Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutR-2024-051 Approval of Distance Waiver for Maverick Liquors LLC (OT001-24)RESOLUTION NO. 2024-Q5' \ A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF DANIA BEACH, FLORIDA, APPROVING THE REQUEST FOR A WAIVER (OT-001- 24) FROM THE ONE THOUSAND (1,000) FOOT DISTANCE SEPARATION REQUIREMENT PERTAINING TO THE SALE OF ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES, SUBMITTED BY THE APPLICANT, PEARL BEN YORAM AND MOR BEN YO RAM OF MAVERICK LIQUORS LLC, FOR THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 4501 STIRLING ROAD , WITHIN THE CITY OF DANIA BEACH, FLORIDA, PROVIDING FOR CONFLICTS; FURTHER, PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DA TE. WHEREAS, Chapter 28, Part 1 of the Dania Beach Land Development Code (the "LDC"), Section 110-50(E), entitled "Proximity of Alcoholic Beverage Establishments to Other Establishments and Uses," states that an Applicant for a license to sell liquor, in addition to beer and wine, within one thousand (1,000) feet of another place of business so licensed, may apply for a Waiver of the proximity requirements set forth in Section l 10-50(B)(9); and WHEREAS, the applicant, Pearl Ben Yoram and Mor Ben Yoram, Maverick Liquors LLC, ha s requested a Waiver (OT-043-23) of the distance separation re quirement for property located at 4501 Stirling Road, D a nia Beach, Florida, legally described in Exhibit "A," pursuant to Section 110-50(E) of the LDC; and WHEREAS, the City Planning and Zoning Board, sitting as the Local Planning Agency, held a duly advertised public hearing on March 20, 2024, and determined that the proposed Waiver of the proximity is consistent with the requirements set forth in Section 110- 50(E)(l); and therefore, recommended approval of the proposed waiver of the distance separation; and WHEREAS, the City Commission has determined that the Applicant has met the criteria for a Waiver of the distance separation requirement by a preponderance of the evidence; and WHEREAS, the Staff Report analyzes the applicant's request based on the Waiver of the proximity requirements criteria and support the Applicant's request; and WHEREAS, the City Commission conducted a duly noticed public hearing m accordance with Article 610 of the LDC; and 2 WHEREAS, the City Commission finds that the approval of the Waiver request (OT- 001-24) is consistent with the LDC and Comprehensive Plan. NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF DANIA BEACH, FLORIDA: Section 1. That the foregoing "WHEREAS" clauses are ratified and confirmed as being true and correct and they are made a specific part of this Resolution. Section 2. That pursuant to Chapter 28 "Land Development Code," Part 1 "Use Regulations," Article 110 "Use Regulations for Commercial And Mixed Used Districts," of the City Code, the Waiver request (OT-001-24), as