HomeMy WebLinkAbout2024-03-18 Public Art Advisory Board Agenda CITY OF DANIA BEACH
PUBLIC ART ADVISORY BOARD - AGENDA
NW CONFERENCE ROOM/ CITY HALL
100 W DANIA BEACH BLVD
MONDAY, MARCH 18, 2024 – 5:00 P.M.
I. ROLL CALL
II. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
a) Approval of Minutes of the Public Art Advisory Board from the February 26, 2024 meeting.
III. PRESENTATION
a) Public Art and the Intersection with AI and Technology: Part 2
Joshua H. Lida, Esq. | Senior Associate, Shendell & Pollock, PL
IV. ACTION ITEMS
a) New Project: Dania Beach Marina
b) City Anniversary: Fall 2024
V. ADMINISTRATOR UPDATES
a) City Hall Garage Timeline
VI. MEETING ADJOURNED
CITY OF DANIA BEACH
PUBLIC ART ADVISORY BOARD MEETING – MINUTES
REGULAR MEETING / NW CONFERENCE RM – CITY HALL
100 W DANIA BEACH BLVD
MONDAY, FEBRUARY 26, 2024 – 5:00 P.M.
I. ROLL CALL
The meeting was called to order at approximately 5:05PM by Co-Chair Schipper. Board Clerk Larios
called the roll. Discussions/actions noted below were not limited to what was typed.
Board Members Staff
Chair Kelly Sharaby Late/5:18PM Community Dev Deputy Director Corinne Lajoie, AICP Attended
Co-Chair Lilli Schipper Present Board Clerk Ibel Larios Attended
Joanna Granett Present
Meaghan Kent Late/5:06PM Others
Jennifer Gironda Present Commissioner Joyce Davis, Commission Liaison Attended
Lloyd Goradesky Present Public Art Consultant Linda Flynn, Ph.D, Cultural Planning Grp Attended
Marc Aptakin Present
II. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
a) Approval of Minutes of the Public Art Advisory Board (PAAB) from the January 22, 2024
meeting.
Motion was made by Board Member Granett to approve the minutes of the January 22, 2024 PAAB
Meeting as typed which was seconded by Board Member Aptakin. Motion passed 5-0.
Board Member Kent arrived approximately 5:06PM.
III. PRESENTATION
a) Public Art and the Intersection with AI and Technology: Part I
Joshua H. Lida, Esq. / Senior Associate, Shendell & Pollock, P.L.
This agenda item was heard after City Hall Garage Wall Art Installation Final Concept Review was
presented.
Attorney Lida introduced himself and spoke about the law firm he worked for. He presented a slide show
stating, “Artificial Intelligence (AI) was technology which allowed computers and other devices to
read, write, talk, see, create, and other human things humans can do. He showed examples of AI
and art, spoke about an artist who used AI technologies and techniques, and presented the artist’s
work. He talked about legal issues like copyright infringement lawsuits. He showed examples of
positive use cases for public art and discussed concerns for public art. Attorney Lida said
generative AI was a form of machine AI which was able to produce text, video, images or other
content. In different situations, the person affected by AI needed to know if AI was being used.
For example, a college professor may allow some AI in a student’s paper but the college professor
Public Art Advisory Board Meeting - Minutes 2 February 26, 2024
needed to know what was written by AI. It needed to be identified. Among questions answered
was if there was a program that would allow someone to know if AI was used. The attorney
answered that it was being worked on. People needed to be aware that AI existed and there were
ways to protect themselves. The attorney would present again at the next PAAB Meeting. The
Board thanked Attorney Lida for his informative and interesting presentation.
IV. ACTION ITEMS
a) City Hall Garage Wall Art Installation Final Concept Review:
Public Art Consultant Dr. Flynn made the presentation on the final concept review for the City
Hall Garage Wall Art Installation. Commissioner Davis reminded that there originally was a
Board discussion about more Dania Beach elements in the mural. She herself would like to see
more of a sense of place and cohesiveness. She said that the artist was at the City Commission
Meeting when the Commission approved the mural with the City’s logo. She voted against it as
she wanted the Board to have their last say-so.
Co-Chair Schipper suggested providing a bulleted list with the Board’s suggestions. Public Art
Consultant Dr. Flynn said not to suggest elements but rather ideas, framework, and concepts that
the Board wanted to see. The Board should not dictate to the artist so much. Commissioner Davis
said the mural did not show things like the Totor Dog statue and the weather vane. She would like
a more cohesive feeling. Public Art Consultant Dr. Flynn explained why they had to make a
decision soon. Board Member Aptakin felt that the mural could really represent any place in
Florida. The Board would like the artist to come back one more time so they could talk about an
updated concept. Public Art Consultant Dr. Flynn would see if the artist was available for the next
PAAB meeting.
Chair Sharaby arrived approximately 5:18PM and was made current as to what transpired. She
questioned if the Commission approved this already, why was the Board doing this?
Commissioner Davis said that she believed the Board was going to have their input before the final
decision was made. She felt that the mural missed the mark regarding sense of place and wanted
to see some Dania Beach elements. What they came back with was the logo on the mural. Board
Member Kent recommended seeing mangroves, and Co-Chair Schipper mentioned magical and/or
whimsical. Since the Commission thought the Board recommended the piece and they thought it
was beautiful, they approved it. It technically was a done deal but if the Board had further
recommendations, the City Commission would be open to hear them. As Attorney Lida was
present, the Board asked him to present his agenda item.
b) Public Art Collection Plaques: (Heard after City of Dania Beach Public Art Archive)
Public Art Consultant Dr. Flynn showed pictures of some of the plaques. The type of plaque
would depend on size and location of the artwork. There were many different options for QR
Codes and Braille on certain types of plaques as well as indoor and outdoor plaques. Discussion
ensued how QR Codes could be tampered with and an altered QR Code could bring a person to
the wrong website.
