Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2022-05-10 Hybrid Regular Meeting City Commission Meeting MinutesMINUTES OF HYBRID REGULAR MEETING DANIA BEACH CITY COMMISSION TUESDAY, MAY 10, 2022 - 7:00 P.M. 1. Call to Order/Roll Call Mayor James called the meeting to order at 7:00 p.m. Present: Mayor: Tamara James Vice-Mayor: Marco A. Salvino, Sr. Commissioners: Joyce L. Davis Lori Lewellen Lauren Odman—via virtual attendance City Manager: Ana M. Garcia, ICMA-CM City Attorney: Eve Boutsis City Clerk: Thomas Schneider 2. Moment of Silence and Pledge of Allegiance Mayor James called for a moment of silence followed by the Pledge of Allegiance to the United States Flag. 3. Presentations and Special Event Approvals 3.1 Recognition of Hillel Masri, student in the afterschool program at PJ Meli Park, winner of the Earth Day Beach Clean-up Art Competition—Commissioner Davis Commissioner Davis presented a Certificate of Recognition to Mr. Masri for his winning art piece. She noted the art would be displayed in City Hall for a period and then given to the family to enjoy. 3.2 Dania Pointe quarterly updates by Dania Pointe General Manager Brad Freeman and Marketing Director Maynel Alvarez- Requejo Mr. Freeman and Ms. Alvarez-Requejo gave a PowerPoint presentation on activities, new restaurants and businesses, and events and entertainment at Dania Pointe, which is attached to and incorporated into these minutes. 3.3 Presentation of the Fiscal Year 2020-21 financial results by the Finance Department and report from the City's auditor Keefe McCullough Frank DiPaolo, Chief Financial Officer, gave a PowerPoint presentation on the FY20-21 Annual Comprehensive Financial Report which is attached to and incorporated into these minutes. Marc Grace, Keefe McCullough, provided highlights of the City's audit. 3.4 Parks & Recreation Department/Education Advisory Board recognition of "Teacher of the Year", "Employee of the Year", and "Parent of the Year", nominated by Collins Elementary, Dania Elementary, and Olsen Middle Schools Eric Brown, Director of Parks & Recreation, noted it starts with Parks, and thanked the Commission for their commitment. Members of the Education Advisory Board recognized and presented gift cards and plaques to the following individuals for their hard work, dedication, and resilience: Collins Elementary: Lori Sparks-Lee, Instructional Math Coach, Teacher of the Year; Joyce Hunter, Paraprofessional for Head Start, Employee of the Year; Sharon Bures, Parent of the Year Dania Elementary: Patricia Magliocoa, Autism Coach, Teacher of the Year; Janine Gassin, Office Manager, Employee of the Year; Shannon King, Parent of the Year Olsen Middle: Latisa Williams, Math Teacher, Teacher of the Year; Mircea A. Nemes, Micro Tech, Employee of the Year; Yaninna Aldana, Parent of the Year 3.5 Special Event request from The Trash Pirates for The Trash Pirates Beach Clean-Up to be held at the beach, 151 North Beach Road, on May 22, 2022 from 9:00 a.m. - 11:00 a.m. The applicant is requesting a fee waiver. (Parks&Recreation) Commissioner Lewellen motioned to approve the Special Event request for The Trash Pirates Beach Clean-Up, including a fee waiver; seconded by Vice-Mayor Salvino. The motion carried unanimously. 4. Proclamations 4.1 Mental Health Awareness Month- Mayor James Mayor James read the proclamation for Mental Health Awareness Month. Jennifer Luciani, Co-Chair, National Alliance on Mental Illness (NAMI) Broward Advocacy Group, spoke about the mission and services NAMI Broward offers Broward residents at no charge and noted their programs make a positive difference in mental health outcomes. 4.2 National Safe Boating Week-Mayor James Mayor James read the proclamation for National Safe Boating Week and presented it to Marc Brody, Division 3 Commander, USCGAUX; Paul Greenbaum, FC Dania Beach Flotilla Minutes of Hybrid Regular Meeting 2 Dania Beach City Commission Tuesday,May 10,2022—7:00 p.m. USCGAUX; Natalie Bunting, FVC Dania Beach Flotilla USCGAUX; Peter Paige, FSO-PA Dania Beach Flotilla USCGAUX; and BM1 Smiler and BM2 Burkey (for LDCR Ray Milne, USCG STA FTL). Commander Brody thanked the Commission and noted the increase in boating because of COVID and the safety needs of boaters the Coast Guard Auxiliary continues to fulfill. 5. Citizen Comments Jose Armand, 50 SE 3`d Avenue, congratulated Mayor James on her position at St. Thomas University, and spoke of the Latino Ensemble and its premiere of"Thrill Me to Death!" at My Mama's Records, Books, and Café. Luis Rimoli, 902 Natures Cove Road, thanked City Manager Garcia and the Public Services Department for the stop signs installed on SE 5th and SE 7th Avenues. Linda Wilson, Vice-President of Dania Beach Friends of the Library, questioned the rental term for the Let Love Guide Your Way sculpture and she addressed the Women's Club restoration, the children sculpture being returned to outside the library, and the hours of the Friend's of the Library activities. Joanna Granett, 450 SE 7th Street, #251, President of the Dania Beach Historical Society, spoke of the recent event at the Stranahan House and the status of the Historical Society. 6. Public Safety Reports Captain Daniel Marks, BSO Chief of Police, noted the License Plate Readers are being deployed throughout the City to help solve crime and he addressed additional positions needed for the Dania Beach District. He read the results of a survey taken on BSO initiatives. Captain Sergio Pellecer, BSO District Fire Chief, gave an update on departmental activities including work on the Comprehensive Emergency Plan, attendance at the seniors meeting this month, fire inspection and call volumes, Station 1 hardening, upcoming training to be given to City employees,the new rescue truck, and the SAFER Grant. 7. Consent Agenda Items removed from Consent Agenda: #7.10 7.1 Minutes: Approve Minutes of April 12, 2022 City Commission Hybrid Meeting 7.2 Travel Requests: None Minutes of Hybrid Regular Meeting 3 Dania Beach City Commission Tuesday,May 10,2022—7:00 p.m. g Week-Mayor James Mayor James read the proclamation for National Safe Boating Week and presented it to Marc Brody, Division 3 Commander, USCGAUX; Paul Greenbaum, Resolutions 7.3 RESOLUTION#2022-067 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF DANIA BEACH, FLORIDA, CALLING FOR THE GENERAL MUNICIPAL ELECTION TO BE HELD ON TUESDAY,NOVEMBER 8,2022,FOR THE PURPOSE OF ELECTING TWO CITY COMMISSIONERS TO SERVE FOUR YEAR TERMS; PROVIDING FOR CONFLICTS;FURTHER,PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. (City Clerk) 7.4 RESOLUTION#2022-068 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF DANIA BEACH, FLORIDA, RATIFYING A MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING WITH THE AMERICAN FEDERATION OF STATE, COUNTY AND MUNICIPAL EMPLOYEES ("AFSCME")UNION TO INCLUDE JUNETEENTH AS A PAID HOLIDAY; PROVIDING FOR CONFLICTS;FURTHER,PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. (Human Resources) 7.5 RESOLUTION#2022-069 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF DANIA BEACH, FLORIDA, AUTHORIZING THE CITY TO EXCEED THE ANNUAL VENDOR THRESHOLD TOTAL AMOUNT OF TWENTY-FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS ($25,000.00) FOR CDW-G; AUTHORIZING SUCH PURCHASES WITHIN THE INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY FUND APPROVED ANNUAL BUDGET APPROPRIATIONS; PROVIDING FOR CONFLICTS;FURTHER,PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. (Finance) 7.6 RESOLUTION#2022-070 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF DANIA BEACH, FLORIDA, APPROVING EXECUTION BY THE PROPER CITY OFFICIALS OF THE 2022 AMENDMENT TO AN INTERLOCAL AGREEMENT EXISTING BETWEEN BROWARD COUNTY,FLORIDA AND THE CITY OF DANIA BEACH, FLORIDA;A COPY OF WHICH AGREEMENT IS ATTACHED AND INCORPORATED BY REFERENCE AS EXHIBIT "A", WHICH AGREEMENT PROVIDES FOR THE DIVISION AND DISTRIBUTION OF THE PROCEEDS FROM THE BROWARD COUNTY ADDITIONAL THREE(3)CENT LOCAL OPTION GAS TAX ON MOTOR FUEL ORDINANCE TO THE PARTICIPATING MUNICIPALITIES; PROVIDING FOR CONFLICTS;FURTHER,PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. (Finance) 7.7 RESOLUTION#2022-071 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF DANIA BEACH, FLORIDA, APPROVING THE EXECUTION BY THE PROPER CITY OFFICIALS OF THE 2022 AMENDMENT TO AN INTERLOCAL AGREEMENT EXISTING BETWEEN BROWARD COUNTY,FLORIDA AND THE CITY OF DANIA BEACH, FLORIDA,A COPY OF WHICH AGREEMENT IS ATTACHED AND INCORPORATED BY REFERENCE AS EXHIBIT "A"; PROVIDING FOR DIVISION AND DISTRIBUTION OF THE PROCEEDS FROM THE BROWARD COUNTY ADDITIONAL FIVE (5) CENT LOCAL OPTION GAS TAX ON MOTOR FUEL FOR TRANSIT;PROVIDING FOR CONFLICTS;FURTHER,PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. (Finance) 7.8 RESOLUTION#2022-072 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF DANIA BEACH, FLORIDA, AUTHORIZING THE EXPENDITURE OF FUNDS FOR CLOUD INTERNET PHONE SERVICES PROVIDED BY RINGCENTRAL, INC. AND AUTHORIZING THE CITY TO EXCEED THE ANNUAL VENDOR THRESHOLD TOTAL AMOUNT OF TWENTY-FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS ($25,000.00) FOR EACH Minutes of Hybrid Regular Meeting 4 Dania Beach City Commission Tuesday,May 10,2022—7:00 p.m. YEAR THE AGREEMENT IS IN EFFECT; AUTHORIZING SUCH PURCHASES WITHIN THE INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY FUND APPROVED ANNUAL BUDGET APPROPRIATIONS; PROVIDING FOR CONFLICTS;FURTHER,PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. (Finance) 7.9 RESOLUTION#2022-073 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF DANIA BEACH, FLORIDA, DECLARING CERTAIN INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY EQUIPMENT TO BE OBSOLETE, SURPLUS AND OF NO FURTHER USE TO THE CITY OF DANIA BEACH AND DECLARING THE INTENT OF THE CITY TO DISPOSE OF THE SAME AT THE DIRECTION OF THE CITY MANAGER; PROVIDING FOR CONFLICTS; FURTHER,PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. (Finance) Commissioner Lewellen motioned to adopt the Consent Agenda,with the exception of Item 7.10; seconded by Vice-Mayor Salvino. The motion carried unanimously. 7.10 ORDINANCE#2022-020 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF DANIA BEACH, FLORIDA, AMENDING CHAPTER 28,ENTITLED"LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE", (1)PART 2,ENTITLED"SITE DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS,"ARTICLE 265, ENTITLED "OFF-STREET PARKING REQUIREMENTS" AT 265-92, ENTITLED "PAYMENT IN-LIEU OF PROVIDING OFF-STREET PARKING" IN ORDER TO MODIFY THE OFF-SITE PARKING PAYMENT IN LIEU AMOUNT; (2) AMENDING PART 5, ENTITLED "SITE DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS,"ARTICLE 505, ENTITLED "SIGNAGE REGULATIONS", AT SECTIONS 505-20, ENTITLED DEFINITIONS, SECTION 505-40, ENTITLED "DETAILED SIGN STANDARDS", SECTION 505-50, ENTITLED "PROHIBITED SIGNS" TO STRIKE SUPERGRAPHICS AND TO ADD MURALS; SECTION 505-90, ENTITLED"SIGNAGE REGULATIONS FOR THE MIXED-USE CRA FORM-BASED ZONING DISTRICTS (CC, SFED-MU, EDBB-MU, GTWY-MU,NBHD-MU)",AND SECTION 505-170,ENTITLED "NONCONFORMING SIGNS", TO REMOVE REFERENCE TO SUPERGRAPHICS AND TO INCLUDE MURALS; AND (3) PART 6, ENTITLED "DEVELOPMENT REVIEW PROCEDURES AND REQUIREMENTS," AT ARTICLE 635, ENTITLED "SITE PLANS", AT SECTION 635-50, ENTITLED "SITE PLAN DATA REQUIREMENTS", TO REQUIRE A SHADOW STUDY AS PART OF THE SITE PLAN REVIEW PROCESS; AND (4) PART 8, ENTITLED "TECHNICAL APPENDIX," ARTICLE 811, ENTITLED PUBLIC ART PROGRAM" AT SECTION 811-20, ENTITLED "DEFINITIONS", AND CREATING SECTION 811-140, ENTITLED "MURAL GUIDELINES", TO CREATE A DEFINITION FOR MURALS AND PROCEDURES FOR REVIEW OF MURALS; PROVIDING FOR CODIFICATION, PROVIDING FOR CONFLICTS; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; AND FURTHER, PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. (FIRST READING) (Community Development) City Attorney Boutsis read the title of Ordinance#2022-020. Mayor James noted there is a lot of language in this ordinance to digest. Corinne Lajoie, Assistant Director of Community Development, gave a presentation on the text amendment. Commissioner Lewellen motioned to adopt Ordinance #2022-020, on first reading; seconded by Vice-Mayor Salvino. The motion carried unanimously. 8. Bids and Requests for Proposals Minutes of Hybrid Regular Meeting 5 Dania Beach City Commission Tuesday,May 10,2022—7:00 p.m. 8.1 RESOLUTION#2022-074 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF DANIA BEACH, FLORIDA, AWARDING CITY INVITATION TO BID ("ITB") NO. 22-003, ENTITLED "I.T. PARKER COMMUNITY CENTER HVAC REPLACEMENT" TO ANGELS REMODELING & CONSTRUCTION LLC, IN AN AMOUNT NOT TO EXCEED FORTY-SEVEN THOUSAND NINE HUNDRED THIRTY-TWO DOLLARS ($47,932.00); AUTHORIZING THE PROPER CITY OFFICIALS TO EXECUTE AN AGREEMENT; PROVIDING FOR CONFLICTS;FURTHER,PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. (Public Services) City Attorney Boutsis read the title of Resolution#2022-074. Vice-Mayor Salvino motioned to adopt Resolution #2022-074; seconded by Commissioner Lewellen. The motion carried unanimously. 8.2 RESOLUTION#2022-075 Amended A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF DANIA BEACH, FLORIDA, AUTHORIZING THE PROPER CITY OFFICIALS TO ENTER INTO AGREEMENTS WITH FOUR(4) FIRMS THAT SUBMITTED RESPONSES TO THE CITY'S REQUEST FOR QUALIFICATIONS ("RFQ")NO. 22-010 ENTITLED, "PLANNING CONSULTING SERVICES (POOL)"; WHICH MAY EXCEED AN ANNUAL VENDOR TOTAL AMOUNT OF TWENTY-FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS ($25,000.00); PROVIDING FOR CONFLICTS;FURTHER,PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. (Community Development) City Attorney Boutsis read the title of Resolution#2022-075. Vice-Mayor Salvino questioned how far it would exceed$25,000.00. Corinne Lajoie, Assistant Director of Community Development, explained it is to establish a pool of pre-approved consultants that Community Development could go to as the need arises that would allow them to work more quickly. Vice-Mayor Salvino asked where the money would be coming from. Assistant Community Development Director Lajoie said it comes from the General Fund. Vice-Mayor Salvino asked why it was not coming from the Building Fund and said we need to find a way for it to come from the Building Fund. Assistant Community Development Director Lajoie responded it is not a Building item, it is the Planning Division. Mayor James asked if there is a not-to-exceed cap that we may want to put on it. City Attorney Boutsis clarified this is to exceed $25,000.00; if it was under $25,000.00, it would be at the City Manager's authority. She asked if they wanted to limit it to $100,000.00. Assistant Community Development Director Lajoie said yes. Minutes of Hybrid Regular Meeting 6 Dania Beach City Commission Tuesday,May 10,2022—7:00 p.m. EADING) (Community Development) City Attorney Boutsis read the title of Ordinance#2022-020.Mayor James noted there is a lot of language in this ordinance to digest.Corinne Lajoie, Assistant Director of Community Development, gave a presentation on the text amendment.Commissioner Lewellen motioned to adopt Ordinance #2022- Vice-Mayor Salvino motioned to adopt Resolution #2022-075, as amended, to cap the yearly expenditure at $100,000.00 per firm; seconded by Commissioner Lewellen. The motion carried unanimously. 9. Public Hearings and Site Plans 9.1 ORDINANCE#2022-018 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF DANIA BEACH, FLORIDA,APPROVING THE REQUEST, MADE BY ROD A. FEINER, ESQ., ON BEHALF OF 3851 STIRLING HOLDINGS, LLLP, FOR A REZONING (RZ-055-21) AND ALLOCATION OF FLEXIBILITY UNITS AND COMMERCIAL FLEXIBILITY(OT-057-21)FOR PROPERTIES GENERALLY LOCATED AT 3851 STRILING ROAD IN THE CITY OF DANIA BEACH, FLORIDA, AS LEGALLY DESCRIBED IN EXHIBIT"A," A COPY OF WHICH IS ATTACHED TO THIS ORDINANCE; CHANGING THE CURRENT ZONING CLASSIFICATION OF THE PROPERTIES FROM ESTATE (E-1) TO PLANNED RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT DISTRICT (PRD-1), SUBJECT TO CERTAIN RESTRICTIONS; PROVIDING FOR CONFLICTS; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; AND FURTHER, PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. (FIRST READING) Continued from April 26,2022) (Community Development) City Attorney Boutsis read the title of Ordinance #2022-018 and gave a preamble explaining the process on how we will proceed this evening. City Attorney Boutsis asked the Commission to disclose their communications on this matter. Mayor James disclosed her communications and said she can be impartial. Vice-Mayor Salvino said he has not spoken to anyone but did receive emails both pro and con which are attached to and incorporated into these minutes and said he could be impartial. Commissioner Davis disclosed her communications and said she can be impartial. Commissioner Lewellen disclosed her communications and said she can be impartial. Commissioner Odman disclosed her communications and said she can be impartial. City Attorney Boutsis swore-in those who would speak. Corinne Lajoie, Assistant Director of Community Development, gave a presentation on the rezoning, flexibility units and commercial flexibility requests for Koosh Living. Attorney Rod Feiner, Coker & Feiner, representing the applicant, gave a PowerPoint presentation, which is attached to and incorporated into these minutes. Twee Turner, Turner Planning Solutions, gave her education and experience background, and continued with the PowerPoint presentation and presented expert planning testimony on behalf of the applicant. Minutes of Hybrid Regular Meeting 7 Dania Beach City Commission Tuesday,May 10,2022—7:00 p.m. Ordinance# 2022-020.Mayor James noted there is a lot of language in this ordinance to digest.Corinne Lajoie, Assistant Director of Community Development, gave a presentation on the text amendment.Commissioner Lewellen motioned to adopt Ordinance #2022-020, on first reading;seconded by Vice-Mayor Salvino. The motion carried unanimously.8. Bids and Requests for Proposals Minutes of Hybrid Regular Meeting 5 Dania Beach City Commission Joseph Kaller, Kaller Architecture, architect for the project, continued with the PowerPoint presentation and presented expert architecture testimony on behalf of the applicant. Karl Peterson, KBP Consulting, Inc., registered professional engineer, gave a PowerPoint presentation, which is attached to and incorporated into these minutes and presented expert traffic engineering testimony on behalf of the applicant. Sharon Sharaby, 5310 SW 32 Terrace, Fort Lauderdale, applicant, spoke about spirituality, his background, and his past projects in the City. Attorney Feiner further addressed the rezoning request. City Attorney Boutsis said at least one of the two attorneys representing neighborhood interests in opposition has requested intervenor status; however, our code does not provide for intervenor status but as long as we provide them with the time to speak and for cross examination, she believes the criteria has been met. Tucker Gibbs, 3835 Utopia Court, Coconut Grove, Florida, representing Harger Hills neighborhood, addressed the incompatibility of the requested zoning change. Cecelia Ward, JC Consulting, 18081 SE Country Club Dr., Unit 313, Tequesta, Florida, presented expert planning testimony on behalf of Harger Hills neighborhood. Richard DeWitt, Government Law Group, 200 S. Andrews Avenue, Suite 601, Fort Lauderdale, Florida, representing L'Chaim Farms, gave a PowerPoint presentation, which is attached to and incorporated into these minutes. Attorney DeWitt cross-examined Ms. Ward. Mayor James opened the Public Hearing. Moshe Laniado, 5960 SW 37th Avenue, spoke in support of the project. Romain Delutz, 5425 16th Street East, Bradenton, Florida, spoke in support of the project. Sarah Raskin, 3201 Griffin Road, spoke in favor of the project. Michael Fried, 5745 Brookfield Circle, Hollywood, Florida, spoke in support of the project. Lawrence Frisch, 5821 SW 36th Terrace, spoke in favor of the project. Elias Bichachi, 5910 SW 37th Avenue, spoke in opposition to the project. Israel Valdez, 2612 Griffin Road, spoke in support of the project. Minutes of Hybrid Regular Meeting 8 Dania Beach City Commission Tuesday,May 10,2022—7:00 p.m. s, gave her education and experience background, and continued with the PowerPoint presentation and presented expert planning testimony on behalf of the applicant.Minutes of Hybrid Regular Meeting 7 Dania Beach City Commission Tuesday,May 10,2022— 7:00 p.m. Ordinance#2022-020.Mayor James noted there is a lot of language in this ordinance to digest.Corinne Lajoie, Assistant Director of Community Development, gave a presentation on the text amendment. Commissioner Lewellen motioned to adopt Ordinance #2022-020, on first reading; seconded by Vice-Mayor Salvino. The motion carried unanimously. 8. Bids and Requests for Proposals Minutes of Hybrid Regular Meeting 5 Dania Beach City Commission Tuesday,May 10,2022—7:00 p.m. Erica Roden, 5871 SW 29th Avenue, spoke in opposition to the project due to the endangerment it would pose to school children trying to cross the street. Shira Sipper, 5921 SW 36th Terrace, spoke in favor of the development. Natie Grossnass, 4150 Davie Road Extension, West Hollywood, spoke in support of the project. Anthony Benedict, 5841 SW 37th Avenue, spoke in opposition to the development. Harvey J. Sepler, 5840 SW 37th Terrace, spoke in opposition to the project. Stephanie Jofe, 5880 SW 37th Terrace, spoke in opposition to the development. Michael Jofe, 5880 SW 37th Terrace, presented a brief video and spoke in opposition to the zoning change. James Rizzo, 5821 SW 37th Avenue, presented a Harger Hills Area Homeowners Association PowerPoint slide, which is attached to and incorporated into these minutes, and spoke in opposition to the project. Avi Naider, 3397 Hollywood Oaks Drive, spoke in support of the project. Gregory Musk, 255 W. Dixie Highway, spoke about the neighbors dumping trash on the property and his clearing of the property and noted he supported the project. Louie Granteed, 1101 Ben Tobin Drive, Hollywood, Florida, spoke in favor of the project. Michael Chesal, 5831 SW 33rd Lane, spoke in support of the project. Angel Sipper, 5921 SW 36th Terrace, spoke in favor of the project. Attorney DeWitt cross-examined Mr. Sharaby. Attorney Feiner responded on behalf of Mr. Sharaby. Attorney DeWitt continued with the cross-examination of Mr. Sharaby and Attorney Feiner advised the client not to answer. Valerie Harris, Principal of Olsen Middle School, spoke of the applicant's group partnering with the middle school for mentoring and a$2,500.00 scholarship for one of the students. Seeing as there was no one else to speak in favor or opposition, Mayor James closed the Public Hearing. Assistant Community Development Director Lajoie clarified the record on the Comprehensive Plan and home ownership. Vice-Mayor Salvino motioned to adopt Ordinance #2022-018, on first reading; seconded by Commissioner Davis. Minutes of Hybrid Regular Meeting 9 Dania Beach City Commission Tuesday,May 10,2022—7:00 p.m. mission Tuesday,May 10, 2022—7:00 p.m.s, gave her education and experience background, and continued with the PowerPoint presentation and presented expert planning testimony on behalf of the applicant. Minutes of Hybrid Regular Meeting 7 Dania Beach City Commission Tuesday,May 10,2022—7: 00 p.m.Ordinance#2022-020.Mayor James noted there is a lot of language in this ordinance to digest.Corinne Lajoie, Assistant Director of Community Development, gave a presentation on the text amendment.Commissioner Lewellen motioned to adopt Ordinance #2022-020, on first reading; Vice-Mayor Salvino commented on the remark made that someone poisoned the trees and said as far as legal hurdles, we have legal counsel and legal counsel tells us that we have met everything that needs to be done or the project would not have been brought forward. You have to believe in what is going to happen. There is traffic everywhere, not just in Dania Beach, and he feels people need to adapt to change. Commissioner Odman said she understands legally all the criteria has been met to their satisfaction but requested clarification on the flex units. Assistant Community Development Director Lajoie noted she believes the 1/3 was in reference to the total flex units the City has, although she cannot say for certain as she did not do the research in advance. Commissioner Odman questioned if she could not say for certain that the number was greater than any other project has received. Assistant Community Development Director Lajoie said that is correct. City Attorney Boutsis asked if she could provide that by second reading. Assistant Community Development Director Lajoie responded yes. Commissioner Odman said so it is up to us to decide if getting the majority of the flex units is a special privilege. City Attorney Boutsis said yes. Commissioner Odman asked Mr. Sharaby if he would do something with Hollywood Hills. Mr. Sharaby said at the moment no, but they would like to grow the outreach with other schools as well. Commissioner Odman asked if he believed the video that Dr. Jofe showed. Mr. Sharaby responded it is a video, so he guesses he has to believe it. Discussion ensued between Commissioner Odman and Mr. Sharaby regarding traffic mitigation in the area. Commissioner Lewellen said there were statements made tonight making accusations about Mr. Sharaby poisoning the trees. She asked City Attorney Boutsis for clarification that there was no conclusion on who poisoned the trees, but the reason why they were fined was because they owned the property, not because they did anything wrong. Minutes of Hybrid Regular Meeting 10 Dania Beach City Commission Tuesday,May 10,2022—7:00 p.m. 0,2022—7:00 p. m.mission Tuesday,May 10,2022—7:00 p.m.s, gave her education and experience background, and continued with the PowerPoint presentation and presented expert planning testimony on behalf of the applicant.Minutes of Hybrid Regular Meeting 7 Dania Beach City Commission Tuesday,May 10, 2022—7:00 p.m.Ordinance#2022-020.Mayor James noted there is a lot of language in this ordinance to digest.Corinne Lajoie, Assistant Director of Community Development, gave a presentation on City Attorney Boutsis noted we have no proof of who did the damage. There are some videos that were taken by the neighbors of some people in a pick-up truck. The property owner has reported to the police and offered to enforce no trespassing against the trespassers, but they were never caught. Unfortunately, our police were not able to do so. The code is strict liability, and the property owner is ultimately responsible. Commissioner Lewellen commented, yes, they are asking for rezoning. There is another property L'Chaim Farm, which did not require a zoning change and they collected all these properties and put them together for this farm, that we have all gotten more complaints about than most properties out there. This is a nuisance to a lot of people in the neighborhood, and we get emails, text messages and neighbors complaining about the farm. It is hard to take and hear that the farm is complaining about this when they are not necessarily as good as a neighbor accusing the applicant of not being one. Commissioner Davis said there were technical things and asked if it is 221 flex units or 231. Mayor James noted there are 231 total units, but the flex units are 221. Commissioner Davis commented she thinks it is worth knowing how many meetings the applicant has had with the residents to try to come together; it makes a difference for her to go out and see the property with her own eyes. She had a chance to do that and did look at the farm and the power lines. It puts it in reality and she wants to confirm that nothing can be built where those powerlines are and they are not going to be looking into people's homes. City Attorney Boutsis responded that is correct. Mayor James said she is going to speak on behalf of all the residents. She had the calls, zoom meeting with Harger Hills, and conversations via email. This is not a clear-cut case where the entire community has shown up to not support this, where no matter how much she loved the project, she would not vote for it. This is entirely different and she has had to look at it at from all angels. This is a beautiful project. She is glad this is on a major thoroughfare, and she does think a lot of the issues that are being had with regard to the kids and safety is more of a School Board issue. The responsible people for those kids are the schools and the School Board. No one wants anything to happen to the kids. She commends the community for coming out for and against this; however, this has been a very long process. She does like quality developers; Mr. Sharaby is not the only quality developer. We have others that really invest in our community, and we have developers that come in and you never see them again. They live right here in our communities and are investing millions into our communities. Decisions we make here are going to affect us for the next 50 years and generations to come. The motion carried on the following 5-0 Roll Call vote: Commissioner Davis Yes Vice-Mayor Salvino Yes Commissioner Lewellen Yes Mayor James Yes Commissioner Odman Yes Minutes of Hybrid Regular Meeting 11 Dania Beach City Commission Tuesday,May 10,2022—7:00 p.m. 9.2 ORDINANCE#2022-019 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF DANIA BEACH, FLORIDA, AUTHORIZING THE EXPENDITURE OF AMERICAN RESCUE PLAN ACT("ARPA") STATE AND LOCAL FISCAL RELIEF FUND("SLFRF")PROCEEDS EXCEEDING ONE MILLION DOLLARS($1,000,000.00)FOR POLICE AND FIRE RESCUE SERVICES PROVIDED BY THE BROWARD SHERIFF'S OFFICE ("BSO"); PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING FOR CONFLICTS; FURTHER, PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. (SECOND READING) (Finance) City Attorney Boutsis read the title of Ordinance #2022-019. Mayor James opened the Public Hearing. Seeing as there was no one to speak in favor or opposition, she closed the Public Hearing. Commissioner Lewellen motioned to adopt Ordinance #2022-019, on second reading; seconded by Vice-Mayor Salvino. The motion carried unanimously. 9.3 ORDINANCE#2022-021 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF DANIA BEACH, FLORIDA, AUTHORIZING THE EXPENDITURE OF CITY FUNDS EXCEEDING ONE MILLION DOLLARS 1,000,000.00) PER PROJECT, WHICH EXPENDITURE IS NOT TO EXCEED THE PROJECTS' BID AMOUNT APPROVED BY THE CITY COMMISSION, TO FUND THE SW 37TH TERRACE DRAINAGE IMPROVEMENT PROJECT AND SW 54TH COURT DRAINAGE IMPROVEMENT PROJECT; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING FOR CONFLICTS; FURTHER, PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. (FIRST READING) (Public Services) City Attorney Boutsis read the title of Ordinance #2022-021. Fernando Rodriguez, Director of Public Services, addressed the two drainage improvement projects. Mayor James opened the Public Hearing. Seeing as there was no one to speak in favor or opposition, she closed the Public Hearing. Vice-Mayor Salvino motioned to adopt Ordinance#2022-021, on first reading; seconded by Commissioner Lewellen. The motion carried unanimously. 9.4 ORDINANCE#2022-022 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF DANIA BEACH, FLORIDA, AUTHORIZING THE EXPENDITURE OF CITY FUNDS EXCEEDING ONE MILLION DOLLARS 1,000,000.00) WHICH EXPENDITURE IS NOT TO EXCEED THE PROJECT'S BID AMOUNT APPROVED BY THE CITY COMMISSION, TO FUND THE SOLAR LIGHT REPLACEMENT FIXTURES PROJECT; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING FOR CONFLICTS; FURTHER, PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. (FIRST READING) (Public Services) City Attorney Boutsis read the title of Ordinance#2022-022. Minutes of Hybrid Regular Meeting 12 Dania Beach City Commission Tuesday,May 10,2022—7:00 p.m. s has been a very long process. She does like quality developers; Mr.Sharaby is not the only quality developer. We have others that really invest in our community,and we have developers that come in and you never see them again. They live right here in our communities and are investing millions into our communities. Decisions we make here are going to affect us for the next 50 years and generations to come.The motion carried on the following 5-0 Roll Call vote:Commissioner Davis Yes Vice-Mayor Salvino Yes Commissioner Lewellen Yes Mayor James Yes Commissioner Odman Yes Minutes of Hybrid Regular Meeting 11 Dania Beach City Commission Tuesday,May 10, 2022—7:00 p.m. Fernando Rodriguez, Director of Public Services, addressed the solar light replacement fixtures project. Mayor James asked if funding was coming from reserves. Frank DiPaolo, Chief Financial Officer, responded we are financing this project so we have request for proposals out right now. Mayor James opened the Public Hearing. Seeing as there was no one to speak in favor or opposition, she closed the Public Hearing. Vice-Mayor Salvino motioned to adopt Ordinance #2022-022, on first reading; seconded by Commissioner Lewellen. The motion carried unanimously. 10. Discussion and Possible Action 10.1 Discussion on City advisory boards - Vice-Mayor Salvino Vice-Mayor Salvino noted the Commissioners should review the boards and their respective appointments to be prepared to discuss them at the next meeting. 11. Commission Comments 11.1 Commissioner Davis Commissioner Davis pointed out issues she has seen recently at the beach. She knows we have the BEAM team, but it is way beyond regular maintenance at the beach. We have seen human feces on the beach, and she is looking at cameras or something else. It is beyond the call of duty for our maintenance and BEAM team. She also wants to shout out to Public Services and thank them for all that they do. 11.2 Commissioner Lewellen Commissioner Lewellen said she knows we have had issues with people being concerned with property taxes. There are a lot of exemptions out there that people may not realize. She was at meeting where Property Appraiser Marty Kiar was speaking about different programs and she asked him if he would send someone to City Hall regularly to answer residents' questions and help them sign up for exemptions. They have agreed to do it. There will be someone here once a month for residents to come in and sign up for more exemptions and they will explain things to residents. Commissioner Lewellen noted she attended the 9th District American Legion annual meeting and spoke to their V.A. liaison. The liaison gave her forms entitled "Do you know a veteran who needs help?" If you know a veteran that needs help, medical, financial or anything, you fill out Minutes of Hybrid Regular Meeting 13 Dania Beach City Commission Tuesday,May 10,2022—7:00 p.m. E DATE. (FIRST READING) (Public Services)City Attorney Boutsis read the title of Ordinance#2022-022.Minutes of Hybrid Regular Meeting 12 Dania Beach City Commission Tuesday,May 10,2022—7:00 p.m.s has been a very long process. She does like quality developers; Mr.Sharaby is not the only quality developer. We have others that really invest in our community,and we have developers that come in and you never see them again. They live right here in our communities and are investing millions into our communities. Decisions we make here are going to affect us for the next 50 years and generations to come.The motion carried on the following 5-0 Roll Call vote:Commissioner Davis Yes Vice-Mayor Salvino Yes Commissioner Lewellen Yes Mayor James Yes Commissioner Odman Yes Minutes of Hybrid Regular Meeting 11 Dania Beach City Commission Tuesday,May 10,2022—7:00 p.m. the form and they will send someone from the American Legion to try to help the person. There are some copies in the atrium, and we can have more made to be handed out to people or have them at the parks. It is a really good service that is free that they should afford themselves of. Commissioner Lewellen said she went to the Estates of Fort Lauderdale Women's Club meeting and Parks & Recreation Director Brown was also invited. She asked him to come up and speak. Parks & Recreation Director Brown noted he got a call from the Estates of Fort Lauderdale and they wanted to give a $300.00 donation for our summer camp. It will help kids with field trips and things that we need for C.W. Thomas Park. He picked up the check and it was deposited today. Commissioner Lewellen thanked the Estates of Fort Lauderdale Women's Club. 11.3 Commissioner Odman Commissioner Odman had no comments. 11.4 Vice-Mayor Salvino Vice-Mayor Salvino said last month we did the Prestige Club Etiquette program, and we were short $28.50, and he is asking permission to take it out of his contingency account. The Commission agreed. 11.5 Mayor James Mayor James said hers is also a contingency concern. One of the communities out west wants to start a neighborhood watch or other type program. She knows we have put signs in other communities, and she is requesting $158 dollars from our contingency for BSO signs in the Oakbridge community. The Commission agreed. 12. Appointments 12.1 Marine Advisory Board 12.2 Parks, Recreation and Community Affairs Advisory Board There were no appointments at this meeting. 13. Administrative Reports 13.1 City Manager Minutes of Hybrid Regular Meeting 14 Dania Beach City Commission Tuesday,May 10,2022—7:00 p.m. ents to come in and sign up for more exemptions and they will explain things to residents.Commissioner Lewellen noted she attended the 9th District American Legion annual meeting and spoke to their V.A. liaison. The liaison gave her forms entitled "Do you know a veteran who needs help?" If you know a veteran that needs help, medical, financial or anything, you fill out Minutes of Hybrid Regular Meeting 13 Dania Beach City Commission Tuesday,May 10,2022—7:00 p.m.E DATE. (FIRST READING) (Public Services)City Attorney Boutsis read the title of Ordinance#2022-022.Minutes of Hybrid Regular Meeting 12 Dania Beach City Commission Tuesday,May 10, 2022—7:00 p.m.s has been a very long process. She does like quality developers; Mr.Sharaby is not the only quality developer. We have others that really invest in our community,and we have developers that come in and you never see them again. They live right here in our communities and are investing millions into our communities. Decisions we make here are going to affect us for the next 50 years and generations to come.The motion carried on the following 5-0 Roll Call vote:Commissioner Davis Yes Vice-Mayor Salvino Yes Commissioner Lewellen Yes Mayor James Yes Commissioner Odman Yes Minutes of Hybrid Regular Meeting 11 Dania Beach City Commission Tuesday,May 10,2022—7: 00 p.m. City Manager Garcia deferred most of her report to the next meeting due to the time but thanked the Public Services and Community Development Departments for all their hard work with the numerous projects they have taken on, and thanked the Finance Team for the audit we heard about at tonight's meeting. 13.2 City Attorney City Attorney Boutsis had no comments. 13.3 City Clerk- Reminders Tuesday, May 24, 2022 - 7:00 p.m. City Commission Meeting Tuesday, June 14, 2022 - 5:30 p.m. CRA Board Meeting Tuesday, June 14, 2022 - 7:00 p.m. City Commission Meeting 14. Adjournment Mayor James adjourned the meeting at 11:30 p.m. ATTEST: 8 E44 CIT OF DANIA EACH f I . LLiL i ' 1.'.r. '4 I THOMAS SCHNEIDER, CMC t' cp, ARA JAM S CITY CLERK 4el/SHED ' MAYOR Approved: June 14, 2022 Minutes of Hybrid Regular Meeting 15 Dania Beach City Commission Tuesday,May 10,2022—7:00 p.m. short $ 28.50, and he is asking permission to take it out of his contingency account. The Commission agreed.11.5 Mayor James Mayor James said hers is also a contingency concern. One of the communities out west wants to start a neighborhood watch or other type program. She knows we have put signs in other communities, and she is requesting $158 dollars from our contingency for BSO signs in the Oakbridge community. The Commission agreed.12. Appointments 12. J I V M•4.4al. 4. 0 k . it, iiiiiii*"''''.-- r .. iii,. . I't: 1 .. • . .1":„.„. . . . .1t1,• : .,„it.,1:,.••. ••, .1,,,,, ....„.„. 1.,.•t: 0,it i , : . :::;,,„,!•1,.; •„.. ••••••„:„,,.:.,..,•...„„stt .,,: ..1.i: .1.. i., .1 • •, • ..,1•Ii.:„,„,::•• --, — : .t,:r: 0,•,-., .. 1 1. „, . ., . ,:„.1..: ,•,.:•.:„,,:•,,., . - , •„..1,::. ._,...„ .., I ., . .: .: , ,::.,•„,,,i,,!- •,•. •••,,.*: .,:,•'•••• r a. v wlk .p 4 1 • 1` b I f 44 i W H Z ZO (NI 0 N N H r r-1 Eli t 5 tn17- r d p z 7/3 r Q V 0 t signs in other communities, and she is requesting $158 dollars from our contingency for BSO signs in the Oakbridge community. The Commission agreed.12. Appointments 12. 1 Marine Advisory Board 12.2 Parks, Recreation andCommunityAffairsAdvisoryBoardTherewere no appointments at this meeting.13. Administrative Reports 13.1 City Manager Minutes of Hybrid Regular Meeting 14 Dania Beach City Commission Tuesday, May 10,2022—7: 00 p.m.ents to come in and sign up for more exemptions and they will explain things to residents.Commissioner Lewellen noted she attended the 9th District American Legion annual meeting and spoke to their V.A. liaison. The liaison gave her forms entitled "Do you know a veteran who needs help?" If you know a veteran that needs help, medical, financial or anything, you fill out Minutes of Hybrid Regular Meeting 13 Dania Beach City Commission Tuesday,May 10,2022—7:00 p.m.E 110'. Moll I fti i I I' ir ai 4 3 Ate' litt,. .. 1. .... 45.'4 filt`. +. is 111 1 ';tr. ' '-i, A 4..•••. I S t itzw, ,,,••,_ .• ei ? t .... r 1-'''.. 4.4",'-'...,x14.4,,,..L':,...',-.,-'-''' ,:. . 4 al.\ a. ay r I' . s « t i 1. 1 4:-' 1 i r • i ill a 1 1 . s Aim Z ZO (NI 0 N N H r r-1 Eli t 5 tn17- r d p z 7/3 r Q V 0 t signs in other communities, and she is requesting $158 dollars from our contingency for BSO signs in the Oakbridge community. The Commission agreed.12. Appointments 12. 1 Marine Advisory Board 12.2 Parks, Recreation andCommunityAffairsAdvisoryBoardTherewere no appointments at this meeting.13. Administrative Reports 13.1 City Manager Minutes of Hybrid Regular Meeting 14 Dania Beach City Commission Tuesday, May 10,2022—7: 00 p.m.ents to come in and sign up for more exemptions and they will explain things to residents.Commissioner Lewellen noted she attended the 9th District American Legion annual meeting and spoke to their V.A. liaison. The liaison gave her forms entitled "Do you know a veteran who needs help?" If you know a veteran that needs help, medical, financial or anything, you fill out Minutes of Hybrid Regular Meeting 13 Dania Beach City Commission Tuesday,May 10,2022—7:00 p.m.E 1 15 a a a1 t. w a 44 of N 441 . 