plan Obleclives 8 Policies (mule 9J-5 and Ch. Mule 9J�5 F A C_) 33 163.3178 (2)(h) Policy to relocate, mitigate or See Coastal Element(Objective XII) Yes replace Infrastructure In the Coastal High Hazard Area when Stale Funding is needed. 9J-5.012(3)(c)9 Policy criteria for shoreline Marina Siting Plan is not included in Steward County Yes (NIA) development consistent with Comprehensive Plan countywide marina siting plan 9J•5.012 (3)(c)12 163.3178 (5) The element shall contain one or Polices to resolve Inconsistencies between the local du (Amend plan d the deep water port du more policies ...(that) Include a government comprehensive plan an ring ICE to Include conflict procedure to resolve inconsistencies master plan not included in the Plan. resolution policy ) between the local government comprehensive plan and the deep water port master plan through the dispute resolution ..... 9J-5.012(4) 163.3178 (6) Requirement to include countywide Marina Siting Plan is not included in Broward County Yes (NIA) marina siting plan Comprehensive Plan Requirement to prepare a Poll The Port Everglades Master Plan was adopted in 1988. A new See 9J- 9J-5.012(5) ReqMasuiruir Plan Plan is being prepared for adoption in 1996. Objective VI 5.012(5)(e) below (Coastal Element) will incorporate the 1996 Port Plan by reference once the 1996 Plan is adopted. 9J-5.012 (5)(e) If a port master plan is prepared The Port Everglades Master Plan was adopted in 1988. A new Yes by a deep water port, then the Plan is being prepared for adoption in 1996. Objective VI appropriate local government shall (Coastal Element) will incorporate the 1996 Port Plan by include the port master plans goals, reference once the 1996 Plan is adopted. objectives and policies and port maintenance and expansion sections in the coastal element of its comprehensive plan.... an he 9J•5.0013(1)(a)1 Requirement to identify and analyze of DanlaThis lysis is not will amend lheluded In p an as required red bys19J•5!002 (8)in ily Yes ground water quality 1997 to address this criteria. 9 OI O a a ev sed uleTRevised�Staluteescriolion of Chanoe(based on Comprehensive Plan Obiectives 8 Poicies Qoes Ialisfy Rule 9J•5 F.A.C.1 163? Polic to relocate, mitigate or See Coastal Element(Objective XII) Yes 9J-5.012(3)(c)8178 (2)(h) Y replace infrastructure in the Coastal High Hazard Area when State Funding is needed. 9J•5.012(3)(c)9 Policy criteria for shoreline Marina Siting Plan is not included in Broward County Yes (N/A) development consistent with Comprehensive Plan countywide marina siting plan 9J-5.012 (3)(c)12 163.3178 (5) The element shall contain one or Polices to resolve Inconsistencies between the local No (Amend plan more policies ...(that) Include a government comprehensive plan and the deep water port during ICE to procedure to resolve Inconsistencies master plan not Included in the Plan. include convict between the local government resolution policy ) comprehensive plan and the deep water port master plan through the dispute resolution ..... 9J-5.012(4) 163.3178 (6) Requirement to include countywide Marina Siting Plan is not included in Broward County Yes (N/A) marina siting plan Comprehensive Plan 9J-5.012(5) Requirement to prepare a Port The Port Everglades Master Plan was adopted In 1988. A new See 9J- Master Plan Plan Is being prepared for adoption in 1996, Objective VI 5.012(5)(e) below (Coastal Element) will incorporate the 1996 Port Plan by reference once the 1996 Plan is adopted. 9J-5.012 (5)(e) ... If a port master plan Is prepared The Port Everglades Master Plan was adopted in 1988. A new Yes by a deep water port, then the Plan Is being prepared for adoption In 1996. Objective VI appropriate local government shall (Coastal Element) will incorporate the 1996 Port Plan by include the port master plans goals, reference once the 1996 Plan is adopted. objectives and policies and port maintenance and expansion sections In the coastal element of its comprehensive plan.... 9J•5.0013(1)(a)1 Requirement to Identify and analyze This analysisnot Included In Comprehensive plan. The City or No ground water quality Dania will amend the plan as required by 9J-5.002 (8)in 1997 to address this criteria, 9 i - Revised Rule Revised Stalute pescription of Change (based on Comgrehensivo Plan Objectives 8 Policies RULe Roes Pian satisfy Ie 9J-5 F.A.C.1 163 RU 9J•5 and C_h. 63? 9J•5.0013(1)(a)5 Requirement to Identify and analyze This analysisnol included in Comprehensive Plan. The City of No important fish and shell fish Dania will amend the plan as required by 9J-5.002 (8) in 1997 communities to address this criteria. 9J.5.0013(1)(b) Requirement to Identify and analyze This analysisnot included in Comprehensive Plan. The City of No hazardous waste pollutant for each Dania will amend the plan as required by 9J-5.002 (8) in 1997 resource to address this criteria. 