V. ADMINISTRATOR UPDATES
a) City of Dania Beach Public Art Archive: (Heard after City Hall Garage Wall Art
Installation Final Concept Review)
Public Art Advisory Board Meeting - Minutes 3 February 26, 2024
Public Art Consultant Dr. Flynn displayed what the following Dania Beach web address would
reflect - https://explore.publicartarchive.org/dania-beach-public-art/. It would show where the
artwork was located, all documentation on the artwork, etc.
VI. MEETING ADJOURNED
As all business was concluded, the meeting was adjourned without objection at approximately
6:17PM.
ATTEST:
______________________________ _______________________________________
IBEL LARIOS KELLY SHARABY, CHAIR
BOARD CLERK PUBLIC ART ADVISORY BOARD
(Date) (Date)
For more details regarding this meeting of the Public Art Advisory Board, please request a file of the
meeting by calling Deborah Sabino at (954) 924-6805 x3643 or emailing dsabino@daniabeachfl.gov.
Joshua Lida Shendell & Pollock, P.L Fort Lauderdale, Florida, United States Josh@shendellpollock.com Experience Senior Associate Shendell & Pollock, P.L Nov 2023-Present Founding Partner Twig, Trade, & Tribunal Aug 2020 – Oct 2023 Partner Lida Law, PLLC Dec 2017 - Aug 2020 Associate Attorney Jonathan S. Brooks, P.A Apr 2016 - Nov 2017 Contract Associate, Attorney Greenspoon Marder LLP Oct 2015 - Mar 2016 Legal Intern The Concept Law Group, P.A Jan-Apr ‘15 Jan 2015 - Apr 2015 Legal Intern Warner Music Latina, Inc May 2014 - Aug 2014 Law Clerk Frank, Weinberg & Black P.L Oct 2013 - Dec 2013 Education Nova Southeastern University Shepard Broad College of Law Juris Doctorate 2012 - 2015
Page 1 of 3
Page 2 of 4
University of Central Florida Bachelor of Arts (B.A.), History 2008 - 2012 Publications • NFTs in South Florida Craft Beer: On Their Way to Become a Trend
o Interviewed for article by author
o Browardbeer.com- March 29, 2022 • Copyrights and Public Art: Considerations for Local Governments
o City, County, and Local Government Law Section of the Florida Bar The Agenda Newsletter- Winter 2022 • NFT & ART: What Creators and Collectors Need to Know
o Contributed to blog post by local art conservator Stella Art Conservation
o https://stellaartconservation.com/nft-art-what-you-need-to-know/- December 2021 • The New Small Claims Court for Copyright Infringement
o The Barrister, Broward County Bar Association-June 2020 • What’s in a Name: A Primer on What Governs Beer Labels
o The Barrister, Broward County Bar Association-June 2020 • AOD: Alcohol on Demand
o The Barrister, Broward County Bar Association-May 2020 • Vaping in Florida Update
o The Barrister, Broward County Bar Association-December 2019 • Florida Beer Distribution Laws: A Primer
o The Barrister, Broward County Bar Association-September 2019 • Legal Health Corner: Meditation App Reviews
o The Barrister, Broward County Bar Association-June 2019 Presentations • IP Law in the Metaverse
o February 7, 2024 presented and recorded by MCLE New England • AI Influencing the Law: Image & Voice Scanning
o September 30, 2023 presented and recorded by the Broward County Bar Association for its youtube channel • Artificial Intelligence, Crypto, NFTs, and the Metaverse Applying Today’s Law to tomorrow and Beyond
o September 22, 2023 presented by NSU Shepard Broad College of Law • How Donor Advised Funds Intersect with Art, Real Estate, and NFTs
o May 2023, presented by J.P Morgan Private Fund • AI, Bots, and Crypto: What Young Lawyers Need To Know About Technology and the Practice of Law
o April 26, 2023 presented by the Young Lawyers Section of the Broward County Bar Association
Page 3 of 4
• Artificial Intelligence and the Law
o April 19, 2023 presented and recorded by the Broward County Bar Association for its youtube channel • Connecting It to All: Finding Interoperability within Web3 and the Metaverse
o April 14, 2023 presented by the Intellectual Property Section of the American Bar Association • Incorporating NFTs into the Contract Process for Public Art Agencies
o March 30, 2023 CODAsummit • Analyzing Logan Paul and Cryptozoo Scandal
o January 12, 2023 presented and recorded by the Broward county Bar Association for its youtube channel. • The Future of Music Streaming & Protecting Artist
o March 25, 2022 presented by Florida International University’s Sports, Entertainment, Fashion, and Art Law Society second annual symposium: The Metaverse and the Law • Crypto Assets and Valuations (NFTs, Metaverse, and Asset Backed Tokens)
o March 15, 2022 Family Office Forum, Austin Conference put on by IVYFON • NFTS and Art: Where We Are and Where We’re Going
o February 18, 2022 presented at the Palm Beach Show fine art show • A Conversation About NFTS
o February 1, 2021 presented and answered questions regarding NFTs with Yeasty Brews Artisanal Beers • NFTS and the Future of Art
o October 21, 2021 presented on behalf of the Broward County Broward Cultural Division • Wait, What?: Non-Fungible Token Basics and Looking Forward
Page 4 of 4
o September 1, 2021 presentation given to the Broward County Bar Association • The Art of Negotiation
o July 31, 2021 moderated a presentation in conjunction with Broward County Broward Cultural Division • Art Business Law Workshop with Josh Lida
o February 10, 2021 via Zoom through Nova Southeastern University Department of Communication, Media, and the Arts