1— VI ,a, ti C o O2 VU N tn O O cu z V c V Q c a W 0 0OU w N r p F ..,. so ...., Z 0 e a) a) 15 a a a1 t. w a 44 of N 441 . 1— VI , a, ti C o O2 VU N tn O O cu z V c V Q c a W 00O U w N r p F ..,.so ...., Z 0 e Y` , is 1 R 0 ice lr r Air so, r h i I I , \ P1MI€t- r 1':. a) 4- .0. wen 5 s , ,,,...,„. ... L= 1 i x U—vy mow. 10 a)W c -a E cOO 3s12a) = s O O c fl. tip O N Q a) o O i `C0a) N V 0 d EQEtwOc > Q cv O O + c a)c . cn O ++ A p ++ a3 =•as ai O - m O O 0 A - 8 t ° a) U O d A O 3 = OU N c 'p • O a) 4=1 •p E N t C C Qom) Q.t -0 a) a) a > • ' 3 .Q C c c CO— O +' ca • N a) N co a: s O a) a) 4A bn•_ 0- > 4) a5 ca co — p ca = as 1 a . co O a) I , o _0 > U r Q V 0 t signs in other communities, and she is requesting $158 dollars from our contingency for BSO signs in the Oakbridge community. The Commission agreed.12. Appointments 12.1 Marine Advisory Board 12.2 Parks, Recreation and Community Affairs Advisory Board There were no appointments at this meeting.13. Administrative Reports 13.1 City Manager Minutes of Hybrid Regular Meeting 14 Dania Beach City Commission Tuesday,May 10, 2022—7:00 p.m.ents to come in and sign up for more exemptions and they will explain things to residents.Commissioner Lewellen c a) a) Y _cn N c N ca E2 O U c) p to O O -> Q Qa I)c OU c U C O - O 0 O ea a) c c _0 a)a) CTS N N 4z J N N X O X N Q) cn U 2 a I U CO as X co C 0 ca c LL C5 "O A U ° in -00 A A ajCTa3c i < 6 c 0 en 0 j fa 5 a) W co U) co c E a)CBco co (D co coY C CpO a) o0oas c *- a) 4_, w,EeL cN W U' 8 c m t N N .. , O w m C o CO V U cv c6 0, i CD '„ c Ric a) O N C a) 73 1•1 )......› 1Z ate:'" 0 t signs in other communities, and she is requesting $158 dollars from our contingency for BSO signs in the Oakbridge community. The Commission agreed.12. Appointments 12.1 Marine Advisory Board 12.2 Parks, Recreation and Community Affairs Advisory Board There were no appointments at this meeting.13. Administrative Reports 13.1 City Manager Minutes of Hybrid Regular Meeting 14 Dania Beach City Commission Tuesday,May 10,2022—7: 00 p.m.ents to come in and sign up for more exemptions and they will explain things to residents. Commissioner Lewellen noted she attended the 9th District American itir 0 E Iiii r• iYV•• a fl line;44 "III' :14' : 4 pt 0 ` WIM CC 9N y 1 I 41 c414 a il 4e ' jI '" f " ' s tM E.k V a. t, ',, 1,, 41 4/, t 411 N e° r lift0 Q o 145 P.., A y 't CIA E 1 Q 4-4" 0.,., ,E s*, tatiag , o 0 5 ...--2.-\., Ej # u6, o a. = Ii I If a E C3• c U) E m a)c U s?a`__ - T + co 40 p Q O cu z • c a) E— Ua) c U oE N T.5 N 1"1 ao O J 5 cv a) u) 70 a)E to U Q O N I ' U R c C •cca_ CtS a) c c- O T N N rmk,, t ca C c 0 c N 3 as i6 , i m U O O vJ `—a vi i a) c c U C•4 i O H T y c m U O C co < O h010 X Oct s co N N > ,- O ca U Y i M "O ' CO O L U S Oho• o N E Y U > O 3 J U eaJ 3 0 r- N C as O ca O N d ea O 00 U \ t N o N C U C N c c N '.' co hA C O m W cr., O uNi m O O T LL C p 4WowpN 70 — co N N .c c tw ° l* v= , a O Q 0d n _ O C,r tV C ma n2cn a) V c Ba C) s •c rr s ,. c r ca CV0 _ z J och 3 _In you fill out Minutes of Hybrid Regular Meeting 13 Dania Beach City Commission Tuesday, May 10, 2022—7:00 p.m.E DATE. (FIRST READING) (Public Services)City Attorney Boutsis read the title of Ordinance#2022-022.Minutes of Hybrid Regular Meeting 12 Dania Beach City Commission Tuesday,May 10,2022—7:00 p.m.s has been a very long process. She does like quality developers; Mr.Sharaby is not the only quality developer. We have others that really invest in our community,and we have developers that come in and you never see them again. They live right here in our communities and are investing millions into our communities. Decisions we make here are going to affect us for the next 50 years and generations to come.The motion carried on the following 5-0 Roll Call vote:Commissioner Davis Yes Vice-Mayor Salvino Yes Commissioner Lewellen Yes Mayor James Yes Commissioner Odman Yes Minutes of Hybrid Regular Meeting 11 Dania Beach City Commission Tuesday,May 10,2022—7:00 p.m. W F- z 0 0_ Z a1 t. w a 44 of N 441 . 1— VI ,a,ti C oO2 VU N tn O O cu z V c V Q c a W 0 0O U w N r p F ..,.so ...., Z 0 e mmi pNY CZ PC F w a 44 of N 441 . 1— VI ,a,ti C o O2 VU Ntn O O cu z V c V Q c a W 0 0O U w N r p F ..,.so ...., Z 0 e s-, REQUEST TO ADDRESS CITY COMMISSION AT REGULAR OR SPECIAL VIRTUAL MEETINGS DANIA BEACH SEA IT.LIVE IT.LOVE IT. The City is required by state law to keep minutes of City Commission meetings. To properly identify persons who address the City Commission in those minutes,the City requests that this form be completed and provided to the City Clerk,before the meeting begins. DATE OF COMMISSION MEETING: May 10, 2022 PRINT NAME: JOSS ARMAND 50 SE 3RD AVE ADDRESS: PHONE NO. (Optional): 305-331-4939 PLEASE CHECK ONE OR BOTH OF THE BOXES BELOW: 1) CITIZFN COMMENTS: Comments by Dania Beach citizens or interested parties that are not part of the regular printed agenda may be made during each Commission meeting during the period set aside for"Citizen Conanents." A thirty(30)minute"Citizen Comments"period shall be designated on the agenda for citizens and interested persons to speak on matters not scheduled on that day's agenda. Each speaker shall be limited to 3 minutes for his or her comments. Persons desiring to speak during the citizen comment period shall inform the City Clerk immediately prior to the beginning of the meeting of their intention to speak. If more than 10 speakers express a desire to speak,the Commission shall determine on a meeting by meeting basis whether to(a)extend the time allotted for citizen comments to accommodate all speakers,or(b)whether to limit the number of speakers or amount of time per speaker. A speaker's time shall not be transferable to another speaker. PLEASE BRIEFLY DESCRIBE THE SUBJECT MATTER OF YOUR COMMENT: Latino Ensemble's premiere of "Thrill Me to Death!" at My Mama's Records, Books, and Cafe 2) PUBLIC HEARINGS—ITEM# AS PRINTED ON AGENDA) PLEASE NOTE:IF YOU WISH TO SPEAK ON AN ITEM MAT PERTAINS TO A"ZONING?'TYPE OF MATTER(FOR EXAMPLE,A SITE PLAN,VARIANCE, SPECIAL EXt,rt'flON OR SIMILAR TYPE OF ITEM KNOWN AS A"QUASI-JUDICIAL"MAI IA,YOU ARE SUBJECT TO BEING ASKED TO SWEAR OR AFFIRM THAT YOU WILL BE TRUTHFUL AS TO YOUR COMMENTS OR ITIMONY. YOU MAY ALSO BE SUBJECT TO QUESTIONS ASKED OF YOU BY AN APPLICANT OR AN APPLICANT'S REPRESENTATIVE OR ATTORNEY WHICH RELATE TO THE ITEM. ANY PERSON WHO DECIDES TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE WITH REGARD TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING OR HEARING WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDING,AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDING IS MADE WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED, LOBBYIST REGISTRATION IS REQUIRED. PRIOR TO ENGAGING IN ANY LOBBYING ACTIVITIES, WHETHER OR NOT COMPENSATION IS PAID OR RECEIVED IN CONNECTION WITH THOSE ACTIVITIES,EACH LOBBYIST SHALL FILE WITH THE CITY CLERK AN ANNUAL REGISTRATION STATEMENT AND PAY AN ANNUAL TWO HUNDRED FIFTY DOLLARS ($250.00) REGISTRATION FEE FOR EACH PRINCIPAL OR EMPLOYER. REGISTRATION FORMS ARE AVAILABLE ON THE CITY WEBSITE: WWW.DANIABEACHFL.GOV. (ORDINANCE#2012-019;AMENDED BY ORDINANCE#2019-019) jddP a/c/lea/tee oe.a,4«op ,o=4zaad„e4,05/10/2022 context of other Future Land Use Policies that encourage and direct a mix of residential communities or"mixed-use" development adjacent to the 4 community area planning,and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/ Appeal of Zoning Interpretation-3 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc. 18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815- 4298 As of 3.23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices( MUTCD)for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop-off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication report( IJR); served as the REQUEST TO ADDRESS CITY COMMISSION AT REGULAR OR SPECIAL MEETINGS DANIA BEACH SEA IT.LIVE IT.LOVE IT. The City is required by state law to keep minutes of City Commission meetings. To properly identify persons who address the City Commission in those minutes,the City requests that this form be completed and provided to the City Clerk,before the meeting begins. DATE OF COMMISSION MEETING: c/to 42-- ,20_ PRINT NAME: LiA N'b l .- t ADDRESS: Cs V Z \ l 1 lL E S C-0 J1-% 444 PHONE NO. (optional):t7 I i( ob., 3 PLEASE CHECK ONE OR BOTH OF THE BOXES BELOW: 1) CITIZEN COMMENTS: Comments by Dania Beach citizens or interested parties that are not part of the regular printed agenda may be made during each Commission meeting during the period set aside for"Citizen Comments." A thirty(30)minute"Citizen Comments"period shall be designated on the agenda for citizens and interested persons to speak on matters not scheduled on that day's agenda. Each speaker shall be limited to 3 minutes for his or her comments. Persons desiring to speak during the citizen comment period shall inform the City Clerk immediately prior to the beginning of the meeting of their intention to speak. If more than 10 speakers express a desire to speak,the Commission shall determine on a meeting by meeting basis whether to(a)extend the time allotted for citizen comments to accommodate all speakers,or(b)whether to limit the number of speakers or amount of time per speaker. A speaker's time shall not be transferable to another speaker. PLEASE BRIEFLY DESCRIBE THE SUBJECT MATTER OF YOUR COMMENT: 5 fc' S4 mot' c 5 l s 2) PUBLIC HEARINGS—ITEM# AS PRINTED ON AGENDA) PLEASE NOTE:IF YOU WISH TO SPEAK ON AN ITEM THAT PERTAINS TO A"ZONING"TYPE OF MATTER(FOR EXAMPLE,A SITE PLAN,VARIANCE, SPECIAL EXCEPTION OR SIMILAR TYPE OF ITEM KNOWN AS A"QUASI-JUDICIAL"MATTER, YOU ARE SUBJECT TO BEING ASKED TO SWEAR OR AFFIRM THAT YOU WILL BE TRUTHFUL AS TO YOUR COMMENTS OR TESTIMONY. YOU MAY ALSO BE SUBJECT TO QUESTIONS ASKED OF YOU BY AN APPLICANT OR AN APPLICANT'S REPRESENTATIVE OR ATTORNEY WHICH RELATE TO THE ITEM. ANY PERSON WHO DECIDES TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE WITH REGARD TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING OR HEARING WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDING, AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDING IS MADE WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. LOBBYIST REGISTRATION IS•REQUIRED. PRIOR TO ENGAGING IN ANY LOBBYING ACTIVITIES, WHETHER OR NOT COMPENSATION IS PAID OR RECEIVED IN CONNECTION WITH THOSE ACTIVITIES,EACH LOBBYIST SHALL FILE WITH THE CITY CLERK AN ANNUAL REGISTRATION STATEMENT AND PAY AN ANNUAL TWO HUNDRED FIFTY DOLLARS ($250.00) REGISTRATION FEE FOR EACH PRINCIPAL OR EMPLOYER. REGISTRATION FORMS ARE AVAILABLE ON THE CITY WEBSITE: WWW.DANIABEACHFL.GOV. (ORDINANCE#2012-019;AMENDED BY ORDINANCE#2019-019) G:\Agenda\PUBLIC SPEAKING FORM.doc BEACHFL.GOV. (ORDINANCE#2012-019;AMENDED BY ORDINANCE#2019- 019)jddP a/c/lea/tee oe.a,4«op ,o=4zaad„e4, 05/10/2022 context of other Future Land Use Policies that encourage and direct a mix of residential communities or"mixed-use" development adjacent to the 4 community area planning,and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel,LLC- W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation- 3 Cecelia Ward, AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954) 815-4298 As of 3.23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School, Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD)for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop-off and pick-up)analyses, REQUEST TO ADDRESS CITY COMMISSION AT REGULAR OR SPECIAL MEETINGS DANIA BEACH SEA IT.LIVE IT.LOVE IT. The City is required by state law to keep minutes of City Commission meetings. To properly identify persons who address the City Commission in those minutes,the City requests that this form be completed and provided to the City Clerk, before the meeti begins. DATE OF COMMISSION ETING: i) 20 PRINT NAME: f' 0 çô ADDRESS: vp PHONE NO. (optional): PLEASE CHEC ONE OR BOTH OF THE BOXES BELOW: 1) El CITIZEN COMMENTS: Comments by Dania Beach citizens or interested parties that are not part of the regular printed agenda may be made during each Commission meeting during the period set aside for"Citizen Comments." A thirty(30)minute"Citizen Comments"period shall be designated on the agenda for citizens and interested persons to speak on matters not scheduled on that day's agenda. Each speaker shall be limited to 3 minutes for his or her comments. Persons desiring to speak during the citizen comment period shall inform the City Clerk immediately prior to the beginning of the meeting of their intention to speak. If more than 10 speakers express a desire to speak,the Commission shall determine on a meeting by meeting basis whether to(a)extend the time allotted for citizen comments to accommodate all speakers,or(b)whether to limit the number of speakers or amount of time per speaker. A speaker's time shall not be transferable to another speaker. S P PASE RI F DE CRIB TIE SUBJECT TTER F y O T: 2)14 r , r 2) PUB C HE GS—ITEM AS PRINTED ON AGENDA) 40 PLEASE NOTE: F YOU WISH TO SPEAK ON AN I EM THAT PERTAINSSZONING"TYPE OF MATTER(FOR EXAMPLE,A SITE PLAN, VARIANCE, SPECIAL EXCEPTION OR SIMILAR TYPE OF ITEM KNOWN AS A"QUASI-JUDICIAL"MATTER, YOU ARE SUBJECT TO BEING ASKED TO SWEAR OR AFFIRM THAT YOU WILL BE TRUTHFUL AS TO YOUR COMMENTS OR TESTIMONY. YOU MAY ALSO BE SUBJECT TO QUESTIONS ASKED OF YOU BY AN APPLICANT OR AN APPLICANT'S REPRESENTATIVE OR ATTORNEY WHICH RELATE TO THE ITEM. ANY PERSON WHO DECIDES TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE WITH REGARD TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING OR HEARING WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDING, AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDING IS MADE WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. LOBBYIST REGISTRATION IS REQUIRED. PRIOR TO ENGAGING IN ANY LOBBYING ACTIVITIES, WHETHER OR NOT COMPENSATION IS PAID OR RECEIVED IN CONNECTION WITH THOSE ACTIVITIES,EACH LOBBYIST SHALL FILE WITH THE CITY CLERK AN ANNUAL REGISTRATION STATEMENT AND PAY AN ANNUAL TWO HUNDRED FIFTY DOLLARS ($250.00) REGISTRATION FEE FOR EACH PRINCIPAL OR EMPLOYER. REGISTRATION FORMS ARE AVAILABLE ON THE CITY WEBSITE: WWW.DANIABEACHFL.GOV. (ORDINANCE#2012-019;AMENDED BY ORDINANCE#2019-019) G:\Agenda\PUBLIC SPEAKING FORM.doc G:\Agenda\PUBLIC SPEAKING FORM.doc BEACHFL.GOV. (ORDINANCE#2012-019; AMENDED BY ORDINANCE#2019-019)jddP a/c/lea/tee oe.a,4«op ,o= 4zaad„e4,05/10/2022 context of other Future Land Use Policies that encourage and direct a mix of residential communities or"mixed-use" development adjacent to the 4 community area planning,and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation- 3 Cecelia Ward, AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3.23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD)for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop- off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication 1111 REQUEST TO ADDRESS CITY COMMISSION AT REGULAR OR SPECIAL MEETINGS DANIA BEACH SEA IT.LIVE IT.LOVE IT. The City is required by state law to keep minutes of City Commission meetings. To properly identify persons who address the City Commission in those minutes,the City requests that this form be completed and provided to the City Clerk,before the meetin begins. DATE OF COMMISSION MEETING:5 to 20 2— PRINT NAME: JC 1 11414 ADDRESS: 4.'Cb S 1 v` PHONE NO. (optional): 954, 0 PLEASE CHECK ONE OR BOTH OF THE BOXES BELOW: 1)CITIZEN COMMENTS: Comments by Dania Beach citizens or interested parties that are not part of the regular printed agenda may be made during each Commission meeting during the period set aside for"Citizen Comments." A thirty(30)minute"Citizen Comments"period shall be designated on the agenda for citizens and interested persons to speak on matters not scheduled on that day's agenda. Each speaker shall be limited to 3 minutes for his or her comments. Persons desiring to speak during the citizen comment period shall inform the City Clerk immediately prior to the beginning of the meeting of their intention to speak. If more than 10 speakers express a desire to speak,the Commission shall determine on a meeting by meeting basis whether to(a)extend the time allotted for citizen comments to accommodate all speakers,or(b)whether to limit the number of speakers or amount of time per speaker. A speaker's time shall not be transferable to another speaker. PLEASE BRIEFLY DESCRIBE THE SUBJECT MATTER OF YOUR COMMENT: INO( a k Ct4 A-t. c t CAL a &-1 y -{- 51-17c2 ;, r3 One C6.F\0,h Frei, rase etfr o 5 OL3Q 2) PUBLIC HEARINGS—ITEM# AS PRINTED ON AGENDA) PLEASE NOTE:IF YOU WISH TO SPEAK ON AN ITEM THAT PERTAINS TO A"ZONING"TYPE OF MATTER(FOR EXAMPLE,A SITE PLAN,VARIANCE, SPECIAL EXCEPTION OR SIMILAR TYPE OF ITEM KNOWN AS A"QUASI-JUDICIAL"MATTER, YOU ARE SUBJECT TO BEING ASKED TO SWEAR OR AFFIRM THAT YOU WILL BE TRUTHFUL AS TO YOUR COMMENTS OR TESTIMONY. YOU MAY ALSO BE SUBJECT TO QUESTIONS ASKED OF YOU BY AN APPLICANT OR AN APPLICANT'S REPRESENTATIVE OR ATTORNEY WHICH RELATE TO THE ITEM. ANY PERSON WHO DECIDES TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE WITH REGARD TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING OR HEARING WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDING, AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDING IS MADE WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. LOBBYIST REGISTRATION IS REQUIRED. PRIOR TO ENGAGING IN ANY LOBBYING ACTIVITIES, WHETHER OR NOT COMPENSATION IS PAID OR RECEIVED IN CONNECTION WITH THOSE ACTIVITIES,EACH LOBBYIST SHALL FILE WITH THE CITY CLERK AN ANNUAL REGISTRATION STATEMENT AND PAY AN ANNUAL TWO HUNDRED FIFTY DOLLARS ($250.00) REGISTRATION FEE FOR EACH PRINCIPAL OR EMPLOYER. REGISTRATION FORMS ARE AVAILABLE ON THE CITY WEBSITE: WWW.DANIABEACHFL.GOV. (ORDINANCE#2012-019;AMENDED BY ORDINANCE#2019-019) G:\Agenda\PUBLIC SPEAKING FORM.doc op ,o= 4zaad„e4,05/10/2022 context of other Future Land Use Policies that encourage and direct a mix of residential communities or"mixed-use" development adjacent to the 4 community area planning,and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation- 3 Cecelia Ward, AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3.23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD)for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop- off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication 111, 6? • 1 Job Title: Assistant Director, Community Development Department: Community Development DANIA BEACH Union Eligible: Not Eligible Pay Grade:122 SEA IT.LIVE IT.LOVE IT. FLSA Status: Exempt JOB DESCRIPTION To perform this job successfully, an individual must be able to perform the essential job functions satisfactorily. Reasonable accommodations may be made to enable individuals with disabilities to perform the primary job functions described herein. Since every duty associated with this position may not be described herein, employees may be required to perform duties not specifically spelled out in the job description, but which maybe reasonably considered to be incidental in the performing of their duties just as though they were actually written out in this job description. JOB SUMMARY Position assists the director in all aspects of administration, direction, and management of the City's code and parking enforcement, permitting, building, development, planning, and zoning functions. Employees in this classification are primarily assigned to the function of operations and administration, however, are knowledgeable and equipped to support all department functions as needed. Position is also specifically responsible for overseeing the Building Division, personnel, and activities. Work is performed independently under general supervision of the Community Development Director. ESSENTIAL JOB FUNCTIONS Performs human resource management functions, e.g., interview, selection, hiring, disciplinary action, recommending promotion, performance evaluations. Assists with administering the City's code and parking enforcement, permitting, building, development, planning and zoning in compliance with all applicable ordinances, codes, laws, and regulatory standards applicable to the work. Oversees the preparation and administration of the department's annual operations budget; ensures adherence to and compliance with established budgetary parameters. Develops and recommends operating policies and procedures to ensure regulatory compliance, improve operational performance, and efficiency administer budgeted funds. Prepares reviews and edits agenda item reports for City Commission Meetings. Represents the department, Director and City in meetings, conferences, and professional association forums as directed. Participates in comprehensive review and evaluation of the City's engineering, permitting, building, development, planning and zoning functions; provides recommendations for improving efficiency and systems for future service needs. Conducts research and other special projects as requested by the Director to meet the needs of the City's growth and development initiatives. Communicates with co-workers, management, citizens, and others in a courteous and professional manner. Receives and responds to inquiries and concerns from the general public, public, local business and regulatory agencies; researches and provides response and resolution accordingly. licies that encourage and direct a mix of residential communities or"mixed-use" development adjacent to the 4 community area planning,and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases: o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale, Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation-3 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises, Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3. 23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study, Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices( MUTCD)for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop-off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication report(IJR); served as the task leader for the preparation of the state environmental impact report(SEIR); conducted the interchange operational analysis reports(IOAR)for the adjacent interchanges and developed the public involvement program.Page 2 of 3 J Page 2 of 3 Manages contracts for services agreements with consultants and contractual employees. Assists in preparation of plans, specifications, selection criteria, competency of contractors. Participates in various development review and pre-development meetings to provide information and guidance applicable to the City's engineering and community development goals, objectives and initiatives. Oversees IT support for the Department. Participates in coordination and activities involving applicable intergovernmental agencies. Participates in the management of the City's capital improvement projects within public right-of-way and any other capital improvement projects. Act as Director during the absence of the Community Development Director. Performs other related duties as assigned. KNOWLEDGE, SKILLS AND ABILITIES Knowledge of department practices and policies. Skill in the use small office equipment, including copy machines or multi-line telephone systems. Skill in using computers for word processing and accounting purposes. Ability to organize and communicate effectively. Ability to work and manage staff in a fast-paced, multi-discipline environment. MINIMUM EDUCATION AND EXPERIENCE REQUIREMENTS Bachelor's degree from an accredited college or university in Business or Public Administration, Engineering, Construction Management, Planning or related field; supplemented by five (5) years progressively responsible experience in engineering and community development functions, the majority of which shall be acquired in a supervisor or management capacity with broad exposure to administrative aspects of the work, e.g., budget development and administration, human resources management, organization and delegation of responsibilities. CERTIFICATION, LICENSE AND SPECIAL REQUIREMENTS Possession of a valid driver's license with overall good driving record required. If driver's license is out of state, must be able to obtain a Florida driver's license within six(6) months of hire date. PHYSICAL DEMANDS This work is sedentary work and requires exerting up to 10 pounds of force occasionally and negligible amount of force constantly to move objects; work may also require balancing, crouching, fingering, handling, hearing, lifting, mental acuity, repetitive motion, speaking, stooping, talking, visual acuity, and walking. WORK ENVIRONMENT permitting, building, development, planning and zoning functions; provides recommendations for improving efficiency and systems for future service needs.Conducts research and other special projects as requested by the Director to meet the needs of the City's growth and development initiatives.Communicates with co-workers, management, citizens, and others in a courteous and professional manner.Receives and responds to inquiries and concerns from the general public, public, local business and regulatory agencies; researches and provides response and resolution accordingly.licies that encourage and direct a mix of residential communities or"mixed-use" development adjacent to the 4 community area planning,and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation-3 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3.23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake, Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices( MUTCD)for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop-off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication report(IJR); served as the task leader for the preparation of the state environmental impact report(SEIR); conducted the interchange operational analysis reports(IOAR)for the adjacent interchanges and developed the public involvement program.Page 2 of 3 Page 3 of 3 Work is typically performed in a safe and secure work environment that may periodically have unpredicted requirements or demands. The City of Dania Beach has the right to revise this position description at any time, and does not represent in any way a contract of employment. I have read and understand this classification description and hereby certify that I am qualified to perform this job, with or without reasonable accommodation. Corinne Lajoie Employee Signature Date Eleanor Dg "'°''°"Ekno,N°`'' m.e,ka,eop. oefornmunky Deeeiopmeet.ett Norena `"""`"'`''"•Dace 2021 03 04 11'ICU°-05W Supervisor(or HR) Signature Date 4.sp Cr) A+ J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3, M?1. 41 tif 11 0 CORINNE LAJOIE, AICP 35714 Pebblebrook Manor, Coconut Creek, FL 33073 Corichurch.laloie(c gmail.com 954) 651-5016 PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE May 2020— Present Community Development Assistant Director, City of Dania Beach, Florida Performs human resource management functions, e.g., interview, selection, hiring, disciplinary action, recommending promotion, performance evaluations. Assists with administering the City's code and parking enforcement, permitting, building, development, planning and zoning in compliance with all applicable ordinances, codes, laws, and regulatory standards applicable to the work. Oversees the preparation and administration of the department's annual operations budget; ensures adherence to and compliance with established budgetary parameters. Develops and recommends operating policies and procedures to ensure regulatory compliance, improve operational performance, and efficiency administer budgeted funds. Prepares reviews and edits agenda item reports for City Commission Meetings. Represents the department, Director and City in meetings, conferences, and professional association forums as directed. Participates in comprehensive review and evaluation of the City's engineering, permitting, building, development, planning and zoning functions; provides recommendations for improving efficiency and systems for future service needs. Conducts research and other special projects as requested by the Director to meet the needs of the City's growth and development initiatives. Communicates with co-workers, management, citizens, and others in a courteous and professional manner. Receives and responds to inquiries and concerns from the public, local business, and regulatory agencies; researches and provides response and resolution accordingly. Manages contracts for services agreements with consultants and contractual employees. Assists in preparation of plans, specifications, selection criteria, competency of contractors. Participates in various development review and pre-development meetings to provide information and guidance applicable to the City's engineering and community development goals, objectives, and initiatives. Oversees IT support for the Department. Participates in coordination and activities involving applicable intergovernmental agencies. Participates in the management of the City's capital improvement projects within public right-of-way and any other capital improvement projects. Act as Director during the absence of the Community Development Director. October 2015— May 2020 Planning and Zoning Manager, City of Dania Beach, Florida Served as Acting Community Development Director, overseeing the Planning Division, Building Division and Code Compliance in the Directors absence Coordinated and processed development entitlements and permit review for Dania Pointe, an $800 million mixed use development including 102 acres, featuring 1 million square feet of retail, restaurants and Class A offices, hotels, 1,000 residential units and public event space Review and analysis Request for Proposals for various City projects opment adjacent to the 4 community area planning,and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation- 3 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3.23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration. North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD)for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop-off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication report(IJR); served as the task leader for the preparation of the state environmental impact report(SEIR); conducted the interchange operational analysis reports(IOAR)for the adjacent interchanges and developed the public involvement program.Page 2 of 3 Prepare and process Future Land Use amendment requests Chair the City's Green Advisory Board Coordinate site plan development with Broward County Aviation Department Manage review and permitting of vacation rentals Collaborate with the City's Community Redevelopment Agency regarding ongoing redevelopment opportunities Serves as the municipal representative at the Staff Working Group which implements the Broward County School Interlocal Agreement between the School Board, Broward County and Broward County Municipalities Prepared multiple, City initiated, zoning text amendments Prepare and present staff reports to the Planning and Zoning Board, Local Planning Agency, and City Commission monthly Review, comment, and process site plan developments Chair the City's Development Review Committee's monthly meeting with representatives from various department and developers Oversee consultants providing professional services to the department. February 2002 —October 2015 Principal Planner, City of Dania Beach, Florida Served as Interim Community Development Director, overseeing the Planning Division, Building Division, and Code Enforcement for a period of 18 months Served as the municipal representative at the Staff Working Group which implements the Broward County School Interlocal Agreement between the School Board, Broward County and Broward County Municipalities Prepared multiple, City initiated, zoning text amendments Prepared and present staff reports to the Planning and Zoning Board, Local Planning Agency and City Commission on a monthly basis Created a historic preservation web page for the city's website Created a historic mark and plaque program Prepared award nominations for city-initiated projects Routinely prepared press releases to local newspaper regarding department activities Reviewed, commented, and processed site plan developments Chaired the City's Development Review Committee's monthly meeting with representatives from various department and developers. Oversaw an entire rewrite of the City's Land Development Code, unifying three separate sets of regulations into one unified document Oversaw consultants providing professional services to the department. Administered the sunset provision for pole signs in the City. Attended to the Zoning Counter to answer questions of residents and contractors January 2000— February 2002 Development Review Coordinator, City of Hollywood, Florida Rewrote code of ordinance requirements for the development review process in close coordination with the City Attorney's Office. Supervised four (4) planning staff personnel Chaired and coordinated the Technical Advisory Committee made up of staff from various departments who met bi-weekly with developers to review site plan applications Prepared and presented staff reports to the Board of Adjustment, Historic Preservation Board, Planning and Zoning Board and City Commission Reviewed, commented, and processed site plan developments public event space Review and analysis Request for Proposals for various City projects opment adjacent to the 4 community area planning,and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases: o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation-3 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta, Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3.23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study, Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration. North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices( MUTCD)for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop-off and pick-up) analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication report(IJR); served as the task leader for the preparation of the state environmental impact report(SEIR); conducted the interchange operational analysis reports(IOAR)for the adjacent interchanges and developed the public involvement program.Page 2 of 3 Chaired the Infrastructure Committee of the City-Wide Master Planning process that involved intense community interaction and outreach. September 1998—January 2000 Associate Planner, City of Hollywood, Florida Reviewed building permits for compliance with zoning code Prepared and presented staff report to the Board of Adjustments Served as Planner-of-the--Day providing assistant to the public Prepared letters in response to written zoning questions June 1998 —September 1998 Planning Intern, The Corradino Group, Doral Florida Assisted in contract work with the State of Florida accounting transportation assistance provided through a grant to social service organizations. Assisted in data collection for a traffic master plan for the Miami Beach. January 1998—June 1998 Zoning Technician, City of West Palm Beach, Florida Reviewed building permits for compliance with city zoning code. Performed field inspections Prepared and presented staff reports to Board of Adjustments June 1997 —January 1998 Planning Intern, City of West Palm Beach, Florida Conducted historic preservation structural inventory Assisted in preparation of EAR based Comprehensive Plan amendments. EDUCATION Masters on Urban and Region Planning from Florida Atlantic University, August 2000. Bachelor of Science in Social Sciences from Florida State University, April 1997. MEMBERSHIPS American Planning Association American Institute of Certified Planners Florida Planning and Zoning Association ff reports to the Planning and Zoning Board, Local Planning Agency and City Commission on a monthly basis Created a historic preservation web page for the city' s website Created a historic mark and plaque program Prepared award nominations for city-initiated projects Routinely prepared press releases to From: nweberman@yahoo.com Date: May 9,2022 at 12:50:07 PM EDT To: "Lewellen, Lori"<Ilewellen@daniabeachfl.gov>,Jdavis@deaniabeach.gov Subject:3851 Stirling Rd Reply-To: "nweberman@yahoo.com"<nweberman@yahoo.com> To whom it may concern, I am a nearby Dania Beach resident and I completely approve of the project located at 3851 Stirling Road, Dania beach.We look forward to having more housing in our neighborhood. Sincerely, Naomi Weberman Corinne Lajoie Employee Signature Date Eleanor Dg "'°''°" Ekno,N°`''m.e,ka,eop.oefornmunky Deeeiopmeet.ett Norena `"""`"'`''"•Dace 2021 03 04 11'ICU°-05W Supervisor(or HR) Signature Date 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 w From: Natie Grossnass<n8e247@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, May 9,2022 4:42 PM To:Jdavis@daniabeach.gov; Lewellen, Lori<Iewellen@daniabeachfl.gov>; Lajoie, Corinne clajoie@daniabeachfl.gov>;James,Tamara<tamarajames@daniabeachfl.gov> Subject: Koosh Living 3851 stirling rd Dear city commission, My name is Natie Grossnass. I'm a resident of the West Hollywood community. I live at 4150 Davie Rd Extension. I am in support of the Koosh living project on 3851 stirling road. I think this development will be a huge asset to the community which we will all benefit from greatly. Aside from the jobs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly. Currently cannot find a place for less than$5000 in Emerald Hills for rent and i really want to move there so this project will enable me and others like me to afford housing there. Thanks and have a great day! ng code.Performed field inspections Prepared and presented staff reports to Board of Adjustments June 1997 —January 1998 Planning Intern, City of West Palm Beach, Florida Conducted historic preservation structural inventory Assisted in preparation of EAR based Comprehensive Plan amendments.EDUCATION Masters on Urban and Region Planning from Florida Atlantic University, August 2000.Bachelor of Science in Social Sciences from Florida State University, April 1997.MEMBERSHIPS American Planning Association American Institute of Certified Planners Florida Planning and Zoning Association ff reports to the Planning and Zoning Board, Local Planning Agency and City Commission on a monthly basis Created a historic preservation web page for the city's From: M Emery<memerbie@gmail.com> Date: May 9,2022 at 4:06:23 PM EDT To:"Lewellen, Lori"<Iewellen@daniabeachfl.gov> Subject: Rezoning the "FPL property"at 3851 Stirling Road Dear Ms. Lewellen: I understand that adding affordable housing is essential, and I'm not against adding homes on the"FPL property" on Stirling. But I don't support the large number of efficiencies being proposed.With Hollywood Hills High and Stirling Elementary schools literally across the street, I believe the sensible use of the property is to build family housing accommodating students, not efficiencies for individuals. To be within such short walking distance would be convenient for the students and their parents while also reducing emissions. Please consider all the car trips that would be saved if those potential students walked to school.And for many, many years. Every trip counts against climate change. Another concern is the added traffic in the area--not just on Stirling Road-- but also onto the intersecting 40th Avenue.The residents,employees and customers turning out of 3851 Stirling Road and headed north will choose 40th Avenue, and won't go to 441. 40th Avenue is a compact,two-lane road with no room for expansion and will have more residents turning onto it from new developments directly on 40th.These developments include Oaks Place currently under construction), another in the planning just south of Oaks Place and other large properties on 40th Avenue north of Stirling that will likely be sold and developed. We live on a cul-de-sac off 40th Avenue,and with the public schools on Stirling and Maimonides Academy to the north,the backups at lights and the drop off/pick up lines are extensive.40th Avenue has speeders and I've seen semi-trucks.Turning onto 40th Avenue can be a hair-raising endeavor.About three years ago a driver crashed through the privacy fence of our neighbor on the corner where her children had been playing a few minutes before. I agree that people need affordable places to live, but we also need to protect against climate change and maintain livability in the area. I'm asking that you find a better balance that best works with schools that already exist there and the limitations of Stirling Road and 40th,especially regarding new homes already scheduled for 40th Avenue. Thank you for your time and consideration. Sincerely, Megan Emery 3839 SW 56 Street Dania Beach, FL 33312 ng Counter to answer questions of residents and contractors January 2000— February 2002 Development Review Coordinator, City of Hollywood, Florida Rewrote code of ordinance requirements for the development review process in close coordination with the City Attorney's Office.Supervised four (4) planning staff personnel Chaired and coordinated the Technical Advisory Committee made up of staff from various departments who met bi-weekly with developers to review site plan applications Prepared and presented staff reports to the Board of Adjustment, Historic Preservation Board, Planning and Zoning Board and City Commission Reviewed, commented, and processed site plan developments public event space Review and analysis Request for Proposals for various City projects opment adjacent to the 4 community area planning,and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases: o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation- 3 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3. 