9J-5.013 (2)(b)2 The element shall contain one or Addressed In Conservation Element (Objective # VI, Policies Yes more specific objectives to conserve 6.1, 6.2) and protect the quality/quantity, of waters that flow into estuarine waters or oceanic waters 9J-5.0013(2)(c)1 Policy to protect water quality and See Conservation Element Objective II Yes quantity from adverse land uses 9J-5.013 (2)(c)10 The element shall contain one or See Conservation Element Objective V (Policy 5.5) Yes more polices for.. See Conservation Element Objective II (Policy 2.2), (10) Management of hazardous wastes to protect natural resources. 9J-5.013 (3)(a) 8 (b) Policies addressing wetlands: The Dania Salt Marsh is the major wetland feature within the Yes (a)Wetlands shall be conserved..... City of Dania. The Comprehensive Plan Includes the fallowing (b) Future land uses which are policies related to its protection and conservation: Incompatible with the protection of Future Land Use: Objective II (Policy 2,1), Objective VI wetlands shall be directed away (Policies 6.1, 6.2, 6.3) from wetlands.... Conservation: Objective IV (Policy 4.1) Objective V (Policies 5.1, 5.4) 9J-5.014(1) Identify fresh water beaches There are no fresh water beaches Yes (NA) 9J•5.014 3(b)1 Objective to ensure public access to There are no fresh water beaches Yes (N/A) fresh water beaches and shores J 10 4 Revised Rule Revised Statute pescrialion of Chancre (based on Comprehensive Plan Obiectives & Policies goes Plan salisfv Rule n lion of Change Rule 9J•5 and Ch. 163 9J-5.015 163.3177 (6)(h) Intergovernmental Coordination Requirement for the Intergovernmental Coordination Element Yes( Future ICE Element (ICE)has been substantially rewritten. Pursuant to state law, amendment) the City of Dania will adopt a new ICE for submission to DCA in 1997. See Capital Improvements Objective I, II, III Yes 9J-5.016 Requirement to include an adequate, concurrency management 9J-5.016 (3)(c)6 The element shall contain one or See Capital Improvements Objective I, II, III, Yes more polices providing for the availability of public facilities and services needed to support development concurrent with the Impacts of such development subsequent to the adoption of the local plan..... 9J•5.016 (4)(b) Requirement to include provisions See Capital Improvements Objectives ll, III, Yes that public facilities meet concurrency 9J-5.019 163.3177 (6)(j) .A local government ... within the The 1989 Dania Plan contains a Traffic Circulation Element. Yes urbanized area of a Metropolitan The City of Dania will prepare a "Transportation Element' Planning Organization (MPO)... shall (pursuant to 9J-5.019) as required by 9J-5.002 (8)in 1997. prepare and adopt a transportation element...[which)shall replace the requires plan elements of:traffic circulation 11 Revised Rule Revised Statute Description of Change (based on Comprehensive Plan Objectives 8 Policies goes Plan satisfy Rule 9J-5 F.A.C.1Rule 9J-5 and Ch 183? 9J.5.021(1) Each local government See"Consistency of Dania Comprehensive Plan with Stale and Yes comprehensive plan shall be Regional Plans"which demonstrates that 1989 Dania Plan is consistent with the appropriate compatible with and furthers the " Strategic Regional Policy comprehensive regional policy plan Plan for South Florida". 9J-5.021(4) ... the local government shall attach The 1989 Dania Plan contains a comparison with the State's Yes to Its comprehensive plan or plan Comprehensive Plan. amendment ... a listing entitled "Consistency of the Local Comprehensive Plan with the State Comprehensive Plan" I i 12 IDENTIFY NEEDED ACTIONS I I �I I I I i I I I l I I� I I l NEEDED ACTIONS (9J-5.0053(6)(a)(7)(a-f)) A. POPULATION PROJECTIONS The new population projections being utilized for the comprehensive plan are those developed by the Broward County Department of ' Strategic Planning and Growth Management. These estimates have been accepted by Florida DCA for utilization for local governments within Broward County. The five-year and ten-year population estimates for the City of Dania are as follows: year 2000 - 15,019, and year 2005 - 16,214. These population projections will be utilized in updating the comprehensive plan in the amendment process which will be adopted j by the Spring of 1997. They will also be utilized to update the data and analysis sections. Throughout the EAR a comparison has been identified for many of the tables within the land use; housing; and other elements of the Plan which compare the previous adopted comprehensive plan with the current ' conditions, and these comparisons identify areas that will need to be addressed during the plan amendment process. I I B. GOALS, OBJECTIVES AND POLICIES As noted throughout the EAR and particularly in the goals, objectives and policies analysis section there will be several goals, objectives and policies which will be analyzed during the plan amendment phase of the project. The City will identify revisions as needed to update its goals, objectives and policies