shown on Exhibit "B" is hereby approved. Section 3. That the approvals granted by this Resolution are subject to the Applicant's compliance with the following condition: 1. Applicant must submit a permit for parking stripping of the proposed four ( 4) parking spaces following off-sheet parking requirements from Code Sec. 265-20 prior to the approval of Certificate of Use and Business Tax Receipt. Section 4. That the associated Planning & Zoning Division Staff Report prepared for the above application(s) is/are incorporated into this resolution as findings of fact. Section 5. That the issuance of a Waiver by a municipality does not in any way create any right on the pru1 of an Applicant to obtain a permit from a state or federal agency , and does not create any liability on the part of the municipality for issuance of the pe1mit if the Applicant fails to obtain requisite approvals or does not fulfill the obligations imposed by a state or federal agency, or undertake actions that result in a violation of state or federal law. Section 6. That pursuant to LDC Section 110-50(E)(6) "Resolution to grant waiver" approval shall automatically expire after one hundred and eighty (180) days within which a building permit shall be secured if one is required to implement the u se for which the waiver is granted. The waiver shall expire if the building permit to implement the improvements authorized by the waiver is not secured within the time frame specified in this Resolution. Section 7. That all resolutions or pru1s of resolutions in conflict with this Resolution ru·e repealed to the extent of such conflict. Section 8. That this Resolution shall be effective 10 days after passage. 3 RESOLUT ION #2024-05 I PASSED AND ADOPTED on Pfvr \ \ 9 , 2024. Motion by (lJm tnl 55 \a(li/ ,hraw: , second by C@nnj~)aux ~a_,,\,i\Y~ . FINAL VOTE ON ADOPTION: Commissioner Joyce L. Davis Commissioner Tamara James Commissioner Marco Salvino Vice Mayor Lori Lewell en Mayor Archibald J. Ryan IV ATTEST: Unanimous APPROVED AS TO FORM AND CORRECTNESS: -Jz____:__ 4 RESOLUTION #2 024-OS l u, ;; o rn C/ l 0 r C -l 0 z 'I t : 1' - ' 0 N f-0 Vl MJ U J W . L C ( ; o c t , a, c , , • ~, , , , , . , , . . , ~ "" ' • ~ . A ca • CA T t : : N ~ ca . .- = u , c a. , •~ f " W I Q r 0, ,e o o t £ t f 4 . . « f l 0 l . l CI O • OO J , O l ; l ' T t ll C C o l . , . . _ , < T \ A I - -~ c. • •c c , , r , c l l n l .. . . . . Ot -~ ~ , . D •0 0 . f Af ~ MO l . . ( J C •C A T o. t • C. . C , ~ - - 0 0 •t ' - " •O l l " " " t N l ) Q . P - A T O , , . ~ • mc c O I ~ • a: , . . _ • tc C C Ot .. . '" V i l ., ., . . . . . . . , ~ "" • mt ~ , . • • •~ O t M I L .. . . _. . . . "' • r. . : ) . N .0. - 0 - r i , c I • • ·- - - no •' ° " " " 0 M l . N O C ' U C J L • 'l t . : : L D C T I I '4 : 1 1 0 " •\ N I M . C A ( ) t o : , . . T ' " - . ~ .. .. -<, o .. . :: ; " ' _ _, , •• •, A •I C " ' .. . . ,O