23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School, Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD)for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop-off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication report(IJR); served as the task leader for the preparation of the state environmental impact report(SEIR); conducted the interchange operational analysis reports(IOAR)for the adjacent interchanges and From:Stephanie Jofe<shrinkmom@kidbones.com> Date: May 9,2022 at 3:16:21 PM EDT To: "Lewellen, Lori"<Ilewellen@daniabeachfl.gov> Subject:Zoning change request Dear Commissioner Lewellen, Hi.As you know, I live at 5880 SW 37th Terrace,where I have resided for over 33 years. I raised my family here and chose to live here because it is in the last remaining upland oak hammock in Broward County and a very special and unique part of Dania Beach.. It is a peaceful and quiet community of single-family homes surrounded by majestic old oaks.The oaks, in fact used to extend through the property you are now considering to be rezoned before they were maliciously poisoned. You are being asked to rezone the property smack up against our backyards from E-1,single-family estate homes to PRD-1 with the additional allocation of 221 flex units for a total of 231 new residences and 13.000 square feet of commercial property.The developer's plan is to build a huge U-shaped 6- story+apartment building on that property,along with the 13,000 square feet of commercial space and 4 multifamily,concrete box townhouses. Other than the Comfort Suites Hotel abutting 1-95,that would be the tallest building between 1-95 and State Rd 441. In fact,Stirling Rd. in our neighborhood is primarily residential,with Emerald Hills on the south all the way to Park Rd and private homes and a synagogue buried in the woods on the north from Arapahoe Farms west.Therefore,this apartment complex would be totally out of character with our neighborhood.Other than Lavan Caterers,which is a single story, and Stirling Rd.,the entire perimeter of this property on the east,west and north, is surrounded by a farm and single-family homes. Despite being off Stirling Rd.,this is a residential neighborhood in an oak hammock.We are a neighborhood encompassing all the homes to the east, west and north of this property.Just because our neighborhood is off a large road does not mean we are not a neighborhood. In fact, by placing this large commercial and very large apartment complex smack in the middle of our neighborhood,we will cease to be a neighborhood,especially when you consider that almost all the apartments will be efficiencies and therefore filled by a very high density of primarily transient residents, not the millennials they claim will rent there. When you sink your life savings into a home in the woods,even when it is off Stirling Rd.,and the area behind you is zoned E-1, Estate homes and agricultural and is an easement area with many specimen oak trees,you have an expectation that you have moved into a neighborhood that the city,your city, that you voted to become part of,would never allow developers to build a tall apartment building with a noisy, polluting loading dock directly behind your home. It is truly unconscionable for the City of Dania Beach to allow this to happen to us.This type of development should be concentrated downtown or in Dania Point where there already are tall buildings, restaurants and entertainment within walking distance. When they purchased this property,the developers knew the property was zoned for 1 acre estate homes which would be compatible with our neighborhood.They can build the ten one-acre estate ment adjacent to the 4 community area planning, and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation-3 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3.23. 22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study, Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration. North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD)for the school' s primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking homes this property is zoned for right now!They are asking for this zoning change,which will forever destroy the character of our neighborhood,for one reason:to make more money! We are begging you-please don't do this to us. Thanks so much, Stephanie Jofe I am a nearby Dania Beach resident and I completely approve of the project located at 3851 Stirling Road, Dania beach.We look forward to having more housing in our neighborhood.Sincerely,Naomi Weberman Corinne Lajoie Employee Signature Date Eleanor Dg "'°''°"Ekno,N°`''m. e,ka,eop.oefornmunky Deeeiopmeet.ett Norena `"""`"'`''"•Dace 2021 03 04 11'ICU°-05W Supervisor(or HR) Signature Date 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 From:JOE JOE<josephi2006@gmail.com> Date: May 9,2022 at 3:01:32 PM EDT To: lauren.odman@gmail.com, "Lewellen, Lori" <Ilewellen@daniabeachfl.gov>, Jdavis@deaniabeach.gov Hello all. My name is Joe Izak and I'm a local Dania Beach resident. I am completely in approval of the project located at 3851 Stirling Road, Dania beach. We look forward to having more housing in our neighborhood. Thanks for your consideration.Naomi Weberman Corinne Lajoie Employee Signature Date Eleanor Dg "'°''°"Ekno,N°`''m.e,ka,eop.oefornmunky Deeeiopmeet.ett Norena `"""`"'`''"•Dace 2021 03 04 11'ICU°-05W Supervisor(or HR) Signature Date 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 From: M Emery<memerbie@gmail.com> Date: May 9, 2022 at 4:06:23 PM EDT To: "Lewellen, Lori"<Iewellen@daniabeachfl.gov> Subject: Rezoning the"FPL property" at 3851 Stirling Road Dear Ms. Lewellen: I understand that adding affordable housing is essential, and I'm not against adding homes on the"FPL property" on Stirling. But I don't support the large number of efficiencies being proposed. With Hollywood Hills High and Stirling Elementary schools literally across the street, I believe the sensible use of the property is to build family housing accommodating students, not efficiencies for individuals. To be within such short walking distance would be convenient for the students and their parents while also reducing emissions. Please consider all the car trips that would be saved if those potential students walked to school.And for many, many years. Every trip counts against climate change. Another concern is the added traffic in the area --not just on Stirling Road--but also onto the intersecting 40th Avenue.The residents,employees and customers turning out of 3851 Stirling Road and headed north will choose 40th Avenue, and won't go to 441. 40th Avenue is a compact,two-lane road with no room for expansion and will have more residents turning onto it from new developments directly on 40th.These developments include Oaks Place currently under construction), another in the planning just south of Oaks Place and other large properties on 40th Avenue north of Stirling that will likely be sold and developed. We live on a cul-de-sac off 40th Avenue, and with the public schools on Stirling and Maimonides Academy to the north,the backups at lights and the drop off/pick up lines are extensive.40th Avenue has speeders and I've seen semi-trucks.Turning onto 40th Avenue can be a hair-raising endeavor.About three years ago a driver crashed through the privacy fence of our neighbor on the corner where her children had been playing a few minutes before. I agree that people need affordable places to live, but we also need to protect against climate change and maintain livability in the area. I'm asking that you find a better balance that best works with schools that already exist there and the limitations of Stirling Road and 40th, especially regarding new homes already scheduled for 40th Avenue. Thank you for your time and consideration. Sincerely, Megan Emery 3839 SW 56 Street Dania Beach, FL 33312 d.,and the area behind you is zoned E-1, Estate homes and agricultural and is an easement area with many specimen oak trees,you have an expectation that you have moved into a neighborhood that the city,your city, that you voted to become part of,would never allow developers to build a tall apartment building with a noisy, polluting loading dock directly behind your home. It is truly unconscionable for the City of Dania Beach to allow this to happen to us.This type of development should be concentrated downtown or in Dania Point where there already are tall buildings, restaurants and entertainment within walking distance.When they purchased this property,the developers knew the property was zoned for 1 acre estate homes which would be compatible with our neighborhood.They can build the ten one-acre estate ment adjacent to the 4 community area planning,and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases: o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale, Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation-3 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,# 313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3.23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources. US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC; Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD)for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing( drop-off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access. Page 3 of 3 From: Rabbi Laredo<rabbilaredo@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, May 9,2022 2:01 PM To: Lajoie,Corinne<clajoie@daniabeachfl.gov>;James,Tamara<tamarajames@daniabeachfl.gov>; Lewellen, Lori<Iewellen@daniabeachfl.gov>;Jdavis@deaniabeach.gov;Marco Salvino msalvinosr@leeslocksmith.com>; Lauren.Odman@gmail.com Subject: Koosh living project Dear city commission, My name is Rabbi Laredo, I'm a resident of the community. I live at 5861 sw 36 terrace. I am in support of the Koosh living project on 3851 Stirling road. I think this development will be a huge asset to the community which we will all benefit from greatly.Aside from the jobs it will create it will help with the housing shortage greatly. Thank you very much Rabbi Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 From: ephrain rosenstock<rosenstock10a@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, May 9, 2022 1:48 PM To: Lajoie,Corinne<clajoie@daniabeachfl.gov> Cc:James,Tamara<tamarajames@daniabeachfl.gov> Subject: Koosh living 3851 Stirling rd Dear city commission, My name is Ephraim Rosenstock I'm a resident of the community. I live at 3700 n 56th ave apt 1015 I am in support of the Koosh living project on 3851 stirling road. I think this development will be a huge asset to the community which we will all benefit from greatly.Aside from the jobs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly. Sent from my iPhone he jobs it will create it will help with the housing shortage greatly.Thank you very much Rabbi Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+ J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 From:sarah laredo<myajewelrymiami@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, May 9,2022 2:01 PM To: Lajoie,Corinne<clajoie@daniabeachfl.gov>;James,Tamara<tamarajames@daniabeachfl.gov>; Lewellen, Lori<Ilewellen@daniabeachfl.gov>;Jdavis@deaniabeach.gov; Marco Salvino msalvinosr@leeslocksmith.com>; Lauren.Odman@gmail.com Subject: Koosh living project Dear city commission, My name is Sarah Laredo, I'm a resident of the community. I live at 5861 sw 36 terrace. I am in support of the Koosh living project on 3851 Stirling road. I think this development will be a huge asset to the community which we will all benefit from greatly.Aside from the jobs it will create it will help with the housing shortage greatly. Thank you very much Sarah Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 From: Rachel Lebovics<racshap@yahoo.com> Date: May 9,2022 at 10:08:11 PM EDT To: "Lajoie,Corinne"<clajoie@daniabeachfl.gov> Subject: Koosh Living project Dear city commission, My name is Rachel Lebovics. I'm a resident of the community. I live at 17420 NE 13th ave. I am in support of the Koosh living project on 3851 stirling road. I think this development will be a huge asset to the community which we will all benefit from.Aside from the jobs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly. Thank you Rachel Lebovics set to the community which we will all benefit from greatly. Aside from the jobs it will create it will help with the housing shortage greatly.Thank you very much Sarah Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M? 1. 41 tif 11 0 From:Joseph Krasner<yoskraz@yahoo.com> Date: May 9, 2022 at 8:25:49 PM EDT To: "James,Tamara" <tamarajames@daniabeachfl.gov>, "Lajoie, Corinne"<clajoie@daniabeachfl.gov>, Lewellen, Lori"<Iewellen@daniabeachfl.gov>,jdavis@daniabeach.gov Subject: Koosh Living 3851 stirling rd Dear city commission, My name is Joseph Krasner I'm a resident of the community. I live at 4150 Davie Road Extension. I am in support of the Koosh living project on 3851 Stirling road. I think this development will be a huge asset to the community which we will all benefit from greatly.Aside from the jobs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly. Sincerely, Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3, M?1. 41 tif 11 0 May 2"d,2022 Re: Re-Zoning for Property at 3851 Stirling Road/Koosh Living Dear Mayor and City Commissioners: My name is4ecti4-L24((e94Aand I live at. ( (i-E-.Sifer41) .J S i , Dania Beach, FL. I have reviewed the proposed re-zoning and the site plan for the 10-acre parcel located at 3851 Stirling Road for the project known as Koosh Living. I support and am in favor of the re-zoning request and the site plan. The proposed development will be a welcome addition to the City of Dania Beach, and it goes well with the area. Ari S :tore atly.Aside from the jobs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly.Sincerely,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 May 2nd,2022 Re: Re-Zoning for Property at 3851 Stirling Road/Koosh Living Dear Mayor and City Commissioners: My name is 9eyhicks C( and I live at 212.7 ocp Dania Beach,FL. Cole C(C. I have reviewed the proposed re-zoning and the site plan for the 10-acre parcel located at 3851 Stirling Road for the project known as Koosh Living. I support and am in favor of the re-zoning request and the site plan. The proposed development will be a welcome addition to the City of Dania Beach,and it goes well with the area. S : tore atly. Aside from the jobs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly.Sincerely,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3, M?1. 41 tif 11 0 May 2"°,2022 Re: Re-Zoning for Property at 3851 Stirling Road/Koosh Living Dear Mayor and City Commissioners: My name is beAarve8 and I live at -{6 ZI S U) 2"51-T ,Dania Beach,FL. I have reviewed the proposed re-zoning and the site plan for the 10-acre parcel located at 3851 Stirling Road for the project known as Koosh Living. I support and am in favor of the re-zoning request and the site plan. The proposed development will be a welcome addition to the City of Dania Beach, and it goes well with the area. Si naturetore atly.Aside from the jobs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly.Sincerely,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 May 2nd,2022 Re: Re-Zoning for Property at 3851 Stirling Road/Koosh Living Dear Mayor and City Commissioners: My name is ‘J',, ,f Attki/i,sand I live at 041..,fff'„/Z 4t..3 ,Dania Beach,FL. I have reviewed the proposed re-zoning and the site plan for the 10-acre parcel located at 3851 Stirling Road for the project known as Koosh Living. I support and am in favor of the re-zoning request and the site plan. The proposed development will be a welcome addition to the City of Dania Beach, and it goes well with the area. toreture tore atly. Aside from the jobs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly.Sincerely,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 May 2nd,2022 Re: Re-Zoning for Property at 3851 Stirling Road/Koosh Living Dear Mayor and City Commissioners: My name is -Ct1tt k\ovtek and I live at Z7(.z 112n, ce( ex,- , Dania Beach,FL. I have reviewed the proposed re-zoning and the site plan for the 10-acre parcel located at 3851 Stirling Road for the project known as Koosh Living. I support and am in favor of the re-zoning request and the site plan. The proposed development will be a welcome addition to the City of Dania Beach,and it goes well with the area. Signaturereatly. Aside from the jobs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly.Sincerely,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3, M?1. 41 tif 11 0 May 2nd,2022 Re: Re-Zoning for Property at 3851 Stirling Road/Koosh Living Dear Mayor and pity Commissioners: 2—% 11 t,- s./(LG we G Z 12` My name is 3(.49064zoneand I live at Dania Beach, FL. I have reviewed the proposed re-zoning and the site plan for the 10-acre parcel located at 3851 Stirling Road for the project known as Koosh Living. I support and am in favor of the re-zoning request and the site plan. The proposed development will be a welcome addition to the City of Dania Beach,and it goes well with the area. Al e from the jobs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly.Sincerely,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3, M?1. 41 tif 11 0 May 2nd,2022 Re: Re-Zoning for Property at 3851 Stirling Road/Koosh Living Dear Mayor and City Commissioners: My name is "I'5Jtsg"(j c and I live at 5",20) $(.c/ ,2'ij V. ,Dania Beach,FL. tCM Jaw I have reviewed the proposed re-zoning and the site plan for the 10-acre parcel located at 3851 Stirling Road for the project known as Koosh Living. I support and am in favor of the re-zoning request and the site plan. The proposed development will be a welcome addition to the City of Dania Beach,and it goes well with the area. Signature Al e from the jobs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly.Sincerely,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 May 2"d,2022 Re: Re-Zoning for Property at 3851 Stirling Road/Koosh Living Dear Mayor and City Commissioners: My name isP F4.444 and I live at 32d( CsPli//j 4J I/,Dania Beach,FL. I have reviewed the proposed re-zoning and the site plan for the 10-acre parcel located at 3851 Stirling Road for the project known as Koosh Living. I support and am in favor of the re-zoning request and the site plan. The proposed development will be a welcome addition to the City of Dania Beach,and it goes well with the area. Signatur Al e from the jobs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly.Sincerely,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3, M?1. 41 tif 11 0 May 2nd,2022 Re: Re-Zoning for Property at 3851 Stirling Road/Koosh Living Dear Mayor and City Commissioners: My name i y)'lQ, 11V and I live at 4'(2 32. IL Dania Beach,FL. I have reviewed the proposed re-zoning and the site plan for the 10-acre parcel located at 3851 Stirling Road for the project known as Koosh Living. I support and am in favor of the re-zoning request and the site plan. The proposed development will be a welcome addition to the City of Dania Beach,and it goes well with the area. i aturenatur Al e from the jobs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly.Sincerely,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3, M?1. 41 tif 11 0 May 2nd, 2022 Re: Re-Zoning for Property at 3851 Stirling Road/Koosh Living Dear Mayor and City Commissioners: My name is to 1 _COf LAM0and I live at Slit vw writ Ave,Dania Beach, FL. I have reviewed the proposed re-zoning and the site plan for the 10-acre parcel located at 3851 Stirling Road for the project known as Koosh Living. I support and am in favor of the re-zoning request and the site plan. The proposed development will be a welcome addition to the City of Dania Beach,and it goes well with the area. SignaturerAl e from the jobs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly.Sincerely,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M? 1. 41 tif 11 0 May 2nd, 2022 Re: Re-Zoning for Property at 3851 Stirling Road/Koosh Living Dear Mayor and City Commissioners: My name is eD,?u 1 `d.I live at V26/ Ski av -feieraCe ,Dania Beach,FL. I have reviewed the proposed re-zoning and the site plan for the 10-acre parcel located at 3851 Stirling Road for the project known as Koosh Living. I support and am in favor of the re-zoning request and the site plan. The proposed development will be a welcome addition to the City of Dania Beach, and it goes well with the area. SignatureAle from the jobs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly.Sincerely,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 May 2nd, 2022 Re: Re-Zoning for Property at 3851 Stirling Road/Koosh Living Dear Mayor and City Commissioners: 1, My name is 1 I live at 103 ( IJ Dania Beach,FL. I have reviewed the proposed re-zoning and the site plan for the 10-acre parcel located at 3851 Stirling Road for the project known as Koosh Living. I support and am in favor of the re-zoning request and the site plan. The proposed development will be a welcome addition to the City of Dania Beach, and it goes wel with the ea. gnature Signature Al e fromthejobs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly.Sincerely,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 May 2nd,2022 Re: Re-Zoning for Property at 3851 Stirling Road/Koosh Living Dear Mayor and City Commissioners: My name is nAle{ at Li- and I live at 5tto0 Loco ktca La.t ,Dania Beach, FL. I have reviewed the proposed re-zoning and the site plan for the 10-acre parcel located at 3851 Stirling Road for the project known as Koosh Living. I support and am in favor of the re-zoning request and the site plan. The proposed development will be a welcome addition to the City of Dania Beach,and it goes well with the area. Sig tare Signature Al e from the jobs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly.Sincerely,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 May 2nd, 2022 Re: Re-Zoning for Property at 3851 Stirling Road/Koosh Living Dear Mayor and City Commissioners: P My name is and I live at(- S' '_ / `eDania Beach,FL. I have reviewed the proposed re-zoning and the site plan for the 10-acre parcel located at 3851 Stirling Road for the project known as Koosh Living. I support and am in favor of the re-zoning request and the site plan. The proposed development will be a welcome addition to the City of Dania Beach,and it goes well with the area. gna Al e from the jobs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly. Sincerely,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+ J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 May 2nd,2022 Re: Re-Zoning for Property at 3851 Stirling Road/Koosh Living Dear Mayor and City Commissioners: My name is . A C? J y i and I live at d-14 KS— 5-(71YA Dania Beach,FL. I have reviewed the proposed re-zoning and the site plan for the 10-acre parcel located.at 3851 Stirling Road for the project known as Koosh Living. I support and am in favor of the re-zoning request and the site plan. The proposed development will be a welcome addition to the City of Dania Beach, and it goes well wi e area. ignature a. gna Al e from the jobs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly.Sincerely,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 May 2nd,2022 Re: Re-Zoning for Property at 3851 Stirling Road/Koosh Living Dear Mayor City Commissioners: P My name i at,I live at f'5-4(5- J ft Lz Dania Beach,FL. I have reviewed the proposed re-zoning and the site plan for the 10-acre parcel located at 3851 Stirling Road for the project known as Koosh Living. I support and am in favor of the re-zoning request and the site plan. The pro sed development will be a welcome addition to the City of Dania Beach,and it goes well t the are . natureAl e from the jobs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly.Sincerely,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3, M?1. 41 tif 11 0 May 2nd,2022 Re: Re-Zoning for Property at 3851 Stirling Road/Koosh Living Dear Mayor and City Commissioners: r l G 1 d I live at 2 2 LMynameis3 Dania Beach,FL. I have reviewed the proposed re-zoning and the site plan for the 10-acre parcel located at 3851 Stirling Road for the project known as Koosh Living. I support and am in favor of the re-zoning request and the site plan. The proposed development will be a welcome addition to the City of Dania Beach,and it goes well with the are Signatureomthe jobs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly.Sincerely,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4. sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 May 2nd,2022 Re: Re-Zoning for Property at 3851 Stirling Road/Koosh Living Dear Mayor and City Commissioners: 2; My name is M - 8 I live at i /j tde r-f5. )r,`'Dania Beach,FL. I have reviewed the proposed re-zoning and the site plan for the 10-acre parcel located at 3851 Stirling Road for the project known as Koosh Living. I support and am in favor of the re-zoning request and the site plan. The proposed development will be a welcome addition to the City of Dania Beach,and it goes well with the area. wellwiththe are Signature om the jobs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly.Sincerely,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 May 2nd,2022 Re: Re-Zoning for Property at 3851 Stirling Road/Koosh Living Dear Mayor and City Commissioners: My name is H1 ichkei I.Aaf191(0nd I live at q6// Sc 2 5-4-err-err ,Dania Beach,FL. I have reviewed the proposed re-zoning and the site plan for the 10-acre parcel located at 3851 Stirling Road for the project known as Koosh Living. I support and am in favor of the re-zoning request and the site plan. The proposed development will be a welcome addition to the City of Dania Beach, and it goes well with the area. itctSignature Signature om the jobs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly.Sincerely,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 May 2"d,2022 Re: Re-Zoning for Property at 3851 Stirling Road/Koosh Living Dear Mayor and City Commissioners: My name is —Pkinivxrt VO4Ath and I live at331- (emu L ey o Dania Beach,FL. I have reviewed the proposed re-zoning and the site plan for the 10-acre parcel located at 3851 Stirling Road for the project known as Koosh Living. I support and am in favor of the re-zoning request and the site plan. The proposed development will be a welcome addition to the City of Dania Beach, and it goes well with the area. Sig iature Signature Signature omthe jobs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly.Sincerely,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M? 1. 41 tif 11 0 May 2nd,2022 Re: Re-Zoning for Property at 3851 Stirling Road/Koosh Living Dear Mayor and City Commissioners: My namercl,and I live at ible r t*-;:42 ,Dania Beach,FL. I have reviewed the proposed re-zoning and the site plan for the 10-acre parcel located at 3851 Stirling Road for the project known as Koosh Living. I support and am in favor of the re-zoning request and the site plan. The proposed d opment will be a welcome addition to the City of Dania Beach, and it goes well with Signature rea.Sig iature Signature Signature om the jobs theproject will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly.Sincerely,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 May 2nd, 2022 Re: Re-Zoning for Property at 3851 Stirling Road/Koosh Living Dear Mayor and City Commissioners: My name is 420S/ 4 S• and I live at vQ6 Tf Dania Beach,FL. I have reviewed the proposed re-zoning and the site plan for the 10-acre parcel located at 3851 Stirling Road for the project known as Koosh Living. I support and am in favor of the re-zoning request and the site plan. The proposed development will be a welcome addition to the City of Dania Beach,and it goes well wi the area. Si au atureture Signature Signature omthe jobs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly.Sincerely,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M? 1. 41 tif 11 0 May 2nd,2022 Re: Re-Zoning for Property at 3851 Stirling Road/Koosh Living Dear Mayor and City Commissioners: My name isP v_ Korataiand I live at IN k ew IP Rdli ,Dania Beach,FL. I have reviewed the proposed re-zoning and the site plan for the 10-acre parcel located at 3851 Stirling Road for the project known as Koosh Living. I support and am in favor of the re-zoning request and the site plan. The proposed development will be a welcome addition to the City of Dania Beach,and it goes well with the area. SignaturetureSignature Signature om thejobs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly.Sincerely,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 May 2nd, 2022 Re: Re-Zoning for Property at 3851 Stirling Road/Koosh Living Dear Mayor and City Commissioners: My name is 4-fi IS and I live at Ye? ,51, 2? I Dania Beach,FL. I have reviewed the proposed re-zoning and the site plan for the 10-acre parcel located at 3851 Stirling Road for the project known as Koosh Living. I support and am in favor of the re-zoning request and the site plan. The proposed development will be a welcome addition to the City of Dania Beach, and it goes well with the area. K 'il•k_-V---------Signaturem the jobs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly.Sincerely,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3, M?1. 41 tif 11 0 May 2nd,2022 Re: Re-Zoning for Property at 3851 Stirling Road/Koosh Living Dear Mayor and City Commissioners: My name is 70 A Cal f+r and I live at / A Ili , - /e 4 C ,Dania Beach,FL. I have reviewed the proposed re-zoning and the site plan for the 10-acre parcel located at 3851 Stirling Road for the project known as Koosh Living. I support and am in favor of the re-zoning request and the site plan. The proposed development will be a welcome addition to the City of Dania Beach,and it goes well with the area. 6/".;/? ignatureSignature m the jobs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly.Sincerely,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 May 2nd,2022 Re: Re-Zoning for Property at 3851 Stirling Road/Koosh Living Dear Mayor and City Commissioners: My name is DEAWIs poTTM and I live at 51-161 RAreg.swoop fl ,Dania Beach,FL. I have reviewed the proposed re-zoning and the site plan for the 10-acre parcel located at 3 851 Stirling Road for the project known as Koosh Living. I support and am in favor of the re-zoning request and the site plan. The proposed development will be a welcome addition to the City of Dania Beach, and it goes well with the area. FM*tikb-Signatureaturem the jobs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly.Sincerely,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3, M?1. 41 tif 11 0 May 2nd,2022 Re: Re-Zoning for Property at 3851 Stirling Road/Koosh Living Dear Mayor and City Commissioners: 1531Mynameisievtiv,`t and I live at Y.5:;02..44, ,E #14 , Dania Beach,FL. I have reviewed the proposed re-zoning and the site plan for the 10-acre parcel located at 3851 Stirling Road for the project known as Koosh Living. I support and am in favor of the re-zoning request and the site plan. The proposed development will be a welcome addition to the City of Dania Beach, and it goes well with the area. 04510.90#.0r," Signaturee m the jobs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly.Sincerely,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 May 2nd,2022 Re: Re-Zoning for Property at 3851 Stirling Road/Koosh Living Dear Mayor and City Commissioners: My name is PO 44."— sM.0 U•Cyand I live at 5.1 y2 S i J I Dania Beach,FL. I have reviewed the proposed re-zoning and the site plan for the 10-acre parcel located at 3851 Stirling Road for the project known as Koosh Living. I support and am in favor of the re-zoning request and the site plan. The proposed development will be a welcome addition to the City of Dania Beach, and it goes well with the area. AO Sig- Signature e m the jobs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly.Sincerely,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 May 2nd,2022 Re: Re-Zoning for Property at 3851 Stirling Road/Koosh Living Dear Mayor and City Commissioners: My name is nd I live at_( S,. ania Beach, FL. I have reviewed the proposed re-zoning and the site plan for the 10-acre parcel located at 3851 Stirling Road for the project known as Koosh Living. I support and am in favor of the re-zoning request and the site plan. The proposed development will be a welcome addition to the City of Dania Beach, and it goes well with the area. well with the area.AO Sig-Signature e m the jobs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly.Sincerely,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4. sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 May 2nd,2022 Re: Re-Zoning for Property at 3851 Stirling Road/Koosh Living Dear Mayor and CittyCommis'loners: My name is E e Ceind I live at 2../2 652(/(04/ ,Dania Beach,FL. I have reviewed the proposed re-zoning and the site plan for the 10-acre parcel located at 3851 Stirling Road for the project known as Koosh Living. I support and am in favor of the re-zoning request and the site plan. The proposed development will be a welcome addition to the City of Dania Beach, and it goes well with th- .=. adef all" Sig Lure e jobs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly.Sincerely,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 May 2nd,2022 Re: Re-Zoning for Property at 3851 Stirling Road/Koosh Living Dear Mayor and City Commissioners: H: My name is ‘csa..,,cy,p.0. and?live at 3,' •5 U , C. 3s<zza I have reviewed the proposed re-zoning and the site plan for the 10-acre parcel located at 3851 Stirling Road for the project known as Koosh Living. I support and am in favor of the re-zoning request and the site plan. The proposed development will be a welcome addition to the City of Dania Beach, and it goes well with the area. Signaturebs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly. Sincerely,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+ J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 May 2nd,2022 Re: Re-Zoning for Property at 3851 Stirling Road/Koosh Living Dear Mayor and City m Commissioners: My name is U GA.10QSG,l and I live at S)V1 5(},} 21 46 Dania Beach,FL. I have reviewed the proposed re-zoning and the site plan for the 10-acre parcel located at 3851 Stirling Road for the project known as Koosh Living. I support and am in favor of the re-zoning request and the site plan. The proposed development will be a welcome addition to the City of Dania Beach,and it goes well with the area. Signature ell with the area.Signature bs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly.Sincerely,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 May 2nd,2022 Re: Re-Zoning for Property at 3851 Stirling Road/Koosh Living Dear Mayor and City Commissioners: My name is A GIL. and I live at SI'g61 Sw 2$AI Dania Beach,FL. I have reviewed the proposed re-zoning and the site plan for the 10-acre parcel located at 3851 Stirling Road for the project known as Koosh Living. I support and am in favor of the re-zoning request and the site plan. The op e development will be a welcome addition to the City of Dania Beach, and it goes we 'th ea. Signs e Signature ell with the area. Signature bs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly.Sincerely,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 May 2nd,2022 Re: Re-Zoning for Property at 3851 Stirling Road/Koosh Living Dear Mayor and City Commissioners: 1 My name is I ten J j uypyt and I live at .2 i Qr .f E' ` ,Dania Beach, FL. I have reviewed the proposed re-zoning and the site plan for the 10-acre parcel located at 3851 Stirling Road for the project known as Koosh Living. I support and am in favor of the re-zoning request and the site plan. The proposed development will be a welcome addition to the City of Dania Beach,and it goes well with the area. Signa Signature bs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly.Sincerely,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M? 1. 41 tif 11 0 May 2nd,2022 Re: Re-Zoning for Property at 3851 Stirling Road/Koosh Living Dear Mayor and City Commissioners: My name is /< Avi KnuryegNhd I live at l%.3 u+,6cac.r bit C er , Dania Beach, FL. I have reviewed the proposed re-zoning and the site plan for the 10-acre parcel located at 3851 Stirling Road for the project known as Koosh Living. I support and am in favor of the re-zoning request and the site plan. The proposed development will be a welcome addition to the City of Dania Beach, and it goes well with the area. Signature Signature bs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly.Sincerely,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4. sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 May 2nd,2022 Re: Re-Zoning for Property at 3851 Stirling Road/Koosh Living Dear Mayor and City Commissioners: My name is 4/1 / S and I live at $446' S 4J . f 7p c ,Dania Beach,FL. I have reviewed the proposed re-zoning and the site plan for the 10-acre parcel located at 3851 Stirling Road for the project known as Koosh Living. I support and am in favor of the re-zoning request and the site plan. The proposed development will be a welcome addition to the City of Dania Beach, and it goes well with the area. 441474— SignaSignature Signature bs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly.Sincerely,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M? 1. 41 tif 11 0 May 2nd,2022 Re: Re-Zoning for Property at 3851 Stirling Road/Koosh Living Dear Mayor and City Commissioners: My name is A 13ekr es^#"'ih and I live at Y03 Z. 51." 7 Dania Beach,FL. I have reviewed the proposed re-zoning and the site plan for the 10-acre parcel located at 3851 Stirling Road for the project known as Koosh Living. I support and am in favor of the re-zoning request and the site plan. The proposed development will be a welcome addition to the City of Dania Beach, and it goes well with the area. Signaturenature Signaturebs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly.Sincerely,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4. sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 May 2°d,2022 Re: Re-Zoning for Property at 3 851 Stirling Road/Koosh Living Dear Mayor and City Commissioners: My name is A ti ;d i4i' and I live at 2( _s 0,:,2 q• MKDania Beach,FL. I have reviewed the proposed re-zoning and the site plan for the 10-acre parcel located at 3851 Stirling Road for the project known as Koosh Living. I support and am in favor of the re-zoning request and the site plan. The proposed development will be a welcome addition to the City of Dania Beach, and it goes well with the area. tO;Z:i9///4-x• Signature Signature bs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly.Sincerely,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 May 2nd,2022 Re: Re-Zoning for Property at 3851 Stirling Road/Koosh Living Dear Mayor and City Commissioners: My name isPE- A- -LE live at '7 d ,Dania Beach,FL. I have reviewed the proposed re-zoning and the site pl for the 1 -acre located at 3851 Stirling Road for the project known as Koosh Living. I support and am in favor of the re-zoning request and the site plan. The ' ropo -d development will be a welcome addition to the City of Dania Beach, and it goes wi:d 'th e area. i4.1fAi 1011P tore Signature bs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly. Sincerely,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+ J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 May 2"d,2022 Re: Re-Zoning for Property at 3851 Stirling Road/Koosh Living Dear Mayor and City Commissioners: My name is 1`tf and I live at .3,2 01 Grill rh iPea Dania Beach,FL. I have reviewed the proposed re-zoning and the site plan for the 10-acre parcel located at 3851 Stirling Road for the project known as Koosh Living. I support and am in favor of the re-zoning request and the site plan. The proposed development will be a welcome addition to the City of Dania Beach, and it goes well with the area. se. /../..