consistent with the changing conditions within the community and those required by changes in the rules. I C. FUTURE CONDITIONS MET The EAR package includes updated future land use; future traffic circulation; recreation and open space; coastal zone and wetlands maps. These updates are based upon the additional available information that was developed during the EAR analysis. Any future plan amendments will be sensitive to the revised maps and the population projections for the community. �I I � The City will update its land use map, as appropriate, if the new projections warrant an adjustment of the land use distribution. i D. CAPITAL IMPROVEMENTS During the development of the ERA process a couple of improvements identified by the City in the current comprehensive plan were not implemented. These include the implementation of drainage improvements in the southeastern portion of the City with an anticipated cost of$160,000.00 plus the storage tank for potable water at a cost of between $200,000.00 and $400,000.00. These improvements were not developed because of budget constraints and the need to re-allocate money into other areas such as improvement of certain park and recreational facilities during this time span. However, a drainage study is scheduled to commence in 1996, and this would be a city-wide drainage study which would outline the needs to upgrade drainage throughout the community. Plan amendments will address these capital improvements as well as others that are required to meet the needs of the community as it continues to grow and develop. One area of particular interest will be the annexed area west of community and the capital improvement needs of that area as it is incorporated into the comprehensive plan. Some of the issues that will be occurring in the annexed area include the installation of water and sewer service; street improvements (in many cases full streets are not currently existing) and various public building needs to serve the area, such as a fire station. E. MONITORING/EVALUATION The City has found that evaluating the comprehensive plan every five years is adequate given the rate of growth occurring in the community. However, the Growth Management department will prepare periodic reports concerning the building permit activity in this City. The information contained in these reports will provide useful information for future evaluation and appraisal reports. I .I I The City has developed and implemented monitoring enhancements such as monthly building permit reporting which includes value of building permits, and these are utilized to help guide the development i of the City and balance of growth within the community. The monitoring and evaluation procedures that are currently in place, which ! include the concurrency review for all new developments according to Jthe Land Development Code, and the City's comprehensive plan and ' � 2 other review requirements of the community adequately address the general need for monitoring of the comprehensive plan within the City. F. OTHER STUDIES A couple of studies may be appropriate for the City to address in the coming years. This includes the drainage study which is currently scheduled to occur in 1996. As indicated in previous sections of this report, drainage improvements are needed in older portions of the City. The City will conduct a comprehensive drainage study to identify the improvements necessary to correct existing deficiencies. The i identified improvements will be evaluated and prioritized for inclusion in the Capital Improvements Element. The City may also assess the impact of the airport acquisition on the community's tax base and its socio-economic impacts to the population. The third area of study will be the development of the Redevelopment Plan consistent with Chapter 163 Florida Statutes to assist implementation of that component of the City's comprehensive plan. I i i I i J 3 I _1 PLAN AMENDMENTS I i I II i I , PLAN AMENDMENTS (W-5.0053(6)(a)(8)(a)) A. ANNEXED LAND I As noted previously, the City annexed approximately two square miles of land immediately west of the community. This area will be incorporated into the comprehensive plan amendment that will be adopted in the Spring of 1997. The plan amendment will require the separating of data and analysis currently existing within the Unincorporated Broward Plan into sub-components that would be consistent with the annexed area. It will be rather time-consuming to develop a great deal of this information. At this time the annexed land is intended to be incorporated into the City's comprehensive plan with i the same land use designations that currently exist on the Unincorporated area land use plan map. B. CERTIFICATION REQUIREMENTS The City will also be updating its comprehensive plan to incorporate the certification requirements of the Broward County Planning Council. Certain required revisions to the goals, objectives and