C C \ 41 •O l " ic : , , , . . M Q ) l ( O t C O , J • Ql & l & : T ;; . ., , . , . . , . . . I> \ .. . . "' .. " --I,_ . , ;. , . . .. . .. . -I" ,- : I: : . ,. , . , . . " " ' ° " ~ I' • : fr C l ! o l ' T O, Q . t \ . : - . N 1 .. ,. , . , . l ·-- •f l O W T C , ~ ._ . . .. -- • 1" U i l ' T I ! ro c r .. . . . . . . •t M i P f T O # - - . Y • r. , . n , < . ._ , • IC " ' V 7 .. . . ll 0 0 • UT .. . . . . . &CU C .u r v r , - , . ., . . , , . , _ , •• U T •- ,: , , 0 : ·"- ' " " ' . . , , . J "Q , , • Vf " U 1 " f ! Q . I -- 7i ° ; ; " " ,. . . . . . i it z : , .. ~ / -_. . _ ! ! " ' ! - ·U . \ II ; \ 4~. · ·;: : : l_i: : ., ' ' " ,. 1! " , i· " . ' · __ , \! .i · ~ I, ,l :_ , , ~ -- - , , . a: r CE l l ' T I F I E ) TO : To p o g r a p h i c Su r v e y PR O P E R T Y AO O R E $ S · 4' 0 1 S l l l l U H O - O A D , IW < I A l l l ! A C H f LS X I ~ Fl . 0 0 0 ZO l l E DA T A: I RE W I I O N S: I DA TI : : I IC A L . l : I •• :i v I a: N C : A H 1 C P ' T ( ) ( . A Y D M I ~ · JA I · ~~ 1 ~C X a> I I Y . - 1 1Y O W l . - a c N CO W & t N m , . 12 e o : : w ~M li l . & S U ' F I X : O S G H I (; L . . 1 2 1 ' 1 I DA fl ! ~ ~- ll \ & 1 1 4 l, H ( I T I 1 0, 1 L£ G A I . C E ~ T I 2 ! : ! , ~• ' nc ~ , CO ! N t , ■ o, tl l t A C T "- " ' •fl U r , N C ' O O l i t O W H 1 A1 · ts - , AC C O l D N O T O ~ P \ . A T T~ . AS t t c : o u i C O I N N. A T a o Q I ( :- - . AT •J J : 1 1 . tc Q l f TI C "1 1 1 . C M. C X > U I O I MO « M D CO U O " Y , f' \ . O A I O .A. ff ' N C t . ~ lO " ff W" W U T A U ) I I I O , . , _ f . M T U I L l l . 9 C f K ' " " ' 1 ' A . 1 1 4 . N r D 1 T O A, . . _ , , a, - ~ nc a c : : £ . CO f f T ' N n . a. m t lO " " II " WC T M. . C N I 14 G IA S T I A . Y Li f t 2S . 7 > f' t c ' T T O A IO W T 0- a. , t A • U W : nc J r C I C : " ° " ' " " " " U T U L Y M. O C n c ~ y LM c » ~I AO N A C \ r W Y I : f O Tl C i Lr ; ' l , ,. . \ I N O A ~I O I n1 . n r t r r , M~ D I S T ~ C 0 1 1 1 1 , -. . i t t t t 0 A J 1 1 ; : W J O I ll l l " l l l l f CU . W A T \ M t l : TM O C & CO U ' n M ! U T l t l . Y M/ : I I M O A QH l \ 1 to l t C a : : : M f T NA W I I O A ~ ~ , t i , c r WM & C S T A . . I C S C l f ' -. Z , rt e TO A ro w t OI ' TA N G D t C Y Oi l NI ' ° " ' ° ' &. M l 0# 1" 1 1 . A . . . . . , . A, . nc ; M Q C IO I T ' t i l tr ~W ' t : S T M, . . C I C nc IO , / T ■ LM C M 1' 1 t . A : T , na , , t n , nc : J C Z t 1 0 1 r N t • w • r , t 1 r m TN DC C . . ~ ,r WW tA l f 11>. r , l " f f T : ! ' t t l l ' ~ U' 1 T " t a ' 11' IL A I T . . . . , . ,e r r TO NC ~ O' NO I I M lf O. . f0 L . 0 9 ! . I M 1 •U I O ' I I ~~ ~ - - " " " " ' " " " ' .. . fl C C l O I I I D 'U T AH > ~ . . . . . , _ t o . Cl ) . L. a . i t r & . ~ ~ 8 Y Q . . C t i 1 \ o . . . . _ l M O N A M N II O f U . QI , . '4 0 \o l l .