• 4/4tie" ignature tore Signature bs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly.Sincerely,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 May 2nd,2022 Re: Re-Zoning for Property at 3851 Stirling Road/Koosh Living Dear Mayor and City Commissioners: My name is 5cc c,*AC( and I live at .D01 6-fsICc n Dania Beach, FL. I have reviewed the proposed re-zoning and the site plan for the 10-acre parcel located at 3851 Stirling Road for the project known as Koosh Living. I support and am in favor of the re-zoning request and the site plan. The proposed development will be a welcome addition to the City of Dania Beach, and it goes 11 with the area. Signature ignature tore Signature bs the project will create, it will help with the housing shortage greatly.Sincerely,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4. sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 From:American Metals Sent: Friday, May 6,2022 8:21 AM To:tamarajames@daniabeachfl.gov;msalvino@daniabeachfl.gov;jdavis@daniabeachfl.gov; Ilewellen@daniabeachfl.gov; lodman@daniabeachfl.gov Cc: hsepler@aol.com;Stephanie Jofe Subject: RZ-055-21,3851 Stirling Rd Holdings Good morning Commissioner My name is Barry Reichenberg. I've lived on SW 37th Terrace for 28 years and have been a Dania resident for 50 years. I'm 78 years old I'm vehemently opposed to the rezoning of the abovementioned property from E-1 to PRDA. While the project itself is interesting, it is totally out of place in an area dominated by million dollar plus estate- type homes and should be constructed elsewhere Much of the area surrounding and adjacent to the subject property is unique.There are oak trees that are over 100 years old.There is wildlife such as foxes, raccoons, possums, harmless snakes,squirrels and bob-cats.There are 49 different species of birds including eagles and hawks and owls.The rezoning of the property and subsequent construction of the proposed project would completely destroy the environment,ecology and tranquility of this area The proposed project brings little benefit to the City of Dania Beach. It is destructive. It does bring major benefit to the developers, most of whom have no connection to our city except for the profits they can milk from it. I ask that you look closely at the developers proposal and application for rezoning.. It contains many inaccuracies or falsifications purported to be fact I respectfully remind all of you that you were elected by your electorate to represent the will of the people of Dania as well as to manage the affairs of the city.Those who have chosen to voice opinions about this project are overwhelmingly against it I URGE ALL OF YOU TO VOTE AGAINST THE REZONING OF THIS LAND AND CONSTRUCTION OF THIS PROJECT Thank you Barry Reichenberg, President, Harger Hills Area Neighborhood Association able places to live, but we also need to protect against climate change and maintain livability in the area. I'm asking that you find a better balance that best works with schools that already exist there and the limitations of Stirling Road and 40th, especially regarding new homes already scheduled for 40th Avenue.Thank you for your time and consideration.Sincerely,Megan Emery 3839 SW 56 Street Dania Beach, FL 33312 d.,and the area behind you is zoned E-1, Estate homes and agricultural and is an easement area with many specimen oak trees,you have an expectation that you have moved into a neighborhood that the city,your city,that you voted to become part of,would never allow developers to build a tall apartment building with a noisy, polluting loading dock directly behind your home. It is truly unconscionable for the City of Dania Beach to allow this to happen to us.This type of development should be concentrated downtown or in Dania Point where there already are tall buildings, restaurants and entertainment within walking distance.When they purchased this property,the developers knew the property was zoned for 1 acre estate homes which would be compatible with our neighborhood.They can build the ten one-acre estate ment adjacent to the 4 community area planning,and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation- 3 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc. 18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3.23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20- year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices( MUTCD)for the school' s primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop-off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication report(IJR); served as the task leader for the preparation of the state environmental From: Elias Bichachi<ebichachi@gmail.com> Date: May 9,2022 at 8:05:10 PM EDT To: "James,Tamara"<tamarajames@daniabeachfl.gov>, "Salvino, Marco" msalvino@daniabeachfl.gov>, "Davis,Joyce" <jdavis@daniabeachfl.gov>, "Lewellen, Lori" Ilewellen@daniabeachfl.gov>, "Odman, Lauren" <lodman@daniabeachfl.gov> Cc:Gabi<slpgabi@gmail.com> Subject:Vote Against RZ-055-21: RZ-055-212 3851 Stirling Holdings, LLLP Good evening Mayor,Vice Mayor,&Commissioners, I am writing to you today as a concerned resident of Dania Beach and neighbor of the proposed development, in regards to the Rezoning application RZ-055-21 by Stirling Holdings, LLLP. I kindly ask that you vote against the rezoning of this property for the reasons listed below: 1. This vote is not about approving the development of this property, it is a vote to change the zoning from E-1 to PRD-1.The developer can still build on this property with the current zoning allowed. The proposed development simply does not fit with the surrounding properties.The proposed six story building with flex space would be surrounded by single family homes.The higher units will no doubt look into the residences on 37th Terr.There is simply not enough tree coverage to block the line of vision. Besides the small commercial area to the east of the property,everything is zoned for Low(5) Residential to Low-Medium (10) Residential. It is a big jump to request a property to be changed from Estate Residential to PRD-1,with the plans to have 231 units. Please see the attached PRD-1.pdf that shows that the proposed development is consistent with the city's comprehensive plan. Nor is it the proposed development compatible with existing and conforming developments, and proposed developments in the area surrounding the project site. 2. The infrastructure simply cannot handle this development.The traffic is already a big problem in the mornings and afternoons.The proposed development is right in front of a high school and diagonally facing an elementary school. Now the proposed property will be adding 404 parking spots that will bring potentially 404 additional vehicles to the area.The proposed property has only one entrance in and out potentially impacting traffic even more to the area. Please see the attached Traffic PDF for your review. If you notice on the PDF you will see that SW 37th Terr&SW 37th Ave are right turns only out of those streets, so the only way to go eastbound is to make the U-Turn in front of the high school.The same applies for the proposed development.They will have to cross 3 lanes of traffic just to make the U turn either in front of the High School or travel further down to 56th to make that U-Turn.To add further strain to the area if the tenants of the proposed property are coming from the west(ie.The Hard Rock Hotel&Casino),the only way for them to get home is to make the U-Turn at 37th Ave.There is not a specific light for turns on that street, it usually gets backed up with traffic now, and it currently makes it very difficult for the residences of SW 37th Ave&SW 37th Terr to get home.The homes on SW 36 Terr this property,the developers knew the property was zoned for 1 acre estate homes which would be compatible with our neighborhood.They can build the ten one-acre estate ment adjacent to the 4 community area planning,and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation-3 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815- 4298 As of 3.23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake, Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources. US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration. North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD)for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement will not incur as much traffic as they can get to the U-Turn on Sarazen.This development will make it a logistical nightmare for the current residences,school system and businesses. 3. This proposed development will no doubt increase crime in the area.With shops there is always crime.There are already issues with the children from the high school at the Dunkin Donuts. I spoke with a security official from the high school who advised me that they have issues with kids skipping school and traveling to the area by the Dunkin Donuts to partake in illegal activity.The security has had to work closely with BSO in some cases. Now the property will be building a park with basketball courts for an added appeal for that same element to go elsewhere, but now closer to the surrounding residences. 4.Lastly and probably the most important is the safety of the school children.There is no crosswalk currently at the Dunkin Donuts. Children currently cross Stirling Road unfortunately not at the crosswalks at the 56th Ave or Sarazen,they do it right at the middle between those two streets. It is the shortest distance to their destination,although it is not the safest and correct one. Right now it is a dangerous situation, but if you are adding stores and a park, I imagine the situation will only worsen. I fear that if this is approved and developed we may unfortunately hear a horrible story about a tragic accident of a child not crossing a street properly on their way to the development's park or stores. I want to thank you all for taking the time to read my email and hope you can see why this rezoning of this estate property(E-1)to a PRD-1 should not be approved,and the land should be used as initially intended to build estate homes. Best Regards, Eli Elias A. Bichachi, MBA,CIPS,SFR, LEED AP Bichachi Realty, PLLC C: (786)493-8698 oblem in the mornings and afternoons.The proposed development is right in front of a high school and diagonally facing an elementary school. Now the proposed property will be adding 404 parking spots that will bring potentially 404 additional vehicles to the area.The proposed property has only one entrance in and out potentially impacting traffic even more to the area. Please see the attached Traffic PDF for your review.If you notice on the PDF you will see that SW 37th Terr& SW 37th Ave are right turns only out of those streets, so the only way to go eastbound is to make the U-Turn in front of the high school.The same applies for the proposed development.They will have to cross 3 lanes of traffic just to make the U turn either in front of the High School or travel further down to 56th to make that U-Turn.To add further strain to the area if the tenants of the proposed property are coming from the west(ie.The Hard Rock Hotel&Casino),the only way for them to get home is to make the U-Turn at 37th Ave.There is not a specific light for turns on that street, it usually gets backed up with traffic now, and it currently makes it very difficult for the residences of SW 37th Ave&SW 37th Terr to get home.The homes on SW 36 Terr this property,the developers knew the property was zoned for 1 acre estate homes which would be compatible with our neighborhood.They can build the ten one-acre estate ment adjacent to the 4 community area planning,and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation-3 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3.23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control From: RICK@thedeliguy.com <rick@thedeliguy.com> Sent:Tuesday, May 10, 2022 4:24 PM To:James,Tamara<tamarajames@daniabeachfl.gov>; Lajoie, Corinne<clajoie@daniabeachfl.gov> Cc: RICK@thedeliguy.com;yankeegir123@bellsouth.net Subject: KOOSH LIVING ON STIRLING ROAD My name is Rick Bruskin. My family has been living in Arapahoe Farms,on Stirling Road,for 20 years. My wife Jodi and I are in full support of the project Koosh Living on Stirling Road.Our understanding is this project will open new affordable living accommodations severely need in our community.Thank you for considering the Koosh Project. RICK BRUSKIN THE DELI GUY 954 290 1501 RICK@THEDELIGUY.COM ly, Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 From: Rosalind Hodges<puddyhodges@gmail.com> Sent:Tuesday, May 10,2022 1:39 PM To:Schneider,Thomas<tschneider@daniabeachfl.gov> Subject: REZONING of 3851 Stirling I have had conflicting communication about this hearing request but please be sure my input is on the record and available for the commissioners before a decision is made. I strongly oppose the rezoning of this area because: 1-This will create a dangerous traffic situation as tenants enter and exit on Stirling Road, particularly but not only during school arrival and dismissal hours of Hollywood Hills High and Stirling Elementary. The danger will be first and foremost to students, bus and carpool drivers. The danger will also be to other drivers in an area where traffic frequently backs up during opening and closing of business hours. I urge commissioners to visit this area during these hours several times to experience this in person. 2-This will be another loss of green space in an area already losing a lot of grass and foliage. This deficit greatly impacts climate change in the long term as well as the short term. I hope the commissioners will study, if they have not already done so, how the loss of green space impacts the quality of air we breathe as well as our overall wellbeing. Cities like Los Angeles are realizing this now, late,and taking steps to insert green spaces back into their area. Planting trees in the Everglades does not help our area. Previous rezoning in our area has allowed tree removal, restricted tree removal,and permitted tree relocation. Some of the restrictions have not been observed and relocations not monitored; as a result,trees have been lost. 3-This will be a challenge for Dania to manage oversight of development and to provide quality services for current residents. Thank you for your consideration. R. Marjorie Hodges 3920 SW 56th Street mornings and afternoons.The proposed development is right in front of a high school and diagonally facing an elementary school. Now the proposed property will be adding 404 parking spots that will bring potentially 404 additional vehicles to the area.The proposed property has only one entrance in and out potentially impacting traffic even more to the area. Please see the attached Traffic PDF for your review.If you notice on the PDF you will see that SW 37th Terr&SW 37th Ave are right turns only out of those streets, so the only way to go eastbound is to make the U-Turn in front of the high school.The same applies for the proposed development.They will have to cross 3 lanes of traffic just to make the U turn either in front of the High School or travel further down to 56th to make that U-Turn.To add further strain to the area if the tenants of the proposed property are coming from the west(ie.The Hard Rock Hotel&Casino),the only way for them to get home is to make the U-Turn at 37th Ave.There is not a specific light for turns on that street, it usually gets backed up with traffic now, and it currently makes it very difficult for the residences of SW 37th Ave&SW 37th Terr to get home. The homes on SW 36 Terr this property, the developers knew the property was zoned for 1 acre estate homes which would be compatible with our neighborhood.They can build the ten one-acre estate ment adjacent to the 4 community area planning,and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation-3 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,# 313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3.23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD)for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services 41 A:k 90 N Z 0 L W 11 N E W oz H90 Cc: RICK@thedeliguy.com;yankeegir123@bellsouth.net Subject: KOOSH LIVING ON STIRLING ROAD My name is Rick Bruskin. My family has been living in Arapahoe Farms,on Stirling Road,for 20 years. My wife Jodi and I are in full support of the project Koosh Living on Stirling Road.Our understanding is this project will open new affordable living accommodations severely need in our community.Thank you for considering the Koosh Project.RICK BRUSKIN THE DELI GUY 954 290 1501 RICK@THEDELIGUY. COM ly,Joseph Krasner RN hank you very much Sarah Laredo 4.sp Cr) A+ J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 r-, 1w, kr-1t°s_ i_kL_7'i4.3il1*..'''o, t-; mw,— E_••• i•'a. r,__' i g40k".w- Q:•- a' t__. T i ,- L 1-_ V•'- g.,„--).. 17I.. 7;. 1I:.1,.-.-, i;, t1.•'.1, 1l- o•.,, c.SZ4d,.CA.l' r• iI..wnlo'.l. ijwt. k.smi—:. t rliul1va lfb N — .. j 3 815-U1 31131 6021 8 ' a,_" ' _ 1 rqili, i i 4 ii0 ,e O y. . "4 lw !,' filAillicrJflik ittillikl 1 - • r i w..r..- _..3AV HAM;INS. _ i Flit ri, • IRO % ors tit, oir_."41t.L- -2-1) 64i 14 arrT491111] iY.-KD-, T /„ 3- I c 3 i 4i i IiI kM - •- trt;i,tr Q M tll) OOOMHSV c Wa t”. 41 , t 1 r y y r;3 1111 - ' Grotiiii7 Illitil&LE11211111i.. POO Intl i „ -1: -1,,_ , # -a ilk -- . 4 ' IV') • ror ',10, ...., , cn . 1.. 4 ' - r i as to .+ 1 litbi* '- 07.7• ,.''''. 0 sue.I VI. 11‘ mow mum r •' ' c.,'.- V- 1• 111 log:cA=. 1 S1-1i39TH AVE. _H 55TN AVEv y !}' j tw 1 F. I il s;iet ,6;:r14 i i AIM yy r. di L .. N to 0 ' ia ) t — lip 1 a, r I 1, MI60TH ST STIRUH lip r urrent residents.Thank you for your consideration.R. Marjorie Hodges 3920 SW 56th Street mornings and afternoons. The proposed development is right in front of a high school and diagonally facing an elementary school. Now the proposed property will be adding 404 ii,,,,,,...- . .;17111..-- ...`' 11- 1 pi".., . 1_ 1 '1 .. . I ,,,*, . , ,i k j[DRFIE M f ..r.I 't 1 i \ i i • I - 1..,21 - ' IS 1 \ 0 It 01 1 rh,7 I, , - ,/. . .,' I) Ilig r• G I I r i V4 i .1 1 a 1114116` it ,.... . t. , ` :,,,,...t.....11.„4.4,..40; 11:. , i.,".:.` 4_:, 7.....i.-::7.,...c.:7-_,.... i.•,:irt, 1 it 41 l 30,. SW 35TH AV} H 55IHPAVF 1. 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 ca c C) al I- 3 aQ c a'U U 0 z o g ') o U F.; a o oE a o r 4.4 W u) 7- 1 h TS a' y b o w rn 2Cy O G 0 a0i 0 o 6 o Q CL y m 3 3 00o • o,w a' Z Qai ..+, p Q ';° V j wN O° NO i UWW . N N C3. 4 a ) •y otio on n o LQ° i-.tA oUUccoi a' a'h L co Q p U U o 0. x oAowea v -4pp 0 51' a' zr • a.) i A an w 0 6.0' o c"' O a) a — C 0a)a' C) 0 3 Q ctQ. v v p gP d g c4a' w w w Cl.'i"ai 0' Li ai 4 4a gF.4 N M tw 1 F. I ils;iet , 6;:r14 i i AIM yy r. di L .. N to 0 ' ia ) t — lip 1 a,r I 1, MI60TH ST STIRUH lip r urrent residents.Thank you for your consideration. R. Marjorie Hodges 3920 SW 56th Street mornings and afternoons. The proposed development is right in front of a high school and diagonally facing an elementary school. Now the proposed property will be adding 404 parking spots that will bring potentially 404 additional vehicles to the area. The proposed property has only one entrance in and out potentially impacting traffic even more to the 4.11. 1 W2" M 7 g i 9 „ 41: V 1,lq%ggl.a ,.. fil li gll gWg 9 V"-gb dItli Lti ii7 P n'. P" i i- r. * . It3 -I t5-.. §E§ .,, vte.. .4%-a.,;12 2 3 Alild IFfET T.' ?Ail; fli104 ! 0 = qgd:2 Ili iti !;' 2;11 thrii; di ii 1 6:J::Zi NI 'Miiiiqr- iliglq ' b .; A Ht: OA 1;10C,Wieli 2; 0; :f4 f g % ...... .! klif irg - 1"...,i-Aq veil. D.44 .1!inl, Aelliowlipbt°6i0144 i, ' g d II qr,ifAirMir!,10i14 !RM.. 1'3°! 04;M011104a4lx4Atui tgi-T3 V? Ull et-641 Oy li' 4 ng pi atm/m.443;i— A5/ flw! t4 05C I i g I, t- liii i. . . P.,y o i a t T5-Wle: I ____ ____ _I Isioure: r------ g.ik,,.1o19 I 011111i PiNitt k nt11111 I 4asekits999'cli2414446'41...,,g,,,E9 pi. 0,4/4,,.. I 1USI!,.9905elalaliaki99.919,,..9:1C4izthikill99149199.99I91,-•91.1911014129940099, ip6991.1.99 }4IILI1....,99.SS 9 99 hiS}}91991991091.99..6999.919 9ik9991,9195.911919199999, 1496, 141116 i 11111111 litilliabilln9111111111111111111 li 11 OW 1 11 a Oil 140SHEN: i ' 13 igi 13i 3it .i0 7 3 i k11111101111114114 41141110 191/1411111111111f1111111 111111114iill .,I' I t I 11 i WU il IIJU III I 1,1 I ii BIW H .ISP'i ii sniumilignp.).”., RIF.5,53ilaS35[CSIB.359'5?3°.IE1.21.112 ro, i,i,,,......k...1....A.1...1.4.,1,...1,.. . .4.,...1,......m...4k.4 4i99,99299y1,9990141,199.411119991;1904,9'.9,9411sk iitt9i91,7929+1999999.94991919,0”911149119999.444,, 11}1I4o,•9i9999991111lItilkk,ItikYkk9919119999919i9.991191119999919b1999999914;99399999h91.49969 I tgiIfillInnInf11111VIMPISHM1111! 111114 IOU ittliP111111114.P17.'' 4' 0 li I s• IE . I 1 ill IE 3h 44W 11P1111/Piti1011411114011111111V0111011t1111414111144iitilifilirT 6!;$ YO 1 all k Pgd qig 4 the area if the tenants of the proposed property are coming from the west( ie.The Hard Rock Hotel&Casino),the only way for them to get home is to make the U-Turn at 37th Ave.There is not a specific light for turns on that street, it usually gets backed up with traffic now, and it currently makes it very difficult for the residences of SW 37th Ave&SW 37th Terr to get home.The homes on SW 36 Terr this property,the developers knew the property was zoned for 1 acre estate homes which would be compatible with our neighborhood.They can build the ten one-acre estate ment adjacent to the 4 community area planning,and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation-3 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3.23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration. North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD) for the school' s primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop-off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication report(IJR); served as the task leader for the preparation of the state environmental impact report(SEIR); conducted the interchange operational analysis reports(IOAR)for the adjacent interchanges and developed the public involvement program.Page 2 of 3 Mt_ y y P 1E : ¢ III 3 i i'; aI: •11, 9 a F l°10 c 5ill3S1. H I Si$SRe \ ` 1, 00 i 1'Ee,a c 1 h o i atz, ,,m a.: N' 'ten.0t4 avow 3i ^Nntii... .,, ira WI1,3F•. ,' ro+.ai a fl o t-1, 1;•—._ list t1111 i ' ill::::aa. 4, I a° 9r ' i i III !) ii a — I 1{ i I'A Y,. 1iIf, , ig: i 'Ij• I 11 fib. I A II 1 1 '11 I 11 ji ' 4.,: z; -—/ ---' / li 11 i11 fi iii ° 11 ililtgt 1 if , i i t 1 i ' I— -_ ! C f IF 9, F- 11 Atj 11 6 Eji .41 1 — = a4 1 i j I 1 i i i y u 11, 1 . 1 ! it ; 1 ;'. q! I 1 1 1 Ill ! 10 li tz Op 9 IIrk i i 1 lI}1 1 1 pI 1i I' a e,' TAO al t 11111 I 4asekits999' cli2414446' 41...,,g,,,E9 pi. 0, 4/ 4,,..I 1 USI!,.9905elalaliaki99.919,,.. 9: 1C4izthikill99149199.99I91,-• 91. 1911014129940099,ip6991. 1.99 }4IILI1....,99.SS 9 99 hiS}} 91991991091. 99..6999.919 9ik9991,9195.911919199999,1496, 141116 i 11111111 litilliabilln9111111111111111111 li 11 OW 1 11 a Oil 140 SHEN: i ' 13 igi 13i 3it .i 0 7 3 i k11111101111114114 41141110 191/1411111111111f1111111 111111114 i ill .,I' I t I 11 i WU il IIJU III I 1,1 I ii BIW H .ISP'i ii sniumilignp.).”., RIF.5,53ilaS35[ ii mal uo. 17 w 1 gg€i m i 1 Viti# '# I# # ,#10 i#I# Of 201-1 11 856eSaE€ I`S 3 4 a Iifi I 130,i1.egk - ARR ` ire' 4Ta r t 0 k C JO Z 133HS 335 3N11 HOMY 1 — J 1 ----I—--T-r--i 1 l'ii- 1—i t_ ; Le= 1 i 11 i 1 li i ; '; 41; i i n_> ijIt .' 11 l j I ' ll 1 III ; e i.1 1 1 i( s1 I II 1 1 I'l 1 i pkip'' i i I I tit 1i i e e 0 4; 1 t CL, i 11i1 1 1 i i ` 1 11 I I I I l 1 1k, I I I. I i I 1 I 11+ III I i I I 1 e l 111 i $ 171ifnIi I 1 i 1 la - ,1Ar11iii1f I 1 i 1 i. i 1 III III 1. : I ;I 0-, 11 i1 , ei Int iii gi i y¢!iyr if' 1 lei iii : i Hi I° i t. 1 11 II ! 1 1e, 1igp i I 1 i I i I I` i 1 I i ; i h ! p PR is s 1 Z I I 1 1 i1 i 5 1 1 I I 1 1 I i , 4i:... 1 $: I I i i 1 i N l i I 1 I I 1 I I I p — .- I i I I I I I I , I 1 1, i i '1 I 1 WI 1 1 1 i I 1 1 1 1 '111 1 1 e e i 1 1 1 I I l i 1,- * i i 5 a , Ii1 I I 1 1 1 11 i Lt i 19II ! 111 1 1 11. 'T i' v 1 19 1 i, i I 1 ;E- I I) i t i i 1 i 1 1 '. I'` o,' 1 i f I I 1 t 5 &I 1 s. i i 1 1. , ii 6. Ill i 1"-* x 1 1 ' I I i 1 1l i e l'. L 1 1 e I i 1 ,gi ; I y1t ' -- I I IiI o f i y ' I I F' i i t 1 1. .. ..i.,., se I I w a ii111in111i r'is'a• 1-----------' gPgdqig4theareaifthetenantsoftheproposedpropertyarecomingfromthewest(ie.The Hard Rock Hotel&Casino),the only way for them to get home is to make the U-Turn at 37th Ave.There is not a specific light for turns on that street, it usually gets backed up with traffic now, and it currently makes it very difficult for the residences of SW 37th Ave&SW 37th Terr to get home.The homes on SW 36 Terr this property,the developers knew the property was zoned for 1 acre estate homes which would be compatible with our neighborhood.They can build the ten one-acre estate ment adjacent to the 4 community area planning,and zoning codes. Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation-3 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises, Inc. 18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815- 4298 As of 3.23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD)for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop- off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication report(IJR); served as the task leader for the preparation of the state environmental impact report( b.0 C N 0 v , U U L 0 U. L_ 0 U w a) o cn o i al U N C C0 4.; Z u E N 4- CD O o re)— M N en J o E E L. L a) 0 v_ I c 0 tr) 0 a; o 0 < OC - (NI a, o C M M 0 oI M N a_ 1 it 41 l 30,. SW 35TH AV} H 55IHPAVF 1. 2 V1111 1 3 41 3, M?1. 41 tif 11 0 0 ct E E 0 u 1z) 0 8 c s_ c, 0 o ed a)0 L 6404-) 7,-ci a) Ttj -c) •c c 'V a •- (1) a) 4.) I) E :1-1 4-I 7' ' I I) cl) E (t 0 § 0 E E = tlo to E cut"' ._ 't Lc) 11-3 1 0 U D 21 CI 0-. l 30,. SW 35TH AV} H 55IHPAVF 1.2 V1111 1 3 41 3, M?1. 41 tif 11 0 g II t A Ji il. r ViH19ti , r_. tit < tN lib 071-3r cr., ri. wie rrtiEr piLs.:41.2 et,ilig 1 t •1 4' I 1 Apt NIK1' 1 Jllt k I ii L4 J J! , - . ° *: 1 rz. lobo' Iiii;itthlW 14416.1114.; l 1 , ll 0 M31t1.1531iOV iii or-or UNilo 441 M tila UOOMNStl a r t 1a. 4311- 1, 11,,,1418 MSt!!3V.1p'Oinj ,,1 1 r• ,-, l I sr O 3nv's s,n5,n tjaiosnNpriaucilL. fiS------I D ' I. ra. Y ratter,... ti y Fr'Hii= I a 0 t__ jot=..._,..e,, :-._ ' ii.407 I r ilic 4‘ 1 i ' NIIIII2 ,,,,,,,4 -W 55TN AVE^ r i L. Sy 39TH AVE 11 ine1111 ii,x t.W • ,. V I 11 .. AVER r+. _S AfE ___. 0,,,lidi r..b a 1 t 4 M. rIA t , I 0TH^ST I•RL RDT I i i 1 i N l i I 1 I I 1 I I I p — .- I i I I I I I I , I 1 1, i i '1 I 1 WI 1 1 1 i I 1 1 1 1 '111 1 1 e e i 1 1 1 I I l i 1,- *i i 5 a , Ii1 I I 1 1 1 11 i Lt i 19II ! 111 1 1 11. 'T i'v 1 19 1 i, i I 1 ;E-I I) i cn 0 0 s-- 0 cn CU b.- ° v) a) c tt a u s...4-) a) a) 0c 1) E t OE mi Z En a) tJ -0 ZC S.— ..›. ci) •_ LLI ca.. c •-i--) c CZ 10 0 _ a) *E" c o ed — o 0 .i...--) ccZ0N — 0 ce cn 7:3 C) (1) 04 (t I Z C •r_ s 0- v) tv_ a) 1 v•V L.l— 4-1 E "47., L.,o cuCev) cd E a. 040 0 04 0 0 a- c c 4-) 0 m V) 0 e w•li o C) 0 c a) L. c s- ri s_ c ) 2ud4—J V) cc UJ u c cu at U L v) 0 v) a) a)0 E (43 42 6 B E Ll) ( ) a) cd 0 0 u cd •>< a) u _s 1±-- z u p — .- I i III I I I , I 1 1, ii ' 1 I 1 WI 1 1 1 i I 1 1 1 1 '111 1 1 e e i 1 1 1 I I l i 1,- *i i 5 a , Ii1 I I 1 1 1 11 i Lt i 19II ! 111 1 1 11. 'T i' v 1 19 1 i, i I 1 ;E-I I) i t i i 1 i 1 1 '. I'`o,' 1 i f I I 1 t 5 &I 1 s. i i 1 1. , i i 6.Ill i 1"-* f- =ill i e A 1 1 Z IEEE li 14DV38 VINVO crvoa pNnaus tsar i 1!,11 i 4 E*- ,_. vsri ii '";"—Nin—ITH—s70-51--1 gg vi VIVO 1.13(0114 ,,,, .-, qi Vl IPI NI x (I) WM 1115 0350d011d i illi t i.,t aull.ara , -. Id ci 1: ul E. 1„ ... oili, ;;;' ,ii.!,:i i,:, t ji 11 1,.!;•ti; ,i,,,ii: i 1 2. 1 i 1 i I,,..1!i ilc, q , 11,'5.;* A a;ir i , ' - '''''''I. • 1;!; Ili'01 15 /1 11 .t lh'! 4'P5 I' 1 vily dia e I iI., i ., ,-,, IT 1 1 1 1 . tai:•ftirt,A.' i 11 /;_, t i LK if , el r i 141if,1,:i ;kJ , .i. * 1I +'-.`••• - f'd I -r Is 1. ' EN 1 Il C *. :, 4 i,41I 7,, ' I*.,... k*.*1 t--• ' I I, I . .• "Ir' ' ' : -1 i . e C s 1t ' I1 1 1,1sot 4Ili):Ifni N 0.:i.,. I b ins f., o , I -V"' 541 I '.: ,,, 1`,,,-, .t , ) 1 - ' i 1 zw-simmiliiimsor ,It II - , v"reglEIZIMINI P < ,, . 74" .421-TP-sVi2— ; R? 421 i •. ... ....... .• - 4 e 0101 tel111111 1 f v II I 3 p._ Ogl :... • : ' 4,,,".- cNi F' i i t 1 1. .. ..i.,.,se I I w a ii 11 1 in 1 1 1 i r'is'a• 1-----------' g Pgd qig 4 the area if the tenants of the proposed L41. / 1 y 4. k 0t i41144.t. 55th-Et'-----...----- 144,.. .-,_, 1,,,,,, - 0:!,-1. ,..,•;-4 H- '. 441!': 4 Aly y ii ' a if- t d a + i a. p S f,...:-,,-:,g.„"Z, - .T., .,.•,, ,c.,.4):11' .4,..'ar .. . . . dT r:.' 1'!w tea -v.:- it i- , i c; t s rdko , r irA 4 r4s<' iMSawiiR Ca•I q. kii4 3 K„ n 45 O'. t sa .. i o } M .,0 . t< r t ,;$4t \. - i X Aft' V, i,` ',...;„ I, ;.;,;' 4"... 7.;'. 1' 4:-;1 f.ii. ';''-;;-; ii '; i ' : ii 'i ''';';'"'''; '''' S -;';'.4'4' ; ''' -:"-;;.''''' 44'. •,Air..., P t' 741 ;. a .` •,.-"..... la y m ks fie. d .. ,_•' t I r,.n, ;le, l( f,,,*ir*t ir rt. f t S • i. rT off . s' hi t>a.>r.a as•_ ' ' a 1 - ' i 1 zw-simmiliiimsor ,ItI I - , v" reglEIZIMINIP < ,, . 74" .421-TP- sVi2— ; R?4 2 1 i •. ... ....... .• - 4 e0101 tel1111111 f v II I3p._ Ogl :... • : ' 4,,,".-cNi F' i i t 11. .. ..i.,.,se I Iwa ii 11 1 in 1 11ir'is' a• 1-----------' g Pgd qig 4thearea ifthe tenants of the proposed property are coming from the west(ie.The Hard Rock Hotel&Casino),the only way for them to get home is to make the U-Turn at 37th Ave.There is not a specific light for turns on that street, it usually gets backed up I Y.to 1 a P .. r r y t 9 to 1 _ i . I.7,,m7„.. 77,„ --.,....7,,,-- .. hll E .,.„..t 4.! ., ..!..,. 77. 4.,.. 2 ; t E'e£.. / i',,,,j '. '' :' ' :4-':- .. r.i./— ,::--,---• ., 0)41, . '.... ram:-,I dgpp a 4:r- -...: 4:__:_;., , 7-i' • 'ri 4 Ivv.; 4:. i 0 U D 21CI0-.l 30,. SW 35THAV} H 55IHPAVF1. 2 V1111 1 3 41 3, M? 1. 41 tif 11 0 t *fi,i ; I;;;;; I. ;" I; dam, E 3i tali 4 PR 21 1 i r j--1 i IN c ra s d it iI re E 1 k Ii ,,+'x'arm ...., t y Slip h s.-2. "If WM 1 c '- lie : -„,.. 4,x,z„ M Y1 I M Y4 As t -irl MI i,q t. T. y 3 t i m {'t 1' dY... 1 a- f_ T Y RIB x~ y to L Li r 1 1 yill‘ 14.1, t:..i-3.'-• ,''' Oil :,, .-‘,4,,.,0,,;;„ 11 I;''ail x a 1 elle i o } M .,0 .t< r t ,;$ 4t \. - i X Aft' V, i,` ',...;„ I, ;.;,;' 4"...7.;'.1' 4:-;1 f.ii. ';''-;;-; ii '; i ' : ii 'i ''';';'"'''; ''''S -;';'.4'4' ; ''' -:"-;;.''''' 44'. •, Air..., P t' 741 ;. a .` •,.-"..... la y m ks fie. d .. ,_•' t I r,.n, ; le, l( f,,,*ir*t ir rt. f t S • i.rT off . s'hi t> a.>r. a as•_ ' ' a 1 - ' i 1 zw-simmiliiimsor ,ItII - , v"reglEIZIMINI P < ,, . 74" .421-TP-sVi2— ; R?4 2 1 i •. ... ....... .• - 4e0101 tel111111 1 f v II I3p._ Ogl :... • : ' 4,,,".- cNi F' i i t 11. .. ..i.,., seI I w a ii 11 1 in 1 1 1 i r' is' a• 1-----------' g Pgd qig 4 the area if the tenants of the proposed property are coming from the west(ie.The Hard Rock Hotel& Casino),the only way for them to get home is to NE anIIIIII n o o BB ooc7 0 III IN eg 1 EEIEI _ Ei11IEI , In 33 ia E ®EI e En E NMI tit Ink Min o NM is 4.,..2 ; t E' e£.. / i',,,,j '. '' :' ' :4-':- .. r.i./— ,::--,---• ., 0)41, . '....ram:-,Idgpp a 4: r- -...: 4:__:_;., , 7-i' • ' ri 4 Ivv.; 4:.i 0 U D 21 CI 0-.l 30,. SW 35TH AV} H 55IHPAVF 1. 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M? 1. 41 tif 11 0 wricinals; n 1 va'— is i mai ma liAn INN. nfl'* 7 r E i I NMI ER ' L 1110 IT 111111 0 Fr 7_ 1 II III -1 miniEh+-1, all •— iti „ E] E' E• ] 4.--- b_... i_ II' lam 1gumNBD• U FR r HI L,.., 0 MHO MB I I I I I II I III1iiilin ' .1, am Iiii NI El in i ti. in B: NI INI 1 HI l' I li III l' U .NU, a s a al I a' III::' a• a III I III i 1 i g t.;1.tp_!‘.72 e: x a 1 elle i o } M .,0 .t< r t ,;$ 4t \. - i X Aft' V,i,` ',...;„ I, ;.;,;' 4"... 7.;'. 1' 4:-; 1 f. ii. ';''-;;-; ii '; i ' : ii 'i ''';';'"'''; ''''S -;';'.4' 4' ; ''' -:"-;;.'''''44'. •, Air..., P t'741 ;. a .` •,.-"..... la y mks fie. d .. ,_•' t I r,.n, ; le, l( f,,,* ir* tir rt.f t S • i.rToff . s'hi t>a.> r.a as•_ ' ' a 1 - ' i 1 zw-simmiliiimsor ,ItII - , v" reglEIZIMINI P < ,, . 74" .421-TP-sVi2— ; R?4 2 1 i •. ... ....... .• - 4 e 0101 tel1111111f vII I 3 p._ Ogl :... • : ' 4,,,".-cNi F' i i t 1 1. .. .. i.,., se I I w a ii 11 1 in 1 1 1 i r'is' a• 1-----------' g Pgd qig 4 the area if the tenants of the proposed property are coming from the west(ie. Ell is P. r., .__, 10 Et11 -L—I ir114i, _ ,. art, iiiit E.:. j::i-:_ -a. 444- 4 -k '''Ill• ..A 4 1 WIii1 Y' 'my mom . E 771 7-1 7—y, , •, Ilk 1 I Alk11 , ---kit ass n ,L,n 1111 III la Ar.EP mow , 1 Ar• / 6a u. yw ri 4 Ivv.; 4:.i 0 UD21CI0-. l 30,. SW 35TH AV} H 55IHPAVF 1.2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 z ec¢ia HaviNva i,i 33 -- o till i_ f..i\11 aroa,uneus:ac 1Ili i i i i i t O i C a unnwwo rsnmor ore n wno raa 3a 'f.,1Y 6g NIAII HSOOH scv a3us'au a 1 s 1 t d ul u t n I. E.,"-( ' N, Ira, i' T lA Y Yy . i is A. fi 11i ' 1LAoki s t f' 5 ' , , "4 i aI If1' , L it 1 IL.) 1 -- t s i f i i_ a'. 1 4 z 1*M 1 A i l .,. . X ..,, Q U t.;1.tp_!‘.72e:x a 1 elle i o } M .,0 . t< r t ,;$4t \. - i X Aft' V,i,` ',...;„ I, ;.;,;'4"... 7.;'. 1' 4:-; 1 f. ii. ';''-;;-; ii '; i ' : ii 'i ''';';'"'''; ''''S -;';'.4'4' ; ''' -:"-;;.'''''44'. •, Air..., P t' 741 ;. a .` •,.-"..... lay m ks fie. d .. ,_•' t I r,. n, ;le,l( f,,,* ir*t ir rt.f tS • i. rT off . s'hi t>a.>r.a as•_ ' ' a 1 - ' i 1zw-simmiliiimsor ,It I I - , v"reglEIZIMINI P < ,, . 74" .421-TP-sVi2— ; R?4 2 1 i •. ... ....... .• - 4 e0101 tel111111 1 fvII I3 p._ Ogl :... • : ' 4,,,".- cNi F' i i t 1 1. .. ..i.,.,se I I w a ii 11 1 in 1 1 1 i r'is'a• 1-----------' g Pgd qig 4 the area if the tenants of the proposed property are coming from the west(ie.The Hard u L a EiRI. 13A31 ONf1O21O NVId 3dVOSONV1has i•yh ff Y L L 3 IEEEl3 HOV38VINVO S 11 a L OV02d ONfl IIiS 6SBE q 1 t Tj a a-RI j 18 i ii: it o oo 0 L . J0 p lam I dew 0 7 fkk 1411? 4.°II O'U) .,. •SP 1, 4) fa, \tio' 111:01, cp.* /Ask %aria _ I il O o Ali' c? ig, AV i 0 fi 11*II* Ttliwr 61 i 14,11p St," 1 q FI I oVIO CLllC y C ' W ki lt;, r \ 01 - ,,1pp A ''Qo 9 9g' d 564 Ae)COC; m Z` c„ eff , '' I . Z e ) Y 4E9C+4a v, i 4 1.- Ir wwavoiczts, 1 Li. itI 04)-. 1: i)::--filvT;;-'.\:', - —ti'..1''.< 2,1....:, .0 pwl, . .6 -,..../., .4)000 0 0... . !) wrvvv G3 o Ell) INC).tmly 0 0 te a1fr, air• a0c3 I rib ,.4tl ro° No f `I. NAN> y. it/ i ayt y B si h4 6 —T,338.8 C) ®' Kif !.3 4 4 SW 60th STREETtl STIRLING ROAD(STATE ROAD No.848) off . s'hi t>a.>r.a as•_ ' ' a1 - ' i 1zw- simmiliiimsor , It I I - , v"reglEIZIMINI P < ,, . 74" .421- TP-sVi2— ; R? 4 2 1 i •. ... ....... .• - 4 e 0101 tel111111 1 f v II I 3 p._ Ogl :... • : ' 4,,,".-cNi F' i i t 1 1. .. ..i.,.,se I I w a ii 11 1 in 1 1 1 iII titti 1 iit 13A310M101:10 NVld 3dVOSONYI L.- I 3 et 8 1.• I a:Zitee lA'HOV39 VINVO1`.. i II itr:z' _ Tillil III a Ititl, 1111 CIVOU ONI12111S 1.59£t-..„,:'..5 •:, Z.Th,„/ x INN"91311 11.1111 gi sat1iiilleiltitEllaaltlitil ONIAll HSOON r gNO Ili!! 14 tilt,. 11111 IPA:Ari...a., 11 I MN - 7i111111‘)eil f- 41 d. aeqD6 1. II 0 \ ft11 . P WV-1AP t.41 tn,TO joirl 1,41111 ,....tf, 3 K ' "12 4 Gai'fa tii fe, 11101,; 'TA III pl rf, 44 ,22 to,I A )• ti 1 , 1.110 olirli — i/I to-,,11,'': I `'- 0 i 111 041110 0 0 it;',I tr--I i', 1P-Me , %Aloi.,, f.w lopis,AD gbaikofj1111,6, _ 0.4•1111 Az' l'"C,....-. 10xItgla1:06fierirolitte f..,k0 e it t.t.ttz alL4:2,I..., „,„, A. 11%, O. 1 11. 1, ,—.4... v,t,.• 1Dco 0.- 41'4 21kli ' INF , 111 iskR6, e„ 411,‘Az$ ,, 14— t' 00 ' L- t, 8 te,„6 0,.9_ * :1 1i -11 ) Oth ' I 4112,iiikirlt;tfisl al'" 1$.1 - 2B 04,.,:,•- i Inf) ig O *0cni•LI : e," \ V..60(CC) 94 01) .0ii 4X, 4117,4 I'L J '"- ' ,-• g ,1 0 — 4 V.,-_ ---- Q 6 611e-D 0 ' ' '' ' '''''' 0/.' 0 P'7'0 ijig 1 4$4,4 i VStill•tee Illt;',Ce i7 , °O 01 't0 ‘\ 0 • ilk mar,„! O0 11111/" •'V,ACtill I le.vo• Olt 3,...}4 0'0' Zt I/ 'CO\ I, - 0 S—r-o eklit Ail 0, 00A I pli,, 0)0•ii.... k 1 ,,- 0e _ 0 . h. 4): i 1, .41ev el A,I,gl -"'- iOOOOOO r '''Thi-, ' 4?•°, F1-1,,,- *a , L, —-,,), 0 o o_ o i, Ill,. 1-3 to / ty are coming from the west(ie.The Hard Rock Hotel&Casino),the only way for them to gethome is to make the U-Turn at 37th Ave.There is not a specific light for turns on that street, it usually gets backed upwith traffic now, and it currently makes it very difficult for the residences of SW 37th Ave& SW 37th Terr to get home.The homes on SW 36 Terr this property,the developers knew thepropertywaszonedfor1acreestatehomeswhichwouldbecompatiblewithourneighborhood.They can build the ten one-acre estate ment adjacent to the 4 community area planning,and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases: o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation-3 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3.23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration. North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD)for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop-off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication report(IJR); served as the task leader for the preparation of the state environmental impact report(SEIR); conducted the interchange operational analysis reports(IOAR)for the adjacent interchanges and developed the public involvement program.Page 2 of 3 t•,•,. pat . 3 13n31 JNnoae Nb'ld 3d'dOSONY1 1 , tl. V tptia ill 4103I28P'i S a CIVMI`JNI1HIIS L48£ 1 0 Mliaal 3 qq* 83a +a JNI/11l HSOO>I ri 1 J i r B Pi Fg-! I1n P.:1 IMP g t'D OGY4a3oe.zv d. , abq pop f0a 0o O c o p oxo p I V C4 e': crew D o71rommcr[O or o o'' gi!.:42- 9, a C nD c c6 le 0 at s GDP— . 4, 3 r A. po0Q Qp 0 3 ,.r w•e j 41 ' e;)01`; f o Iov a s ..0* i 41 ED .0.0 Rio Is eq: 0 11 rb• t 1 s.a, k Rt ..07,g rN rp p n 0 0 J 6)!91 (I*®A k ! y 1 o O: O u p t)l••C {DeD $ tt rotoc,. .„...,,,l 41l : :, In.DLL 1711 ENO d. g - D i LIA'stiV I Oo C.' • . a 4(0ex; EDt t;' : s-Qg - a.N I 1 r. 004 I 0:141 1 Gadf Q I L3{{ I ram Q 4 Q4. ^` X , o `i P i l Q ,_. . l•Ios _• AiA44 of*two&k' i1 .;c' - fir 1 a 0 i, O I' 9 / C: J am, to ri a Ri 3; I. O a ® , 1C l - I sk R6, e„ 411,‘Az$ ,,14—t' 00 ' L-t,8 te,„6 0,. 9_ * :1 1 i -11 ) v a a m mt b it.0182 e r g E v > met-So m a cmcmm,g0o >tl. na 9v x m "E &3:g« tem; mm ga . g • oE$m,oEE m 3 kiteamvetoJpacmX .c -- gz w—o 5 s mn x s mc 't `6t2 3' cEmroc a 1.48 ma r_ c'gi : cmE m$ eg it $ ..f 93rm a' iam Emo188E °E 2oc Lomrk- uE_ ma&Eamo m mai81Jpaqgpymc> c - .E pl c 3 N ocE gLcoama w c v o P. cm.. 2 _...s E Cim =crnmo^ cc a E 1.1 a a •gi5.. vo m« O1 2ma g.2 =o g V th N LL:'. CpO «mm q- ,c.,,, fa..mN mm Or)Nifi NO: UQ oO0EOmmmyQ mL LL^i O E Mc' 2 man O: elm f mmOp *" 8 .m S.e 4. ppd Y O i n: $= am0 L A. c$m m 3o'tafA of, co 00 E z0 Nz a o;- mE m U.a °!cm m 2J9ogqymy p $' a o' mV m Z TiI- oio 3a,c c 3'-'mc $E modF o 3n Ja mod O >V.. w V per" m oco,q 9 o ya5 cL. oM H ao m ; oc 3 m) 0 E.. .- ZQ 0d, B Q Doi a .1 twee E -`• o0 -mm>. m i= t mi. ru:! ci 7F rn O K f c'. wrm m K nil wma E0En a2 IF;IHj1m LL t Z QN' pmli 0-- OaE I m. Ew c J ;J , w II N'.. m2 «$• ad c. ma3d= a` ti a•a` Q n_; Z n m a' U myC: O m E a. mG1.._8 8r->:...c E n i N c N WO LL a' a1 EOJ N >- tm mt- m "m ncc3 mn.Q 5 w uN: a m5 ogE m mc_ 5,..n.c `-a 7taci" P zw j421il a° ao «IIIN ?_ 0 aco H aN:: w act `L£ mVHWj,ao N.. °Q aCMJamJN ° wc« ° o ,nad, E.mm`. c my o a mx'E.anB tE ax zm ._ p E>g LH cm miacEofpuZiF' `om ..g a . 0Jm mtilE2 NQ} d Oo Wm3', o$ c0m= m Egm°'c m E _-'3cE a d a a >.5. .sr,, wva ; B›.99Ec f,-,T„-,>6Ea V 2 m txm m VJRca mm£`°c o` 23 >°o>'cI o>,m Oo I- 10 > aolJ', r{ $E 3L £°a,m Jm°moma eE M p= o' c oeo'', "a s'cmmF- caEm° ue_ mmmCmr -.1ocf, ammwt1Z 9 Y x'. JOr a'-._q• gma%-9 g:mE.,catnTN- mN S.-EI cc ma= 8mco` c .r`$yi-m> p$ mcN am.`m',', 23 amm Ha m aQcm O=m8a a c0, c O;ri m J m ic.c 1° Elln mcm 176 dm •§Q4 C 6v, 41za ±' m;=', w3 -`oc'aa cdcaE .6EaLLEE gu m 22zcamJPSI, at A00' c'3 Ea«10p..0U2'" mmmcc a ra og'acLLasza' sm pJ._ g m °'o$ >mRt9c m a•) - 1E6z±. 0>_ a- gmy >m c-- m° z°L° YmEN gam.. 3 oSmast m-rnmmian L>.Esoa Hai 9, sV aVom am-g J oom', vh aEm'c a..E•oLE2 nm= Hmm EumE m ca8E `m• ow o•o aa`z! E8 °dm¢ma£3droE m a6' >.QmmaITVmW' o me cL o o I-IOa c %fJYYSFOama = h° u .u.... I-xOm mmlLad 8 3 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3.23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School, Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD)for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic z 0 a 2 S ce w 70 ®o co E 2ta m § 6 C. E E 2 < z k - a3 > #g E eee eq ar)±§ 3 Z- a' CO 5/ c erg}%G5m J % ( m€ g 2 kk)i) I 0 $I u_ 7\§4 CV ok)3_ | 0 ES«§ 0 \ CO to k 0 M w re a 4:.i 0 U D 21 CI 0-.l 30,. SW 35TH AV} H 55IHPAVF 1. 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 81 Q N b M W Cn' s m A Na. t : 8 w W a a 'O N 5 ai. d y e, 2 m E 2 O 10 N N o°^m OW . m n a a a ECmmU C C N Z m a E a z m a, W g I I-. C— p pc cc C en a Ile0 C WOO - c m _ C D V a O w m yymwmZol° ee d" 2 N L y N E o • x` I- P'' N o i_ c Z 0 -a O n a , a OT ill m Q G wN- a ao '' N CO 5 mgn OU Y a cL® n Oa 'm m e z_ OF sz x a E 3 O y0 n a a . 88 a LLCUWToJ g} F m i QONON V O S t+r gEWmE g o at la O mgnmo . m m CI Q n \ao g ar. oJ m m dumm e e . C E6EaLLa Z c g€ SOyW 0 m o gva na m F mQazN G OQ ~ adW 9 W ' J co 1 4 J W O 00 0=N Qa g0 ,Et =E Qem N m m vE s. 33`E I$ $ ci. d 2 6 E t a' m _ E CC E E ''' r y o m$;# . a Q 2 - s m a rc` m 1 5 •5 O `e 8»a m 0 3 9 rc t y Q' m J W 'r uj , g 2 0 N F O 5 2 ° =m W a a `mm Q N a. A O 2 5 bit. lit-Cif s C On am to€ yNmOm U Q- 03 311ga a Q ti r m E uni m m L Z a 2 a 0 = aaoQrvmmom8 _ J O m Qm ei5'.6 A• Wy 2 N tNtQQ _ O o.AilE8 L 0 O 1[f m ' 3 y la a 17 Q C 4 D m a 0 8» M N S .. x U N c v ffi X 0 m g ,p O a-0 : 2zm .. = y m y C o 1- $ ro .mo z X m . t o o w z• E a m .. h E1 3 Z. w a 3 z o y o .'al m 313.. d' a 2 v o. o Q m ?+ 0' m m d$ i a. o m o Z• > o - v x v = 8 € i Qa Am , 51 2 ye a a 09 U O a. $ p m E m e '5 m U o 2 m u m 5 p S _U is A m o 3 o i s z' o gam"6 x 002NV2Oin vJ Q x ma.?`m:' v, 41za ±' m;=', w3 -` oc'aa cdcaE .6EaLLEE gu m 22 z camJ PSI, at A00' c'3 Ea«10p..0U2'" mmmcc a ra og'a cLL as z a' smpJ._ g m °'o$ >mRt9c m a•) - 1E6z±. 0>_a- gmy > m c-- m° z°L° YmEN gam.. 3 oSmast m-rnmmian L>.Esoa Hai 9,sV aVom am-g J oom', vh aEm'c a..E•oLE2 nm= Hmm EumE m ca8E `m• ow o•o aa`z! E8 °dm¢ma£3droE m a6' >.Qmma ITVmW' o me cL ooI-IOa c %fJ Y YSF Oama = h° u .u.... I-xOm mmlLad 8 3 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3.23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD)for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of 11 E N b - - _ a. § 8 } z qg o 2 o ( ill§ } w -7} o a ! cc wk£ o = . 0 I < 0 F LEI2o f m ; ; e : - 2 '.4 3 j f 8 z ; 8 i! 2 k 0 )EA ® E z } k /m ! e e0 t ! : A. f}$\ { 0 z / a t1 n z 3,i 2 7, n 7 e / k} \ 7 = l;= !k G / } E I$ $ci.d 2 6 E t a' m _ E CC E E ''' r y o m$;# . a Q 2 - s m a rc` m 1 5 •5 O `e 8»a m 0 3 9 rc t y Q' m J W 'r uj , g 2 0 N F O 5 2 ° =m W a a `mm QNa. A O 2 5 bit.lit-Cif s C On am to€ y N m O m U Q- 03 311ga a Q tirm Eunimm L Z a 2 a 0 = a a oQ r vm mom8 _J O m Qm ei5'.6 A• Wy 2 N tNtQQ _ O o. AilE8 L 0 O 1[f m ' 3 y la a 17 Q C 4 D m a 0 8»M N S .. x U N c v ffi X 0 m g ,p O a- 0 : 2 z m .. = y m y C o1- $ ro . mo z X m . t o o w z• E a m .. h E1 3 Z.w a 3 z m y a. cy -mm og c o D o m- = O > N S m gm QmCL ey5. 75 MmVa° E a co-L.,c_ vtm ` ' c E m = u2' m = m m cc m m ycraeom = tL p SoEa >c c m m3of w cU nEanRI38oL > N. . y 1 m = E a 20 NL1-1 m I m 2 m m m a < ' 8 - a c mh ° R Ec E 2 22 > o al m° E a y f0 m CO y c CO o = a t U a vtm d c w c o m x R m81 3, E aamx - y m` c m Pi Em ` el 05ar, m o N € c2o m E S n oNdQ. Q ° E0N mE C ° mNm § a am acS vmE E NN m yCOacC2mca; m N 7...; Cr CO p, ja m = o m > ` H .cEmvR mmadWaomu0pwaxjL4'> r ai m a EdE mo EQoa -m m! m c LL 3 o°r 4 m CO ami OG n° c a 2o c m m E i p m5m° mm o N m8ULE ' mEcmramacmEm z'0 m Cmmw2 c m LL eg ' U N AC m mmSLLm . o 0 m" ° Ey mmmmg22- N z .z2mNy ° Q Z m2m-- ` E L8C,, a L = Nm = y LLmULCL c m c N Eam " 3 m EN cNN-m aN8 aa, CtO N g 2 W >'9L m 1NacoN[n O W L LL p,m m N ;Ncq 84. o n 3 m 4O c, = 6 U m my mEnCCEgdNII: .QyCm U U yEa _ y1 m W - a > ooa t E2 = yE ccn c8000omB ' ° o mmTT,. a •- d o Do w y.om €ammE op a nEoLL a m 0 m "c R. 0.. p g o mEv>° > m 2 5D 2 o oL m d .m o amame4' tm = o muti v 22- .ma2N oomcm°a Eo 2mcoVin Y Ea Nmga8 ° m o.m m =am Q 2 u amg m m J2 -t" 2t. E r 2 s.O poa opa = 0Cn—VVES.t FEUUHLEm00gE ° _ mm N °F. —2 m mL a mL m m 0-c c9 ito-§ 2 .0 L t >° e. ° v $ a m 06- ar a3 . ° v 22a21n2 Fog 5 p w n.° N w Nm HUCQmU6 -I m l m E E E wc gym'- m t a H m 7i . Raa L c E m c r = a an d a = =F- m g_ L„p m ° i ° °L m_T m m °° E Et `g E N m m 3 m'O m o N f0 v O m '- N E °t m o w a >roemmLo Em .vmadm 6mSnd 0 mr m m - z' 1- m m licmLNNUm = am a - m V-2m yUL >NL m C ?- -4 ° mEy86 m'm o°0 L N m3 m 6 m,' 'c Vi to % Q m3LC Nmm ° ay t E Nm. 8 I- a t-U 08 rn$Qc88 an ITVmW' o me cL o o I- IOa c %fJ Y YSF Oama = h° u .u.... I-xOm mmlLad 8 3 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta, Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3.23.22 ial feasibility study fortheimplementationofatollroad in Chesapeake,Virginia. Thisinvolveddevelopmentoftrafficvolumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources. US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD)for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop-off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication report( IJR); served as the task leader for the preparation of the state environmental impact report(SEIR); 0 an 0Z 111 72 m T. anU a L N P Q1 03mm a) rn y E m « a IX N J Z d I— m m N C jg E y N rg 7Q v CC Fc V O W VC U m O OL TU y U L3a. cu rr 4: I m 61 N c CV0ellE rVCVo M U COm to 2, V 0 Vl w axjL4'>r aim a EdE mo EQoa - m m! m c LL 3 o°r 4 m CO ami OG n° c a 2o c m m E i p m5m° mm o N m8ULE ' mE cmr am acm Em z'0 m Cmmw2 c m LLeg ' U N AC m mmS LL m .o 0 m" ° Ey mmmm g22- N z .z2 m Ny ° Q Z m2m-- ` E L8C,, a L = Nm = y LLmULCLcmc N Eam " 3 m EN c NN-m aN8 aa, Ct O N g 2 W >'9L m 1 Na coN[ n O W L LL p,m m N ;Ncq 84.o n 3 m 4O c, = 6 U m my mEn C C E g d N II: . QyCm U U yEa _ y1 m W - a > ooa t E2 = yE ccn c8 000 om B ' ° o mm TT,. a •- d o Do w y.om €ammE op a nEoLL a m 0 m "c R. 0.. p g o mEv>° > il C 0 ..