policies of the City's plan are required by Broward County in order to fully certify the City's plan. The plan amendment that will be adopted in Spring of 1997 will incorporate all the certification requirements of the Broward County Planning Council, which is the agency charged with administering the Broward County Land Use Plan. C. GOALS, OBJECTIVES AND POLICIES As outlined throughout this report, and particularly in the section which analyzes the plan's objectives, the City will be updating and reevaluating the current goals, objectives and policies as it develops the plan amendment for adoption in the Spring of 1997. These amendments to the goals, objectives and policies will also incorporate any needed changes required by amendments to the State Plan, Regional Plan, 9J-5, and Chapter 163, Florida Statutes as noted in previous sections of this document. j Objective III of the Drainage will be revised in the Plan Update section to state 250' versus 100'. I , Objective II of the Capital Improvements Element will be modified in the Plan Update section to specify measurable targets by which the Objective can be measured, as required by Rule 9J-5.0053(6)(a)3. -�� D. UPDATE DATA/ -' The plan amendment will also update the data and analysis sections of the current comprehensive plan. This would include an update of the j population projections as well as the capacity of services within the community including water, sewer, parks and recreation, solid waste, I conservation and coastal resources. The five (5) and ten (10) year population projections that will be used in the plan are 15,019 (year 2000) and 16,214 (year 2005). These projects will be utilized to determine the level of service standards and infrastructure needs for the community. j E. URBAN INFILL I � Broward County recently enacted a Transportation Concurrency Exception Area (TCEA) which affected all of the City of Dania. The City of Dania will develop an urban infill TCEA amendment consistent with the Broward County amendment for incorporation into the City's plan. The essence of this amendment is to encourage infill development and enhance the mass transit system as a means of meeting the concurrency requirements within this area. F. ICE AND TRANSPORTATION UPDATE The City will also be developing the Intergovernmental Coordination Element and updating the Transportation Element which is required under State Statute. These elements are intended to be adopted by April 1997, as required by the EAR process. The City will work closely with all adjacent governments including the South Florida Regional Planning Council in the development of the ICE Element to ensure compatibility with all local governments. During the Plan Update, the City will analyze traffic circulation levels of service and system needs based upon accident frequency that may be available for the City of Dania. The Plan update will also address the j need for the new facilities or expansions as required by Rule 9J-5.007 (2)(a). The Plan update will also provide an analysis of projected AI levels of service and system needs based upon the Future Land Use Map and addressing the need for the facilities or expansions required _1 by Rule 9J-5.007(2)(b). JThe City recognizes that the new requirements for the transportation element focus on linking land use and transportation planning 2 A -• processes as well as placing a strong emphasis on transit facilities. Broward County is responsible for regional roads in the area as well as the provision of transit facilities. At this time, the County is considering the establishment of a regional transit authority along with Dade and Palm Beach Counties. During the plan update, the City will coordinate with Broward County in order to develop a local transportation element that is consistent with the County's efforts. Coordination mechanisms such as the MPO and TCC are currently in place and will be utilized during the plan update process. The City will also incorporate any Eastward Ho related land use plan amendments that are determined to be appropriate for the City. The City's land use element currently incorporates several provisions that promote mixed land uses. Plan amendments are anticipated to enhance these provisions and encourage developments that can support transit service. I ' G. COASTAL MANAGEMENT Revisions to Rule 9J-5 modified the definition of coastal high hazard area to include those areas located in the evacuation zone for a Category 1 Hurricane. There is no distinction between the category 1 and 2 hurricane evacuation zones within the City of Dania. In Dania, the newly defined Coastal High Hazard Area includes all of the land area located east of SE 5 Avenue / 14 Avenue. The coastal high hazard area, as identified in the current plan, is limited to the land located east of A1A. As a result of this change in definition, plan amendments will be required to add approximately 407 acres to the