~~ ~ - . o c a : : r , ' T A S -.. . . ,. , . , . . . . - v r ' l ' - - . S N U ' _ , . . D' A t n . o u Tl t o l l t J C H 1 " 0 1 • ff l \ C CO I W T W 0. ' 1 1\ o l ] l l l l f O f t nt t ON L . Y -- , r , Mi 4 ns - «: S ~M l PU I TM t ll l t C O f l l O "- A T 11 C M .. _ v H ~ M .ff f. a O I M. C O I I Q . . C T PC M ' N W M C > t C . A I It ro c . , r i o 1 N nt f . ,. . . 1 1 1 . J C . c o c l S O& T H s ; ~ Q N C C. Q ; h ' T Y 01 1 Jt C C O l l l : D , . . (f l . ' 1 - 1 " ~ . - o a t l l ~ f O N. A . . VA • - 11 . I M O W , t . l t O I Cu : Y A n o - ; . UV IN. . 0 . 1 1 1 1 . 11 , l : , f ~ C\ 1 1 0 " OF ~ SI J ' t \ l ! Y · ,. . , _ . _ , . C O l f ' f ' V T W l - r, , _ , ,u c y a , . . , . . . . _, .: . ~1 1 ' 11 1 1 t ( • ~ ~ A , w : : : , TO N I Nl ' 1 C- W~ n4 a c ; t r - - .. 1M .. . . . tT r .. . r. a t ff l C ~ \J I I I O a ' l ) t v o u . , · c. u . , , n 1 1 . . , , _ . l ' : 'm . : r l . O I U I A .. ,, _ , .. . "" _ , , . I ! , _ ~ .. . . ., , .. ,_ . , _ ~ fl lS T ¥ h v t C 0 : . ~ 0 mJ U , , n . . D U ) 4 ff " ' 1 V " ' { L . / / ; ~- , -~ UC : 0 0 1 .. . . . ,. . f1 • • n~ • _lO l r ' I O A _ ~ GA V Y & AS S O C I A T E S , IN C LA N D SU ~ V E Y OR S LB f6 9 7 1 26 S 7 S .W . 11. S C h AV E N U E MI A M I , I L 33 1 7 5 PH O N E : ITI 6 ) 23 6 - U M ~ ~i ;; ~ -< : : ~ °' ;; : : , [1 ' J C/ . l 0 r C :: l 0 z ,: I : : I-. . J 0 N A 0 \J \ ~ Of ~ SP E C IAL PURP O S E - RA D I U S SU R V E Y .. . .. . . . .. ~ ~ ,, ,, . , , _ ,. , . . , . , '1 0: : J I M l ; l : ! ' O I .. . . . .. . ., , . , . . ,. ._ • .1 : 1 "' ! " ' "" .. ,; - -= - .. . . . . . . . . ., . , , .. • •- . . • NI C ! Z m ' : l t tA • ~ M t l C I ' r. A Tl •Gl , L l f V l rJ ( f O• C . A L C I . A " D l l l l ) l ' l l . O Ol l •Q t . O . U t t D M C I I ~ 0, 1 0 ( J 4 t l ( I S ' I K I , . .. , .. . . . . . CO C • Q ) Q ! : l l tl • t< I M i t ( ( C A S ( K \ 1 , , ,v , • Pl • J' ! C t r f O l , n J t t c t t f t ~• ' - ' O J I P' • JO M C, 1- a J C t II C • S Ch) I l' C o t O I I I C , - Q , r , \ T' A ' • ~ '1 1 : • l ' O " C ' ll f \ ( U l c. , t ,1 . f Ml •Ml l ' ; I ,c : ; . , JQ , IC J C C I W ' 0 . 1 0 " " " " ' O' l l • o. # 7 ~ fo t t • l ' I C ) W T C l l f U l ' V G n• mf " M ! ' . 1 1 1 1 : I W l l t '" X . • ' 0 1 1 l r l c o - ( J , ( t ' - V f f IA • !/ 1 1 1 . .. . l. . _ . , I . . , ,. . . , . - c o . " t . 4 " 6 1 \# • \ . 1 1 . n , C U ,- , , o o . •.. w •• M I P l i l t V I 'W • ' M t l i l l M . W. fl " " ' ? , f • W , W f ' \ . O l ' A . . f - ~r t t M S N U < i l l i £ l l t A o f NJ I U 1 ' f . l , l ( N O A J ' # , ' J r Q '- • UI U f Y l ' I U •• "A I U 0 •1 . 0 ' T , C U i • C1 1 1 " U I U I I ( 11 : 1 •" ' - ! C > " " ' I \ , , Nr f ' I V I U V •f A e ~ ' f i e' J • A I I C O \ t t ' 1 ' 0 . e •IN Q I . U• I O ' I C L O .. • lf W H ' t t o . W ' •M St e " .M l •~ I IC ' " ( J &• ~ N i W G P W : l .o - , uc o r - . C l ) U ( ~ +· "" " ' " " " ' l" ' - C l l . ;, a ) ' I( ) < 3' 0 3 ( ) 0 10 ·P R O f ' O S W MA \ l t l ~ UO \ J O R S ' AL C O t ' O i . l' f R . V I' s. , , , , ! Y r, v , m ro s ,U . < : , lf V V !I A C C I ll ' t - 5~ ,so , ,n •.. 