**,... vi _ L.. ct a.) = C > 4—) s_ v, vl G) ( 1) L t)co tIO cd — 4-3Cl.) coC_ E 0 CU C _c ,0 E o v) r—, C1 0 0 E c o 0 o o o al 4_1 Ct N cu rd s_ co o 4-, 0. ---rq ri 0 (N1 -0 ct 4 c ---- ----- •— r•-1 rn VI 17II 3 0.„ il rA I4 ct CNI cn 0 CO a) rg s_ CU C CU LLJ 1.4 0 I— c 0 la C D 7, 0 col 0 s_ b.° 1_ C cn 4-4 C1) U 0 CD 4-) CU c co CO O ONN ON C CL en D sa) . • • _. „, „. 4 ,_,-,„ ,,„v) lam. 3 aa, Ct O N g 2 W >'9L m 1 Na coN[n O W L LL p,m m N ;Ncq 84.o n 3m4O c, = 6 U m my mEn C C E g d N II: . QyCm U U yEa _ y1 m W - a > ooa t E2 = yE ccn c8 000 om B ' ° o mm TT,. a •- d o Do w y.om € ammE op a nEoLL a m 0 m "c R. 0.. p g o mEv>° >m 2 5D 2 o oL m d .m o amame4' tm = o muti v 22- . ma2N oomcm° aEo 2mcoVin Y Ea Nmga8 ° m o.m m =am Q 2 u amg m m J2 - t" 2t. E r 2 Karl B. P.E.Years of Experience Peterson , 33 Senior Project Manager Education Master of Civil Engineering, 1990 '' Mr. Peterson offers more than 30 years of engineering experience directing, North Carolina State University :"" conducting and reviewing traffic engineering/transportation planning analyses, traffic impact/concurrency evaluations, parking demand studies, Project B S Civil Engineering. 1988 Development and Environment(PD&E) studies, corridor planning studies, and North Carolina State University interchange justification and modification reports (IJR/IMR). He has extensive experience in conducting public involvement programs for transportation related Professional Registrations s projects, serves as city traffic engineer for several south Florida municipalities, Professional Engineer, 1996, F and has performed numerous traffic operations and safety studies for the Florida 49897 Department of Transportation (FDOT). He has a firm understanding of Professional Engineer, 1994, N ,, community issues, assembles and manages strong project teams for large 19813 transportation projects, and is well-respected for his ability to communicate with Professional Engineer, 1999 NV clients agencies, elected officials, and the public. In addition, Karl has a long 13818 track record of delivering successful projects on-time and within budget. Organizations Transportation Services for Land Development Institute of Transportation Karl has conducted more than 1,000 transportation and traffic engineering studies Engineers (ITE). Associate for private land development clients, attorneys, architects, and engineers. His Member services have included traffic impact analyses, concurrency evaluations, Past-President—Gold Coast Chapter developments of regional impact(DRI), parking design and supply studies, signal warrant studies, access management evaluations, and concurrency audits. These studies have been conducted throughout the state of Florida, primarily from the Florida Keys to Palm Beach County. Municipal Services As Project Manager and primary contact for several cities in south Florida, Karl has advised staff and elected officials on issues regarding site planning and design, traffic impacts, access management evaluations, site circulation, land use planning, location and type of landscaping (as it relates to sight distances and safety measures), traffic signal warrant studies, signing and pavement markings, and parking facilities. Planning / Project Development and Environment (PD&E) Studies Karl has performed and/or supervised all aspects of the PD&E and corridor study process. Key elements of these studies include analyses of transportation/land use relationships, travel demand estimates and forecasts, level of service analyses, benefit-cost comparisons, and financial feasibility studies. His project experience includes studies with significant natural and physical environment impacts including those to historically significant properties. Karl has also prepared design traffic memorandums, project purpose and need statements, alternatives analyses and has conducted extensive public involvement programs on highly controversial projects. Traffic Operations and Safety Studies As part of several work-order contracts with Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT) in Districts Four and Six, Karl conducted and/or assisted with the technical analyses of more than 75 traffic operational and safety studies. These studies included crash diagrams and analyses, signal warrant studies, intersection analyses, travel time and delay studies, queuing analyses, and pedestrian safety studies. Infrastructure, Privatization and Finance Since 1993, Karl has been involved in multiple transportation-related finance studies, including tollroad feasibility analyses, evaluation of managed lanes, privatization studies, benefit-cost analyses, and congestion pricing evaluations. He also performed research and drafted the enabling legislation resulting in the creation of the Miami-Dade County Expressway Authority(MDX). Airport Planning Karl has also been involved in a wide range of airport and aviation related planning activities. These include preparing airport site selection studies, terminal area analyses, and airport master plans. He also has conducted air traffic control tower location studies, environmental assessments, and performed statewide aviation system planning. Page 1 of 3 r. Provided traffic engineeringservicesinsupportoftheircapitalimprovementprograms. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop-off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication report(IJR); served as the task leader for the preparation of the state environmental impact report(SEIR); conducted the interchange operational analysis reports(IOAR)for the adjacent interchanges and developed the public involvement program.Page 2 of 3 Relevant Project Experience: Traffic Engineering Services,Sunrise, FL; Project Manager. Serves as the traffic engineering consultant to the City of Sunrise in Broward County, Florida. In this role, he reviews applications for new development projects within the City. These reviews focus on the layout of the proposed site plans, access issues, internal site circulation, sight distances, and traffic impacts. Traffic Engineering Services,Tamarac, FL; Project Manager. Serves as the traffic engineering consultant to the City of Tamarac in Broward County, Florida. In this capacity, he reviews applications for site plan development, traffic impact studies, parking studies, and project access. New River CSX Railroad Bascule Bridge PD&E Study, Fort Lauderdale, FL, Project Manager. This PD&E Study involved a Scherzer Rolling Lift railroad bridge constructed in 1927 over the South Fork of the New River. This historically eligible bridge was determined to be structurally deficient and the project team evaluated rehabilitation options as well as bascule, rolling lift and vertical lift replacement options. Other options considered included a 40 foot diameter tunnel and a fixed span bridge with 55 feet of vertical clearance. This project involved extensive Section 106/SHPO coordination as well as regular USCG, marine, and railroad industry involvement. SR 93/1-75& Pembroke Road Interchange PD&E Study, Pembroke Pines/Miramar, FL, Project Manager. The study included the analysis of the mainline adjacent interchanges, and a proposed interchange using CORSIM simulation software to determine the operational characteristics of 1-75 with and without the proposed interchange in place. Three alternatives were evaluated as part of the study, including the baseline'no-build'condition, single point urban interchange and tight diamond interchange alternatives. In addition to the engineering aspects of the project, these alternatives were evaluated with respect to potential environmental impacts resulting from the proposed interchange. Congress Avenue(SR 807) PD&E Study,Lake Worth, FL; Project Manager. Studied the widening and rehabilitation of Congress Avenue(SR 807)from Lantana Road to 6th Avenue South in Palm Beach County, Florida. Both five-and six- lane alternatives were considered along with special treatment and/or additional lanes at major intersections, bridge improvements, widening of the crossroads up to 1,000 feet in each direction where necessary to provide intersection operation at Level of Service(LOS) D or higher, drainage improvements, and the addition of bicycle lanes and sidewalks. The alternatives were considered on left, right, and best fit alignments within the existing right-of-way. University Drive PD&E Study, Broward/Palm Beach Counties,FL; Traffic Engineering Task Manager. Directed the traffic engineering and planning services to complete the PD&E study for the extension of University Drive in Broward and Palm Beach Counties. Also responsible for completing the Public Involvement Program, assessing community impacts of each proposed alternative, assisting with public involvement activities, completing traffic analyses for each proposed alternative, preparing the Design Traffic Memorandum, and finalizing roadway design for the preferred alternative. Turnpike PD&E Study, Palm Beach County,FL;Assistant Project Manager. PD&E Study to evaluate and document proposed transportation solutions for this segment of the Turnpike Mainline in Palm Beach County, from Atlantic Avenue to the Lantana Toll Plaza. Proposed improvements included capacity enhancements (widening to six lanes)and widening three existing bridges at Atlantic Avenue, Lake Worth Drainage District Canal, and Boynton Canal. This study involved preparation of a State Environmental Impact Report(SEIR). NW 107 Avenue AIS and PD&E Study,Miami-Dade County, FL;Task Manager. Conducted an arterial investment study and PD&E study along one of the most congested transportation facilities in Miami-Dade County. Alternatives considered included enhanced transit services, ITS applications,TDM and TSM strategies and alternative corridors. US 1 PD&E Study, Martin County, FL; Project Manager. Developed roadway expansion concepts and the public involvement program for the US 1 corridor in Martin County. Also directed community involvement efforts, environmental analyses, and agency coordination. Kings Highway(SR 713) PD&E Study,St. Lucie County, FL;Task Manager. Conducted detailed traffic forecasting and projections for the Kings Highway corridor between State Road 70(Okeechobee Road)and US 1 for the 2040 horizon year. Developed various roadway alternatives in order to accommodate the future transportation demand. Sawgrass Expressway/Panther Drive Interchange,Sunrise, FL;Assistant Project Manager. Responsible for overseeing and performing traffic analyses associated with the interchange justification report(IJR); served as the task leader for the preparation of the state environmental impact report(SEIR); conducted the interchange operational analysis reports(IOAR)for the adjacent interchanges and developed the public involvement program. Page 2 of 3 CR 510 PD&E Study, Indian River County, FL;Task Manager. Provided traffic engineering services and public involvement coordination for the CR 510 PD&E Study. This analysis involved multiple land use scenarios and traffic simulation efforts. The District, Boca Raton, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering consulting services for this mixed-use redevelopment project in Boca Raton. The impact analysis was performed in accordance with the county traffic performance standards and city land development regulations to assess impacts to the transportation system. Lynn University, Boca Raton,FL; Project Manager. Provides ongoing traffic engineering services in support of various development related project on campus. These studies include traffic concurrency analyses, signal warrant studies, parking analyses and master planning efforts. Florida Atlantic University Football Stadium Traffic Analysis, Boca Raton, FL; Project Manager. Conducted the traffic analysis for the 30,000 seat football stadium that opened in fall 2011. This analysis evaluated the entering and exiting traffic and prepared a traffic simulation analysis to evaluate the traffic operations within the study area. Bank of America Plaza, Boca Raton, FL; Project Manager. Traffic analysis for the Bank of America Plaza retail development located on Federal Highway in Boca Raton. This involved a traffic concurrency evaluation as well as an access classification study. Key West International Airport, Key West, FL; Project Manager. Traffic impact analysis to address the roadway impacts associated with the proposed airside and landside expansion of the Key West International Airport. Traffic Impacts Studies, Monroe County, FL; Project Manager. Conducted more than 300 traffic impact studies throughout the Florida Keys for retail,office, residential, municipal, entertainment, and lodging facilities. Growth Management General Consulting Contract, Fort Lauderdale,FL; Project Manager. Provided professional planning services to FDOT District Four on a task work order basis. Areas of planning assistance included review of Local Government Comprehensive Plan Amendments, transportation corridor analyses, level of service and transit mitigation plans, review of development plans and proposals,and assistance with transit, bikeway and pedestrian infrastructure needs. SR 25/US 27 Action Plan, Broward County, Florida; Project Manager. Developed a long-range plan for the preservation and implementation of mobility strategies within the US 27 corridor in southern Broward County. US 1 (SR 5)Alternative Corridors Study,Martin County, FL; Project Manager. Performed an area wide analysis of alternative corridors and transportation modes within the rapidly growing Treasure Coast Region of Florida. Project included and extensive origin and destination study and public involvement program. City of Coral Springs Traffic Engineering Services,Coral Springs, FL; Project Manager. Karl has served as the traffic engineering consultant to the City of Coral Springs in Broward County, Florida. In this role, his reviews focused on applications for new development projects within the City. These reviews focused on site plan layouts, project access, internal site circulation, traffic impacts, and parking. The project team also provided advice to the City regarding traffic operations, safety and traffic calming issues within the City. FDOT District Six Traffic Operations and Safety Studies, Miami, FL; Task Manager/Quality Control Officer. Assisted with and reviewed more than 50 traffic operations and safety studies. Studies included crash analyses, signal warrant studies, intersection analyses, delay studies, queuing analyses and pedestrian studies. US 168 Corridor Tollroad Feasibility Study,Chesapeake,VA; Project Manager/Task Manager. Conducted financial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources. US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration. North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD)for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road. Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop-off and pick- up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access. Page 3 of 3 ication report(IJR); served as the task leader for the preparation of the state environmental impact report( SEIR); conducted the interchange operational analysis reports(IOAR)for the adjacent interchanges and developed the public involvement program.Page 2 of 3 a) c cu J co c U 4—N L= ; Li-CO 0 > CO Cr c) cn 00 X 5 W I I— I5s a N C3) o 2 E ( C co 4.-J 2 a) 1 cz c cn ro c o) .v— L co a. 0 0_ -1=•" C 0 w Ci) 4 Q sI:) c o o 1 " 0 TO' Cr) O 0 I.a° ‘' 16 w I— O cm O O u) 0 ci. -62 R, L6aDo0_ 8LL < II 0 4 CO H u I hi IL L' Iiiii 3 55 1 1 110 a N t r - a y 9 y5l a 1 ali llilitxt e m f. fii 3 3 p if ri... 4P it Ygi Z9 E Q i gny9 it CD g ' a Y z o VJdC0 -.. I el I 1 et ill i m eg Lf CI i I gt i 111101 F il . 7, C Iv pi! ig i It it Iii ioi IilffiI L4 5 = 8f 1111 3 1'lltM R Al'ikeg t h Mil ppirt - '74 tiA er lif . 1 tlg IA Pi%!ID Igil ill 6-. 1} y ii i PP MD 1 IgIR4 Can V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 73 A. 00 n i S. O O -.+ O enN O Cil) Tct a D pi. I I- 0-0 N 00 1113 VJ CZ Cl CCS C Fi I E co xo o 4.w r v, o W c T i. C.:', 0 01) 0 0 CI) = o d 71- cc N C 4-- Hots o C.A ACrNorIr Q• im•C 13 V CD M e) Cli) 0 • • 0 c W o 4) 0 I— U c OUO U 0 1--0 i - 0— 3 ' q ? 0 4) co •MIME O ti ceto CUIII ell as an access classification study.Key West International Airport, Key West, FL; Project Manager. Traffic impact analysis to address the roadway impacts associated with the proposed airside and landside expansion of the Key West International Airport.Traffic Impacts Studies, Monroe County, FL; Project Manager. Conducted more than 300 traffic impactstudiesthroughout theFloridaKeysfor retail,office, residential, municipal, entertainment, and lodging facilities.Growth Management General Consulting Contract, Fort Lauderdale,FL; Project Manager. Provided professional planning services to FDOT District Four on a task work order basis. Areas of planning assistance included review of Local Government Comprehensive Plan Amendments, transportation corridor analyses, level of service and transit mitigation plans, review of development plans and proposals,and assistance with transit, bikeway and pedestrian infrastructure needs. SR25/ US 27 Action Plan, Broward County, Florida; Project Manager. Developed a long-range plan for the preservation and implementation of mobility O u O O b O o^0 N l O N xi N M 00 O N [ .. O b cl c O F cu a W W U d U pq U U U U co ei i0., L II) e c No O o 2 x o O. c N c Cr; a W rzj U < U U A 1 rs. GG LCOA L. ' x N N N 0 00 Ham 0 U 0 a W U d U U U a- v o' L.o a i 0 0 0 rn o 0 0 o . d 3 W U d U U W rs. CD v v W a N V'. y L. g• el C CD C14 , C O z g O l 01 d" Cr) CI) 00 a CC x oo N vO N ez U p 1.0 W U d U U U as Elm h 7 o L IIII y olt O M co, o^o Lc) 1 V! y x Q NN p ol a W U < U U = w 1 W 1) CO tv o C Q oobo O d al O CO vas o W Ln ca 0 oA A O E ° •E 0 o ai o f H g CO O d 0 Q on oA tO =t t.4 y? Q to 0 i b ook CA 4 ment General Consulting Contract, Fort Lauderdale,FL; Project Manager. Provided professional planning services to FDOT District Four on a 4. a N o Nu © x ci M 06 O N O etz et p .x c U F-0 a W L U '< U C C) U U U U Np O F. oCOI el n_. y, x O O, N M CND M 0 CSC N... i ' i W W U < U U L3. CO2 U 4.• O M cr, \O r? [ x N N N D oo iiii o +. c4w U .< U cc) U U V N }" Czt O a 4. I 0000 O ^^ 0^O u p L4 p x a1 i d V N `O O Y i 3ces u_ U Q U U CYO CI., 0) U wP. o el = ct g c p O l O M M 00 RS x 00 N \O i o ti UCI W44,U Q U A? U U Uo CI O E O h M 00 kn t d p x 00 i M M N . i x cu a w U ¢ U U CC) w w Cin CO z 0 C oo• •-, > Q c/D_ O Q Q o 0 0 ch Z •o 2 00 .. OO 00 0 ai 0 00 C y 00 0 00 to_4. 00 I. C4 .... cC CI) W cl 0o < S• c -O o 70 -0 124 70 C -° 0 CD a o 0 0 0 0 0 o u C C2 C4 ctt rL A C4 -0 O M s. Areas of planning assistance included review of v, s. O e O O b O ^ N l O N E x N - M 0o O N l •--+ O 1:3 at a bcNs o Ey t> W r1 U d U Gq U U U U -. c. N O L 6 Ua O q O^ N ' R. Ih G70 a W r U d U U G 1 w PO tnli A i,lit oot^rCh n [ d o0axOLoNM UCI) W U d U al U U d N L C:1 O 0.4 6 I O O 0^O O ^ o^O c O O d N N 4 A. W U d U U CO w CD ci) co PT.4 c4 et CW = O 01 d' M M 00 el a A v x kr, 006 i M `p N i h a 0 a W V a W U ¢ U W U U r> 0 ' GO 0 a..o L. N_ 1111.1J py G o b O l M 0^O d 0 n x c k a W U ¢ U U = w W Can CO 1. 40C en Q ran O Q Q E o cd o o H 0 y O bA Q , 'N O 00 y 00 O 00 N r d- c-.H CO s- \ Q T) -0 ..O y "Cs n C C 7:: -O -O "al -O O O O . V1 gycdclcCcdOCa x O O O .. O 0 O O L W sue- 5 .5 aA . O O a; .a O up v oA nt Comprehensive Plan Amendments, transportation corridor analyses, level of service and transit mitigation plans, review of development plans and proposals,and assistance with transit, bikeway and pedestrian infrastructure needs.SR 25/US 27 Action Plan, Broward County, Florida; Project Manager. Developed a long-range plan for the preservation and implementation of mobility strategies within the US 27 corridor in southern Broward County.US 1 (SR 5)Alternative Corridors Study,Martin County, FL; Project Manager. Performed an area wide analysis of alternative corridors and transportation modes within the rapidly growing Treasure Coast Region of Florida. Project included and extensive origin and destination study and public involvement program.City of Coral Springs Traffic Engineering Services,Coral Springs, FL; Project Manager. Karl has served as the traffic engineering consultant to the City of Coral Springs in Broward County, Florida. In this role, his reviews focused on applications for new development projects within the City. These reviews focused on site plan layouts, project access,internal site circulation, traffic impacts, and parking. The project team also provided advice to the City regarding traffic operations, safety and traffic calming issues within the City.FDOT District Six Traffic Operations and Safety Studies, Miami, FL; Task Manager/Quality Control Officer.Assisted with and reviewed more than 50 traffic operations and safety studies. Studies included crash analyses, signal warrant studies, intersection analyses, delay studies, queuing analyses and pedestrian studies.US 168 Corridor Tollroad Feasibility Study,Chesapeake,VA; Project Manager/Task Manager. Conducted financial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices( MUTCD)for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop- off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication report(IJR); served as the task leader for the preparation of the state environmental impact report( SEIR); conducted the interchange operational analysis reports(IOAR) for the adjacent interchanges and developed the public involvement program.Page 2 of 3 W U C.) s- o 4 CO o o Co4) 0 ct C M 0 Cow OCtv C ti V n 2CO - Lc) O O ( 3 L O rt o L, m L a a g m U >- ig i It it Iii ioi IilffiI L4 5 = 8f 1111 3 1'lltM R Al'i keg t h Mil ppirt - '74 tiA er lif . 1 tlg IA Pi%!ID Igil ill 6-. 1} y ii i PP MD 1 IgIR 4 Can V1111 1 3 41 3,M? 1. 41 tif 11 0 U Co F U Cts a) I m 0 U0co U U Q < U O Cas 0 76' O2 G) o ECE2 c ".E E. a-0.—E o Q F- I O O ( 3 L O rt o L, m L a a g m U >- ig i It it Iii ioi IilffiI L4 5 = 8f 1111 3 1'lltM R Al'i keg t h Mil ppirt - '74 tiA er lif . 1 tlg IA Pi%! ID Igil ill 6-. 1} y ii i PP MD 1 IgIR 4 Can V1111 1 3 41 3,M? 1. 41 tif 11 0 Cecelia Ward, AICP President JC Consulting Enterprises Inc. Experience Highlights Over 40 years of experience in comprehensive planning, urban and regional planning,community area planning, land development codes and zoning regulations. 10 years of public sector planning and zoning experience. JC Consulting Enterprises, Inc., President, 2006 to present Planning Commissioner Town of North Hempstead, New York-2006 Deputy Director of Strategic Planning,City of New York,2004 Director of Construction Services Bureau,City of Fort Lauderdale, 1999 Planning Administrator,City of Fort Lauderdale, 1998 Senior Planner,City of Fort Lauderdale, 1995 VP Governmental Planning,Coral Ridge Properties, 1986 Senior Planner,Coral Ridge Properties, 1984 Planner, Mid-South Engineering, 1978 Education Florida Atlantic University Bachelor of Arts-Political Science Professional Certifications American Institute of Certified Planners (AICP), since 1993 Professional Affiliations American Planning Association Florida American Planning Association r. Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc. 18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3.23.22 Q Q E o cd o o H 0 y O bA Q , ' N O 00 y 00 O 00 N r d- c-.H CO s- \ Q T) - 0 ..O y "Cs n C C 7:: -O -O "al - O O O O . V1 g y cd cl cC cd O C a x O O O .. O 0 O O L W sue- 5 .5 aA . O O a; .a O up v oA nt Comprehensive Plan Amendments, transportation corridor analyses, level of service and transit mitigation plans, review of development Honors and Awards Former Exemplary Employee—City of Fort Lauderdale,2007 Leadership Fort Lauderdale-1999,2000,2001 City of Fort Lauderdale—Commitment to Excellence in Business,2003 Fort Lauderdale's Finest,2003 Cecelia Holler Appreciation Day—Fort Lauderdale Downtown Development Authority for contributions to Downtown Economic Development Planning,2004 Certificate of Appreciation for Participation in Community Redevelopment Plan for Atlantic Beach CRA City of Pompano Beach,2000-2001 Community Service League of Women Voters, 1991 Coral Springs Economic Development Task Force, 1991 South Florida Regional Planning Council Strategic Regional Policy Plan, 1994 City of Pompano Beach Planning and Zoning Board,Alternate Member, 1991-2001 City of Pompano Beach—Beach Community Redevelopment Advisory Board Member,2001 Marjorie Stoneman Douglas High School Mentor Program, 1992-1993 Junior Achievement,Student Assistant, 1993 Leadership Fort Lauderdale, 1999-2004 Background Ms.Ward is a recognized national and international urban planning and zoning professional with more than 30 years of planning and zoning expertise in the states of Florida, New York and Maine, and in Nova Scotia,Canada. Starting her career in the late 1970s Ms.Ward worked on the Town of Davie Comprehensive Plan,one of the first Comprehensive Plans ever developed in the State of Florida. She continued to develop her professional planning and zoning skills through the 1980s while working for Coral Ridge Properties, a then Fortune 500 land development company,where she worked in concert with the City of Parkland as Vice President of Government Planning to create land use and zoning regulations for corporate land holdings in Parkland. After more than nine years with Coral Ridge Properties, Ms. Ward was retained by the City of Fort Lauderdale, for the express purpose of updating and bringing in to compliance that city's Comprehensive Plan,which had not been updated for more than 10 years. Ms.Ward was also tasked with updating Fort Lauderdale's entire zoning code,which was more than 40 years old and internally inconsistent with the vision established for certain redevelopment areas, including the Fort Lauderdale Beach, the Downtown and Community Redevelopment Areas of the City. Meeting a 2 year deadline, Ms. Ward was successful in bringing both the City's Comprehensive Plan into compliance, and in updating the City's land development regulations to ensure consistency with the Plan. As a result, Ms.Ward was promoted to Director of Construction Services,which included supervising all activities and functions of the City of Fort Lauderdale Planning,Zoning, Building Departments,with responsibility of interpreting and implementing the City's Comprehensive Plan and Unified Land Development Regulations. During this time, Ms. Ward oversaw the creation of a Downtown Master Plan ensuring that such plan provided for new urbanism and smart growth standards. Because of her leadership in this regard, Downtown Fort Lauderdale has developed into a vibrant and pedestrian 2 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc. 18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3.23.22 Task Manager/Quality Control Officer.Assisted with and reviewed more than 50 traffic operations and safety studies. Studies included crash analyses, signal warrant studies, intersection analyses, delay studies, queuing analyses and pedestrian studies.US 168 Corridor Tollroad Feasibility Study,Chesapeake,VA; Project Manager/Task Manager. Conducted financial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School, Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD)for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop-off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication report(IJR); served as the task leader for the preparation of the state environmental impact report(SEIR); conducted the interchange operational analysis reports(IOAR)for the adjacent interchanges and developed the public involvement program.Page 2 of 3 friendly area, for which Ms. Ward was awarded Fort Lauderdale's Finest by a local community grass- roots organization, and was honored by the City's Downtown Development Authority, a not-for-profit authority,for her outstanding contribution to the renaissance of the downtown area of Fort Lauderdale. In 2006, she was subsequently awarded the "Former Exemplary Employee Award" by the City, in recognition of the positive impact she had in the land use and zoning changes that were implemented under her direction and leadership throughout the City of Fort Lauderdale. Ms Ward has also utilized her planning and zoning expertise in the State of New York where she has provided planning and zoning services for the City of New York,the Town of North Hempstead,and the City of Ogdensburg, including the preparation of various zoning regulations and vision plans for those entities. As Planning Commissioner, she managed the development of a Vision Plan for Port Washington,a large multi-neighborhood waterfront area located in North Hempstead. This project led to the adoption of a Vision Plan for the Port Washington area,and implementation of land development regulations intended to steer development to commercial parcels in need of revitalization. In 2006,Ms.Ward established JC Consulting Enterprises, Inc. Since then she has represented a large number of private developers and local government agencies on numerous land use,zoning and land development projects. One of her more significant long term projects was the management of the planning of an eco-oriented community envisioned for a 3,000 acre privately owned site,located in the State of Maine. She has also led a team of professionals in preparing vision plans for a 1,900 acre golf course community located in upstate New York and a Windmill project in Gulliver's Cove,in Nova Scotia, Canada. In 2009, her firm was retained by the City of Pompano Beach Community Redevelopment Agency CRA). Ms. Ward represented the Pompano Beach CRA on all planning and zoning related matters, including but not limited to evaluating Pompano Beach and Broward County land use plans and Pompano Beach zoning regulations for the express purpose of identifying land use and zoning provisions necessary to implement the City's East and West Community Redevelopment Plans. This effort led to a rewrite of the City's Atlantic Boulevard Overlay regulations for the East CRA,and a Transit Oriented Corridor land use designation for a 269 acre area located in Downtown Pompano Beach CRA area,both of which Ms.Ward participated in. Since 2010, Ms.Ward's firm has been retained by the Town of Lauderdale-By-The-Sea,for which Ms. Ward has provided professional expertise on planning and zoning related matters of the Town on a case by case basis. One such project included an evaluation of the Town's Comprehensive Plan and Land Development Regulations, wherein she provided professional recommendations and identified implementation measures necessary to update the Town's LDRs in terms of consistency and compatibility with the Town's Comprehensive Plan goals,objectives and policies. Ms.Ward is also recognized as a planning and zoning expert, and has testified in a numerous public hearings, and legal matters as an expert in comprehensive planning, land development regulations, community area planning,and zoning codes. Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases: o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation- 3 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc. 18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3.23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20- year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices( MUTCD)for the school' s primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop-off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication report(IJR); served as the task leader for the preparation of the state environmental Expert Testimony Public Hearing Law Firms: Shutts and Bowen Steven Tilbrook Akerman Senterfitt William Spencer o Cardinal Gibbons High School,Fort Lauderdale, Ball Field Lighting-Expert Testimony Public Hearing Law Firms: Shubin&Bass- John Shubin,Amy Huber Lochrie&Chakas Robert Lochrie o Casa Medico,LLC- Special Exception/Thrift Store Pompano Beach- Expert Testimony Public Hearing No law firm involved Consultatio Key Biscayne, LLC-Sonesta Beach Hotel Site Plan-Expert Testimony Public Hearings Law Firms: Shubin&Bass- John Shubin Amy Huber Akerman Senterfitt William Spencer Fairfield Manor,Village of Bal Harbour- Neighborhood Group Repeal of Issuance of Permit for Bal Harbour Shoppes-Expert Testimony Public Hearing Law Firm Akerman Senterfitt William Spencer Grand Birch LLC, Grand Birch Condominium Fort Lauderdale-Site Plan 4 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc. 18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3.23.22 unity envisioned for a 3, 000 acre privately owned site,located in the State of Maine. She has also led a team of professionals in preparing vision plans for a 1, 900 acre golf course community located in upstate New York and a Windmill project in Gulliver's Cove, in Nova Scotia,Canada.In 2009, her firm was retained by the City of Pompano Beach Community Redevelopment Agency CRA). Ms. Ward represented the Pompano Beach CRA on all planning and zoning related matters,including but not limited to evaluating Pompano Beach and Broward County land use plans and Pompano Beach zoning regulations for the express purpose of identifying land Expert Testimony Public Hearings Law Firm: Gunster Yoakley Don Hall Heidi Davis Kinderhook NY-Private Residence-Historic Preservation Board- Approval of improvements to historic building-Expert Testimony Public Hearing No Law Firm Involved. Related Group-Icon Las Olas Condominium,Fort Lauderdale-Site Plan Expert Witness Litigation for City of Fort Lauderdale Law Firm: Gunster Yoakley Michael Marcil o Southern Development Services Inc.,-Land Use Amendment/Land Development Code Amendment Retail Use to allow for Dollar General store-Delray Beach- Expert Testimony Public Hearings Law Firm: Siegel, Lipman, Dunay,Shepard Miskel, LLP- Bonnie Miskel o Transacta Development LLC-Surfside Hotel-Site Plan Expert Testimony Public Hearing Law Firm: Akerman Senterfitt William Spencer, Neisen Kasdin o Royal Atlantic LLC, Royal Atlantic Condominium Fort Lauderdale-Site Plan 5 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc. 18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3.23.22 954)815- 4298 As of 3.23.22 unity envisioned for a 3, 000 acre privately owned site, located in the State of Maine. She has also led a team of professionals in preparing vision plans for a 1, 900 acre golf course community located in upstate New York anda Windmill project in Gulliver's Cove,in Nova Scotia,Canada. In 2009, her firm was retained by the City of Pompano Beach Community Redevelopment Agency CRA). Ms. Ward represented the Pompano Beach CRA on all planning and zoning related matters,including but not limited to evaluating Pompano Beach and Broward County land use plans and Expert Testimony Public Hearings Law Firm: Gunster Yoakley Don Hall, Heidi Davis o Cortez Development-Fort Lauderdale-Site Plan Expert Testimony/Public Hearings/Litigation Law Firms Poole,McKinley and Blosser Jim Blosser Hopping Green and Sams Miguel Collazo Ruden McClosky o The Sails Fort Lauderdale- Site Plan-Expert Testimony Public Hearings Law Firm: Mastrianna and Christensen Ron Mastriana o Bayshore Development- Fort Lauderdale Site Plan Expert Testimony Public Hearings Application Law Firm Greenberg Traurig Debbie Orshefsky o First Presbyterian Church- Fort Lauderdale Site Plan Expert Testimony Public Hearings Law Firms Lochrie and Chakas Robert Lochrie Law Office of Hugh Chappell,Jr. Hugh Chapel! 6 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc. 18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3.23.22 81 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954) 815-4298 As of 3.23. 22 954)815-4298 As of 3. 23.22 unity envisioned for a 3,000 acre privately owned site,located in the State of Maine. She has also led a team of professionals in preparing vision plans for a 1,900 acre golf course community located in upstate New York and a Windmill project inGulliver's Cove, in Nova Scotia,Canada.In 2009, her firm was retained by the City of Pompano Beach Community Redevelopment Agency CRA). Ms. Ward represented the Pompano Beach CRA on all planning and zoning related matters, including but not limited to evaluating Pompano Beach and Broward County land use plans and Pompano Beach zoning regulations o Largo Mar Hotel and Club Site Plan Expert Testimony Public Hearings Law Firm Lochrie and Chakas Robert Lochrie o VIntro Fort Lauderdale Site Plan Expert Testimony Public Hearings Law Firm Siegel,Lipman, Dunay,Shepard& Miskel,LLP Scott Bachman o West Second Street Associates -Oakland Park Site Plan Veteran Administration Building Expert Testimony Public Hearings Law Firm: Mastrianna and Christensen Ron Mastriana o Casa Medico-Pompano Beach-Code change for Special Exception Use/B-3 Zoning to allow for Thrift Store-Expert Testimony Public Hearing No law firm involved. 7 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc. 18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3.23.22 hakas Robert Lochrie Law Office of Hugh Chappell,Jr. Hugh Chapel!6 Cecelia Ward, AICP JC Consulting Enterprises, Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,# 313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815- 4298 As of 3.23. 22 81 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta, Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3. 23. 22 954) 815-4298 As of 3.23. 22 unity envisioned for a 3,000 acre privately owned site,located in the State of Maine. She has also led a team of professionalsin preparing vision plans for a 1,900 acre golf course community located in upstate New York and a Windmill project in Gulliver's Cove,in Nova Scotia, Canada.In 2009, her firm was retained by the City of Pompano Beach Community Redevelopment Agency CRA). Ms. Ward represented the Pompano Beach CRA on all planning and Summary of Public Sector Experience: City of Fort Lauderdale Comprehensive Planning Zoning and Land Development Regulations Community Redevelopment Plans Master Plans Development Permit Application Reviews,including but not limited to Site Plan,Variances,Vacations,Plats Interpretations of Land Use Plans,Code and City Ordinances Represented the City on Land Use Litigation matters Town of Lauderdale-By-The-Sea,Florida Comprehensive Planning Zoning and Land Development Regulations Other general planning and zoning consulting services City of Pompano Beach Community Redevelopment Agency Comprehensive Planning Zoning and Land Development Regulations Nuisance Commercial Uses City of Sunrise Development Services Department Comprehensive Planning Zoning and Land Development Regulations Development Agreements City of New York Strategic Planning Town of North Hempstead Land Use Plans Zoning and Land Development Regulations Community Redevelopment Plans Master Plans Development Permit Application Reviews,including but not limited to Environmental Permit Applications, Site Plan,Variances,Vacations,Plats,Historic Preservation Interpretations of Land Use Plans,Code and City Ordinances Management of Grants as Director of Department City of Ogdensburg Review of Waterfront Redevelopment Plan and Scope of Services for Request For Proposals Summary of Other Private Sector Experience: Mid South Engineering o Worked on one of the first comprehensive plans developed in southeast Florida-Town of Davie Coral Ridge Properties o Assisted in land use and zoning issues related to all land development activities for corporate land holdings in the City of Parkland 8 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc. 18081 SE Country Club Dnve,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3.23.22 o Assisted in the drafting of City of Parkland Parks and Recreation land use and zoning regulations Siren Management Corp.-[Winter Harbor,ME;Trenton, ME;Loon Lake,NY;Gulliver's Cove,N.S.] o Land Use and Zoning Expertise for Private Land Owner with Properties located in Nova Scotia, Maine and New York State Recent Projects: NRNS IV Acquisition,LLC-[Pine Hollow-Parkland,Fl] Expert Witness Litigation for Defendant(Gunster Law- Fort Lauderdale) Citizens for Responsible Development Inc v.City of Dania Beach and Dania Entertainment Center LLC- Expert Witness Litigation for Plaintiff(Conrad& Scherer Fort Lauderdale) Zaveco vs.Woodmont Development Corp.-Expert Witness Litigation for Plaintiff (Conrad&Scherer Fort Lauderdale) TS&B,LLC.Vs.City of Hallandale Beach-Expert Witness Litigation for Plaintiff(Gunster Law-Fort Lauderdale) Realty Assoc.Funds IX LP vs.Town of Cutler Bay and GCF Investments Inc.-Shoppes of Cutler Bay-Expert Witness Litigation for Defendant(Gray Robinson— Miami) Keystone,Florida Property Holding Corp.—Galleria Mall,-Fort Lauderdale,Proposed Planned Development-Rezoning and Site Plan Town of Lauderdale-By-The-Sea,FL-General Planning and Zoning Services;Evaluation of Comprehensive Plan;Study of Annexed Area Zoning City of Pompano Beach CRA—Zoning in progress issues—Nuisance Commercial Uses City of Pembroke Pines—Wastewater Capacity Planning Analysis Robert Black—Riverland Estates Plat—City of Fort Lauderdale—Plat Application Broward Design Center—City of Fort Lauderdale- Planning review of Parking Related issues MB Development—Town of Surfside—Planning Analysis of Beach Concessions 9 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc. 18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3.23.22 18081 SE Country Club Dnve,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3. 