coastal high hazard area. Of the 173 acres of vacant land added to the coastal high hazard area, only 26 acres (15%) are developable. The remaining acreage has been purchased by the public for preservation or will be restricted for development based on Broward County Department of Natural Resource Protection regulations due to the existence of wetlands. Public investment in the newly defined coastal high hazard area is limited to roadways, bridges and utility lines. There are no public utility plants, public service buildings or hospitals located within the coastal high hazard area. The City has not met its objective to prepare a post disaster redevelopment plan by 1991. This objective will be reestablished during the plan amendment process. Broward County is embarking on a county-wide post disaster redevelopment plan and the City anticipates coordinating its post disaster redevelopment planning efforts with that of the County. Existing intergovernmental coordination mechanisms such as the League of Cities Technical Advisory I � A 1 Committee will be used to facilitate coordination of these planning efforts. Due to the limited public facilities in the coastal high hazard area, it is not anticipated that major policy changes will be required as a result of the post-disaster redevelopment planning efforts. However, following a complete analysis of the existing improvements in the area and any damage due to previous storms, the City will evaluate the need to additional policies to protect the coastal high hazard area. H. NEW DEFINITIONS Several new or revised definitions have been incorporated in Rule 9J- 5. The need for amendments to the plan related to the new definition of coastal high hazard area is discussed above. The term urban j sprawl is anticipated to have a significant impact on many communities. However, Dania is located in the eastern, developed portion of Broward County. The corporate limits for the city do not extend west of SR 7. In addition, all of the land area in the City is located within the Broward County Urban Infill Transportation Concurrency Exception Area. Therefore, the new definition for urban sprawl will not impact the City of Dania. I. HOUSING ELEMENT Amendments to Rule 9J-5 require that local governments address the housing needs of very low income households. Of the vacant land in the City approximately 207 acres is designated residential on the land use plan. Over 40% of this residential, vacant land in the City, approximately 207 acres is designated residential on the land use plan. Over 40% of this residential, vacant land is designated for densities of 10 dwelling units per acre or greater. Therefore, additional land area exists to accommodate residential units for very low income households. In addition, approximately one-half of the existing dwelling units are comprised of multi-family units and mobile homes. 1990 Census data also indicates that approximately 25% of the housing stock in the City of Dania is valued below $60,000 as compared to 13% countywide. Finally the median value of dwelling units in the City is $84,600 which is almost $7,000 less than the countywide median. _I Further analysis is required in order to determine if plan amendments are required to meet the housing needs of very low income i households. However, readily available data indicates that the City of Dania currently provides a substantial amount of affordable housing. M1 4 i J. TIME SCHEDULE (9J-5.0053(6)(a)(8)(b)) The following provides an outline of the time schedule for the development of the plan amendments for the City of Dania: Spring 1996 initiate work on plan amendments. . Fall 1996 - review by the Planning and Zoning Board and City Commission. Late 1996 transmittal by the City Commission. . Spring 1997 - adoption of the amendment by the City Commission of the City of Dania. i I . I I i ..i _J 5 I 4 } PUBLIC PARTICIPATION 1 l l I . � I j e i MONITORING / IMPLEMENTATION ELEMENT i I Citizen Participation I In order to encourage and provide for public participation within the comprehensive planning process, the City of Dania will ensure that the I` general public is informed and will be notified of aff public meetings regarding the Evaluation and Appraisal Report as well as amendments to r the Comprehensive Plan. This will include advertised notices of hearings before the local planning agency and the City Commission which shall be published in newspapers of general circulation at least seven (7) days prior to the date of the hearing. The notice shall specify the time and place of the hearing, the matter to be considered and where the materials to be considered can be reviewed. This process will also permit opportunities for interested parties to provide written and/or oral comments at the public hearings so said comments can be considered in the deliberations. i I I ,.I J > i I f I _.l J : ""1 I I I '� i ', ', j �) I i �j i �,� I .. _ � 1 , . '�:� _.