1 r r. ,o o D-' . ' ; ) e{ IC J ' ,r t . 3 3 J 1 . i . ic e . m •« u . eM t . w c o o i , . r s C' R O ' O : f , '1 CC ! W rt r . OA l , ' A r , u , ( r , . ~ \. \I ~ _ 5( C ,I J f' J : ( } ( v r , ( ( ¥ CM "' · - ' . i - 11! 5 ! ro Al . O f ' l " U , l'W tll l l ! D 1 0 C > 111 M · ,• 5 , 1 1 , t { Y A l C O I O d C e t ~ r O \ ~V i ' l ~ O f 1 0 K O ' f nt tT.t t J :: : O , on 1 t R •r ,1 , , \ 1o m: J \ 1t 1 . . D 11 5' 1 . 1 5 ( C ! ( I ! < t, a ! ;t ' - ' J , et : ff ' .. ( ) 1 t ! ! W . ! 0 A f Alf t LO C A i ° ' Y. 1 rt 1 t. . O' l t l rO U 5 , l \ O I .O I X > i rt t t rJ A. .\ Y(Y ' Trt t fQ. . . O M ' G l b ' 1 D~ ll )I O , , O C t, • ,( Sl l «J . S . • t, t( O\ t $ ( ) ( 5 t « J t C , . - .U 6r 5r " t G 1 . 0 A D . rr, r !. M . I I X c : r . r . u , fl J !l t ◄ OA " " ~ - ~ (II P- " 6 Of i~ l . . "' + P . () j ll ' ( A f t b. f◄I r .> . m O . e e . ~1= • ~ . '" r, . . ' y A. l f au e o , m MV 5 t M M I . . ~. 16 • > . l ! l ! i¼ tt 'l l5 . <' I "- 't f O ' M t i' Al C : O , : : U : ~> G t : 5~ ~ ~ l l " I A V A U ) , X '. c J , 1 ' 1 , '5 1 ! a" - S f ro s r r v r uoq r0\ C O < S l l 1 ' 1 ' a. (> . O \ { Y r l' 1 f m. \ \ : l b . ~0 ' 'V J I) " ( Ol f - 1 . . R r, , NI f> b l L ' i G :. I C U « 5- " I H . l "\ A ' ,t A \ t: 5 1 O RJ G - 1 1 10 r1 . N , C i t l it ' ! . lG : 1 0 ! ' 0N ,on t P JX J , . T l ( N i\ '" ' 11 ~ OM: n< I L , X t J 1 1,c o : i ; r u r ry . :r , t fR ) f d , 1 ; ll i . . l A ' 5 ( D l 0 C A ' 0 1 5- A ( t . ~t) ' LO h l V -' ? I I N5T [ f ( » . 0 7 , t ' ( ) U . W. 'C X X > , r~ n c : z 1 1 J Q J C r . . , l o i : t l lW O . ! l l l L I I n• SJ M ~ll ! , \ , W ; O I. I O l l t( ~ I == ~ ~ ~ . _ _ , I U( ' W ( l t tl TH S O l f Q \ l t .U S O~ J < l l t l ) J- . S l l ( l ( A f f l l ~ U C X J l "l l \ . lf ' O R C , SU t ~ . t O O M P . , f Y ~ U l t t , ,v u r c , e 1 .t . "' - I O ; l . % C l l l l t l ' r w . c t . N: o c , t ll M T C l t O 't C tC T W t ~ " ' O ' t$ 1 1 1 U t a l : O l : : O . " - ' < D G l ( I I I ' \ ~ fQl l : \ $ 1 ' . l l t a G N C l l l ~ "- « f < S 1 ~ : t t l : J I M " r f t J A S S A I U Ml l l S F O > ~ [ , t rt l UJ C I UJ C . \ S UN Tt C fl Q l ' A l l . l l l' O ,I O O I I Q Nl l , CL A I - . 2, N ( ' f f t ' C ( j » O l f t ' 9 ( 0 C A , I I ( U~ ' f , f r : , , 1 t Q l l ~ t t l f n l \ {N , f l t< ( f f S J ! , O f f l l l l l l OCJ N N l W. 1 l ' l l \ t 0 1 - F U C l 1H S a : C Q : 1 1 1 1 t - , 1 IE ~ I OI I O , I N , , l ( U l l l t U . r-H l ID M : l l l ' ° " t , ,CA O W I C U w . J E -0 . 4. \ ' t l( l ( U 1,1 ,U S , VI ( W, - . , ; "I O ' . Q . : I AOU l ' ~ f t c , ( , , t O , . Y U X A l m SU I J C Q J U R S I . O I P J R > S B Ql ? [ J I N , ! D f , , ~ ~ O t l , 0 , , . . 0 a: w o » n J Q r . l K I I M I C o l t 11 1 ! 