23.22 ulations for the express purpose of identifying land use and zoning provisions necessary to implement the City' s East and West Community Redevelopment Plans. This effort led to a rewrite of the City's Atlantic Boulevard Overlay regulations for the East CRA,and a Transit Oriented Corridor land use designation for a 269 acre area located in Downtown Pompano Beach CRA area, both of which Ms.Ward participated in.Since 2010, Ms.Ward's firm has been retained by the Town of Lauderdale-By-The-Sea,for which Ms.Ward has provided professional expertise on planning and zoning related matters of the Town on a case by case basis. One such project included an evaluation of the Town's Comprehensive Plan and Land Development Regulations, wherein she provided professional recommendations and identified implementation measures necessary to update the Town's LDRs in terms of consistency and compatibility with the Town's Comprehensive Plan goals, objectives and policies.Ms.Ward is also recognized as a planning and zoning expert, and has testified in a numerous public hearings, and legal matters as an expert in comprehensive planning, land development regulations,community area planning,and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation-3 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3.23. 22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake, Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources. US 17 Bypass Corridor Study, Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration. North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices( MUTCD)for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop-off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication report(IJR); served as the task leader for the preparation of the state environmental impact report(SEIR); conducted the interchange operational analysis reports(IOAR)for the adjacent interchanges and developed the public involvement program.Page 2 of 3 Collins and 72nd Street Developers—City of Miami Beach—North Beach Area Study—Planning Analysis of Proposed Master Plan Grande Bay Estates—Neighborhood Association— Wellington—Planning Analysis of Gate Issue Seneca Industrial Development—City of Pembroke Park—Review of Site Plan application related to Seneca Town Center PMG Riverfront—City of Fort Lauderdale—Review Historic Preservation Related Issues in conjunction with Site Plan application Investments Limited LLC—City of Boca Raton-Expert Witness for Plaintiff related to redevelopment potential of property(Attorney's investments Limited LLC) Granite Investments LLC—City of Aventura-Proposed Land Use and Land Development Code changes to permit mixed use development Indian Creek Country Club—Indian Creek Village,FL— related to request for Dock Permit Port Aventura Gross Holdings LLC—Aventura,FL- Land Use and Zoning text amendment and site plan for mixed use development Alexan Fort Lauderdale-Site Plan Land Use and Zoning review for Hotel/Condo DR Horton—Fort Lauderdale rezoning and site Plan for townhouse development 8995 Collins—Surfside,FL-Site Plan Land Use and Zoning review for Hotel/Condo RK Centers LLC—Comprehensive Plan and Zoning analysis In opposition to proposed development— expert witness—Sunny Isles,FL 222 Lakeview LLC-RedSky Capital WPB Land Use Zoning Litigation on behalf of Plaintiff(Nason Yeager Gerson,White I Lioce,PA—WPB) Conrad Scherer—Comprehensive Plan and Zoning analysis In opposition to proposed AHF development— Fort Lauderdale,FL TS&B,LLC-Impact of NE 1 Avenue Lane Reduction on Land Holdings—Hallandale,FL Town of Poultney,Vermont-Economic Development Consultant and review of Land Use and Zoning regulations 10 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc. 18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3.23.22 lations for the express purpose of identifying land use and zoning provisions necessary to implement the City's East and West Community Redevelopment Plans. This effort led to a rewrite of the City's Atlantic Boulevard Overlay regulations for the East CRA,and a Transit Oriented Corridor land use designation for a 269 acre area located in Downtown Pompano Beach CRA area,both of which Ms.Ward participated in.Since 2010, Ms.Ward's firm has been retained by the Town of Lauderdale-By-The-Sea,for which Ms. Ward has provided professional expertise on planning and zoning related matters of the Town on a case by case basis. One such project included an evaluation of the Town's Comprehensive Plan and Land Development Regulations, wherein she provided professional recommendations and identified implementation measures necessary to update the Town's LDRs in terms of consistency and compatibility with the Town's Comprehensive Plan goals,objectives and policies.Ms.Ward is also recognized as a planning and zoning expert, and has testified in a numerous public hearings, and legal matters as an expert in comprehensive planning, land development regulations,community area planning,and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation-3 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3. 23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD)for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop-off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication report( IJR); served as the task leader for the preparation of the state environmental impact report(SEIR); conducted the interchange operational analysis reports(IOAR)for the adjacent interchanges and developed the public involvement program.Page 2 of 3 Ori Lapidot—Land Use and Zoning Fort Lauderdale Properties(Crush Law) City of Sunrise FL-Planning Consultant West Shore LLC -Alachua County Land Use/Zoning— Litigation on behalf of Plaintiff(Akerman—Fort Lauderdale) 4112 El Mar Drive—Single Family Conditional Use— Lauderdale-By-the-Sea(Crush Law) City of Miami Beach—Land Use/Zoning Review of Permits issued for South of Fifth Properties Flagler Village—Review of Proposed Development of One Stop Shop Property(Flagler Village Neighborhood Assoc.-Fort Lauderdale) West Shore Point of Naples LLP—Land Use/Zoning Review of St.Matthews House CPUD application Akerman PA) Current Projects 2021-2022/Associated Law Firms: KZ Copans LLC—Small-Scale Land Use Amendment— and Rezoning-City of Pompano Beach(Gunster,PA) Hayes Street Properties—Zoning Issues(Angelo& Banta PA) Davie—Billy Jack's—Site Land Use and Zoning Issues Angelo&Banta PA) Ocean Park Residences and Hotel—Site Plan Level IV- Fort Lauderdale(Lochrie&Chakas PA) Hillcrest By The Sea,Surfside,FL—Multifamily Residential Site Plan(Shubin&Bass,PA) 11 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc. 18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3.23.22 analysis In opposition to proposed development—expert witness—Sunny Isles, FL 222 Lakeview LLC-RedSky Capital WPB Land Use Zoning Litigation on behalf of Plaintiff(Nason Yeager Gerson,White I Lioce,PA—WPB)Conrad Scherer—Comprehensive Plan and Zoning analysis In opposition to proposed AHF development—Fort Lauderdale,FL TS& B,LLC-Impact of NE 1 Avenue Lane Reduction on Land CITY OF DANIA BEACH REZONING APPLICATION NO. RZ-055-21 3851 STIRLING HOLDINGS, LLP Expert Planning Opinion by Cecelia Ward, AICP PRESIDENT JC CONSULTING ENTERPRISES INC. 18081 SE Country Club Drive, Unit 313 Tequesta, Florida PH: (954) 815-4298 cward@icconsultinqinc.net MAY 9,2022 O rt o L, m L a a g m U >-ig i It it Iii ioi IilffiI L4 5 = 8f 1111 3 1'lltM R Al'i keg t h Mil ppirt - ' 74 tiA er lif . 1 tlg IA Pi%!ID Igil ill 6-. 1} y ii i PP MD 1 IgIR 4 Can V1111 1 3 41 3,M? 1. 41 tif 11 0 Table of Contents Executive Summary 3 Review of Rezoning Criteria 3 Appendices 11 Appendix A. Applicant's Responses to Rezoning Review Standards 12 Appendix B. Excerpts from the City of Dania Beach Comprehensive Plan 16 Appendix C—City of Dania Beach Zoning and Land Use References 19 ice p 1. 1— -'-.----- T N ' I ' J±_ 1 e 1,4 1 b I H 4.•+. p\ t,,t\`‘ '*,,),. m ., I Y P .',x A, mac. " 1 pt: 1'444...4 44p .". ' a Vie „'#' 9u+ Figure 1.Site Location Aerial 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 Executive Summary I, Cecelia Ward, AICP, President of JC Consulting Enterprises Inc., was retained by Harger Hills Area Neighborhood Association to provide this expert planning opinion regarding the proposed 3851 Stirling Holdings, LLLP application for rezoning of a 10-acre property, located at 3851 Stirling Road, in the City of Dania Beach, Florida, ("subject property"). The rezoning application is also referred to by the city as Koosh Living&Rezoning&Flex",City Rezoning Case No. RZ-055-21. The subject property has a current zoning designation of Single-Family Estate Residential (E-1). The request is to rezone the 10-acre site to Planned Residential Development(PRD-1)to permit a mixed-use development on the site. A corresponding site plan application has been filed with the city proposing a mix of retail and commercial uses on the ground floor of a proposed building fronting on Stirling Road, with residential apartments above the commercial uses. Townhouses are proposed along the northerly 2/3rds of the eastern boundary of the property. The applicant is also requesting an "allocation of flex" units from the City of Dania Beach to provide the needed 231 residential dwelling units and 1/3 acre of commercial use to accommodate the proposed development. The details of this proposal are addressed in the site plan application now pending before the city. The site plan elements will be addressed under a separate review. This opinion provides a review of the rezoning application, which will demonstrate that the rezoning request from E-1 to PRD-1 does not meet the City of Dania Rezoning Criteria as provided under Section 645-40 of the City's Land Development Code(LDC). Review of Rezoning Criteria The following provides a review of each of the rezoning criteria contained in Section 645-40 of the City's LDC,identifying the errors in the responses that the applicant,and city staffs,used to base a determination of compliance with the rezoning criteria. The following information has been attached to this report. Appendix A - Coker & Feiner Memorandum — January 11, 2022 (Applicant's Responses to Rezoning Review Standards Appendix B - Excerpts from the City of Dania Beach Comprehensive Plan — Future Land Use Element,Transportation Element and Housing Element. 1See City of Dania Beach Community Development Department Staff Memorandums—Case No.RZ-055-21 dated April 20,2022 and May 10,2022. 3 269 acre area located in Downtown Pompano Beach CRA area,both of which Ms.Ward participated in.Since 2010, Ms.Ward's firm has been retained by the Town of Lauderdale-By-The-Sea,for which Ms.Ward has provided professional expertise on planning and zoning related matters of the Town on a case by case basis. One such project included an evaluation of the Town's Comprehensive Plan and Land Development Regulations, wherein she provided professional recommendations and identified implementation measures necessary to update the Town's LDRs in terms of consistency and compatibility with the Town's Comprehensive Plan goals,objectives and policies.Ms.Ward is also recognized as a planning and zoning expert, and has testified in a numerous public hearings, and legal matters as an expert in comprehensive planning, land development regulations,community area planning,and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel, LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale, Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation-3 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc. 18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954) 815-4298 As of 3.23. 22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC; Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD)for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road. Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop-off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication report(IJR); served as the task leader for the preparation of the state environmental impact report(SEIR); conducted the interchange operational analysis reports(IOAR) Rezoning Criteria(1)The request is consistent with the city's comprehensive plan. Review of Applicant's Response to Rezoning Criteria(1): a) Applicant's Response Regarding Allocation of Flex Units: The applicant claim's that the rezoning to PRD-1"will be"consistent with the City's Comprehensive Plan in that the flex residential units and flex commercial acreage would allocate the required units and commercial acreage necessary for development of the subject property as proposed. Error in Applicant's Response:While it is true that the allocation of flexibility units and commercial acreage are allowed under the City's Comprehensive Plan, the review of the appropriateness of allocating flex units and flex acreage must also be considered. In this particular case, if approved, the allocation as requested would deduct almost a 1/3 of the available residential flexibility dwelling units allowed within the Unified Flex Zone (221 of the 784 remaining flex units). This would greatly diminish the city's ability to allocate flex units throughout the City, where such increases in density may be more appropriate, such as future Local Activity Centers(LAC). Additionally,the allocation of such a significant amount of flex units to this site may compete with the objectives of the City's Comprehensive Plan that direct mixed use development more appropriately to those properties located within the City's Community Redevelopment Area(CRA),especially those fronting on transit corridors and adjacent to the Tri-Rail Station in the CRA. b) Applicant's Response of Consistency with Future Land Use Policy 1.1. Provide for a mix of residential communities which will promote a diverse population and a healthy environment. Error in Applicant's Response: It is true that Policy 1.1 encourages a mix of residential communities; however, it is an overreach to presume that the intent of the Policy is in support of a such dramatic increase in density from E-1 Single Family Estate Residential(1 dwelling unit per ac)to a PRD-1 Planned Residential Development(permitting a requested 22 dwelling units per acre). Rather,Policy 1.1.must be viewed within the context of Objective 1,which requires that the provision of a mix of residential communities, etc., are done so in a way that promotes ... "orderly growth, development,and placement of land uses,which will encourage a mix of residential types and provide good quality of life for the residents of the City of Dania Beach. [emphasis added]". There has been no evidence shown that the change in zoning to allow a much greater density on the subject property(and the interjection of additional commercial acreage)will result in providing a good quality of life for residents of the city that reside adjacent to the subject site. Regarding the Plan's requirement to promote development that provides a healthy environment,the rezoning does not address the potential health impacts that may result from increasing density and locating townhomes adjacent to the numerous FPL high-tension wires that span nearly 93% of the property Further, Policy 1.1 should also be reviewed within the context of other Future Land Use Policies that encourage and direct a mix of residential communities or"mixed-use" development adjacent to the 4 community area planning,and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/ Appeal of Zoning Interpretation-3 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta, Florida 33469 954) 815-4298 As of 3.23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD) for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road. Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing( drop-off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication report(IJR); served as the task leader for the preparation of the state environmental impact Tri-Rail Station and towards development within the CRA and LAC areas of the City (Transportation Element Policies 3.9, 3.10,9.4,and 9.5, Housing Element Objective XII—Policy 12.1). Lastly, Policy 1.1 should also be considered in connection with Future Land Use Policy 25.1., which states that the City shall encourage "homeownership... by encouraging and supporting residential development that contemplates the sale of dwelling units in fee simple or as condominiums." Residential rental apartments that would be permitted as a result of the rezoning appear to be in contradiction with this policy. c) Applicant's Response Regarding Consistency with Future Land Use Policy 5.1. Encourage development to enhance the tax base of the community. Error in Applicant's Response: The applicant refers to Policy 5.1,implying that redevelopment of the site for a more intensive and dense use than what is currently allowed under the Estate zoning would result in an enhanced tax base. However, there is no study or review of the potential negative tax base implications that may result due to the negative impact the rezoning may have on property values of adjacent E-1 and RS zoned single family homes surrounding the subject site. d) Applicant's Response Regarding PRD Zoning Provides a Well-Balanced Transition. Error in Applicant's Response: The applicant claims that the rezoning from Estate to PRD will result in a well-balanced transition between adjacent residential properties to the east and commercial property to the west of the subject site. A closer review of the surrounding land use, zoning and existing uses reveals that the PRD zoning would have the effect of carving out a rather large area to permit development that is out of scale with the pattern of development that is adjacent to the subject property, and therefore does not provide a for a well-balanced transition in zoning. An assessment of the adjoining 106.565-acre neighborhood, generally bounded by Stirling Road on the south, SW 40th Avenue on the west, Shady Ridge Road on the north, and the Dania Beach city limits on the east, reveals that the PRD-1 rezoning would be in conflict with the nearly 100.09 acres 93.92%) of existing low/low-medium density single family zoning, within the area, as further addressed below: o Stirling Road is an east-west transportation corridor within Dania Beach,and functions as the southern limit anchoring the "neighborhood". From there, all residential and commercial lands north of Stirling Road in an approximate square totaling nearly 106.56 acres in size were taken into account in this review. o Within that area, residential lands are zoned E-1, RS6000, and RS12000. Commercial lands are zoned either C-1,C-2,or C-3. o The nearest multifamily zoned properties are west of SW 40th Avenue, a distance of approximately 1,200 feet west of the site. The land immediately adjacent to and just west of SW 40th Avenue is zoned RM-6000 Low-Medium Residential with a density of 5-10 units per acre. 5 on wires that span nearly 93% of the property Further, Policy 1.1 should also be reviewed within the context of other Future Land Use Policies that encourage and direct a mix of residential communities or" mixed-use" development adjacent to the 4 community area planning, and zoning codes. Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel, LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation- 3 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc. 18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3. 23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake, Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD) for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop-off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project Summary of Findings: 93.9%of the lands adjoining the subject property are zoned Low—Low Medium Density. The proposed project would insert a 22-unit per acre development midway into the neighborhood—at a density approximate to the City's RM-2 zoning. Existing commercial lands adjacent to the property total approximately 4.6 acres. The development would add approximately 14,600 SF of additional commercial use to the area. There is no indication that the existing commercial development does not meet the commercial needs of the adjacent existing residential community and that there is a demand for additional commercial development to serve the community. Rather, the plan is to provide commercial retail to meet the needs of the increased density that is proposed for the development site. Approximately 97% of the subject property is encumbered by FPL easements for existing, above-ground power transmission lines.These electrical power lines have been a permitted use in the E-1 District since the adoption of Ord. No. 2010-20, § 2, 9-14-102.The rezoning would allow a development on the site with garages for the townhomes and open space for the entire development to be located directly under these transmission lines. The townhomes would be located adjacent to the lines potentially creating a more incompatible scenario by adding more residential density in close proximity to the existing power lines. Note: This assessment utilized Broward County Property Appraiser data including measured distances. Zoning and land use information derived from the City of Dania Beach regulations has been provided in Appendix C. Rezoning Criteria (2) The request is consistent with all applicable redevelopment plans, corridor plans, neighborhood plans and master plans approved by the City Commission. Review of Applicant's Response to Rezoning Criteria(2): a) Applicant's Response Regarding Consistency with All Applicable Plans—"to the extent that such plans exist for this area." Error in Applicant's Response: This response is accurate to some degree in that the subject property is not contained within a CRA redevelopment area,or in an LAC area,which would otherwise support mixed use development. However,what is not noted in the response is that mixed use development within CRA or LAC areas, or adjacent to the Tri-Rail Station would be consistent with the applicable City of Dania Beach Comprehensive Plan (see Transportation Element Policies 3.9, 3.10, 9.4, and 9.5, Housing Element Objective XII-Policy 12.1), which raises the question of consistency of the rezoning request with applicable City plans. b) Applicant's Response Regarding PRD Minimum Frontage: Error in Applicant's Response: The fact that the subject property has sufficient frontage on Stirling Road to meet a minimum lot standard in the PRD is irrelevant to this rezoning criteria and should not be considered by the City in terms of compliance with this criteria. 2 See City of Dania Beach Ord.No.2010-20,§2,9-14-10. 6 also be reviewed within the context of other Future Land Use Policies that encourage and direct a mix of residential communities or" mixed-use" development adjacent to the 4 community area planning,and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel,LLC- W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation-3 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815- 4298 As of 3. 23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD)for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop-off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication report( IJR); served as the task leader for the preparation of the state environmental impact report(SEIR); conducted the interchange operational analysis reports(IOAR)for the adjacent interchanges and developed the public involvement Rezoning Criteria(3): The request would not give privileges not generally extended to similarly situated property in the area or result in an isolated zoning district unrelated to adjacent or nearby districts. Review of Applicant's Responses to Rezoning Criteria (3)a,b,c,and d: 3. Applicant's Response Regarding PRD will not result in an Unrelated or Isolated Zoning District. Error in Applicant's Response: The applicant claims that the rezoning to PRD will not result in creating an unrelated or isolated zoning district when compared to adjacent nearby zoning districts. However,as reflected in the neighborhood analysis provided in this report,the applicant erroneously claims that the rezoning from E-1 to PRD-1 will result in a well-balanced transition between adjacent residential properties to the east and commercial property to the west of the subject site. As previously noted,a closer assessment of the adjoining 106.565-acre neighborhood surrounding the proposed project reveals that the PRD-1 rezoning would be in conflict with the nearly 100.09 acres (93.92%) of existing low/low-medium density single family zoning. This would have the effect of carving out a development that is significantly incompatible and out of scale with the patterns of development adjacent to the subject property. Rezoning Criteria 3.a: The request furthers the City's adopted community redevelopment plan, if applicable. a) Applicant's Response Regarding support for increase in Density and Intensity on Arterial Roadway. Error in Applicant's Response: The subject property is not located in the CRA, as acknowledged by the applicant. However, the applicant attempts to conflate the provisions of the City's Comprehensive Plan,which rather encourage and support mixed use development in relation to the CRA areas of the City, as noted in the City's Transportation Element and Housing Element. See also Appendix B). Transportation Element Policy 3.9 Adjacent to the Tri-Rail Station and to principal arterials providing BCT services within the Community Redevelopment Area("CRA")encourage mixed-use(emphasis added], and low-medium to medium-high density home-ownership residential (10—25 units per acre) when designed and located to be compatible with existing residential development." Housing Element-Objective XII Implement neighborhood improvement projects identified in the Community Redevelopment Area Plan. 7 rehensive Plan (see Transportation Element Policies 3.9, 3.10, 9.4, and 9.5, Housing Element Objective XII-Policy 12.1), which raises the question of consistency of the rezoning request with applicable City plans.b) Applicant's Response Regarding PRD Minimum Frontage:Error in Applicant's Response: The fact that the subject property has sufficient frontage on Stirling Road to meet a minimum lot standard in the PRD is irrelevant to this rezoning criteria and should not be considered by the City in terms of compliance with this criteria.2 See City of Dania Beach Ord.No.2010-20,§2,9-14-10.6 also be reviewed within the context of other Future Land Use Policies that encourage and direct a mix of residential communities or"mixed-use" development adjacent to the 4 community area planning,and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/ Appeal of Zoning Interpretation-3 Cecelia Ward, AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc. 18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3. 23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD) for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop-off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication report(IJR); served as the task leader for the preparation of the state environmental impact report(SEIR); conducted the interchange operational analysis reports( IOAR)for the adjacent interchanges and developed the public involvement program.Page 2 of 3 Policy 12.1: It is recommended that the various Comprehensive Plan elements be updated,as appropriate,to assist with the provision of ownership opportunities at higher income levels,as follows: Continue to expedite permitting, prioritize the allocation of flex units, and sponsor Future Land Use Plan amendments for luxury housing projects. Promote mixed-use development that provides an array of housing types along transit corridors,including the establishment of a Local Activity Center(LAC)future land use designation,the development of mixed use zoning districts,and the allocation of flex units to mixed-use projects. Implement neighborhood improvement projects identified in the Community Redevelopment Area." The idea that mixed use development is intended to be directed to the CRA [and LAC areas of the City]is further evidenced by additional City Transportation Element objectives and policies. Objective IX The City of Dania Beach,pursuant to the Community Redevelopment Agency(CRA) and Local Activity Center(LAC)land use plan designation,shall promote transit- oriented development. Policy 9.1 The City shall encourage and support private development in the CRA and LAC that include the following: 1. Mixed land uses including both residential and commercial uses. Policy 9.5 Include provisions in the City Land Development Regulations to encourage mixed use developments in the CRA and LAC." It is clear from the provisions of the City's Comprehensive Plan that mixed use development is encouraged in relation to properties,including those on transit corridors,that are located within the CRA,as well as the LAC areas of the City and those properties adjacent to the Tri-Rail Station, none of which pertain to the subject property. Rezoning Criteria 3.b: An error or ambiguity must be corrected. b) Applicant's Response Regarding Correcting a Code Error or Ambiguity. Error in Applicant's Response: While the applicant attempts to utilize a code clarification regarding criteria within the PRD zoning regulations, it is clear that the rezoning of the subject property cannot be supported on the basis that it in some way corrects an "error or ambiguity" in terms of the current zoning of the property. 8 t neighborhood improvement projects identified in the Community Redevelopment Area Plan. 7 rehensive Plan (see Transportation Element Policies 3.9, 3.10, 9. 4, and 9. 5, Housing Element Objective XII-Policy 12. 1), which raises the question of consistency of the rezoning request with applicable City plans.b) Applicant' s Response Regarding PRD Minimum Frontage:Error in Applicant's Response: The fact that the subject property has sufficient frontage on Stirling Road to meet a minimum lot standard in the PRD is irrelevant to this rezoning criteria and should not be considered by the City in terms of compliance with this criteria.2 See City of Dania Beach Ord.No.2010- 20,§2,9-14-10.6 also be reviewed within the context of other Future Land Use Policies that encourage and direct a mix of residential communities or"mixed-use" development adjacent to the 4 community area planning,and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel, LLC- W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation-3 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954) 815-4298 As of 3. 23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources. US 17 Bypass Corridor Study, Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School, Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices( MUTCD)for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop-off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication report(IJR); served as the task leader for the preparation of the state environmental impact report(SEIR); conducted the interchange operational analysis reports(IOAR)for the adjacent interchanges and developed the public involvement program.Page 2 of 3 Rezoning Criteria 3.c: There exists changed or changing conditions which make approval of the request appropriate. c) Applicant's Response Regarding changed conditions which make approval of the rezoning appropriate. Error in Applicant's Response: There is no doubt that mixed use development supports the interplay of providing connections to essential services for residents living within the mixed-use development. Additionally, there have been changes in telecommuting, with more people working from home. While these are trends that support mixed use development,the applicant has failed to demonstrate that conditions have changed which support mixed use development at this particular location. Further, the Applicant does not assess the proposed development and its potential adverse impacts and incompatibility that could result in relation to its changing conditions of the site by adding more residential development beneath the existing E-1 zoned permitted FPL electrical power transmission lines. Rezoning Criteria 3.d: Substantial reasons exist why the property cannot be used in accordance with existing zoning. d) Applicant's Response regarding substantial reasons why the property cannot be used in accordance with existing zoning. Errors in Applicant's Response: The applicant fails to demonstrate that the property cannot be used in accordance with its existing E-1 zoning. Rather, the Applicant attempts to substantiate the justification for rezoning on the basis that the proposed mixed-use development could not proceed without it. While true, such a rationale, if considered appropriate, could become the basis for rezoning any property within the City simply because a property owner or developer desires to develop it for uses not permitted under the current zoning. This rationale could lead the city into granting rezonings based upon a variance in use,or spot zoning. On that note, with respect to the existing FPL easements, there is no evidence provided by the applicant to demonstrate that the property could not be "used in accordance with the existing zoning". For example, an adjacent property located just west of the subject site, also contains FPL easements, and is being utilized as a "community farm",which is a permitted use under the existing E-1 zoning. This is not to say that a"community farm"is the highest or best use for the subject property, but rather that the applicant has not met the burden under the rezoning criteria necessary to reach the conclusions that substantial reasons exist as to why the subject site cannot be used in accordance with the existing zoning. 9 Frontage:Error in Applicant's Response: The fact that the subject property has sufficient frontage on Stirling Road to meet a minimum lot standard in the PRD is irrelevant to this rezoning criteria and should not be considered by the City in terms of compliance with this criteria.2 See City of Dania Beach Ord.No.2010-20,§2,9-14-10.6 also be reviewed within the context of other Future Land Use Policies that encourage and direct a mix of residential communities or"mixed-use" development adjacent to the 4 community area planning,and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation-3 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises, Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,# 313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954) 815-4298 As of 3.23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources. US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD)for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop- off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication report( IJR); served as the task leader for the preparation of the state environmental impact report(SEIR); conducted the interchange operational analysis reports(IOAR)for the adjacent interchanges and developed the public involvement program.Page 2 of 3 Rezoning Criteria 3.e: The rezoning is appropriate for the orderly development of the City and is compatible with existing(conforming)adjacent land uses, and planned adjacent land uses. e) Applicant's Response that the PRD is appropriate for the Orderly Development of the City. Error in Applicant's Response: The Applicant reiterates their contention that the PRD mixed use is appropriate because of its relationship to adjacent uses and the arterial roadway[Stirling Road]. However,as previously noted,the City's Comprehensive Plan directs mixed use development to certain areas of the City, i.e. the CRA, the LAC, and areas adjacent to the Tri-Rail Station, which have been identified as being those areas of the City that are appropriate for mixed use development. With respect to the remaining portion of the criteria, which requires that the rezoning be " compatible with existing (conforming) adjacent land uses...", the applicant failed to provide a response to this portion of the rezoning criteria. As previously noted in this report, the intensity and density allowed by virtue of the proposed rezoning from E-1 to PRD-1, results in a dramatic change in density, which is not compatible in relation to the adjoining properties or the neighborhood and surrounding land uses. The rezoning from E-1 to PRD-1 as proposed,would increase the total number of dwelling units that would be permitted on the subject property (from 10 du's to 231 du's), which equates to an increase of more than 220%in density from its current zoning. Additionally,the PRD would introduce 1/3 acre of commercial uses in an area of the City where such mixture of commercial and residential development has not been planned for or supported by the City's Comprehensive Plan,as demonstrated herein. As required under Future Land Use Element Policy 5.6,the City is required to"...employ its local land use plan and zoning ordinance to establish differing intensities of commercial development compatible with adjacent and surrounding land uses." [emphasis added] As such, it is not sufficient to simply defer to allowing differing intensities of commercial development, but rather it must be done in a manner that is"compatible with adjacent and surrounding land uses." Conclusion: In conclusion,the Applicant's request to rezone the subject property from E-1 to PRD-1[RZ 055- 21], should be denied by the City Commission for being inconsistent with the City's Comprehensive Plan and for noncompliance with the City's Rezoning Criteria as contained in Section 645-40 of the City's LDC. 10 necessary to reach the conclusions that substantial reasons exist as to why the subject site cannot be used in accordance with the existing zoning.9 Frontage:Error in Applicant's Response: The fact that the subject property has sufficient frontage on Stirling Road to meet a minimum lot standard in the PRD is irrelevant to this rezoning criteria and should not be considered by the City in terms of compliance with this criteria.2 See City of Dania Beach Ord.No.2010-20,§ 2,9- 14- 10.6 also be reviewed within the context of other Future Land Use Policies that encourage and direct a mix of residential communities or"mixed-use" development adjacent to the 4 community area planning, and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/ Appeal of Zoning Interpretation- 3 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3.23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC; Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD) for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop-off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication report(IJR); served as the task Appendices 11 3 Review of Rezoning Criteria 3 Appendices 11 Appendix A. Applicant' s Responses to Rezoning Review Standards 12 Appendix B. Excerpts from the City of Dania Beach Comprehensive Plan 16 Appendix C—City of Dania Beach Zoning and Land Use References 19 ice p 1. 1— -'-.----- T N ' I ' J±_ 1 e 1,4 1 b I H 4.•+. p\t,, t\`‘ '*,,),. m ., IY P .', x A, mac. " 1 pt: 1' 444... 4 44p .". 'a Vie „'#'9u+ Figure 1. Site Location Aerial 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 Appendix A. Applicant's Responses to Rezoning Review Standards wawuaR COKER&FEINER y yRCFRII Al Mf11R Awls pare and ow.nomm.ern. Rrt NRpo ozsiL LL.A tIRswnrseai0+lb111 IIaPI WOO ewes !f aMA RAl#RV1tLOOM arw aim rwsliw iiirrmes MEMORANDUM Dalt: hasty 11.3022 To: City of Dania Beech From Red A.Feiner,Esq. Re: 3151 Sliding Holdings,LLLP Re-Zoning de Allman Unit?Awn Grime er PlitfurrT mirspr roar NATURE OF TEE REMISE The Applicant and Owner. 31151 Sir1Eg Hoidiogs.LLLP( tlesg likings")is the caner ovna of this mai of potpaw and pedaled tie pigsty in N bes 2M. The wpm coeisa of an lot he pigmy weds to be pin*thugh his snbatariely burdened wilt use Florin Prwr& Light easement it both poseur lees ad access ad beibeg are not gland is be loaned within the essa n ant kits ea mnk FptitL has i nnaltd parr Fames. The prepay is nownly awed&1. The Omer acquired the papetty fir the pmtpase of riot g a aibed siroed-aiot ieswlspi t which will a r.f• -.•s.- • trie s as the beedies-s pond fls "bids feats St1Lt deed ned do a sesiireed apartments ahem the ccmmactai uses sung;with tens homes elan the non bender!side pommy. The tesnhees sate AS di addtnami buffer fir the adpcedt she-fasily Mmes. Tits type of atlrss fell use of de p merry as paring and recreational anions can roan it the easement arse wrier the prep Lees. The pmpeeed deeeh ptemt is alined is the p!D-1 Zoning Dt Sec!send me development is'sinned to help let casual lse s men is she domot. especially with wan diney ad p rdeing,aeon let the time of**big bra trteil'steblisls!s stand—aim coemettiat development lave past as aay of these stores are suer fling banbtnory and C—leCI1le-S. 12 n and zoning ordinance to establish differing intensities of commercial development compatible with adjacent and surrounding land uses." [emphasis added] As such, it is not sufficient to simply defer to allowing differing intensities of commercial development, but rather it must be done in a manner that is"compatible with adjacent and surrounding land uses."Conclusion:In conclusion, the Applicant's request to rezone the subject property from E-1 to PRD-1[RZ 055-21], should be denied by the City Commission for being inconsistent with the City's Comprehensive Plan and for noncompliance with the City's Rezoning Criteria as contained in Section 645-40 of the City's LDC.10 necessary to reach the conclusions that substantial reasons exist as to why the subject site cannot be used in accordance with the existing zoning.9 Frontage:Error in Applicant's Response: The fact that the subject property has sufficient frontage on Stirling Road to meet a minimum lot standard in the PRD is irrelevant to this rezoning criteria and should not be considered by the City in terms of compliance with this criteria.2 See City of Dania Beach Ord.No.2010-20,§2,9-14- 10.6 also be reviewed within the context of other Future Land Use Policies that encourage and direct a mix of residential communities or" mixed- use" development adjacent to the 4 community area planning,and zoning codes. Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale, Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation-3 Cecelia Ward, AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta, Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3. 23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration. North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD)for the school' s primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop-off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication report(IJR); served as the task leader for the 11Z-ZONINGOrtST A rtreetion Z-1 a>bas 1 t 4Pa I. ntt ttipteitt earitalattataraaA oho CA*eta', • Piot The reorants rompost is anatomist with duo Cay's , Past Tin Owner and Applicant aid to the Ciett far a flan oak allocatioa Chas tlracmen eta allocated tiiaa the prod sonnest as'soar win the Coy's Maas Pam,a nand wrr .