1 . A ~ i ' O n c : w o u . t . l l l t tl -= ' ~ ll t l ' R C l ( HW ! l r ~ w , , w , ,t _ l( D ( Q G G i O t l m t T OIL O l [ o . £ M : . ' ~ li ~O I I I U T O I M l ' S • Ol l f M l " > I I M l l • < f P l t G " W C l : 0 . 0 IC " A [; ) J I O I T Qd . l \J C 1 8 1 ( J 1 0 U , 1 ) ~ " ' •C lt O T IC £ . I H0' " . > 1 0l ¢ l " 1 Q Jl l ( C J" ( J , U ' .. . . . • H. . f f l 'I O f J U i l t M l O# C h~ f l ; ) I W u ax 1 i: , ~ i: , . . o - t u 1 1 . - i o v o "l : W I OI I l( J I T l ! ~ i . t " 1 ' C A . G I . I \ N I K . A , 'l ' C . ,.A : . f l o t J 1 ¥ 1 A I O f t . , Ml . K I J O l , I I J NI J C O n a tM : \ lQ O ~l < N . 1 1 D . C l l l , t , , S U l l 0 1 1 , D IIO O ' l ' W T r T T M l 1 1 > 1 6 P t . : : W . l ' \ f f ' G : : t l , l l ' , C Y I G 1 l M S T ~ f 7 lN f f o : l t P S S l - 0 , \ ' t A l " R r t . 1 , t a, 1 , r . . , 1 1 1 1 1 I =~ ~ ~=; : . aJ t ( f\ R l M " ! O l( ~m u , . l ' \ ( l l l l ) O W \ . 1 C l , A / O I W . l P 1 : 0l C " f D C I\ . I U O l t f l l S l . l M l ' A U X I I O . f f . l t l f f l " A G IJ I C A l , Ql l ,& l l ( « f ' # N N S a . . c » < : : I ~U O I I T i J l r ; l t i O - N ' T [ l l U : 1 £ : I I I IJ , 1l4 ~ C , T ) ( ' l t c , I ~ . , , . E -- - - 1r-. . . . - - 1 tr ' O I I W l l ! t T 0 1 1 n 1 t ° ' n . r : r , c 1 1 '- G N ( 1 " J I I M l ! t ( . M . l , ( J I O . : I G ' f 1 P l l ; l ( ( W I I J A J K T ' C K ' M ll 0W ' I V f J . 1 1 0 C - - t. . U M ., 0" ' f S O I S l i O D O f N O W IC o n l m M 1 " ~• o u ~ t n : a , . n 0 1 1 C M . r ~ n n a .. . . . . . °" " ' L M I H I ' ,w 1 W M 1 1 1 1 µ i - a c u 1C J 1 1 1 1 1 , ~ ._ ,_ , ~I O U - - pr Pa b l o A Al v a r e z , .. . ,. • ,, _ , ,. . , . . . , . . 71 I I,, . . .. . ,. . . . , _, ,. . , , . . . , ,,. . ,, . ,1 '° "" " ' " • •• ... ., . . .. . . . . . , . ., , , •• .. , . . . . . . , • .. . , , . • ., . ., ., . ~ . .. .. Di g ita l l y si g ned by .- . . - ff l l D J C ou . , : , i .J I C \ 'I S C D M O U S · •u N: w . c -: . 1 • Da t e : 20 2 4 . 0 2 . 13 09 · 1 3 : 3 2 05 ' 0 0 ' fl O I I I Et. . . . . . - i &N. . . . , _ ~ , . . . , , . , , .. . . . . . . . .. . . . , , ,. . , , . . . . ,~ l l l C l / l ' f l J I T S O F T H I S W M ' Y S H O l . l O ni , . . . . . . . , .. . . . . . ,. . . . 1 y .. ~. . . . . _ ~ . , _ . • • ~r H E " " ' " " ' ° ' , . , n r , , c f l J ' i l ' S W J I W A . ; 1 1 > 8 • E u l 1 0 \ W ' r o r > n o c , . . . . . . i , u . w 1< o u .s. H 1 Y V 1 , S U 1 o 3 3 1 l LA N D ~ EC 7. X 4 l ' U I [ GI , ; . 1. u .20 1 - 1 Nm ~ P a h ! B e a c h , F l l 3 4 0 & "A . 0 . l t ' I M ( z . t ' l l l 7 l ™ : u l ' I T : Ytl U N I I W " I A f \ O I C . " A f l ~ " ' O f l l ' ! • =i ~ s u R V E y I N G :c i " : a : : ~ O l . ~ ~ ~ = ~ ~ = : : M C M } ww w . t . a , d l c ~ . c c m 1e a l . r t t r m Y I ·- - ~ - - - - nn , 1 ,PW . -, , / ti lo - I '( J J .. . ; i t, , j ~i :~ ~ ea ~ ~ -<