• Wail s Ides tits PID Zonton Di os allows,to convona with no Cup's C __._x RAW empaciallyabets artetaidontithats, la addiciasa deoproposed PII)-1 Zenists Dubin wanes*a*a , x t, traission besswas the • properams to der east amid ant of to orbital rags Etat of do sito air dw a ° , : a adult t + of no property aaa a , •; £ as a crrraoAs kat trosoviiig fias pvertr to PRD-1, area amwd mos.will allow the proposty to sem an a tansitios bane* E tad ronlaaaa n awe sainant this praparty u beetroot Iapartiathr.ens anamonag roquita is ortareston weltties tddso •,.<>.:_ Pita foray 1.1. Pommies for a a ia atressimental 1,2 Watch veil prowl.a disarm and ahisahlay x • P I.I. Eacauraga • as annum the raa base ofthe 2. lb orgoost to walk ati rats• mat,oarottiorpdanut r _••r= plan andd asuaaotr piano by Riot Ci C sssr Ths is with a plas arm neater pinta to no extant that far that sear ;_ ,. . . do rospeit' is anamisatee wait tar A ..••.. . , of,i I to tones of the aaattaaa of fsaaaag as Am at lutist re aaiatay sad any aas an no pa+apwaty wall ba cater aaaaat with det MD- 1 a I_ to storotofy stoma or the 13,62,of rest&as ow gralgooli wormy tskorrisiodaas or oloorfoy‘tiorion Tbs solatmetin regant oil oat sine pardopt eitanded to vitae inislatity sinned ponsinsos or noun ra an PRD sad residential wan, to eras as one peoperty prosided that Gab as arterial roadway and popery time)an tatiefie1. In this mato dot.nos Saatairata all et do nadarlyiwyg ; tin 1 D-I Zenon act. Pia,mann the beidinp Rand Conran there ato ,x :_.,. s stead pompom which friar Stirlitep mad with tonadestiolly monad poverty lohnol th w._,__. -,••,- property, Tfaa proposed atratosting sllorrst bade the asta n ecial aaad dal was as reaaais aad boas tits PRO r sirwoliosal Itta Milt it?mai*a 1 13 ance with the City' s Rezoning Criteria as contained in Section 645-40 of the City's LDC.10 necessary to reach the conclusions that substantial reasons exist as to why the subject site cannot be used in accordance with the existing zoning.9 Frontage:Error in Applicant's Response: The fact that the subject property has sufficient frontage on Stirling Road to meet a minimum lot standard in the PRD is irrelevant to this rezoning criteria and should not be considered by the City in terms of compliance with this criteria.2 See City of Dania Beach Ord.No.2010-20,§ 2, 9-14-10.6 also be reviewed within the context of other Future Land Use Policies that encourage and direct a mix of residential communities or"mixed-use" development adjacent to the 4 community area planning,and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases: o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale, Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation- 3 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,# 313 Tequesta, Florida 33469 954)815- 4298 As of 3. 23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School, Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD)for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop-off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication report(IJR); served as the task leader for the preparation of the state environmental impact report(SEIR); conducted the interchange operational analysis reports(IOAR)for the adjacent interchanges and Zanies District 1r 1 e st soak s i nreh st at slosh lei csapni spit aim aai seairy asap tiara sterner, the patent PVD 1 T)iesict serves ae a trasibaa lamas the aarpowt}srpraie so ti Mat ad ant d i abject seas Past of is as ale homes aids so the west d at ropaty as a ouial use as a cars*irk_ e tits!openy se hxD-1,which dims aimed mohis am plapetry is sae the a sisainsa wneaea tits cameariei ad wsiitstid wet les mate aw. ar MD Zeais 'apidont arsci6GsDy alas fir fedi a iesigisas sties as undea oasis of Ferny ores scassed seseldep a at heat a 1 seas let aed emcee 5orap alas i anal gsdssy. Shashi mew property wow`sae a fad a let sr ass aims as amid astray which antis them alter acts hey will aim be ale s WW1 as sand as peaaiss d is RID jai Max has aaaaitai that decal aniaps a ant bag rasa a. On eyssat iirirs it Caps aa/eraa/esanssa y etdeetispota /apicaai1i This ate sat aiopsi asarsoaq aiesdgsst piss for this ass lit the bans,d Amity ash marl paws oral has aims as amid aaasiasy is as endatbal pad is fa Cayes Casip issi s. h. An errs or aai*pny seats the oirreJ.S Thin is as soot at aIl¢y s its Cade.let issued i 1!D ass*aphtiias was clii3d as sp ticaly sales axed so Meisptat s ciss setae-, laaiiss le ifs d straws to as rush coda this pro fatty saw ages the misi all ass tin seas*as be sit a misty i aka gaily. c. Mope eaaM aisapt a &wog aseuhsrar ins** art gpasst she sweat Cisapri as ciaapsa asatiai awl such ado append dais rapist aprspes. 1s taffy's sway a sand sae daaeirp at is asaensial far anseirah ieda*aaat s aecani ash the raw atasatisi seam Ind for a said see iekyaeaat whore—arts_swam cgs la laa da s to area also they bin The as d.-idea sal csisachaa aars as Ilea Gant all tart' a as the aeaaiahsta sets as ceased ine s die iiebp,at ad the cenaisal sass ay s*5 nadosatal all bra anima bites As say sae retie wit*la thee.asirssssb sal de sot here trims Ant saw abides(am*Mamaan a psYc turaalsontan)it beams has ad for thorn as e warty osmsos3ai ran g swat the asiiitid ass. A and tea psaSas this taetaties wanly. la adaitias.the midi ass ssias assists asitasaiaral ass maw a as imam aspecisly was ate ass all dry sof lsarisseias,aims tat the his ef the Zia Ilse sand Msillansrt a semi--rasa eeasieai develalsst sans a arse per a nay logs trees a saes lira Ilaab sty arts daps basin n Ms.ales*nisi as aid a sail io RID alsaas aproptic s as of in oasaaiialy nasal property.ss/ocially ekes i land ISM. el 8idsees el mum cam why at papaw wow he tired to acmtria is week autos aeaa. Tin popsty saris be glad is satirises dlh eat*maw Tim sir*swag antics heat at galas a mindless i sierra is shads.as saasrh anal aatr seapeasaa loss dais surmises de sat tale here seeds i l iies arse d a lissom essai msa.which is toady was i!SD 14 bject property has sufficient frontage on Stirling Road to meet a minimum lot standard in the PRD is irrelevant to this rezoning criteria and should not be considered by the City in terms of compliance with this criteria.2 See City of Dania Beach Ord.No.2010-20,§2,9-14- 10.6 also be reviewed within the context of other Future Land Use Policies that encourage and direct a mix of residential communities or"mixed- use" development adjacent to the 4 community area planning,and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation-3 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta, Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3.23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20- Zags Omar* aosi fa to acraopti+i la elation. islet the prepay beim. bodsend by 3'PiL somerts the PAD Zo'ies District is tie only method by aebich al of the property cam be sobs.&. c, The ss Jk+r drc opekrly t t-yry aweI to ui eletemseqg Opares t>lwrt r+rer,and planed lard ter. The reotemor is rppmpeiate dot the at+Msly _ • of tie City. The rrsories snows a aimed t m peoject.witch is apt carn.dy'Wooed a the irides eating dissacs,aka,a stator+ctmssd ras&s:y due atoms tie for foomoop ad teed lot ties. Is abhors. the grooms art the proposed woad&ac* lty attar ram doe aes tmamtty pseteiari art'&prosier laic bee a a mote coherent ado arse 15 444...4 44p .". 'a Vie „'#'9u+ Figure 1.Site Location Aerial 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M? 1. 41 tif 11 0 Appendix B. Excerpts from the City of Dania Beach Comprehensive Plan FUTURE LAND USE ELEMENT Objective I Land development regulations shall be maintained which promote orderly growth,development and placement of land uses,which will encourage a mix of residential types and provide good quality of life for the residents of the City of Dania Beach. Policy 5.6 Dania Beach shall employ its local land use plan and zoning ordinance to establish differing intensities of commercial development compatible with adjacent and surrounding land uses.(B.C.P.#02.04.03) Policy 9.2 All proposed development and future land uses shall be compatible with adjacent land uses. Objective XXIV Develop and implement land use programs to encourage the elimination or reduction of existing incompatible land uses and prevent future incompatible land uses.(B.C.O.#14.02.00) Policy 24.1 Dania Beach shall minimize the impacts of existing incompatible land uses through requirements within their land development codes and regulations,such as buffering and setbacks.(B.C. P.#14.02.04) Policy 25.1 Dania Beach shall support home ownership by encouraging and supporting residential development that contemplates the sale of dwelling units in fee simple or as condominiums. TRANSPORTATION ELEMENT Policy 3.9 Adjacent to the Tri-Rail Station and to principal arterials providing BCt service within the Community Redevelopment Area ("CRA"),encourage mixed-use and low-medium to medium-high density home- ownership residential(10—25 units per acre)when designed and located to be compatible with existing residential development. Policy 3.10 Adjacent to principal arterials providing BCt service within the Local Activity Center("LAC"),encourage mixed-use and high density home-ownership residential(as per LAC intensity/density criteria)when designed and located to be compatible with existing residential development. Objective IX The City of Dania Beach,pursuant to the Community Redevelopment Agency(CRA)and Local Activity Center(LAC)land use plan designation,shall promote transit oriented development. 16 midi ass ssias assists asitasaiaral ass maw a as imam aspecisly was ate ass all dry sof lsarisseias, aims tat the his ef the Zia Ilse sand Msillansrt a semi--rasa eeasieai develalsst sansa arse per a nay logs trees a saes lira Ilaab sty arts daps basin n Ms.ales*nisi as aid a sail io RID alsaas aproptic s as of in oasaaiialy nasal property.ss/ocially ekes i land ISM.el 8idseesel mum cam why at papaw wow he tired to acmtria is week autos aeaa.Tin popsty saris be glad is satirises dlh eat*maw Tim sir*swag antics heat at galas a mindless i sierra is shads.as saasrh anal aatr seapeasaa loss dais surmises de sat tale here seeds i l iies arse d a lissom essai msa.which is toady was i!SD 14 bject property has sufficient frontage on Stirling Road to meet a minimum lot standard in the PRD is irrelevant to this rezoning criteria and should not be considered by the City in terms of compliance with this criteria.2 See City of Dania Beach Ord.No.2010-20,§2,9-14-10.6 also be reviewed within the context of other Future Land Use Policies that encourage and direct a mix of residential communities or"mixed-use" development adjacent to the 4 community area planning, and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/ Appeal of Zoning Interpretation-3 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises, Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta, Florida 33469 954) 815-4298 As of 3.23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study, Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD)for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop-off and pick-up) analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication report(IJR); served as Policy 9.1 The City shall encourage and support private development in the CRA and LAC that include the following: 2. Mixed land uses including both residential and commercial uses. 3. Construction of sidewalks and installation of pedestrian improvements such as benches, interconnected walkways,and lighting. 4. Construction of transit stop improvements and convenient walkways that connect development to transit stops. Policy 9.4 Work with FDOT to assure that access management criteria is not applied in such a way as to discourage mixed use development in the CRA and LAC Policy 9.5 Include provisions in the City Land Development Regulations to encourage mixed use developments in the CRA and LAC. B.Selecting the Land Use Pattern Monday,August 25, 1997,the Transportation Element subcommittee("TE subcommittee") met to consider the selection of alternative future land use scenarios for modeling purposes.Seven 7)future land use scenarios were provided for their consideration and members were encouraged to develop additional scenarios.The seven (7)initial scenarios provided for discussion included: Scenario 5: Exclusive public transportation corridor mixed use nodes The only exclusive public transportation corridor is Tri-Rail.This approach would increase densities and intensities within a quarter mile radius of a Tri-Rail terminal. 1. Establishment of Community Redevelopment Area and Local Activity Center Land Use Designation In April 2004,the Broward County Commission approved the City of Dania Beach Community Redevelopment Area ("CRA") Plan for a 500 acre CRA to include commercial properties along the US 1 corridor,the Dania Beach Boulevard Corridor,as well as the central business district surrounding city hall.Also in 2004, both Broward County and DCA approved the City's 150 acre Local Activity Center" land use plan amendment designation within the urban core of the CRA See Map 2-5). Both the CRA and LAC land use designations are intended to foster redevelopment of Dania Beach's 100 year old business district as a mixed-use pedestrian friendly urban village incorporating Transit-Oriented-Design (TOD)to increase transit usage and reduce reliance on single occupancy vehicle usage. 6. Intermodal Facilities The summary of projected needs included in this subsection is based on the Transit Needs Assessment(1996), prepared by Carr Smith Corradino for the Broward County Mass Transit Division,and the Transit Development Plan (TDP), Fiscal Year 2004 Update, prepared by the Tri- County Commuter Rail Authority.The following analysis of the projected deficiencies and needs are focused on terminals,connections, high occupancy vehicle lanes,and park-and-ride lots. 17 14 bject property has sufficient frontage on Stirling Road to meet a minimum lot standard in the PRD is irrelevant to this rezoning criteria and should not be considered by the City in terms of compliance with this criteria.2 See City of Dania Beach Ord.No.2010-20,§2,9-14-10.6 also be reviewed within the context of other Future Land Use Policies that encourage and direct a mix of residential communities or"mixed-use" development adjacent to the 4 community area planning, and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation-3 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc. 18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3. 23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD)for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing( drop-off and pick- up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication report(IJR); served as the task leader for the preparation of the state environmental impact report(SEIR); conducted the interchange operational analysis reports(IOAR)for the adjacent interchanges and developed the public involvement program.Page 2 of 3 b.Terminals. Tri-Rail has completed construction of a train depot in the Sportsman's Park Development in Dania Beach.This facility serves the City as well as the airport and the port.The City will encourage redevelopment in the area to incorporate mixed uses which will enhance ridership. HOUSING ELEMENT Objective XII Implement neighborhood improvement projects identified in the Community Redevelopment Area Plan. Policy 12.1 It is recommended that the various Comprehensive Plan elements be updated,as appropriate,to assist with the provision of ownership opportunities at higher income levels,as follows: Continue to expedite permitting,prioritize the allocation of flex units,and sponsor Future Land Use Plan amendments for luxury housing projects. Promote mixed-use development that provides an array of housing types along transit corridors, including the establishment of a Local Activity Center(LAC)future land use designation,the development of mixed use zoning districts,and the allocation of flex units to mixed-use projects. Implement neighborhood improvement projects identified in the Community Redevelopment Area. 18 Scenario 5: Exclusive public transportation corridor mixed use nodes The only exclusive public transportation corridor is Tri-Rail.This approach would increase densities and intensities within a quarter mile radius of a Tri-Rail terminal.1. Establishment of Community Redevelopment Area and Local Activity Center Land Use Designation In April 2004,the Broward County Commission approved the City of Dania Beach Community Redevelopment Area (" CRA") Plan for a 500 acre CRA to include commercial properties along the US 1 corridor, the Dania Beach Boulevard Corridor, Appendix C—City of Dania Beach Zoning and Land Use References Zoning Districts Reviewed-Dania Beach Zoning Code,Sec. 100-60.Zoning Districts District map Full district title Intent and purpose of district designation A) Residential zoning districts E-1 Single-Family Estate Provides for use and occupancy of properties within areas of the city annexed from Residential District Broward County in 1990 and 2001,and previously zoned Broward County E-1,A-1 or A-3. Implements the Estate Residential category of the comprehensive plan. RS-12000 Single-Family 12000 Provides for use and occupancy of one-family dwelling units at low densities and Residential District related essential services and facilities.Implements the Low(5)Residential category of the comprehensive plan. RS-6000 Single-Family 6000 Provides for use and occupancy of one-family dwelling units at low densities and Residential District related essential services and facilities. Implements the Low (5) Residential and Low-Medium(10) Residential categories of the comprehensive plan. Commercial zoning districts. C-2 Community Business Provides for retail stores, offices and service establishments with convenient District pedestrian access throughout the district,excluding vehicular-oriented activities that have large acreage requirements or which may adversely impact adjoining residential areas. This district is appropriate for community shopping centers. Implements the Commercial category of the comprehensive plan. C-3 General Business Applies to arterial streets where business establishments properly locate to serve District large sections of the city and metropolitan area. Such businesses generally require considerable ground area, do not cater directly to pedestrians, and need a conspicuous and accessible location convenient for motorists. Implements the Commercial category of the comprehensive plan. PRD-t Planned Residential Provides flexibility in the design and development of infill residential lots with odd Development District shapes or small sizes, in a manner that is compatible with existing residential development and the comprehensive plan.implements the Residential categories of the comprehensive plan.Developments previously zoned PUD-A or PUD-B have been rezoned to PRD-1. Land Use—Density Comparison District Map Full District Title Land Use Intensity Designation E-1 Single Family Estate 1 Unit per Acre RS-12000 Single Family 12000 Low(5)Residential RS-6000 Single Family 6000 Low(5)and Low Medium(10) Proposed Development PDR-1 Approximately(22)Units per Acre Commercial Flex 1/3`d Acre C-2 Community Business Commercial—Pedestrian Access C-3 General Business Commercial with arterial Access 19 idered by the City in terms of compliance with this criteria.2 See City of Dania Beach Ord.No.2010-20,§2,9-14- 10.6 also be reviewed within the context of other Future Land Use Policies that encourage and direct a mix of residential communities or"mixed-use" development adjacent to the 4 community area planning,and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation-3 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3.23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study, Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School, Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD) for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop-off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication report( IJR); served as the task leader for the preparation of the state environmental impact report(SEIR); conducted the interchange operational analysis reports(IOAR)for the adjacent interchanges and developed the public involvement program. Page 2 of 3 N ON 0 N o W L.) o • a_ r C W O 0 31.7 o Lfl f1 Q Xt 0 w r , Z < O CCuzOo z aJ O w c CA 3 O I 1Uz Ow m LT-) a 2 Q) Gt p U U woad&ac* lty attar ram doe aes tmamtty pseteiari art'&prosier laic bee a a mote coherent ado arse 15 444...4 44p .". 'a Vie „'#'9u+ Figure 1.Site Location Aerial 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M? 1. 41 tif 11 0 00, II tit-NI, r, ii.,.. ,.,, i" t.,: i... 4: r,.i.:,'. 11.'. 44e.''',..,.; . l' fi... 4 g. t F u F e g'Y. 1 k WykT t lfiry I pi: 7,1..., -,e r, ,„4.,.... ..:::., 0, ,,,,,Si 4 R J A. p4 4° • , 01 4,1.. i 40 4,.• ,I.',3•0 1:7'''''44.4')II ii,,,. 4... 'it rilr" I j, c., 1,17•Y' r ir.17.,. j .: ' it t . be7, A '. : ' ' ', ' ': 174' f ,.....,'',,,Li,:,,7..''' 44k. „ti iti44i ' '%' ' ''' ilr' 1, 1411:01- 11111111: 11r. '' 11 '''. 4' a, 9 ', a; f p J'' -0 A3 3 '• ' .- • , . I A' •-, • . 1 , 4 4 , r ^ dam 9 1't Via: A.,- ifs 4 I% I ' r46 94''sit-, ', r' -'.' '', k''':''". At . ' 414 ' 1 °' ' .. 1 * - fir.. '1, :. to y sections of the city and metropolitan area. Such businesses generally require considerable ground area, do not cater directly to pedestrians, and need a conspicuous and accessible location convenient for motorists. Implements the Commercial category of the comprehensive plan.PRD-t Planned Residential Provides flexibility in the design and development of infill residential lots with odd Development District shapes or small sizes, in a manner that is compatible with existing residential development and the comprehensive plan.implements the Residential categories of the comprehensive plan.Developments previously zoned PUD-A or PUD-B have been rezoned to PRD-1. Land Use—Density Comparison District Map Full District Title Land Use Intensity Designation E- 1 Single Family Estate 1 Unit per Acre RS-12000 Single 4 Yi` t , is`.r 141111\ lt 1 1 4', - .111,,;,, ct .,,,,i;L:7- .- e Ai, 1, 4 -e - a 6CD 7S.v, h 4... S 440 0 ` it kt ''' r i tl1 R gF. it.F 1 i 4p 41°45 - ,,-,. , ii ' 9. 4 fi too "a: ,i p 1?‘ r,pip "4 , stitt" tir . , 4.sp Cr) A+ J M 2 V1111 13 41 3, M?1. 41 tif 11 0 O oo v-, U Ct 4) C/1 N .O a) ta.1P-1 M 14 (1) = Cid C/ fa ›, o v-,!;). c, • 6 cu e4 Cl)Pi ThEI , 1 fal v1 O E O cl) i l N 5-) A4, ci 8 c... vsz) ct o 0 bah el fa, •a) r--) it.F 1 i4p41°45 - ,,-,. , ii ' 9.4 fi too " a: , i p1?‘r,pip " 4 , s titt" tir . , 4. spCr) A+ J M 2 V1111 13 41 3, M?1. 41tif 11 0 fir"t sv, 4 4•' p vn p O Iv ` 3 6 cue4Cl)Pi ThEI ,1 fal v1 O E O cl)i l N 5-) A4, ci 8 c... vsz) ct o 0 bah el fa, •a) r--) it.F 1 i 4p 41°45 - ,,-,. , ii ' 9.4 fi too " a: ,i p 1?‘r,pip "4 , s titt" tir . , 4. sp Cr) A+ JM 2 V1111 1 3 41 3, M? 1. 41 tif 11 0 a O U o O a ct N N o N N 1) CZ$ r .. . co I TiuA-) a.• -c 2 a) I-) 4....,8E .,c-) Plm. C:)° 4) 4) bbA AE c O O O E rE +.4 cz: v) (i) cd H H H oel fa, •a) r--) it.F 1 i4p41°45 - ,,-,. , ii ' 9.4 fi too " a: , i p1?‘r,pip " 4 , s titt" tir . , 4. spCr) A+ J M 2 V1111 13 41 3, M?1. 41tif 11 0 o ct bA c' c' . a o o oo7C.) cu = d- cu a.) to On" la r-' w O cu O U N N CD N 1 -;; U N cu, 4 cn ,sz u b.) _4_,'-- 2 Sr 1 ct -4-i cd 0 4_1 ,4 c,) 4 .,...) .F__). -4- c; a,4 , cl., (1., L) r,0 (I) ct cc;)) ret -Go (I)bo •. =0 cu cu ::: 1... i_ e...) '0 .'-' 6 c5' 0 v) ,- .`424 7:, PO N 4 Ti,"- 5 I.) N 1.Cn N......1 t:I) e.\ 0 :J.: E s _04 ( 14 cu 5 •. ,•-, I) v O E E c gcn U ilr' 1, 1411: 01- 11111111: 11r. '' 11 '''. 4'a, 9 ',a; f p J'' -0 A3 3 '• ' .- • , . I A' •-, • . 1 , 4 4 , r ^dam 9 1't Via:A.,- ifs 4 I% I ' r46 94''sit-, ', r' -'.' '', k''':''".At . ' 414 ' 1 °' ' .. 1 * -fir.. '1, :. to y sections of the city and metropolitan area. Such businesses generally require considerable ground area, do not cater directly to pedestrians, and need a conspicuous and accessible location convenient for motorists. Implements the Commercial category of the comprehensive plan.PRD- t Planned Residential Provides flexibility in the design and development of infill residential lots with odd Development District shapes or small sizes, in a manner that is compatible with existing residential development and the comprehensive plan.implements the Residential categories of the comprehensive plan.Developments previously zoned PUD-A or PUD-B have been rezoned to PRD-1. o o 4 o aL 4) O ' bi) 4) 1 O O 7 " ct r:1•1 (-9-1 L:1" r8 0 at vs O ' ercn 0 (I) ,_,0 #.) ;'14 ct v o bO + E v .- Plm. C:)° 4) 4) bbA AE c O O O E rE +.4 cz: v) ( i) cd H H H o elfa, •a) r--)it.F 1 i4p 41°45 - ,,-,. , ii ' 9. 4 fi too "a: ,i p 1?‘r, pip " 4 , s titt" tir . , 4. sp Cr) A+JM 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 a)a O O 3 0 c, CD ci 0 F Q Crj o .a) .- b, o I)0 > L _a -d, c •> O Q ; ctCl b .- cn " 3 a) I O C cu O a O rL ^? O cti• O , ctO Q- p V1 C.) • ' c'v) a) A Cl.) ,..; '7, v.-. E uCt k '•'" (1) C1) .4 (-) +-• d O a) i- iccl O v,ct 1)ci) RI C-) C1) .4 -4-',„, -th 3czt . f bA o r.4 11.7j P4 E-0 a) .-9., a)''' (1.) a) .4 ct•'''' a) O O 4 N I C 0-1 O ' T ) in ••— 4'+ ram, V 1 N a) '-' II) N a) p. c UE0E V 1 V• > . to 3 co a) bQ CU O O O o bA y o a) a) ba- no O" 0. v, x N • r--4 as L C C o o m , >, cl ' o II T—' 0 CI) •'-' P4 CDT 1 CA o C ° o .o I.)4 1 P-- H •A.,- ifs 4 I% I ' r46 94'' sit-, ', r' -'.' '', k''':''". At . ' 414 ' 1 °' ' .. 1 * -fir.. '1, :. to y sections of the city and metropolitan area. Such businesses generally require considerable ground area, do not cater directly to pedestrians, and need a conspicuous and accessible location convenient for motorists. Implements the Commercial category of the comprehensive plan.PRD-t Planned Residential Provides flexibility in the design and development of infill residential lots with odd Development District shapes or small sizes, ct aU CU Ct ;-eooa) o to ct cn '— 1.) czt a> '; •En v) Ovct of lo bA J U N UOOn• p I' c5 • •-1 "Az' Aa' 4-. qc"5" ,.V) , 1 CD Ua) t3 a) a)a) 1-) Ca) .'tl:i' 1' ''') 2 4-4 E •• CA 0 I .5 a.) i (g ct C o o -4 0 0 r-- NO .O OU O 0 ct 1 a'OA U .. y a) O v) O 3 O C EQ.O~ Q,,, gCtr:4 ( I) >' , Q" cu 0 Cl.) O O sue. r U N . a Q". C cct 'cs C1.1 O a1 A--' a) •-' ri fl...11 kr) T-• c.) Q a) •— r 0 U • o O EA a) Q 4'+ ram,V 1 N a) '-' II) N a) p. c U E 0 E V 1 V• > . to 3 co a) bQ CU O O O o bA y o a) a)ba- no O" 0. v, x N • r--4 as L C C o o m , >, cl ' o II T—' 0 CI) •'-'P4 CDT 1 CA o C ° o . o I.)4 1 P-- H •A.,- ifs 4 I% I ' r46 94'' sit-, ', r' -'.' '', k''':''".At . ' 414 ' 1 °' ' .. 1 * -fir.. '1, :. to y sections of the city and metropolitan area. Such businesses generally require considerable ground area, do not cater directly to pedestrians, and need a conspicuous and accessible location convenient for motorists. Implements the Commercial category of the comprehensive CA a V) cdo °)- thc. o >, 3 `dcd E.. U4 CVIU aczt• ° N C E a o a33 Ellimilmil c+E.3 U am a. 1- o =..p O p._ . v a C to.— c..) s_>' O p a) _U a) n cC G 0_,_, ccdd.t ad cat cl: O ct p C a) Cy •n cA 4 cd M +- N cd a) cd U a) U O ct t cn C v Q.w Z 1.) U., tab Fal 0- 3-4 o cd CI,a U U o m oon o 0. R'-- 4_, l an o a. cn an I) o E cd bA d a)-0 Via) U a, a) =oo o °'" p O C' .a°.mac) en cit o a) , cat Q.3 o -•,- ,, 0 =o w o a) d 4 RI c) c) Ct vpi U s. to4o C Uagy o ct ay. 4]4. N s. a) •- cdc Ea a)4 o-5a TiHaaaado '4 th,40 =- 5. a) bA• cA 4 4- O p U 0y at um oa)s., U Ct C.) ct • At . ' 414 ' 1 °' ' .. 1 * -fir.. ' 1, :. to y sections of the city and metropolitan area. Such businesses generally require considerable ground area, do not cater directly to pedestrians, and need a conspicuous and accessible location convenient for motorists. Implements the Commercial category of the comprehensive plan.PRD-t Planned Residential Provides flexibility in the design and development of infill residential lots with odd Development District shapes 0 N 1—'-- ct ct T4 H 7:3 cn le 0 ct W ,4 as m I) c oA O .,3 ,. o C 'j a- 'Ct 1 " 3 C 2 „ r A—e Q, c .4 E o 0 O o8 ,, E8 4 u __i_ c_ e) i) E 1) 7.--, 0 1--1 cn CD • C 4 cC3 • • O 00 cil a) 0 r'_' Q >, s..b CA Ct I)r-., s,O 5 s,.., P p4el) , bye "-v) O O N •vn C3 N N V 'p N o 6 V1 4 b1 cC CDO S Q" b!J r Q O Lrj vD .. Clii 0 tA a) `""I .2 Cli .'s ...:_ M • r- bA O M r' [ f:L N U 0 Cam) ° o a) , cat Q.3 o -•,- ,, 0 =o w o a) d 4 RI c) c)Ct vpiUs. to 4 o C Uagy o ct ay. 4] 4. N s.a) •- cdc Ea a) 4 o-5a TiHa aa ado ' 4 th,40 =- 5. a) bA• cA 4 4- O p U 0yatum o a)s.,U Ct C.) ct •At . ' 414 ' 1 °' ' .. 1 * -fir.. ' 1, :. to y sections of the city and metropolitan area. Such businesses generally require considerable ground area, do not cater directly to pedestrians, and need a conspicuous and accessible location convenient for motorists. Implements the Commercial category of the comprehensive plan. PRD-t Planned Residential Provides flexibility in the design and development of infill residential lots with odd U C: 0 cDE al U U cn ,-c a.) 7s ct 4., U c U ^cj • O CA N O cn U E O E :54 ap to O rn ci) o 1 K1 cp 7-. m ., 4' 04cpa.),_ a) 1)0 CA Cld 0CD Cli V• N I U U Cl O U r--' U •, ct cl CZ: C14 ) NU T C 0 Cid N ^- 1, b.A U E a 0 v cl ^?-- O 'EO al '_ gzi N o to 1) F:, ct cd .4 a) v--4 U iE fI ir) 4% r•-,;-' c E L 2 oEct 4 O c v1 cA v1 oO a.) r--, bA O M r' [f: L N U 0 Cam) ° o a) , cat Q.3 o -•,- ,, 0 =o w o a) d 4 RI c) c) Ct vpi U s. to4o C Uagy o ct ay. 4]4. N s. a) •- cdc Ea a)4 o-5a TiHaaaado '4 th,40 =- 5. a) bA• cA 4 4- O p U 0y at um oa)s., U Ct C.) ct • At . ' 414 ' 1 °' ' .. 1 * -fir.. ' 1, :. to y sections of the city and metropolitan area. Such businesses generally require considerable ground area, do not cater directly to pedestrians, and need a conspicuous and accessible location convenient for motorists. Implements the Commercial category of the comprehensive plan.PRD-t Planned Residential Provides flexibility in the design and development of infill residential lots with odd Development District shapes O v v15- O U 4 CA O ' 4) 1) C i• 1) i 7,-- 4. 7:9'-' a) o zi O E C U O0 N N O >1 Ct cc,c1) >1 E -t 46' cl oQ) 4) U t Q 0 ; E rrt 6W p b.O ct v, ct ct •cu r--)it.F 1 i 4p 41° 45 - ,,-,. , ii ' 9. 4 fi too "a: ,i p 1?‘r,pip "4 , s titt" tir . , 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 o „Si r2.1 rzi cocit to4 At 1) C i• 1) i 7,-- 4. 7:9'-' a) o zi O E C U O0 N N O >1 Ct cc,c1) >1 E -t 46' cl oQ) 4) U t Q 0 ; E rrt 6W p b.O ct v, ct ct •cu r--)it.F 1 i 4p 41° 45 - ,,-,. , ii ' 9. 4 fi too "a: ,i p 1?‘r,pip "4 , s titt" tir . , 4.sp Cr) A+J M 2 V1111 1 3 41 3,M?1. 41 tif 11 0 Li: c a=' ca E. N a) • 0 O co 0c Q co co U 2 ca-0 0 0 - C N = c 0 -I--' coOU•N •N D E U N Q N C6 CO2 0 '9 E O " p Q Ccalca 0 4 ' = Q CD 0 QU v ca 0 O a) el 1 a) C 4-, a). a) C w t Q a) 7 C }, 0 co a = U 0C x Q= a_+ O 0 4- a) LU O O ca C )>Via)E a) +., Q a)- E co a) a) C 0a) v0L_ cn U _0u N 13 Q CD p c 'N E 0 O CU p 0 N 0- l,A a)a) c a U U _a Q a--+ a..' 0- -0 N u N Co 0 0O qA N O o •— ca a) N 0 0 MD a) E W 7, a) L) CD U — 4-1 0NN • b 0 ca cam ,> 0-01 p O C C -C cn i . co V p > +ca ca U +,ca CD `4 a +-, +-,-0 •'? u 64-1 00 .XI- Q• E_ = = = ba)z L . -0 a) 0 oN Q O n •,, O 3 ('s- ON•E co_c cn VI Cup 0 0 - O 0 O C V O a) 0 --.7_o 0 p c ., a) a) 0 Q Cc 'c— fa Ni N NO 40 CO • O . ., w a) a) v i a) Q 0 0 v u 00 N N ca ••X Ni co a) OD +, D = 0 I . v f_ a va) Na) _ QU 1' L_ a) a)- a) Cl) a) I a) Q v a) 0- _0 a) a) E ,ca co U 0 L_ L_ L_ }' U o - Q = - a) = s00 a) (i).bp a) .c-c) E— co < 1— i- v) -i-, H U co aJ c - - a) a_' 5 0 1— I— c I— N co ' Eca 0 U -O Cl) CU NJ m O Q a X X X X 7 LnCO ii a U- C le) < cti• a Z CU Vf Q Land Use— Density Comparison District Map Full District Title Land Use Intensity Designation E-1 Single Family Estate 1 Unit per Acre RS-12000 Single Family 12000 Low(5)Residential RS-6000 Single Family 6000 Low( 5)and Low Medium(10)Proposed Development PDR-1 Approximately(22)Units per Acre Commercial Flex 1/3`d Acre C-2 Community Business Commercial—Pedestrian Access C-3 General Business Commercial with arterial Access 19 idered by the City in terms of compliance with this criteria.2 See City of Dania Beach Ord.No. 2010-20,§2,9-14-10.6 also be reviewed within the context of other Future Land Use Policies that encourage and direct a mix of residential communities or"mixed-use" development adjacent to the 4 community area planning,and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel,LLC- W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation-3 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,# 313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3.23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study, Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD)for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop-off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication report(IJR); served as the task leader for the preparation of the state environmental impact report(SEIR); conducted the interchange operational analysis reports(IOAR)for the adjacent interchanges and developed the public involvement program.Page 2 of 3 REQUEST TO ADDRESS CITY COMMISSION AT REGULAR OR SPECIAL VIRTUAL MEETINGS DANIA BEACH SEA IT.LIVE IT.LOVE IT, The City is required by state law to keep minutes of City Commission meetings. To properly identify persons who address the City Commission in those minutes,the City requests that this form be completed and provided to the City Clerk,before the meeting begins. DATE OF COMMISSION MEETING: May 10, 2022 PRINT NAME: W. Tucker Gibbs 3835 Utopia Court, Coconut Grove, FL 33133 ADDRESS: PHONE NO. (Optional): 305-448-8486 PLEASE CHECK ONE OR BOTH OF THE BOXES BELOW: 1) CITIZEN COMMENTS: Comments by Dania Beach citizens or interested parties that are not part of the regular printed agenda may be made during each Commission meeting during the period set aside for"Citizen Comments." A thirty{30)minute"Citizen Comments"period shall be designated on the agenda for citizens and interested persons to speak on matters not scheduled on that day's agenda. Each speaker shall be limited to 3 minutes for his or her comments. Persons desiring to speak during the citizen comment period shall inform the City Clerk immediately prior to the beginning of the meeting of their intention to speak. If more than 10 speakers express a desire to speak,the Commission shall determine on a meeting by meeting basis whether to(a)extend the time allotted for citizen comments to accommodate all speakers,or(b)whether to limit the number of speakers or amount of time per speaker. A speaker's time shall not be transferable to another speaker. PLEASE BRIEFLY DESCRIBE THE SUBJECT MATTER OF YOUR COMMENT: 2) PUBLIC HEARINGS—ITEM# 9' 1' AS PRINTED ON AGENDA) PLEASE NOTE:IF YOU WISH TO SPEAK ON AN ITEM THAT PERTAINS TO A"ZONING"TYPE OF MAFIER(FOR EXAMPLE,A SITE PLAN,VARIANCE, SPECIAL EXel&i ION OR SIMILAR TYPE OF ITEM KNOWN AS A"QUASI-JUDICIAL"MA Fait, YOU ARE SUBJECT TO BEING ASKED TO SWEAR OR AFFIRM THAT YOU WILL BE TRUTHFUL AS TO YOUR COMMENTS OR TESTIMONY. YOU MAY ALSO BE SUBJECT TO QUESTIONS ASKED OF YOU BY AN APPLICANT OR AN APPLICANT'S REPRESENTATIVE OR ATTORNEY WHICH RELATE TO THE ITEM. ANY PERSON WHO DECIDES TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE WITH REGARD TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING OR HEARING WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDING,AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDING IS MADE WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED, LOBBYIST REGISTRATION IS REQUIRED. PRIOR TO ENGAGING IN ANY LOBBYING ACTIVITIES, WHETHER OR NOT COMPENSATION IS PAID OR RECEIVED IN CONNECTION WITH THOSE ACTIVITIES,EACH LOBBYIST SHALL FILE WITH THE CITY CLERK AN ANNUAL REGISTRATION STATEMENT AND PAY AN ANNUAL TWO HUNDRED FIFTY DOLLARS($250.00) REGISTRATION FEE FOR EACH PRINCIPAL OR EMPLOYER. REGISTRATION FORMS ARE AVAILABLE ON THE CITY WEBS ITE: WW W.DANIABEACHFL.GOV. (ORDINANCE#2012.)19;AMENDED BY ORDINANCE#2019-019) Kav ae..,o«po a,os«dad„,ea,05/10/2022 10-20,§2,9-14-10.6 also be reviewed within the context of other Future Land Use Policies that encourage and direct a mix of residential communities or"mixed-use" development adjacent to the 4 community area planning,and zoning codes. Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation-3 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises, Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,# 313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954) 815-4298 As of 3.23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20- year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD)for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop-off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication report(IJR); served as the task leader REQUEST TO ADDRESS CITY COMMISSION AT REGULAR OR SPECIAL VIRTUAL MEETINGS DANIA BEACH SEA IT.LIVE IT.LOVE IT. The City is required by state law to keep minutes of City Commission meetings. To properly identify persons who address the City Commission in those minutes,the City requests that this form be completed and provided to the City Clerk,before the meeting begins. DATE OF COMMISSION MEETING: May 10, 2022 PRINT NAME: Cecelia Magro, AICP ADDRESS: 18081 SE Country Club Dr. Unit 313 Tequesta, FL 33469 PHONE NO. (Optional): 954 8154298 PLEASE CHECK ONE OR BOTH OF THE BOXES BELOW: 1) CITIZEN COMMENTS: Comments by Dania Beach citizens or interested parties that are not part of the regular printed agenda may be made during each Commission meeting during the period set aside for"Citizen Comments." A thirty(30)minute"Citizen Comments"period shall be designated on the agenda for citizens and interested persons to speak on matters not scheduled on that day's agenda. Each speaker shall be limited to 3 minutes for his or her comments. Persons desiring to speak during the citizen comment period shall inform the City Clerk immediately prior to the beginning of the meeting of their intention to speak. If more than 10 speakers express a desire to speak,the Commission shall determine on a meeting by meeting basis whether to(a)extend the time allotted for citizen comments to accommodate all speakers,or(b)whether to limit the number of speakers or amount of time per speaker. A speaker's time shall not be transferable to another speaker. PLEASE BRIEFLY DESCRIBE THE SUBJECT MATTER OF YOUR COMMENT: Present Expert Planning Testimony regarding Rezoning Case No. 055-21 - on behalf of Harger 2) PUBLIC HEARINGS—ITEM# 1 AS PRINTED ON AGENDA) PLEASE NOTE:IF YOU WISH TO SPEAK ON AN ITEM THAT PERTAINS TO A"ZONING"TYPE OF MAI ER(FOR EXAMPLE,A SITE PLAN,VARIANCE, SPECIAL EXCtPI ION OR SIMILAR TYPE OF ITEM KNOWN AS A"QUASI-JUDICIAL"MALT K, YOU ARE SUBJECT TO BEING ASKED TO SWEAR OR AFFIRM THAT YOU WILL BE TRUTHFUL AS TO YOUR COMMENTS OR TESTIMONY. YOU MAY ALSO BE SUBJECT TO QUESTIONS ASKED OF YOU BY AN APPLICANT OR AN APPLICANT'S REPRESENTATIVE OR ATTORNEY WHICH RELATE TO THE ITEM, ANY PERSON WHO DECIDES TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE WITH REGARD TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING OR HEARING WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDING,AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDING IS MADE WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED, LOBBYIST REGISTRATION IS REQUIRED. PRIOR TO ENGAGING IN ANY LOBBYING ACTIVITIES, WHETHER OR NOT COMPENSATION IS PAID OR RECEIVED 1N CONNECTION WITH THOSE ACTIVITIES,EACH LOBBYIST SHALL FILE WITH THE CITY CLERK AN ANNUAL REGISTRATION STATEMENT AND PAY AN ANNUAL TWO HUNDRED FIFTY DOLLARS($250.00) REGISTRATION FEE FOR EACH PRINCIPAL OR EMPLOYER. REGISTRATION FORMS ARE AVAILABLE ON THE CITY WEBSITE: WWW.DANIABEACHFL.GOV. (ORDINANCE#2012-019;AMENDED BY ORDINANCE#2019-019) 17-e eeeee' eveze 05/10/2022 of other Future Land Use Policies that encourage and direct a mix of residential communities or"mixed-use" development adjacent to the 4 community area planning,and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation-3 Cecelia Ward, AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3.23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD) for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop-off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access. Page 3 of 3 ication report(IJR); served as the task leader for the preparation of REQUEST TO ADDRESS CITY COMMISSION AT REGULAR OR SPECIAL VIRTUAL MEETINGS DANIA BEACH' SEA IT.L1YE IT.LOPE IT. The City is required by state law to keep minutes of City Commission meetings. To properly identify persons who address the City Commission in those minutes,the City requests that this form be completed and provided to the City Clerk,before the meeting begins. DATE OF COMMISSION MEETING: May 10, 2022 Richard Dewitt PRINT NAME: ADDRESS: 200 S. Andrews Avenue, Ste 601 PHONE NO. (Optional): PLEASE CHECK ONE OR BOTH OF THE BOXES BELOW: 1) CITIZEN COMMENTS: Comments by Dania Beach citizens or interested parties that are not part of the regular printed agenda may be made during each Commission meeting during the period set aside for"Citizen Comments." A thirty(30)minute"Citizen Comments"period shall be designated on the agenda for citizens and interested persons to speak on matters not scheduled on that day's agenda. Each speaker shall be limited to 3 minutes for his or her comments. Persons desiring to speak during the citizen comment period shall inform the City Clerk immediately prior to the beginning of the meeting of their intention to speak. If more than 10 speakers express a desire to speak,the Commission shall determine on a meeting by meeting basis whether to(a)extend the time allotted for citizen comments to accommodate all speakers,or(b)whether to limit the number of speakers or amount of timee per speaker. A speaker's time shall not be transferable to another speaker. PLEASE BRIEFLY DESCRIBE THE SUBJECT MATTER OF YOUR COMMENT: Opposition to SR RZ 055-21 Rezoning of 3851 Stirling Holdings, allocation of Flex Units and 2) PUBLIC HEARINGS—ITEM# Public ( AS PRINTED ON AGENDA) PLEASE NOTE:IF YOU WISH TO SPEAK ON AN ITEM THAT PERTAINS TO A"ZONING'TYPE OF MA1-fEK(FOR EXAMPLE,A SITE PLAN,VARIANCE, SPECIAL EXCErt ION OR SIMILAR TYPE OF ITEM KNOWN AS A"QUASI-JUDICIAL"MA1'1'hR, YOU ARE SUBJECT TO BEING ASKED TO SWEAR OR AFFIRM THAT YOU WILL BE TRUTHFUL AS TO YOUR COMMENTS OR TESTIMONY. YOU MAY ALSO BE SUBJECT TO QUESTIONS ASKED OF YOU BY AN APPLICANT OR AN APPLICANT'S REPRESENTATIVE OR ATTORNEY WHICH RELATE TO THE ITEM. ANY PERSON WHO DECIDES TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE WITH REGARD TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING OR HEARING WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDING,AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDING IS MADE WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED, LOBBYIST REGISTRATION IS REQUIRED. PRIOR TO ENGAGING IN ANY LOBBYING ACTIVITIES, WHETHER OR NOT COMPENSATION IS PAID OR RECEIVED IN CONNECTION WITH THOSE ACTIVITIES,EACH LOBBYIST SHALL FILE WITH THE CITY CI FRK AN ANNUAL REGISTRATION STATEMENT AND PAY AN ANNUAL TWO HUNDRED FIFTY DOLLARS($250.00) REGISTRATION FEE FOR EACH PRINCIPAL OR EMPLOYER. REGISTRATION FORMS ARE AVAILABLE ON THE CITY WEBSITE: W WW.DANIABEACHFL.GOV. (ORDINANCE#2012.019;AMENDED BY ORDINANCE#2019.019) a,aae.. oam,as.. an-,et o eK Gt K., a ea,4mzozo e,o=a=dan,,,ea,05/10/2022 olicies that encourage and direct a mix of residential communities or"mixed-use" development adjacent to the 4 community area planning,and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation-3 Cecelia Ward, AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3.23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD)for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road. Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop-off and pick- up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication report(IJR); served REQUEST TO ADDRESS CITY COMMISSION AT REGULAR OR SPECIAL VIRTUAL MEETINGS DANIA BEACH SEA It LIVE IT LOVE IT. The City is required by state law to keep minutes of City Commission meetings. To properly identify persons who address the City Commission in those minutes,the City requests that this form be completed and provided to the City Clerk,before the meeting begins. DATE OF COMMISSION MEETING: May 10, 2022 PRINT NAME:Anthony Benedict ADDRESS: 5841 SW 37th Ave PHONE NO.(Optional): 9542579831 PLEASE CHECK ONE OR BOTH OF THE BOXES BELOW: 1) V CITIZEN COMMENTS: Comments by Dania Beach citizens or interested parties that are not part of the regular printed agenda may be made during each Commission meeting during the period set aside for"Citizen Comments." A thirty(30)minute"Citizen Comments"period shall be designated on the agenda for citizens and interested persons to speak on matters not scheduled on that day's agenda. Each speaker shall be limited to 3 minutes for his or her comments. Persons desiring to speak during the citizen comment period shall inform the City Clerk immediately prior to the beginning of the meeting of their intention to speak. If more than 10 speakers express a desire to speak,the Commission shall determine on a meeting by meeting basis whether to(a)extend the time allotted for citizen comments to accommodate all speakers,or(b)whether to limit the number of speakers or amount of time per speaker. A speaker's time shall not be transferable to another speaker. PLEASE BRIEFLY DESCRIBE THE SUBJECT MATTER OF YOUR COMMENT: Re-zoning for 3851 Stirling Rd 2) V-PUBLIC HEARINGS-ITEM#9-1 AS PRINTED ON AGENDA) PLEASE NOTE:IF YOU WISH TO SPEAK ON AN ITEM THAT PERTAINS TO A"ZONING"TYPE OF MArI1*((FOR EXAMPLE,A SITE PLAN,VARIANCE,SPECIAL EXci viION OR SIMILAR TYPE OF rTEM KNOWN AS A"QUASI-JUDICIAL"MATTER,YOU ARE SUBJECT TO BEING ASKED TO SWEAR OR AFFIRM THAT YOU WILL BE TRUTHFUL AS TO YOUR COMMENTS OR TESTIMONY. YOU MAY ALSO BE SUBJECT.TO QUESTIONS ASKED OF YOU BY AN APPLICANT OR AN APPLICANT'S REPRESENTATIVE OR ATTORNEY WHICH RELATE TO THE ITEM. ANY PERSON WHO DECIDES TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE WITH REGARD TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING OR HEARING WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDING,AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDING IS MADE WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WI-IICHTHE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. LOBBYIST REGISTRATION IS REQUIRED. PRIOR TO ENGAGING IN ANY LOBBYING ACTIVITIES, WHETHER OR NOT COMPENSATION IS PAID OR RECEIVED IN CONNECTION WITH THOSE ACTIVITIES,EACH LOBBYIST SHALL FILE WITH THE CITY CLERK AN ANNUAL REGISTRATION STATEMENT AND PAY AN ANNUAL TWO HUNDRED FII TY DOLLARS($250.00) REGISTRATION FEE FOR EACH PRINCIPAL OR EMPLOYER. REGISTRATION FORMS ARE AVAILABLE ON THE CITY WEBSITE: WWW.DANIABEACHFL.GOV. (ORDINANCE#2012-019;AMENDED BY ORDINANCE#20I9-019) as-et/tasty Aestea'ece. 05/09/2022 9.019)a,aae.. oam, as..an-,et o eK Gt K., a ea, 4mzozo e,o=a=dan,,,ea,05/10/2022 olicies that encourage and direct a mix of residential communities or"mixed-use" development adjacent to the 4 community area planning,and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation- 3 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3.23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC; Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD) for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop-off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication report(IJR); served as the task REQUEST TO ADDRESS CITY COMMISSION AT REGULAR OR SPECIAL RTt l n 14 E GS DANIA BEACH SEA IT.LIVE IT.LOVE IT. The City is required by state law to keep minutes of City Commission meetings. To properly identify persons who address the City Commission in those minutes,the City requests that this form be completed and provided to the City Clerk,before the meeting begins. DATE OFCOMMISSION MEETING: May 10, 2022 PRINT NAME: Harvey J. Sepler 5840 S.W. 37th Terrace ADDRESS: PHONE NO. (Optional):(954) 663-1599 PLEASE CHECK ONE OR BOTH OF THE BOXES BELOW: 1) V CITIZEN COMMENTS: Comments by Dania Beach citizens or interested parties that are not part of the regular printed agenda may be made during each Commission meeting during the period set aside for"Citizen Comments." A thirty(30)minute"Citizen Comments"period shalt be designated on the agenda for citizens and interested persons to speak on matters not scheduled on that day's agenda. Each speaker shall be limited to 3 minutes for his or her comments. Persons desiring to speak during the citizen comment period shall inform the City Clerk immediately prior to the beginning of the meeting of their intention to speak. If more than 10 speakers express a desire to speak,the Commission shall determine on a meeting by meeting basis whether to(a)extend the time allotted for citizen comments to accommodate all speakers,or(b)whether to limit the number of speakers or amount of time per speaker. A speaker's time shall not be transferable to another speaker. PLEASE BRIEFLY DESCRIBE THE SUBJECT MATTER OF YOUR COMMENT: opposition to re-zoning request 2) w PUBLIC HEARINGS-ITEM# 9 (1) AS PRINTED ON AGENDA) PLEASE NOTE:IF YOU WISH TO SPEAK ON AN ITEM THAT PERTAINS TO A"ZONING"TYPE OF MAITht(FOR EXAMPLE,A SITE PLAN,VARIANCE,SPECIAL EXGK:t'IION OR SIMILAR TYPE OF ITEM KNOWN AS A"QUASI-JUDICIAL"MATTER.,YOU ARE SUBJECT TO BEING ASKED TO SWEAR OR AFFIRM THAT YOU WILL BE TRUTHFUL AS TO YOUR COMMENTS OR TESTIMONY. YOU MAY ALSO BE SUBJECT TO QUESTIONS ASKED OF YOU BY AN APPLICANT OR AN APPLICANT'S REPRESENTATIVE OR ATTORNEY WHICH RELATE TO THE ITEM. ANY PERSON WHO DECIDES TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE wrnt REGARD TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS. MEETING OR HEARING WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDING,AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDING IS MADE WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. LOBBYIST REGISTRATION IS REQUIRED. PRIOR TO ENGAGING IN ANY LOBBYING ACTIVITIES, WHETHER OR NOT COMPENSATION IS PAID OR RECEIVED IN CONNECTION WITH THOSE ACTIVITIES,EACH LOBBYIST SHALL FILE WITH THE CITY CLERK AN ANNUAL REGISTRATION STATEMENT AND PAY AN ANNUAL TWO HUNDRED FIFTY DOLLARS($250.00) REGISTRATION FEE FOR EACH PRINCIPAL OR EMPLOYER. REGISTRATION FORMS ARE AVAILABLE ON THE CITY WEBSITE: WWW.DANI ABEACHFL.GOV. (ORDINANCE#2012-019;AMENDED BY ORDINANCE#2019-019) elatct yooeGP/pr rc.r vpu.&,aan¢aod,Da4,avxironaer__ - 05/09/2022 et o eK Gt K., a ea,4mzozo e,o=a=dan,,,ea,05/ 10/2022 olicies that encourage and direct a mix of residential communities or"mixed-use" development adjacent to the 4 community area planning,and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale, Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation-3 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises, Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta, Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3.23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD)for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop-off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication report( 1. 9 S PE/4k REQUEST TO ADDRESS CITY COMMISSION AT REGULAR OR SPECIAL VIRTUAL MEETINGS DANIA BEACH SEA IT.LIVE IT.LOVE IT. The City is required by state law to keep minutes of City Commission meetings. To properly identify persons who address the City Commission in those minutes,the City requests that this form be completed and provided to the City Clerk,before the meeting begins. DATE OF COMMISSION MEETING: May 10, 2022 Barry ReichenbergPRINTNAME: ADDRESS: 5921 sw 37 terr, Dania Beach PHONE NO.(Optional): PLEASE CHECK ONE OR BOTH OF THE BOXES BELOW: 1) I CITIZEN COMMENTS: Comments by Dania Beach citizens or interested parties that are not part of the regular printed agenda may be made during each Commission meeting during the period set aside for "Citizen Comments." A thirty(30)minute"Citizen Comments"period shall be designated on the agenda for citizens and interested persons to speak on matters not scheduled on that day's agenda. Each speaker shall be limited to 3 minutes for his or her comments. Persons desiring to speak during the citizen comment period shall inform the City Clerk immediately prior to the beginning of the meeting of their intention to speak. If more than 10 speakers express a desire to speak,the Commission shall determine on a meeting by meeting basis whether to(a)extend the time allotted for citizen comments to accommodate all speakers,or(b)whether to limit the number of speakers or amount of time per speaker. A speaker's time shall not be transferable to another speaker. PLEASE BRIEFLY DESCRIBE THE SUBJECT MATTER OF YOUR.COMMENT: rezoning of 3851 stirling rd from E-1 to mixed use 2) Li PUBLIC HEARINGS-ITEM# 9(1) a ( AS PRINtD ON AGENDA) PLEASE NOTE:IF YOU WISH TO SPEAK ON AN ITEM THAT PERTAINS TO A"ZONING,'TYPE OF MArimt(FOR EXAMPLE,A SITE PLAN,VARIANCE,SPECIAL EXcrytION OR SIMILAR TYPE OF ITEM KNOWN AS A"QUASI-JUDICIAL"MArrh72,YOU ARE SUBJECT TO BEING ASKED TO SWEAR OR AFFIRM THAT YOU WILL BE TRUTHFUL AS TO YOUR COMMENTS,O.R TESTIMONY. YOU MAY ALSO BE SUBJECT TO QUESTIONS ASKED OF YOU BY AN APPLICANT OR AN APPLICANT'S REPRESENTATIVE OR ATTORNEY WHICH RELATE TO THE ITEM, ANY PERSON WHO DECIDES TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE WITH REGARD TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING OR HEARING WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDING,AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDING IS MADE WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. LOBBYIST REGISTRATION IS REQUIRED. PRIOR TO ENGAGING IN ANY LOBBYING ACTIVITIES, WHETHER OR NOT COMPENSATION IS PAID OR RECEIVED IN CONNECTION WITH THOSE ACTIVITIES,EACH LOBBYIST SHALL FILE WITH THE CITY CLERK AN ANNUAL REGISTRATION STATEMENT AND PAY AN ANNUAL TWO HUNDRED FIFTY DOLLARS($250.00) REGISTRATION FEE FOR EACH PRINCIPAL OR EMPLOYER. REGISTRATION FORMS ARE AVAILABLE ON THE CITY WEBSTTE:' WWW.DANIABEACHFL.GOV. (ORDINANCE#20t2-019;AMENDED BY ORDINANCE#2019-019) Sion.la Soatol Do a429 uacaa'.rrr*e#(6r4g 05/10/2022hatencourageanddirectamixofresidentialcommunitiesor"mixed- use" development adjacent to the 4 community area planning,and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation-3 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises, Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta, Florida 33469 954) 815-4298 As of 3.23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD) for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road. Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing( drop-off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication report(IJR); served as the task leader for the preparation of the state environmental impact REQUEST TO ADDRESS CITY COMMISSION AT REGULAR OR SPECIAL VIRTUAL MEETINGS DANIA BEACH SEA IT.LIVE IT.LOVE IT. The City is required by state law to keep minutes of City Commission meetings. To properly identify persons who address the City Commission in those minutes,the City requests that this form be completed and provided to the City Clerk,before the meeting begins. DATE OF COMMISSION MEETWG: May 10, 2022 PRINT NAME:Stephanie Jofe 5880 SW 37th, Ft Lauderdale, FL 33312 ADDRESS: PHONE NO.(Optional): ( 954)292-3030 PLEASE CHECK ONE OR BOTH OF THE BOXES BELOW: 1) CITI7.FN COMMENTS: Comments by Dania Beach citizens or interested parties that are not part of the regular printed agenda may be made during each Commission meeting during the period set aside for"Citizen Comments. A thirty(30)minute"Citizen Comments"period shall be designated on,the agenda for citizens and interested persons to speak on matters not scheduled on that day's-agenda. Each speaker shall be limited to 3 minutes for his or her comments. Persons desiring to speak during the citizen comment period shall inform the City Clerk immediately prior to the beginning of the meeting of their intention to speak. If more than 10 speakers express a desire to speak,the Commission shall determine on a meeting by meeting basis whether to(a)extend the time allotted for citizen comments to accommodate all speakers,or(b)whether to limit the number of speakers or amount of time per speaker. A speaker's time shall not be transferable to another speaker. PLEASE BRIEFLY DESCRIBE THE SUBJECT MATTER OF YOUR COMMENT: 2) k PUBLIC HEARINGS—ITEM#9(1) AS PRINTED ON AGENDA) PLEASE NOTE:IF YOU WISH TO SPEAK ON AN ITEM THAT PERTAINS TO A"ZONING"TYPE OF MATI'Elt(FOR EXAMPLE A SITE PLAN,VARIANCE,SPECIAL EXeEt LION OR SIMILAR TYPE OF ITEM KNOWN AS A"QUASI-JUDICIAL"MATTER,YOU ARE SUBJECT TO BEING ASKED TO SWEAR OR AFFIRM THAT YOU WILL BE TRUTHFUL AS TO YOUR COMMENTS OR TESTIMONY. YOU MAY ALSO BE SUBJECT TO QUESTIONS ASKED OF YOU BY AN APPLICANT OR AN APPLICANT'S REPRESENTATIVE OR ATTORNEY WHICH RELATE TO THE ITEM. ANY PERSON WHO DECIDES TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE WITH REGARD TO ANY MATI'L1t CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING OR HEARING WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDING,AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT.A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDING IS MADE WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED, LOBBYIST REGISTRATION IS REQUIRED. PRIOR TO ENGAGING IN ANY LOBBYING ACTIVITIES, WHETHER OR NOT COMPENSATION IS PAID OR RECEIVED IN CONNECTION WITH THOSE ACTIVITIES,EACH LOBBYIST SHALL FILE WITH THE CITY CLERK AN ANNUAL REGISTRATION STATEMENT AND PAY AN ANNUAL TWO HUNDRED FIFTY DOLLARS($250.00) REGISTRATION FEE FOR EACH PRINCIPAL OR EMPLOYER. REGISTRATION FORMS ARE AVAILABLE ON THE CITY W EBSITE: WWW.DANIABEACHFL.GOV. (ORDINANCE#2012-019;AMENDED BY ORDINANCE#2019.019) y_S' 05/10/2022 WWW.DANIABEACHFL.GOV. (ORDINANCE#20t2- 019;AMENDED BY ORDINANCE# 2019-019)Sion.la Soatol Do a429 uacaa'.rrr*e#(6r4g 05/10/2022 hat encourage and direct a mix of residential communities or" mixed-use" development adjacent to the 4 community area planning,and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation- 3 Cecelia Ward, AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta, Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3. 23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration. North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD)for the school' s primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop-off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication report(IJR); served as the task leader for the REQUEST TO ADDRESS CITY COMMISSION AT REGULAR ta OR SPECIAL VIRTUAL MEETINGS DANIA BEACH SEA IT.UVE IT.LOVE IT. The City is required by state law to keep minutes of City Commission meetings. To properly identify persons who address the City Commission in those minutes,the City requests that this form be completed and provided to the City Clerk,before the meeting begins. DATE OF COMMISSION MEETING: May 10, 2022 PRINT NAME:Michael Jofe ADDRESS: 5880 SW 37th, Ft Lauderdale, FL 33312 PHONE NO.(Optional).(954)445-6800 PLEASE CHECK ONE OR BOTH OF THE BOXES BELOW: 1) 1 CITIZEN COMMENTS: Comments by Dania Beach citizens or interested parties that are not part of the regular printed agenda may be made during each Commission meeting during the period set aside for"Citizen Comments." A thirty(30)minute"Citizen Comments"period shall be designated on the agenda for citizens and interested persons to speak on matters not scheduled on that day's agenda. Each speaker shall be limited to 3 minutes for his or her comments. Persons desiring to speak during the citizen comment period shall inform the City Clerk immediately prior to the beginning of the meeting of their intention to speak. If more than 10 speakers express a desire to speak,the Commission shall determine on a meeting by meeting basis whether to(a)extend the time allotted for citizen comments to accommodate all speakers,or(b)whether to limit the number of speakers or,amount of time per speaker. A speaker's time shall not be transferable to another speaker. PLEASE BRIEFLY DESCRIBE THE SUBJECT MATTER OF YOUR COMMENT: 2) PUBLIC HEARINGS—ITEM# 9(1) AS PRINTED ON AGENDA) PLEASE NOTE:IF YOU WISH TO SPEAK ON AN ITEM THAT PERTAINS TO A"ZONING'TYPE OF MATTER(FOR EXAMPLE,A SITE PLAN,VARIANCE,SPECIAL EXcEeiION OR SIMILAR TYPE OF ITEM KNOWN AS A"QUASI-JUDICIAL"MATTER,YOU ARE SUBJECT TO BEING ASKED TO SWEAR OR AFFIRM THAT YOU WILL BE TRUTHFUL AS TO YOUR COMMENTS OR TESTIMONY. YOU MAY ALSO BE SUBJECT TO QUESTIONS ASKED OF YOU BY AN APPLICANT OR AN APPLICANT'S REPRESENTATIVE OR ATTORNEY WHICH RELATE TO THE ITEM, ANY PERSON WHO DECIDES TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE WITH REGARD TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING OR HEARING WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDING,AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDING IS MADE WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED, LOBBYIST REGISTRATION IS REQUIRED. PRIOR TO ENGAGING IN ANY LOBBYING ACTIVITIES, WHETHER OR NOT COMPENSATION IS PAID OR RECEIVED IN CONNECTION WITH THOSE ACTIVITIES,EACH LOBBYIST SHALL FILE WITH THE CITY CLERK AN ANNUAL REGISTRATION STATEMENT AND PAY AN ANNUAL TWO HUNDRED FI}TY DOLLARS($250.00) REGISTRATION FEE FOR EACH PRINCIPAL OR EMPLOYER.REGISTRATION FORMS ARE AVAILABLE ON THE CITY WEBSITE:: W W W.DANIABEACHFL.GOV. (ORDINANCE#2012.019;AMENDED BY ORDINANCE#2019-019) 6)7f f 05i1 oi2o2zK., a...>x WWW.DANIABEACHFL.GOV. ( ORDINANCE#20t2-019;AMENDED BY ORDINANCE#2019-019)Sion. la Soatol Doa429uacaa'.rrr*e#(6r4g 05/10/2022 hat encourage and direct a mix of residential communities or"mixed-use" development adjacent to the 4 community area planning,and zoning codes. Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation-3 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises, Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,# 313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954) 815-4298 As of 3.23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20- year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD)for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop-off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication report(IJR); served as the task leader REQUEST TO ADDRESS CITY COMMISSION AT REGULAR OR SPECIAL VIRTUAL MEETINGS DANIA BEACH' SEA IT.LIVE IT.LOVE IT. The City is required by state law to keep minutes of City Commission meetings. To properly identify persons who address the City Commission in those minutes,the City requests that this form be completed and provided to the City Clerk,before the meeting begins. DATE OF COMMISSION MEETING: May 10, 2022 PRINT NAME:James Rizzo 5821 SW 37th Avenue, Fort Lauderdale, FL 33312 (in Dania Beach) ADDRESS: PHONE NO. (Optional): PLEASE CHECK ONE OR BOTH OF THE BOXES BELOW: 1) CITIZEN COMMENTS: Comments by Dania Beach citizens or interested parties that are not part of the regular printed agenda may be made during each Commission meeting during the period set aside for"Citizen Comments." A thirty(30)minute"Citizen Comments"period shall be designated on the agenda for citizens and interested persons to speak on matters not scheduled on that day's agenda. Each speaker shall be limited to 3 minutes for his or her comments. Persons desiring to speak during the citizen comment period shall inform the City Clerk immediately prior to the beginning of the meeting of their intention to speak. If more than 10 speakers express a desire to speak,the Commission shall determine on a meeting by meeting basis whether to(a)extend the time allotted for citizen comments to accommodate all speakers,or(b)whether to limit the number of speakers or amount of time per speaker. A speaker's time shall not be transferable to another speaker. PLEASE BRIEFLY DESCRIBE THE SUBJECT MATTER OF YOUR COMMENT: 2) PUBLIC HEARINGS—ITEM# 1 AS PRINTED ON AGENDA) PLEASE NOTE:IF YOU WISH TO SPEAK ON AN ITEM THAT PERTAINS TO A"ZONING"TYPE OF MATT (FOR EXAMPLE A SITE PLAN,VARIANCE,SPECIAL,EXCaYiLON OR SIMILAR TYPE OF ITEM KNOWN AS A"QUASI-JUDICIAL"MA t t ,YOU ARE SUBJECT TO BEING ASKED TO SWEAR OR AFFIRM THAT YOU WILL BE TRUTHFUL AS TO YOUR COMMENTS OR TESTIMONY. YOU MAY ALSO BE SUBJECT TO QUESTIONS ASKED OF YOU BY AN APPLICANT OR AN APPLICANT'S REPRESENTATIVE OR ATTORNEY WHICH RELATE TO THE ITEM. ANY PERSON WHO DECIDES TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE WITH REGARD TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING OR HEARING WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDING,AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDING IS MADE WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED, LOBBYIST REGISTRATION IS REQUIRED. PRIOR TO ENGAGING IN ANY LOBBYING ACTIVITIES, WI-TETHER OR NOT COMPENSATION IS PAID OR RECEIVED IN CONNECTION WITH THOSE ACTIVITIES,EACH LOBBYIST SHALL FILE WITH THE CITY (`I FRK AN ANNUAL REGISTRATION STATEMENT AND PAY AN ANNUAL TWO HUNDRED FIFTY DOLLARS($250.00) REGISTRATION FEE FOR EACH PRINCIPAL OR EMPLOYER. REGISTRATION FORMS ARE AVAILABLE ON THE CITY WEBSITE: WWW.DANIABEACHFL.GOV. (ORDINANCE#2012-019;AMENDED BY ORDINANCE#2019-019) 7jaoad aamoss s. C7 ze 05/10/2022DINANCE# 20t2-019;AMENDED BY ORDINANCE#2019-019) Sion.la Soatol Do a429 uacaa'.rrr*e#(6r4g 05/10/2022 hat encourage and direct a mix of residential communities or"mixed-use" development adjacent to the 4 community area planning,and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation-3 Cecelia Ward, AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3.23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD) for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop-off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access. Page 3 of 3 ication report(IJR); served as the task leader for the preparation of REQUEST TO ADDRESS CITY COMMISSION AT REGULAR OR SPECIAL MEETINGS DANIA BEACH SEA IT.LIVE IT.LOVE IT. The City is required by state law to keep minutes of City Commission meetings. To properly identify persons who address the City Commission in those minutes,the City requests that this form be completed and provided to the City Clerk,before the meeting begins. DATE OF COMMISSION MEETING: N) Iv ,20— - PRINT NAME: fl Ai h GL ADDRESS: y 3c ti000k OGi5' 0•ri A- PHONE NO. (optional): PLEASE CHECK ONE OR BOTH OF THE BOXES BELOW: 1) b- CITIZEN COMMENTS: Comments by Dania Beach citizens or interested parties that are not part of the regular printed agenda may be made during each Commission meeting during the period set aside for"Citizen Comments." A thirty(30)minute"Citizen Comments"period shall be designated on the agenda for citizens and interested persons to speak on matters not scheduled on that day's agenda. Each speaker shall be limited to 3 minutes for his or her comments. Persons desiring to speak during the citizen comment period shall inform the City Clerk immediately prior to the beginning of the meeting of their intention to speak. If more than 10 speakers express a desire to speak,the Commission shall determine on a meeting by meeting basis whether to(a)extend the time allotted for citizen comments to accommodate all speakers,or(b)whether to limit the number of speakers or amount of time per speaker. A speaker's time shall not be transferable to another speaker. PLEASE BRIEFLY DESCRIBE THE SUBJECT MATTER OF YOUR COMMENT: Sit-N r- L f v l ' ( Ci ire/fi I ) ufty 2) PUBLIC HEARINGS—ITEM# AS PRINTED ON AGENDA) PLEASE NOTE:IF YOU WISH TO SPEAK ON AN ITEM THAT PERTAINS TO A"ZONING"TYPE OF MATTER(FOR EXAMPLE,A SITE PLAN,VARIANCE, SPECIAL EXCEPTION OR SIMILAR TYPE OF ITEM KNOWN AS A"QUASI-JUDICIAL"MATTER,YOU ARE SUBJECT TO BEING ASKED TO SWEAR OR AFFIRM THAT YOU WILL BE TRUTHFUL AS TO YOUR COMMENTS OR TESTIMONY. YOU MAY ALSO BE SUBJECT TO QUESTIONS ASKED OF YOU BY AN APPLICANT OR AN APPLICANT'S REPRESENTATIVE OR ATTORNEY WHICH RELATE TO THE ITEM. ANY PERSON WHO DECIDES TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE WITH REGARD TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING OR HEARING WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDING, AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDING IS MADE WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. LOBBYIST REGISTRATION IS REQUIRED. PRIOR TO ENGAGING IN ANY LOBBYING ACTIVITIES, WHETHER OR NOT COMPENSATION IS PAID OR RECEIVED IN CONNECTION WITH THOSE ACTIVITIES,EACH LOBBYIST SHALL FILE WITH THE CITY CLERK AN ANNUAL REGISTRATION STATEMENT AND PAY AN ANNUAL TWO HUNDRED FIFTY DOLLARS ($250.00) REGISTRATION FEE FOR EACH PRINCIPAL OR EMPLOYER. REGISTRATION FORMS ARE AVAILABLE ON THE CITY WEBSITE: WWW.DANIABEACHFL.GOV. (ORDINANCE#2012-019;AMENDED BY ORDINANCE#2019-019) G:\Agenda\PUBLIC SPEAKING FORM.doc e 05/10/2022 DINANCE# 20t2-019;AMENDED BY ORDINANCE# 2019-019)Sion.la Soatol Do a429 uacaa'.rrr*e#(6r4g 05/10/2022 hat encourage and direct a mix of residential communities or"mixed-use" development adjacent to the 4 community area planning, and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/ Appeal of Zoning Interpretation-3 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises, Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta, Florida 33469 954) 815-4298 As of 3.23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study, Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD)for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop-off and pick-up) analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication report(IJR); served as REQUEST TO ADDRESS CITY COMMISSION AT REGULAR OR SPECIAL MEETINGS DANIA BEACH SEA IT.LIVE IT.LOVE IT. The City is required by state law to keep minutes of City Commission meetings. To properly identify persons who address the City Commission in those minutes,the City requests that this form be completed and provided to the City Clerk,before the meeting begins. DATE OF COMMISSION MEETING:20 PRINT NAME: 41;21,/,12M/ ADDRESS:l t Z% 411C1-- PHONE NO. (optional): 951 2r l PLEASE CHECK ONE O OTH OF THE BO S BELOW: 1) CITIZEN COMMENTS: Comments by Dania Beach citizens or interested parties t are not part of the regular printed agenda may be made during each Commission meeting during the period set aside for"Citizen Comments." A thirty(30)minute"Citizen Comments"period shall be designated on the agenda for citizens and interested persons to speak on matters not scheduled on that day's agenda. Each speaker shall be limited to 3 minutes for his or her comments. Persons desiring to speak during the citizen comment period shall inform the City Clerk immediately prior to the beginning of the meeting of their intention to speak. If more than 10 speakers express a desire to speak,the Commission shall determine on a meeting by meeting basis whether to(a)extend the time allotted for citizen comments to accommodate all speakers,or(b)whether to limit the number of speakers or amount of time per speaker. A speaker's time shall not be transferable to another speaker. PLEASE BRIEFLY DESCRIBE THE SUBJECT MATTER OF YOUR COMMENT: 2) PUBLIC HEARINGS—ITEM# /It / (AS PRINTED ON AGENDA) PLEASE NOTE:IF YOU WISH TO SPEAK ON AN ITEM THAT PERTAINS TO A"ZONING"TYPE OF MATTER(FOR EXAMPLE,A SITE PLAN,VARIANCE, SPECIAL EXCEPTION OR SIMILAR TYPE OF ITEM KNOWN AS A"QUASI-JUDICIAL"MATTER,YOU ARE SUBJECT TO BEING ASKED TO SWEAR OR AFFIRM THAT YOU WILL BE TRUTHFUL AS TO YOUR COMMENTS OR TESTIMONY. YOU MAY ALSO BE SUBJECT TO QUESTIONS ASKED OF YOU BY AN APPLICANT OR AN APPLICANT'S REPRESENTATIVE OR ATTORNEY WHICH RELATE TO THE ITEM. ANY PERSON WHO DECIDES TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE WITH REGARD TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING OR HEARING WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDING, AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDING IS MADE WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. LOBBYIST REGISTRATION IS REQUIRED. PRIOR TO ENGAGING IN ANY LOBBYING ACTIVITIES, WHETHER OR NOT COMPENSATION IS PAID OR RECEIVED IN CONNECTION WITH THOSE ACTIVITIES,EACH LOBBYIST SHALL FILE WITH THE CITY CLERK AN ANNUAL REGISTRATION STATEMENT AND PAY AN ANNUAL TWO HUNDRED FIFTY DOLLARS ($250.00) REGISTRATION FEE FOR EACH PRINCIPAL OR EMPLOYER. REGISTRATION FORMS ARE AVAILABLE ON THE CITY WEBSITE: WWW.DANIABEACHFL.GOV. (ORDINANCE#2012-019;AMENDED BY ORDINANCE#2019-019) G:1Agenda\PUBLIC SPEAKING FORM.doc ANCE#2019-019)G:\Agenda\PUBLIC SPEAKING FORM. doc e 05/10/2022 DINANCE# 20t2- 019;AMENDED BY ORDINANCE# 2019-019)Sion.la Soatol Do a429 uacaa'.rrr*e#(6r4g 05/10/2022 hat encourage and direct a mix of residential communities or" mixed-use" development adjacent to the 4 community area planning,and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation- 3 Cecelia Ward, AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta, Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3. 23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration. North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD)for the school' s primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop-off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication report(IJR); served as the task leader for the REQUEST TO ADDRESS CITY COMMISSION AT REGULAR OR SPECIAL MEETINGS DANIA BEACH SEA IT.LIVE IT.LOVE IT. The City is required by state law to keep minutes of City Commission meetings. To properly identify persons who address the City Commission in those minutes,the City requests that this form be completed and provided to the City Clerk,before the meeting begins. DATE OF COMMISSION MEETING: 447G 20 PRINT NAME: L.l ( 1. e", ADDRESS:10/ /3P^ J 6,-- 1' 3 PHONE NO. (optional): Vira 46, PLEASE CHECK ONE OR BOTH OF THE BOXES BELOW: 1) El CITIZEN COMMENTS: Comments by Dania Beach citizens or interested parties that are not part of the regular printed agenda may be made during each Commission meeting during the period set aside for"Citizen Comments." A thirty(30)minute"Citizen Comments"period shall be designated on the agenda for citizens and interested persons to speak on matters not scheduled on that day's agenda. Each speaker shall be limited to 3 minutes for his or her comments. Persons desiring to speak during the citizen comment period shall inform the City Clerk immediately prior to the beginning of the meeting of their intention to speak. If more than 10 speakers express a desire to speak,the Commission shall determine on a meeting by meeting basis whether to(a)extend the time allotted for citizen comments to accommodate all speakers,or(b)whether to limit the number of speakers or amount of time per speaker. A speaker's time shall not be transferable to another speaker. PLEASE BRIEFLY DESC E THE SUBJECT MATTER OF YOUR COMMENT: 2) PUBLIC HEARINGS—ITEM# AS PRINTED ON AGENDA) PLEASE NOTE:IF YOU WISH TO SPEAK ON AN ITEM THAT PERTAINS TO A"ZONING"TYPE OF MATTER(FOR EXAMPLE,A SITE PLAN,VARIANCE, SPECIAL EXCEPTION OR SIMILAR TYPE OF ITEM KNOWN AS A"QUASI-JUDICIAL"MATTER, YOU ARE SUBJECT TO BEING ASKED TO SWEAR OR AFFIRM THAT YOU WILL BE TRUTHFUL AS TO YOUR COMMENTS OR TESTIMONY. YOU MAY ALSO BE SUBJECT TO QUESTIONS ASKED OF YOU BY AN APPLICANT OR AN APPLICANT'S REPRESENTATIVE OR ATTORNEY WHICH RELATE TO THE ITEM. ANY PERSON WHO DECIDES TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE WITH REGARD TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING OR HEARING WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDING, AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDING IS MADE WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. LOBBYIST REGISTRATION IS REQUIRED. PRIOR TO ENGAGING IN ANY LOBBYING ACTIVITIES, WHETHER OR NOT COMPENSATION IS PAID OR RECEIVED IN CONNECTION WITH THOSE ACTIVITIES,EACH LOBBYIST SHALL FILE WITH THE CITY CLERK AN ANNUAL REGISTRATION STATEMENT AND PAY AN ANNUAL TWO HUNDRED FIFTY DOLLARS ($250.00) REGISTRATION FEE FOR EACH PRINCIPAL OR EMPLOYER. REGISTRATION FORMS ARE AVAILABLE ON THE CITY WEBSITE: WWW.DANIABEACHFL.GOV. (ORDINANCE#2012-019;AMENDED BY ORDINANCE#2019-019) G:\Agenda\PUBLIC SPEAKING FORM.doc enda\PUBLIC SPEAKING FORM.doc e 05/10/2022 DINANCE#20t2- 019; AMENDED BY ORDINANCE#2019- 019)Sion.la Soatol Do a429 uacaa'.rrr*e#(6r4g 05/10/2022 hat encourage and direct a mix of residential communities or"mixed- use" development adjacent to the 4 community area planning,and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation-3 Cecelia Ward,AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,# 313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3.23. 22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices( MUTCD)for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop-off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication report(IJR); served as the task leader for the preparation REQUEST TO ADDRESS CITY COMMISSION AT REGULAR OR SPECIAL MEETINGS DANIA BEACH SEA IT.LIVE IT.LOVE IT. The City is required by state law to keep minutes of City Commission meetings. To properly identify persons who address the City Commission in those minutes,the City requests that this form be completed and provided to the City Clerk, before the meeting begins. DATE OF COMMISSION MEETING:20_ PRINT NAME: C LSZ CL 2 5J C J ADDRESS: PHONE NO. (optional): PLEASE CHECK ONE OR BOTH OF THE BOXES BELOW: 1) El CITIZEN COMMENTS: Comments by Dania Beach citizens or interested parties that are not part of the regular printed agenda may be made during each Commission meeting during the period set aside for"Citizen Comments." A thirty(30)minute"Citizen Comments"period shall be designated on the agenda for citizens and interested persons to speak on matters not scheduled on that day's agenda. Each speaker shall be limited to 3 minutes for his or her comments. Persons desiring to speak during the citizen comment period shall inform the City Clerk immediately prior to the beginning of the meeting of their intention to speak. If more than 10 speakers express a desire to speak,the Commission shall determine on a meeting by meeting basis whether to(a)extend the time allotted for citizen comments to accommodate all speakers,or(b)whether to limit the number of speakers or amount of time per speaker. A speaker's time shall not be transferable to another speaker. PLEASE BRIEFLY DESCRIBE THE SUBJECT MATTER OF YOUR COMMENT: 2) PUBLIC HEARINGS—ITEM# . 1, (AS PRINTED ON AGENDA) PLEASE NOTE:IF YOU WISH TO SPEAK ON AN ITEM THAT PERTAINS TO A"ZONING"TYPE OF MATTER(FOR EXAMPLE,A SITE PLAN, VARIANCE, SPECIAL EXCEPTION OR SIMILAR TYPE OF ITEM KNOWN AS A"QUASI-JUDICIAL"MATTER, YOU ARE SUBJECT TO BEING ASKED TO SWEAR OR AFFIRM THAT YOU WILL BE TRUTHFUL AS TO YOUR COMMENTS OR TESTIMONY. YOU MAY ALSO BE SUBJECT TO QUESTIONS ASKED OF YOU BY AN APPLICANT OR AN APPLICANT'S REPRESENTATIVE OR ATTORNEY WHICH RELATE TO THE ITEM. ANY PERSON WHO DECIDES TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE WITH REGARD TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING OR HEARING WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDING, AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDING IS MADE WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. LOBBYIST REGISTRATION IS REQUIRED. PRIOR TO ENGAGING IN ANY LOBBYING ACTIVITIES, WHETHER OR NOT COMPENSATION IS PAID OR RECEIVED IN CONNECTION WITH THOSE ACTIVITIES,EACH LOBBYIST SHALL FILE WITH THE CITY CLERK AN ANNUAL REGISTRATION STATEMENT AND PAY AN ANNUAL TWO HUNDRED FIFTY DOLLARS ($250.00) REGISTRATION FEE FOR EACH PRINCIPAL OR EMPLOYER. REGISTRATION FORMS ARE AVAILABLE ON THE CITY WEBSITE: WWW.DANIABEACHFL.GOV. (ORDINANCE#2012-019;AMENDED BY ORDINANCE#2019-019) G:\Agenda\PUBLIC SPEAKING FORM.docDANIABEACHFL.GOV. (ORDINANCE#2012-019;AMENDED BY ORDINANCE#2019-019)G:\ Agenda\PUBLIC SPEAKING FORM.doc enda\ PUBLIC SPEAKING FORM.doc e 05/10/2022 DINANCE#20t2- 019;AMENDED BYORDINANCE#2019-019)Sion.la Soatol Do a429 uacaa'.rrr*e#( 6r4g 05/10/2022 hat encourage and direct a mix of residential communities or"mixed-use" development adjacent to the 4 community area planning,and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation- 3 Cecelia Ward, AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3.23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD)for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop- off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication REQUEST TO ADDRESS CITY COMMISSION AT REGULAR OR SPECIAL MEETINGS DANIA BEACH SEA IT.LIVE IT.LOVE IT. The City is required by state law to keep minutes of City Commission meetings. To properly identify persons who address the City Commission in those minutes,the City requests that this form be completed and provided to the City Clerk,before the meeting begins. DATE OF COMMISSION I MEETING:(' 20 PRINT NAME: )7-8` I PP c-' ADDRESS: 21 V 1 C ( 'T",mac se PHONE NO. (optional): PLEASE CHECK ONE OR BOTH OF THE BOXES BELOW: 1) Li CITIZEN COMMENTS: Comments by Dania Beach citizens or interested parties that are not part of the regular printed agenda may be made during each Commission meeting during the period set aside for"Citizen Comments." A thirty(30)minute"Citizen Comments"period shall be designated on the agenda for citizens and interested persons to speak on matters not scheduled on that day's agenda. Each speaker shall be limited to 3 minutes for his or her comments. Persons desiring to speak during the citizen comment period shall inform the City Clerk immediately prior to the beginning of the meeting of their intention to speak. If more than 10 speakers express a desire to speak,the Commission shall determine on a meeting by meeting basis whether to(a)extend the time allotted for citizen comments to accommodate all speakers,or(b)whether to limit the number of speakers or amount of time per speaker. A speaker's time shall not be transferable to another speaker. PLEASE BRIEFLY DESCRIBE THE SUBJECT MATTER OF YOUR COMMENT: 2) / PUBLIC HEARINGS—ITEM#Qi 46 7(AS PRINTED ON AGENDA) PLEASE NOTE:IF YOU WISH TO SPEAK ON AN ITEM THAT PERTAINS TO A"ZONING"TYPE OF MATTER(FOR EXAMPLE,A SITE PLAN,VARIANCE, SPECIAL EXCEPTION OR SIMILAR TYPE OF ITEM KNOWN AS A"QUASI-JUDICIAL"MATTER, YOU ARE SUBJECT TO BEING ASKED TO SWEAR OR AFFIRM THAT YOU WILL BE TRUTHFUL AS TO YOUR COMMENTS OR TESTIMONY. YOU MAY ALSO BE SUBJECT TO QUESTIONS ASKED OF YOU BY AN APPLICANT OR AN APPLICANT'S REPRESENTATIVE OR ATTORNEY WHICH RELATE TO THE ITEM. ANY PERSON WHO DECIDES TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE WITH REGARD TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING OR HEARING WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDING, AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDING IS MADE WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. LOBBYIST REGISTRATION IS REQUIRED. PRIOR TO ENGAGING IN ANY LOBBYING ACTIVITIES, WHETHER OR NOT COMPENSATION IS PAID OR RECEIVED IN CONNECTION WITH THOSE ACTIVITIES,EACH LOBBYIST SHALL FILE WITH THE CITY CLERK AN ANNUAL REGISTRATION STATEMENT AND PAY AN ANNUAL TWO HUNDRED FIFTY DOLLARS ($250.00) REGISTRATION FEE FOR EACH PRINCIPAL OR EMPLOYER. REGISTRATION FORMS ARE AVAILABLE ON THE CITY WEBSITE: WWW.DANIABEACHFL.GOV. (ORDINANCE#2012-019;AMENDED BY ORDINANCE#2019-019) G:\Agenda\PUBLIC SPEAKING FORM.doc 19-019)G:\ Agenda\PUBLIC SPEAKING FORM.doc enda\ PUBLIC SPEAKING FORM.doc e 05/10/2022 DINANCE#20t2- 019;AMENDED BYORDINANCE#2019-019)Sion.la Soatol Do a429 uacaa'.rrr*e#( 6r4g 05/10/2022 hat encourage and direct a mix of residential communities or"mixed-use" development adjacent to the 4 community area planning,and zoning codes.Private Sector Expert Testimony/ Expert Witness Cases:o Capri Hotel,LLC-W Hotel Fort Lauderdale,Board Of Adjustment/Appeal of Zoning Interpretation- 3 Cecelia Ward, AICP JC Consulting Enterprises,Inc.18081 SE Country Club Drive,#313 Tequesta,Florida 33469 954)815-4298 As of 3.23.22 ial feasibility study for the implementation of a toll road in Chesapeake,Virginia. This involved development of traffic volumes, construction and operating and maintenance costs, projection of toll revenues, and identification of alternative funding sources.US 17 Bypass Corridor Study,Washington, NC;Task Manager. Developed traffic forecasts for a 20-year period on the US 17 corridor in eastern North Carolina. Also prepared roadway concepts for design consideration.North Broward Preparatory School,Signal Warrant Study, Broward County, FL; Project Manager. Performed traffic analyses and signal warrant study in accordance with the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices(MUTCD)for the school's primary entrance on Lyons Road.Pine Crest Schools, Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, FL; Project Manager. Provided traffic engineering services in support of their capital improvement programs. These services included parking evaluations, queuing(drop- off and pick-up)analyses, on site circulation, and project access.Page 3 of 3 ication